dejwv1iae2 - nber

49
© IJOJCC AQU O 1JQ 2OflLCG' xccq tio b r1bp2 urnA Q dnoq iporn xbj1c bu1Jajou bLo/qq tp inj cLGqt © ycL? Qoi4ou Juq jJcp9Iq joacu' yjj i.'p L2Quq' pou cpou o QX uoi io O M!OUJ B"" 0J ECOUOWJC JQGftCJJ h1 uq Cothoi juucc' uA ob!u!ou cxbLcq m po o, ntpo12 uq uo poc DffiGQ OL COUJUJUI2 uq ri lou' jp2 bb bn.i o J4BEK LGffLC bLo19w2 lu jpmc o Bcu QLUUJ(Q bcicL QLpV 1nJ!o owpci ctIJ? cpiuq uq bQcwJJA QI.c Vb41 c"pqq VLV OI38 Joo A2CJJfl2QU2 ACIJf1Q MYBOMYF BflBEVfl OI ECOI4OWIC KE2EVJCH fAOLP bbQL MO' IOO IcCPU1 JçO2u QLX QoI4ou BVPIK2 VViD DEJWV1IAE2 I4BEK 1OKKIMG bVbEK 2EKIE2

Upload: others

Post on 14-Jan-2022

6 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

© IJOJCC AQU O 1JQ 2OflLCG'xccq tio b r1bp2 urnA Q dnoq iporn xbj1c bu1Jajou bLo/qq tp inj cLGqt© ycL? Qoi4ou Juq jJcp9Iq joacu' yjj i.'p L2Quq' pou cpou o QX uoi io

O M!OUJ B"" 0J ECOUOWJC JQGftCJJh1 uq Cothoi juucc' uA ob!u!ou cxbLcq m po o, ntpo12 uq uo pocDffiGQ OL COUJUJUI2 uq ri lou' jp2 bb bn.i o J4BEK LGffLC bLo19w2 lujpmc o Bcu QLUUJ(Q bcicL QLpV 1nJ!o owpci ctIJ? cpiuq uq bQcwJJA QI.c

Vb41c"pqq VLV OI38

Joo A2CJJfl2QU2 ACIJf1QMYBOMYF BflBEVfl OI ECOI4OWIC KE2EVJ�CH

fAOLP bbQL MO' IOO

IcCPU1 JçO2uQLX QoI4ou

BVPIK2 VViD DEJWV1IAE2

I4BEK 1OKKIMG bVbEK 2EKIE2

Page 2: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

JJIJqCJbJJIIJ bY IôIOf bP!I9t1C1bP! bY ThTOtflUIACI2IA O bCUU1A1JT flUJACL21JX O bCUUJAJJJC J/JJI4OU CJJOOJ JPG fiJLtOU 2CJJOOJDCbI4WCU1 O JTIIJCC DCbI4UJCU O E!1JCC

O040 cpuq KO2CU

NpoJC CQ2 JJUJQ UC !IUCLG2-LC LJC LOW Mb boojo

!UCLC1 OL GCLQ2C 2ACUJC 42J( U 111G 112 frnuJqIJ )cur JJC mq ip pujcJuO fl COU3IJJCLC!I pUJc2 10 GWbT4CJJ?i vqqic 1JC dflC2OU O /AJJGJCL 2/ith COUiLC JAC

inrnJA2i2 yc C2j WC UJILJCC1 AIJflC2 9uq CLQ21-LG 2C AC2 O4 JIUCLQ LC 2Mth bojojj

UJUIJ 2X21CUF DCb!1C 1}JC !qqc2bLCrq UCU1OU 10 CLJAI1IAC2 IjJQLC JJS2 CCU JUJG 2X21CWC

C1AU) IJ 2UJSJJ IJflUJpCL O JLW2 JJ 2flp muijj) UCLC2C fiG L!21C O cojJth2Q Oj fiG /AOLJq

IIWCJ? iiJOUiwpOu COUCCUJ!U fIG AJflC 0j JUIJ qc4Afic boou miq qic COucCUPfOU o

cowbjcxA miq LJC M!fJ fJC2C Gcrn.fC fJG CfIJfG2 M1p CCfILCJ? LCbOLpJ

niq COUaOAGL2I9Je bLoqnc tOL COWUJCLC!9J JuJc2 JpC COULOACL COUCCLU MJJGfJGL fiG

fIG j ICU O IJJCCU AGI2 jIrniJCUJ CLAUAC 2CCI1LfC2 pVG GcOWG U UJbOLWIU

VBLKVC1

BVI.1K2 V'1D DEBIAVJJAE2

yb4JI1BEB IAOLICII3 bbGL JOO

Page 3: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

(J]v BY UE1 fl COACUJUJCIU yCCOflIU1UCC (it).(r3Y H° C011111flU 011 9I1JCU1 JTU1JCC 91J flL91J VT (I) fl2 C0mb01ICL oUJJc crn..cucEflWLC2 jLq1u C 2i011 (J QLOfth ojjip.A (I3v T4Y H0112C BU1q1 COIUUI!U AUOUA2nbcwiou (J3v B C DY 09Iq ooACUJoI2 OLJJC Cqc2.sJ jc2ciJcaiCW v (iooY cowwoqrA1JC 0L JUCUWl10119J 2CUICWC1U (iôY BI ouuq (ig, jY BI COWU31UC 011

v J9LC UmIJpCL o LcboLj2 p) ocunucui uq gizqc oL J1qou pvc pcuqciocq o 2jnqA1u qcuAsIAcv 2GC

coucctuLGq !' LGj!AGJA 2UrnJJ UIIUJpGL OIJUUC1J IucuuGqi9uc EOL cxwbjc jwo Mo-

OLG!U cxcjrnuc 2Mb2 (cu Jçcbo2 oucowc vuq couqou) y{oLcoAcL

(j)) fl COUIUJGLC1J 91JJC2 Ouc pcq J PJfflOU OI!UGLG2l i.c amb q .xo plll!ou °L

41I!0u uq pc onuqw uoiou wornuocnacucA vb2 z u u.ii!ou (2M9b ouzoL

IJ1I1LC2 \J JJC cuq O 1pC 1101T0U91 1JJ0flIU oon42uq1u 1U1GLC21 i.tc vMba M2

1U1CLG21 L11C OLGT1J GXCp1JG LfG 01. b4CG DG4A!AC2 iucjnqc ob1ou2 O1JAL2 9uq

DC4AAC CCflU2 LG COIULC2 IP PC!L 'P JOW JJG IGAGI O 1J 111JqCLJAIU

CJ2CMJJCLC nj puj bowojio

2Mb2 pcq pA c"i HOCACL Ofli. Ctqqcucc 2nFC22 lpj 2Thb boiou2 LG j9i.8cJA pqcq

2CU2TTAC KCJ1AC1A 2Wfl !UCLC2G2 IU I1JtGLG21 L4C2 C1J Cfl2C !LJA i2c qccpuc iu pc Ajf1C o

wc iqo iu iUGI. LG 21ib2 pc puqu aw uc bo!ou 2 2OWGMJJ !UGLG-L9CqcuAJAc 2cCfrufA rIuGLo2 z.c 2M9b uq ijuq sMqcucc pG UJC2 Mp0G 4JCC pc

AJflC uq !UGLC1.G 2GIJ2fTA1A OI)VU1C qcuA AG bo!ou2 J/G 0Cfl2 OIl a!UJG !WbO141U

UJJG2 1PGU 4JJC pUJCIU 2A2CW 12 AJ1JUGLpJG jp bvbct 12 1pG UL21 0 G2I1UJG JJG UJL(GI

2urn iu cowb11u2ou o pc joac2 pA pujca j u qqiiorf pC wiox. pup i.c jj au 2ru11J9L

LCCCUf oca 011 qcuAiAG2 2ncp 2 O2G 0LOGL q GffUP1 uq OLIG UrnA ccw

i.o coucciuicq v L" 19LG i9i2 i IL puc2 ic nu qGLAAG2 o UCLG2G L2j pcu

puuu 2HJCG UJC2 qowuc wo WLJCC2 uq MUpIU P9U1UU qG4A91Ac pOJqu2

booJio2 oqcuAwAG2 JjJc LcIou2p!b pcwocu 92C q q4! !2 c2bcc!9JJA iwboii !

!CGL cuia LC pcqiu 01. abccnjwu !2 uo 2!WbjC urnct GCfl2G ! !2 qiujcn o inc

L12JC H0MCAGL IJJGA 9J20 ll0M 9GUI2 10 drncjqA vuq cpGbJA Jcc 2bGCflj!AG 142JC DccI.uJ!u!u8

C0UL0ACL211 bLoqncl1 JJJG2G 2ccnuica 9L6 boIAcqpj !uLnwcu2 OL 1L1J2LCWU uq pGqiu

pI 1p6 J2 CU 0 fflGCU AG9L2 U1JIJC!I 4'!'° 2GCflUI!02 JJAG PGCOWG !Wb0I41U uq

I. JULOqUC4IOLJ

Page 4: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

2.U d bId tnuorns rIt1O .23hsib5m-xtni Isi3nsrIfl irrnwi Ino d bIr1 is aqswa'Io abiirlt

ifl313q F 13V0 io1 i11U033S aAnsd 131sb jisI nva a1nsd 1Eb1fflrno3

ia31ini in di nsd3x a3i1sq owi d3uIW ibnu baitnoa £ al qswa tsi taiini nA

£ s qswa isi la31tni la3Iqmia 3rIi nI .lEqi3nnq 1noiion di as nworr1 inuorns ns no ain3msq fftnOm-xi2 th as d31JE) isi iaiini inrxu3 di a'sq snsq no a1wiini rfinom-xia b ah52

no sisi ia13ini bsxF! io ts23q s asq iIsq13lnuoa 211 3lirfw isqi3nflq Isnoilon 3rfi no 51OffIJ

ni aisi la13lni noxln3vno3 'fl .bnsr13xs isvn ai Isqianhq Isnojion 3dT .Isqbnhq Isnoilon 3rfi

b3isqioilnsnu 315 313f1Y11 .noiisitini is 3utsv 13)hsm ox £ asH qswe 3(11 isrli oa 132 31S qswa £

'risq no io'I iaas ns rn1no33d artsd3 111w qswa s b sulsv ihsm 3th a3is 123131ni flu a3nsr13

.i1sq13ifwo3 ,rIi iob iiIidsi1 £ bris

io) bisii1ni asw qswa sill nsdw no noiisrrnoIni asliupsi qswa sisi tasisini ns niulV

.qswa sub 'ihuisrn 3ninismsl sth bris in3msq'Io arrnsi silt (ai stsi iasisini bsxfi sf11 isdw

liSili idi asufsv ts*Ism nsvs Lssvs arrnil ws1 bns noitarrrio1ni aidt lssvsi oi bsiiupsi ion S1S acrnii

'e1 sdT .insuloqmi leom ai rbiclw u1sv is*ism insTtuo sri i ion ai ii isvosioM aoiIoThoq qswa

.oiloThoq sill o siiviliana sts-i-iasistni srli ai oildthoq qswa £ 1o 1th srtt 8niriirrnsisb iii 1Oi3S1

snsrb ns3 qswa £bo uLsv r1l 1idai1e snsrb asisi lsisini'll .1its!ov 'isv sd nso outsv qsw 2irfi ot sanoqasi ni '11sitis9I .jluafflib al aqswa mon aLth sill nhoiinom audT .'1Isoiismsib

1o 'ivili2n sii-iaistrii sili 1svi 01 anoiiuiiiarii sliupsl nitioqsi qswa nirrnoIsi ioI alsaoqoiq

lilnTJ .asisi snsdoxs nisioI as rl3ua aiolsb isrlio 01 asiliviliansa 2fl llsw as) anoiiiaoq qswa iirii

SiR aqswa aoi1oThoq qswa usd3 bo 'iivitiansa sisi-tasisini r1t i-Ioqsi ol bs-tiupsu 51S enoiiuliieni

insiaffluanFbo sausasa .oiloThoq so lah sift isils s1sviansqxsni bns bbiup 01 sw ass 'is 03 aisbiatuo idI iluafflib siom ii sfsm 01 beau sd nsa aqswa ainsmsuiup3i nitIoqei If1STIIJ3

.Iah uoinom

£ olni nhsins tisq srfi nsrlw tnsrioqmi 11siasqas 21 Iah anholinom iii i1uaffiiG

.elsqxannq sbiaiuo uoI snom nisnsm as ai qswa s as rlaua noitasansut sviisvhsb

woCi) stsluasqe 01 Ismitqo ii bnfl sm inss as uoiinom 11th ionnso alsqiannq sbzaiuo usvsnrfW

1thOmrnO3 btis vlwps Snshi3xS fli31O Isi lasistal iot flocpi ot bsiwp d 111w alnsd (1QQ I flu nifls12 .atzas 315 tsili atzsiino3 lo 3u1sr ñi as lbw as a3liilidsuI 318 isdi at61ino3 lo su!sv 3i1i asvi1svi13b

Page 5: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

no2di IdmED bn ioizoiq d asaoflo 2tIoq3l 1n3331 i&Ii 2ns3m ii1T .(QQQ!) norioO bcxs

di 13r1ir1w in3gs i&li 1Eni2 'm sinuoD nsiO brIE fiEd3 !3llsi9M (afIii981D

ol asviiEvh3b riiw ris3d 3vsd -i8aEr1Em snom 1snoi31o1q 10 2191U2E9fl 3iE10q1O3

(IS lii 213b1or13)1E12 13db brIE alsqi3nnq .ai3Eqmi ta3libni brIE 1331ib 9vE11 23oI1o abnbl 323dT

ri8uoldi beTIs iQ3libni 31di2oq £ oEIs i 313dT .ifiu kuoivdo 22o1 'd iffi fI0iiExI1IE10

as b3w3iv 3d sm noiiBsirI1o no d o1 bxi1ai .s 3upsqo 31E 3viisvh3b 33(Iia .gni1thria

1siuisn 3(11 3i aifi3 3a3dT .anoiiEsins1o 13(110 b enoiiiaoq oilothoq 3(11 buodE noiismioIni

a3in1sqi3inum noibE1oq1o3 io1 3mb blorl dT .nin 'ns lIE ni 82fi3131 noii&rnoIni b 11u231

smo uc1i enoII3sanEll asviisvrI3b moil am1doiq 3dT .thisd brIE gnsm bniiI

10 3lLrI rIthIuo33E 131th3 in ri&I3 lob b33r1 3111 mo 2inioq 2irIT .2rn3ldolq noiifirrnoIni

.2nOiiSlu31 1n3m123vn1

iaii1 .uai owl is sisdT .sisvse siom si.s amsldoiq sili 2sviiEvn3b San a1nd nsrlW

213b10d91512 biaiuo wolls ion sm lrisd B bo noibiaoq a3vilEvn3b sill buods siom r1iworI?L flSVS

abnsminbani sviisvi-isb-non 'rism ni iasvni aAnsEL .lnEd 311110 aasnthn ll613V0 3(11 snimiisb ob

ii JIWOID1 313W afioiiiaoq vi1svnb 11511110 utav 3(11 Ii 113V3 aUr1T .supsqo bns biupilli ss 16th

.sd bluow lnsd 1iln3 3111 aleh 13(110 bns Sis1-taSlSirn ob 1331du2 woii worDl ol bisri sd bluow

.aSvibEvnSb ni iasvni isrlb iiOiiEsins1O ir1io leom moil lrI313Thb msrll 23?IEm aiflT

bBS! ns a*isd 3IS! !B1SV3E 10 iulii1 silT .abfls lBuIlsiXs svsrl risc aiu!iil )Lnsd bno33

sasdT .arrrth 161 213)llsm bibsl3 b saqsh1o 3111 bns ms1aa 2ifl3ffP5q 3(1110 IIWOb)1631d 3(11 ot

ilimi Esi Its alflBd saisI IL (1133fl0) 1o 316 'Laii 31(1 ,12'2 26 'I3Vii331103 flWO(D! amsldoiq

ii isdi 15313 ai II .afloibi2oq lslimi2 nbtsb as beviS3lsq 315 10 213)hSffI aviivnb ni anoiiieoq

32uB338 .nsr&bo siuhi1 sill rissm Ein )lnBd snob siulisI 3(11 arioiliaoq islitnia svsrf a)lnEd

sids 3d ion 21sqf3flflq sbiaiuo anoi1iaoq tiisisThb vsd alnsd Ii IISVS 31JpSqO 315 asviisvrisb

alnsd 13(110 Is sidnoib ElEna ta )lfIsd 3(1010 iu1t1 3(11 isdlsilw sctirrnsisb 01

aqswa sisi lasislimi (10 21J30I idiimf1 sW .thisd 3fII(flEX3 03 au bEs! asuaai )1an 3Im3b2'

Io esrioliaoqsi 315 'l1siuisn thisd sau533d bilE IdaIuiaivibnon at 4an 3151-laslSlni 32U533d

3vUsvk13b Ii3di fli 1ID11 313W tti )krl $V1iS!1J3qau tis fluli bmis13 ifs sd 31qfflsx 3a1tt (Ii 2JnS i1T E

.1noijnjniiw asw anoiiieoq

Page 6: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

nErli 2313r131Jp5ft 1n81&ftib i hqi afaas li3dtIi Aüi 31-i-r3irii 13d thia .h 1-i3ini 1-fa313fni 33ub81 of i f&lt -- b3rf of 31s1 i1ofni nizu d 'm thisa .a3iiilidEi! li3df

8fE1ua9q of io -- Ath

3Ifn3i2 ei 31&f I 13di8dw rIithrrri3i3b ni qia fii 8th fiviiian3e 91-f1ni eizrnit oT

8th maIl mo sb 81d1isvfi Lno 3(11 .sfb nuiaix3 3111 no 3lufoirn2 8lom fuq of b33n 3W )12fl

b811s3 l3dmun £ au1sv IBnolion i-ioq3l thIEd 31811w noiiibnoD bris 8rno3flflo atIog3$1 IIsD

1a no nsth 3lom) a3viisvh8b isi fa3lsfni b 'thuisrn aninism3l r1f bns "f2O3 3n3m336Iq31

fsi ini a'lnsd £ b fao3 1f13m33s1q31 3dT .(3ninism3l is' 8110 nsdf aa1 bns nnism3i 23vifavfl8b iuo r1ifl8n ion) lnsd 3111 of aiaaa 315 fsth a3viisvh8b 8111 b 3ulsv 3111 al a3viisvil3b

33)ham (13V3 10 iiviiian8a 3151-12313frn 3isliJ31s3 Of ffI8i3fflU2fli is slab 82311T .(a8ililidsil 315 fsdi

b aeisrnifa of siab 3ldslisvs ecu mall oa of au wolla isdi anoilqmuaas 3lqmia 1sm 3W .eUIEv

.1wiii2n32 8151-125131n1 bits eUISV 13)1lSffl

qawe f3n £ asri m312v2 nb1cisd sdj lath woc1 izviflanea 31s1-123131n1 b 281Smu123 iuO

815Ibo anoiliaoq 8d3 of 3ub ei fivifianea aiufT .32(1 28151 12313fn1 11 8LJISv it! aIIil 1sf! I noifiaoq

.anoiiiaoq qswa 113111 ni 23151 1281311!! of 3luaoqx8 ionim '1no 3V&h of bnet alcisd 11sm .2)lflSd

aeob ii1i 2noiiiaoq qswa svifxan3a elsl-f28181n1 8v511 alnsd eiI lath worle 23frriii23 mo eIrfW

alnsd 311T .fn81x3 8(11E2 3(11 of 3V1112n32-8151-123181n1 315 anoiliaoq iwp8 calnsd 3111 Isrhl nsrn ion

a3viisvneb 13(110 au bliJo3 3fh1 10 1th e1E1-125131n1 333(12 33n515d-nO Ob3f1 of aqwa 32U 'Sm

qawa 13(113(1w 81s81123vn1 3W .eluaoqxe qswa 113(11 eabecl of i3)hsm eeiuiüI 3(11 25 cbua 2f3)hsffl

'dfaom 3vsd aAnsd sis1 isth bnfl 3W .afda 33nsIad lnsd no 818r1w8213 beb3rf 21 31LF20X8

nhiup3s ai odwbo noifa3up fnstloqmi '(13v 3(11 neqo 23v581 airiT .1th 3151-fa3l3fni qawa b3b3r1

.alnsd 3g1s1 mall lah efEl-123131n1 ecu

iaeiefni no bnuoigbsd 31(102 eblvolq 8W II no11382 itT .awolldt as ab3e3olq ieqsq edT

Isievea 22U32ib 8W .b3aau3aib at 38*iarn qswa 8(11 ni alnadbo 8101 8(11 ffi fl0it33 fiT .eqBwa elsi fsdl Ieborn eth afneaeiq VI noii38 .f3)hsm qswa 3111 ni inernevlovni lnsd luods a823r11oqr1

V noif33 .sisb bodailduq mail sf ivif 121132 3fal-f23,3fni bns 3ulsv f3hsm 3vneb 01 au awohls

313113 v1invn3b isi 3a3131n1 1111w li1nu md aeviivFib '(311nu3 ni31o1 ni eaiis anoitaup ms di tsili 33014 .niin1uqe to nibd i Ii 13111311W £Ioitioq avi1zvirnb niw Lnscf £ moft wonA 01 nw on ai

Page 7: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

-aini briE uIsv hsm b aetsmita3 .!bom 3th rtits1di1E3 io1 3wb930lq 3d aeriiliuo

b3d a!nEd idirfwbo rioiaup 3dr asaa81bbn 1W flOi332 .W noi3 ni n3vig 31E 'ivrriena .11W noi2 ni b3insa1q anoIeuIDrioD .3uaoqxe qswa li8fIt

bnuoigbsfl :aqtiw JcSL t29191n1 .11

a13fliO 1i3S3 sq 01 331S a3Lrzsq Owl cf3trfW l3bnu iosiinoo 5 ai qswa tsi 12319fl11 nA

03 beau ai rt3irlw lsqi3rthq 1snoiior? B riø basd 315 qswa £ uI ewoft das3 3rlT .anoiislldo ia81tni

as fiworDi s-rB 23i:rIsq owl OLIT .(b3WIsdax9 Ion ai md) wofl r12s3 3f13 31511J3153

no asisb bistuqiia 1o a3ha £ IA .sib3rrn3ini !si3rIEfth £ 21 asitIsql3inuo3 sill bo srio 1lsuaU

Ia Isa lsi 123133111 bsxft erfi 'd b3rIirrn13b 1r13mssq noquoa s aswo (isssq 31s1-bsxft sit r) tiEq niisoft lnsv9lsl sill no bsasd mnsmisq "riOUO3 £ bswo al rriusi ni bns i no1lsriiho 135111103

or 132 21 slwi bsxft sth slirlw msi anumsofl sill as bsu ai 510811 ats1irIo3 qswa iaom 1o1 .l sls1

ivo bssiqa £ as 'b In auorll sd ns sisi bsxft silT .ois bo sulsv lsiiini ris sysil qswa srh slsm

sfqmsxs idb .)Iarl iibsl3 1sf1si nso bssiqa sill sisriw bnod (Iuass1T 'thuism-stshqoiqqs siLt

eiriioq aiasd aulq stsi bnod '0uassiT iss'-svft srli is sisi bsxiI sill Isa idaim qswa i-oviI £

.SIOffIJ nlinorn-xia sill Is sisi nilsofl sill bns

lo sisb noiisniho sill ai M sisrlw i is Isa 21 sisi bsxlb siLt oini bsisins 21 qswa rli nsrlW

1s'sq SIE1-bsxfi sri T .Iaqisnnq Isnoilon sill ai J 31311w JM1 :2'sq is'sq sisi-bsxfl sifT .qswa sill

21 Isql3nnq Isnoimon sill IsrIt soiloM .stsb Isasi last suli Is 5151 isisini sill ai ji sisulw J3i : 23v15351

aIn9maq tasisini bsaimoiq 3r11 111 s3nsl3Tfib sift fno l stsb tcism3Ittsa ff363 mA .bsnsd3xs 13V311

- ,i) :)135r13 sansiflib £ (aaq io) 23V13351 issq sisi-bsxlI suli .bsnsrbxs al

b S1I1 Sill 13V0 O13 21 qEwa sb sulsv Isilini Sill SIIIIW .nOibBanEii mua-oisx £ 21 qswa A

-bsxft sill) nsq 5f10 ol 13225 nE smo3sd ol qswz sill ni2us3 33f1s113 'sm aslsi lasisini qswa sill

niaa attIsq 3110 h5s13 (l1ái asisi 'Ii is'sq sisi-bsxft sill idI) lilidsi1 £ io (sth alsi 'Ii issq sIsi

ii niisoR sd .is-i iiinom-xia inm,3 n,di iD niw adinom xia yiv isaz ai '1L63ici lgi niiioll ,dT xza m'om( al tth 1nin1flsa 1xn di Is woft d253 ssIi qswa di iuoducnc1i .1n3fnIfla 01 ionq adinom xi bninnb

.33flBVbE iii adinom

Page 8: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

)133d3 33n31Thb edt ner!t i ot ,i mouI aeth etsi anitsoft edt1i e1qmsxe io1 .22o1 iedto edt

- ji) ot J(MI - ji) mofi eah 1e'sq etci-bexft edt d bevi33el

edt Il '3noP 2.6 tnsqx3irIsq qsw s enfieb eW .qswa sIo eIqrnsxe eblvoiq I eiuiI 8noI .s dtlw Lnsd £ 2worle !ensq qot erIT .eisi nitsofl £ 23v1e3e1 bris etsi bexft £ asq t(ISqiaitiSq

1:1 oa .etsi $IOffIJ rftnorn-x12 edt Eevie3ei bris h6q-1etnuo3 au ot o\0 I .V a'sq lnsd edT .noitiaoq

ai $lOffLJ neriw nedt adtnom xia ieve ebsm eis 2tnerrrsq bna noilhim I Z ai Iaqbnhq Isnoiton edt

nedW .( \ - o\°I.V) * noillim IZ) stIsqietnuo3 au ot 0?.EIo ten £ assq edt o\°.ô tasietni iiedw anis lnsd edt aurfT aevie3e1 kisd edt brtsd ierlio edt rio o\°.V 21 51081J

.8th aetsi

li13x1qmi evd ew tsrlt ealtoM .noitiaoq iiorla £ ril fnsd edt awod Iensq elbblm edT

bexfi edt nsdt aael airlioq aiesd 01 ai asq ii etni bexft edt 33(112 ie!seb £ 21 !nscf edt tuft bemuaas

noitiaoq 1-ioda s asH !nsd £ nedW .ee1 ielseb edt at eane-ieThb tnioq aiasd 01 aidT .2eV13351 ti eiai

.3211 2etSI taeietru1i 2820! ii

a1nsd erIT .qswa sIo t'ae1 dtod ibfsm lnsd edt awoda I eiui1 Io Iensq tasi edT

aiasd 01 1o ten £ aevieaei Ansd edt evom aetsi taeietni wod iettsm on eania beber1 a! noitiaoq

.(tkthleb on nurnuas) qswa edt mon atnioq

(a

.aeitnuea emoani-bexfl ils ot nomrno eis tuft eaodt ebulani aqswa mofl a)Ian iojsm edT

tibeia oatA .qswa £ b eulsv edt t3e'fls aetsi taeieini it! aeansda eausaed ataixe )krl etsi-taeietnl

£ 'd tluâIeb nedt ti1idsi1 £ 21 qswa aM .tlus'1eb am 'tisq1etnuoa £ eausaed ataixe )farl

ebuuinasrn edt oa (qawa £ it! be3nsriaxe ton at lsqtarinq Isiioiion oe1A .'!t203 ion 2t '1iaqietnuoa

.beaubei at )f iibeia'1o

taeietni b noitorlLfi £ 25 aqawa evlsv ot elds ed 01 been ew Lah etai-taeie in! enirnsxe oT

nsa esq etsi-bxft edT .ansolbo noitsriidmoa s as qswa £ weiv nsa 3W aiifi ob oT aetsi

.etsi nitsoft s ts tnuorns emsa edt nibneI Iauoenst1umia bits etsi bexft £ is 8niwonod as beweiv

ot unelaviupe a! qswa ise-evft £ 1e'sq etsi-bexil edt'1o weiv'1o tnioq edt mo1 (elqmaxe 1oI

nitsoft edt iedw) noitsaildo etsi-nitsofl ise-evfl £ anhud bits bnod noquoa ise-evfl £ fl1u22!

Page 9: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

V

qswa 3u15v of eu 2q1311 2irlT .(oi 21 nsd3x3 &liIo 3lJIcv i6iiini di isdi bue ie 21 3151

3r11 qsw 1s-3vfi 3(11 olni is owl biswith nb1oo1 1qrnsx3 ioI .3u22i iiili of insupsadu2

sisi iss-svft I6niho silt Is bnod noquo iss'-ssirlt .s bsui fls iii svsd 111w is'sq sisi-bsxi

1o sulsv isiism srh smif iii lnioq Isrft lA .briod srsi-anitsofi iss-ssirff £ liluod svsd 111w bns

bsue2i bnod i -ssidf sIo sulsv silt nsswfsd sansiflib silt 21 iesq sfsi-bsxil sill of qEw2sth

.fhuism of its! 21s' ssiili (111w briod isss-svfl Isitini sill b sulsv silt bits nsrll

noifsriihobo slab sill sd M qsw2 siWbo ihuism !srti3ilo sill sd o Is! qsw2 £ su!sv oT

isl!ob sno £ b I stsb Is sulsv silt is! isilti&1 .qswa silt 3fIruISv 512 5w if 3111W 15 slsb silt sd I bits

£ IsdI s3zloM .°'1 :sd o liiufsm l.sniho ilhiw M Is bsuaai (I=J .s.i) bnod (lsqi3nulqbo)

Insssiqsi of au awolls aiilT .(1ss1 bss1 srlf nhoni) isq Is bsahq asw1s ai bnod slsl-8rliisofl

:as !sqianhq Isnoifonlo OO.I iIiiw qswa sbo sulsv sill

rW 1 r1....O 4 Mi 1J 4.j

aA .sn6d3 estst laslsfni ridw asnsrb qswa a 1o ou!sv sill wod 332 of biswio1idisila 21 ii woM

.r1ib1o3as bsisils 21 sulsv qswa sift bits aensila [1 bnod sdl b u1sv 5(11 5VOr1I asiEl 128151ni

b lsborn £ 2511U51 ii 331112 bsls3ilqmo3 510(11 15V5WOf1 2i 25161 125131111 iii 3fIsd3 3(11 Wlidh32sQ

.23161 i2SlSlflibO 31U13U112 misI 3111

qswa sb isblorl sill of llusIsb b ifis silT .fluiIsb bsioni svsd 3w inioq zirli oT

't1sq13lnuo3 sIT .tluslsbIo smil sill is sli!idsi1 s o isaas ns ai qswe silt isrlisdw no abnsqsb

srll of elnsrn"sq nblsm 21 isb!od silt • . .) isblorl sill oh iilidsil £ 21 qswa dt I ud ailuáIsb

II .l3sfls stsibsmmi on ai sisdi bits ainsm'sq slsm of 2sunuIno3 isblod silt risrlf ('DisqIstnuo3

nb1sm ed bluorla rtsq1slnuo3 sill isill anssm tluilsb nsrfl isvswod 15225 115 21 qswa 5111

.lnioq 16(1116 qswa sill 'to sulsv sill of tnsl.sviups 21 isblorl silt of 2201 sifT .ion Esob lud 2insrnsq

.bsilus'Isb rIsq1sfnuo3 srll'ti bsnu3ni sd bluow lsdt aaol sill at qswa £ 'bo 1203 IrIsms3sIqsi silT

O15 £ ssilqrni isb1od-lses as d t!us'tsb 531112 svila3snnon esw1 211203 lnsms3slqsi isill stoM

.flsq1slnuo3 211 oh aeol

Page 10: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

8

qcw t$I 1zntnI bn2 aInifl

%Ma\o zlci%o9L

qwa isi taitni b u1sv Isnoitori 'd btaiI arrriII qswa qot 3rit b tail £ atnaiq I &dsT

uIEv Isnoiton d arrrzfi nst qot dtbo 3vi1 .a1nd 1sz31rnfno3 &rnII 3aodtbo iaoM .anoitiaoq

o b ?&d naitha £ 21 &io a1nd bnwo-ststa cfoniI 1E ir!i aLnd 121319mmo3 2.U3is

anoitiaoq qwe tas1BI erli rltiw rrnf inwi qot dfbo ntrf8i 13vo1oM .rrnft a3ithua .2.TJ £

.athsm asviisvh3b wr!io ni arioitiaoq 3is1 9vEd ot bn9t oats errriil 323dT .alrisd 31S

1dsT .a1nd is! wI £ Iii b3is1tn3no3 aqswa m9te'a 8nblnsd 2.U silt nkliiW

A lsnsq .sbs3sb teEl sift ni a[nd tsi3lsrnmo3 2 .Ubo noitiaoq qwa sun ta5istni silt aworla

ta aqswa 'n svsrl alnsdbo tns3lsq ssidi nEff i iws1 t&lt eworl {a)lrIsd lSi3lsfnfflo3 lIE nhsvo qswa o tns3Isq vft-tnvsa isvo aqawa bloif alnad OO sliluoi duorftIs siorrrisrlti&I .lth

tiidt d blsrl ai unsisq 'tsnin lsvo bn lsn&1) aInEd islssb nsvsa d blsrl ai sulsv lsnoiton

.(D bris alsnsI) thisd

dtiw anoits insaio nb1nsd ot noitnstts t3ntasl sw 2woIlo1 tsift how ls3hiqms rlt nI

bits 2qswa sau ton ob 'llsisnsa aunt risrlt isllsma alnsfl .noillirn OOZ risrit istssi eioaas Istot

nsvs thisd iasis! isv sift idl tqs3x3 .tslisrn silt bo noirloq trisfturtiani its io inUoO3s

ssa) uIsv Isnoitori qswabo atnuoms tns3iIinaia blorl 'Isisi atsaas ni noillirn OO2 nrlt isisI atsaas Isiotlo noitsII 'nit £ idi tnuo3os aqswa tsrft worla I - (I abnsI .( sldsTlo 1 - CI aIsrisI

.iiiRt qot rlt wolsd elnsd is

d3um ai aqswa moil mstaa 3rlblnsd sift 01 lah lsitnstoq silt tsdt awoila oals sldsT

bohsq sift isvO .enoitiaoq qswa lnsd ni dwoi3 silt lb sws3sd tasq sift flu nsdi won

A Isn&Ilo anmulo3 owt Isna silT .ise isq tns3isq Ol 'd bses5I3ni a3niblorl qswa EQI-a8QI

nbInsd silt flu iiups bits atsaas ni uliwoi silt itiswb suLsv isnoiton qswa flu diwoia sift isrlt work

8nlnsd silt iii tiups Istot sift asmit fist isvo aaw sulsv Isnoiton qswa QI lb bits silt 'H .mstae

.mstaa

lsIlOijsW iiiI qiooiiiD Ins 1simdD jxsflsilitsM 3asd3 mT aiAnsE sth,mA&tsa 3buL3ni aAnsd IsU .nsoM 1T. bits os3idD lo nsfl

Page 11: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

2

a 1ns22333rI ion ai 2)Lnsdlo l8dmurI llsm a is anib1or1 qswaIo nOiislin33no3 3dT

b8T1&tns1i 3d 01 3151 123131ni wolls sm aqsw .m3iea nb1nsd cIi ni 1th 3a5813ni aqaw isdi

a1nad won woIf2 w woJ3a .b33ub3, i kh 8llJIthI *isd I1svo lath \.6W S (I3u ni 21flBd n38w13d

io aiham 3viisvh3b isdio ni b3ab3d od 'tam anoiliaoq qsw2 .aqsw f1!a1J )1211 8EflEffl 1153

to nOiislin33no3 3113 isrhi ei l3rIionA .enoilieoq ida 83n51sd-no 3ab3If ot b!8d 3d 'tam qswa 3113 2i 2111311 .2311!v!135 Iah ru ol thiad 3rs1 ioi vitn33ni rliiw ob 03 2511 anibIor1 qawa

.1th 31m3ta'2 325313111 eqswa (13111 32S3

(a

3(10 .13* am aqswa 3111 3ianimob a1nsd w1 £ r1w tuoda 23a8dioq'th owl 3loIqx3 3W

)tan 31s1-323131r11 3351 r1i 32us33d ihsm qawa 3(11 3iarumob !E13fl3 ni alnad isdl i 3i1idiaoq

n013513n33no3 311T .1th ich3 5flBffl 01 beau sd ns3 2q5w2 .aa3niaud li3rhiIo r3uJbo1qd £ 25

)1 3351-323133111 3(11 nusnsm ru 3x1ai33q2 e?lrisd 323(13 32u533d 11.1330 'sm a>Iriad W31 a noma iarfl 2i '3i1idia2oq l3rfionA .ai91hsrn 131110 (11 3b3d am '8di (13111w m3i2'2 ribInacf 31i1f13 3111 io1

a±isd r1ro mofi 1th 123131111 tho2ds 01 alnad 31a1 ldI 3v13n33111 cia 315913 anoiiloi2ib 'xoisIui .3b8r1 ion ob thzsd i1 3(11 d3irIw heh arrnfl lnsdnori mofi bna

b 'inisfl3a b3iflBW 213W0T]oC1 32LJZ33d 211501 3i51-b3xft b3uai aAnad h1snoi1ibsiT

11us13b sm l3wollod 3(11 ie1iI .±iad 3(13 ol 1th owl a3vlovcui cisol 3151-b3xFt A '.in3maq

(rrn3i-florl2) 3lsliniiaoR 'ilhamhq wlq ansol 3rhi nislnoo aoiloThoq lnSd bno33 .1th iib3lo)

3(11 1o 3uIsv 9(13 (b8naia r133d asd iosltno3 nsol £ l3fIs 38115113 231a1 123131111 1i audT .a3iiihidsiI

3113 a3i3ihidsi1 3151-3nuisofI bns ansol 3isl-b3xfi 8nibIod a .(lah 3351-129133(11) 238115113 oiIoItioq

.1th 3351-3a3131n1 bns Ath 1ib313 chiod a163d Ansd

.'13ia1sq3a bI3d bn b3bafl b3ahq 3d 03 Aah 3351-323131(11 bns Ath 11b313 3(11 wolla aqaw

1153 ,ktad £ 18rIt1I .eaw owl ni Ath 335-1-325133111 brxa Ath 31b31o 33516q32 01 26W2 3W 1163 2)I11SH

1diaaoq) t1sq biirli a 1111w b3xfi 01 aqswa (13(11011w l3woTlod £ 01 nsol 3361-2n13soR5 311221

.2813111d511 8is1nu1aofl brus ansol 3351-8nhiSoft 1131w flsl ai Anad 3113 32E3 airli nI .(Ansd 131110(15

niisofl 3W acicol 1si31mcnoo (3u15v d) 1n33i3q tio1 !3Jamixo1qqs EQ1 - V'Q1 bon3q ifi v0 ' fD ni abzisii 1fls311 nia on 318 5I3dT .(bicoa 3VZ 1513b&I vwa nthnJ nb1nsalo aunT yf13i181JO)

tniThb b zLnad noma 10 llffl3VO boh3q aiili s,o ansol 1si-niisofl b 3au 3vii5131

Page 12: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

C91Cfl(94!U 4G W9LICG4 A9jnca 9uq riUGLC24-L94c 2c112!4!Mffc2 OIP91J1C 1U4GL624 L94G 2M9b bo2ruou2

J1J 41J12 2GCPOU MG qr2CITa2 4JJG 9A9!!9PIC 919 9uq On1IrIJG OflL cuJbruc9J bLoccqnlc LOL

1A J/[oqJIJ 4JJG J9LJCG4 J9JflG O 2M9b2

MpG4JJGL 4pGA 9AG pcqcq

MJJG4JJCL 4J1G P! P9IJIC2 4JJ94 0UJ1U94G 4JJG WSLJCG4 9AG U64 J0U 01. UG4 2p014 2M91) boi.q,ojroa uq

bo2Uiouw jO SLG22 4JJ12 122r3G MG uccq 40 JCUOTh 1104 )fl24 4}JC 110410119! bo2!i!ou2 0Ij)9UJC2 fl4

IAOf1 2fl8G24 4P4 P! p9UJC2 fl4 1104 2111811 9UJC2 Monq poq J9LG nupcqcq !U4GLC4 L94G 2M9b

p0qCL23 J9LG 01. 2UJ911 JjR2 2GLAG2 92 9 2np2qA 50 LaJc-crn pA soo-pr-so-r p9111c2 IP!2

ipT fluqel. 41112 bopcA LC11J90L2 cxscuqcq qcbo2s !U2(IL9IJCG 95 4G2G 9UJC2 40 COACL 811 1!9P!111A-

COUJUJGLCT9J 9UJC2 JJ9AG pecu (Lor.UJ9IJA 01. !ULOUJJ9I1A) bLosccsGq pA spc boircA ICIJOMU 92 4OO P! o

Spe LGr1JS4OLA 2A24GUJ Jç0f1}JA C0IJCiqiU M!SP spe GXI24GUCG OLSPC 2M9b2 1JJ9LJcG1 f9LG fl•

u (pA 2bGcnf9trIJ) JJJC iUcGIJ5!AG2 L01 j9LC 9IJ]C2 40 pcqc !USCLG2S-L94G L12JC W9A pc iccscq pA

J0W 5J1G 1.625 °L SPG P91J1C1XJ 2A256u? 9Uq MJJG5GL 4}JGA CJJOO2G 40 920L vqq1srou9 iu5GLC24-L956

IPG 1U46LG25-L94G L121C 5 j9LC P9151(2 qcbcuq2 OU MpGS}JG1. pcA pGqG 4156 U2JC 4L9U2GLLG

IJJOLG JJIJJJA couccusL9scq

poq!u rwpGqGq 2M9b b02r4i0U2 jJJra MOfljq JG9AG OAGL9JJ 421C UI 4156 2A256W nucjrnucq fl4

pcqc ffJG 2W9fl 9UJ(2 !U46L625L95G U2JC jJi4p GWGL °L 515626 GX9U1b1G2 19LG 9UJ(2 cuq rib

OCCI1L2 !LpOLLOMGL2 49J(G xcq-L9sG 109112 9IJ 415611 415626 2UJ9I!GL JGUGL2 2Th9b M1515 J9I2G 91JJC2 40

U0941IJ 1.9462 fl5 2M9b M14p P9111(2 50 pcqc !USGLGaI-L956 142JC E226114!9!IX 4JJ6 291116 1.621115

4156 IGAGI OLIUSGLG2S-L9SG U2JC 111 p9lJ1aU B00MG1.2 UJ1p5 pOU.0Th 0W 0156 264 0LP91J1C2 94

M9b2 UJ1J4 !IJSGLG2S-L946 1.121(50 G Lcqas14pns6q 9UI0U p9uJc2 M!SPOflS CP91JJU

415626 2M9b 4L91J29C5!0152

b9A2 U094i1J' 0116 °LP6 1221162 MC qi2Cn22 CJ0M 12 M15GS15GL J812G p9111(2 91.6 4156 SpILq b.s!G2 !

142 J09u2 MO4ICG 594 111 p0415 C92G2 5156 4JI.q bgi.jA 12 GU5GU1J 11340 9 2M9b MjI!CP LCCGIAG2 jxcq

spTLq bo22!p1A 9UOSJJGL p9uc SJJG 9UJ( cuq rib G4LGCSIAGIA LGCC!MIJ 9 095!IJ 1.946 OU

OL 4156 P9IJI( C9U 122116 9 4xGq-L95G J0911 9uq 611461. !1U0 9 b9A-xGq LGCG!AG-4J0941U 2/i9b M415 9

I0

Page 13: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

H

3vh3b 01 rn3I3muarIi ai aioi1ui or xiocpi ol b8liup3i And 1io1emmo3 sisb 3dT

iedT .arzoiiqmu2a 902 ni2oqmi iuodiiw 2311 1112(192 sii-tini io 23uIsv i3)hm 13(1119

rIoq3l sr11 bsoiani ;uI6v iA1J1m 1-Ioq3l ion ob a*iad 121ii .Eib rfi diiw 2rn9ldrnq id 331111

3t1 123131111 'to flOii3Efi 3111 bus 12O3 1fl3m33E1q31 b31163 niñ19mo2 3utsv Isnoilon 1no

bsrioqsi ai sulsv lsnoiion bno3s2 .is3 no usd1 2231 'to ihuism rxiriisrnsi s 1111W svi1svhsb

1203 lnsmsosIqs1 iud asvilsvii,b bsasd 91ai-iaslsini isrlio bns aqswa 3161 123131111 lot '13iS1Sq32

rtliw asviisvi-isb sIsi 123131111 IIs'to si sis sill io't s1no bsrioqsi sis thu1sm nini&nsi bns

alnsd 31111w llsniI .(aiuith 8nibul3xs lud) anoilqo bn.s abisw'io't aqswa nibu13ni lth iibsl3

Ion 313W srl1 8Q1 'to istisup bno3sa 3(11 11 niris1a i1sv Isnoiton rIoq3l ol bsiiupsi 313w

audT .OQ1 'to 191-isup laifi sill lilnu '1hUIBm aninismei bns 1203 1n3ms3s1qx tIoqsl 01 bsliup3l

.laoo 1n3m3361q31 no anoiisv-isado 'hstisup'to ais iuo'I '1no evsd SW

tlog3SI IlsD sill or nib1o33s 12o3 1nsmsaIqs5I .svods sulsv Isnoilon bsnhI3b svarl sW

:awollo't as ai a1nsd 01 anoilainlani

n3i-ith bus 316-1 lasiolni seoth '1no io1 3i116v is*ism-ol-±sm 3(11 [elI leoa In9mSaslqel 3(11

3viis3n rlliw 213s11no3 seoth Ion 1203 irasmsaslqsi sviiiaog £ ifliw 2136111103 3161 erisdaxs 111 bsriuani sd bluow lsrlI eaol 3(11 2B b3nflsb 211203 1fl3m9361q31 311T .e3uIsv 13)llSm-oi-)llSm

is 13511(103 3111 nias1qsi 'to 1203 isn 5(11 d b8luas3m as 11us'tsb 'tt.Sq1sinuo3 'to fl3V3 9111

.asisi ihm insliua

sisi 123131f11'to 32u533d daidw 213511(103 3aodl'to sulsv 3(11 '1no 23bu13n1 ICOQ 1n3m3351q351

sdi'to sijl.sv isrAism eiIi wo1sd sisflwlli sw as abiow isclio uI .aIseas stnoasd 3vEf1 21113(n3VOm

135't iilT .sviflaoq 211203 lnsmsas!q31 28 3(1111 smse sill is svilssn sd 'sm noiiiaoq 19(1 2)1flsd

.boo1aisbnu 1sbiw m3sa ion asob

'1hu1sm n1nismsi bus tao3 rrismsaslqsi asii1v IRnoilon no slsb alnsesiq £ oldsT

Isdi 3aiioM .bslduob usd1 s-iom asrl slJlsV Isnoilon boh9q atili -isvO Q I -OQQ I mofl 1isrisup

laifi sill nsSwl3a .lnslanoa Ion ai sulsv rnsmsaslqsi bus sulsv Isnoilon nsswlsd qiilanoilsls 3(11

ol 3ub 3u16v v ii2oq di a1113231q31 isdmjrn sdi 13111311w 21(1331103 1203 1n9m9381q31 b3tIoq3l 1111w 3u221 l3IflonA ii! .asiflsq1311w03 b kh 11b313 3fii in 2n01131Jb31 e3IElocpo3ni oals Ii 1fi9i1w io aln3m3vom tsi 12313111i 31dfilov1

3U16V 01 23W kisd 3111 fI3UfW bbom £ 1dsmzieiq ei di dnwn 1203 1n3m3351q31 iI1 lo 1001 311116 abiow u11o ,a1bom 113111 floq3i 03 b31wp51 ion s akiza .al3boin 329th luods awoml ci nis1ioT4 .23viisvil3b 9161 i2513111i cu

J2o3 1n3m33s1q31 b3floq5l olni 2'19103 )Lcn 3th313 woif iuodii noiisnriomni on 3VW1 3W 02

Page 14: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

1InC o eib boi.oi!o 1 ! 8JACU pA:

BUP LCb014 uooirnj tjnc uq i.cbccwci coai JAIqJ pC pOAC UOjOUa IpG HO(OU

qtc 14 M!W OU!U1 UrnU1LIA oo

pc JJG qOJJL °L2p014 !UGL6 LG Wb COIULC12 qc i: mpcp MCLG OuiuGq

qc j iiip oL!u9J urnuiqiA ow uq

G pc qojj wonu o jou 11uCLC21 LC 2Mb COULCj2 91 qc 1 MIJ!CP MCLC OuiirnlCq

uq LccciAG2 IJoTu iulcLc2 LC rc:

BA COIJAGIJ!OU MC 2(TWC }J JOUR !IUCLC2I LC atAb couc bA2 9 pccq !UGLC L9jC

cpu !U LGbJCCWGUl coç

2UJG GxuJb1C2 o poi i uoi boaipj€ o fUICL IJJ4CG A9IflC JU /MA ow

HC Iu qcbGuqa ou pc wnuA wrcwc o iba uq bp o !uCLC cw JAG bi.oiiqc

IPG LG1!OU2JJ!b pcnGCu LCbcCwGu CO2l /1pcp pup bLoAiqc3 uq urnI.jcc AJnG MJJ!CP

S) tcU CO%

IJJG LC OOflL wbj€ bGI4oq JAG LGIT!LII O JJ1I2flG jGU

LJC 3 JOM 1UCLG21 LC2 qccjiuCq 1jJI.OflJJ unq-j uq IJGU 1.02G UJJJ 9UIOflIU qr!4u

z iuijnucq pA pop uoiouj iujnc mq pc wnuA 24LflC4flLG o 2Ib2 jpc juj cojnwu o

wni.uA wrcwLc qcbcuq ou !UGLG LG2 JJJC GGCI O LG UJOAGWCU OIJ LCb!CCWCU1 ,Jnc

qCqAiou 49 j4CL JJJC LC19110112p!b UJOU UOPOUJ AVJflG LGbI9CGWGIU CO2 uq

OflL wbJG bcqoq JJJG prnp COJflUJU 2JOM2 U C2iwCq LWO OL Mba OUC JAG 111G

qcLAiAG2 /JJ LGWU!U WV4n14IA 0LJ6 ijrnu ouc Aci. J4OG 1p 1}IG L!O ! COJIU OAGL

Q8o\° MJMJC LCb1CCWGuf CO LO2G pA tôo\° JJJC pn.q COJJ1WU 2OH2 qic bi.obo ou O!IUCLC2 L9TC

qonpcq ELOUJ 1pG orn.p dn1.1GL oj jj aorip pc irn dncL o uopou9j ijnc LOZC

dn9x.Gi. o jo uq JJC ornp dnI4cL jj uorouj A9JflC LO2G 5Jo\O,liJJ!JC LCbjCGWCIU AflC

Page 15: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

£1

Ir\ -I- !.% '7 '7 — L) =

:d rrsvi al to inm9sIq9$1

I - '' ' M '7 '7 = \ / 1 W '3 -t dL

M 3tsb is n3flhw sq is-bxft r!1 01 qswa sulsv !snoion OO.1 sb sulsv 9r11 21

n9rIw qswa £o 3uIsv 3d1 oi anqqsd itiw 1biano3 () bnsial3bnu oT .co thuism Isniaho rftiw

s bns iaq 31s1-b9xII 3rf 1 01 i3aas its 2mo3d qswa dt ndi th atsi 'II .3nsrb atsi 123181f

inm3sIq313 3111 iii b3bul3ni ai qswa 3111 '10 eulsv 3111 audT .isq 3is1-nutsofl ñi 01 ii1idsi1

jasl3jni Ii bnsd ir1io 3111 nO .isq 3is1-nuisoR r1i wi ion iud isq 31si-b3xiI 3f11 io'1 ieo3

1no ti2O3 in3m33s1qs-? iii bebubni ai qswa 8i11'bo sutsv 3111 n3111 3bsm ai qswa £ ifis lls'I asisi

'1o au1sv 3111(i) :10 rnue erfi ai oil6thoq s '1o 3203 3n3m93s1q81 311T .isssq 3isi-nuisofl sill io'1

213511n03 'to astilav sili (ii) bns ;0 <q su1sv sviiiaoq £ svsrl bits sisi bsxa £ 'sq lEnt 21351ifl03

.0> (o2q uIsv sviiiaoq £ svsnl bits sisi iiisoft s sq isili

:ai 2135111103 qswabo oiloThoq sb uIv ls*uun silT

(f\ (t I w- '7 — V1 \V€ - V.i) =

as abaas ai3s13r1o3 qswa ils 'to mua snli ai uIsv is*tsm lath s3iion ) ol nloilsups aithi nihsqmoD

.asiiihidail as1oni laoa insms3slqs5l .asiiilidsil as IIsw

its lsbi2no3 sulv istham bits 1203 insms3alqsl rieswisd qidanoiislsi srhi snimsxs oT

.ninismsi issy sno diiw Its oiloThoq £ itl nibnsiaiuo sqswa esiiht sis sisrli saoqqu .slqmsxs

sisi niiaofl sill isth muaaA .oilo'thoq qawa sill id! anoiis3ffl3sqa t3aflno3 snhi asvi sldsT

:ai sulsv is)hsM .Q eldsTbo A 13115q) \0 (2100.0-) noillirn IZ - (200.0) noihhim 1 - (200.0-) noillirn C = 1VM

.8881Z- =

:ai 1203 iflsms3EIqsSI

Page 16: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

11

8881Z = (Q100.O-) noillim IZ - =

in3rn331q31 3Iifiw 3visn si su1v tAiim pa .*tEd sib oi issas ns 2! i3s1no3 as1 sili Ino 33ffl2

.svineoq si (sw1s as) t2o3

sib bns sulsv ishsrn sift diod ascii o\° mof! o\0 ot asnsd3 sisi anilsoft silt II

:sas3 suit a! .Q sldsTIo H Isn&1 sss) tnsisfiib sis isoo insms3aIqsl

(QOO.O-) noillirn IZ - (0) noillim !Z - (1OO-) noillirn 2 = NM

I8Z- =

baa

IV8 = (QOO.0-) noillirn 1 - = D5I

!isi1id S 1203 lnsms3alqsi iud s1qrrinxs auoivsiq sib cii nail iswol si sulav isAism os

isrlisi noilhim iri sulsv Iaaoiion sad 1 sldsT ni 13511(103 no1 siliui Isilt 53i10fl 11stiiI

moft sill! sisi issisiai sdt nsrlw ssssiorii thod 12o3 insmsaslqsi baa sulav idism noillitn 2 nsrit

o\° i tai silt nsdw sliriw 8ö881Z = ,D51 brx,s 0 = NM o\° si sisi sib nsrlW :o\° 01 o\°

3ilsmsi2\2 On 21 sisib tath 3i5li2Ulli sslqmsxs sssilT .1V8Z = ,D5I baa CQZ = NM

.1503 insms3sIqsl baa sulav ts*ism nsswtsd qirisnoitsisi

nsswisd qiclanoilslsi £ ot bssl tacit snoilqmussaIo tss Isminirn £ tnseslq won sW

cliod snsd3 sstai tasistrii cisrlw tacft iá1 silt ssu sW .sulsv ts*Ism baa 1203 lnsmsaalqsi

sw lafit flsss svsrl sw s1ui31rIts isthth tuorliiW .snsfl3 uisv isham baa ieoa insms3alqsi

snoitqmusas sill isbnU .ssiai issisini cii srtar1s sib moui snsil u1sv te*ism sill islai ionrts3

rio1) noilasiib silt tacit (ii) brt lnatsaoa si nstthw 233aiino3 srfl1o siui3znta thularn sill (i) tacit

tasms3slqsi moft ssulsv is*isrn svrisb (183 sw 3nat5c1O3 osla si nslthw 21351tn03 wsn Io (tiorls io

worDl sw tacit 8nimussa asciI istssw sis snoitqmusas sssdi tacit 33!toM .ssulsv lanoilon bits 1503

si noii33lib silt tacit smusas lno sw ssnia nsflhw atasitnos wsnIo (tiorla io rio1) rtoitasiib sib

.srnii 13V0 trIalsnO3

Page 17: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

' EO uA w j4 &uq K <:

IACIJ Wf1LJA I? 1}JC 29IJJC OACL 4!WC LCLq1Ca OLMPCIPCL C COUjLC ! 10 01. JJO14

ijxcq OACL 1UJC JJI1 2f1IJJb!OU ao ipc bLobo1.iou O COULC12 JJ 91.6 /AI4UCU O

y2nuJbpou j rni ipc bLoboI.iou 0j co1u1.9c 1M.GU p91 91.6 O 9 JA6U W9W41A

\. J0L 9IJA wnuA Co uq !a2n9ucG qc f =

/JG 92f1UJC JJG ojJoHqu:

+ V ('x)

tpi2 JwbpG fp9:

()

9uq

.'cv= _____________—

wnuA 0) p9 9L6 LC2bCCrACJA' jou 9uq 20I4 sic:

jpcif jJc 9LG2 0 IJGM COIU1.9C12 !U C)2iCUCC 9 MCLG I1LUCU 9 q916 J4 /Iqlp 014U9J

= + (t)

IJCIA COU4LC ouirnJcq J4 44bLobol4!ou 0 UClA C01U1.9C 11J91 9LC J0U 9IJq potr jO qo JJIa' UL2 qCJuG 1JJ6 U01!0U91 A9Jf10 0

C0UL9C12 /ALI6U bGI4oq u .G oL W9WIA w (ao' r = j j0 MW pG

jo nuqci.&uq qic 922nwb!ou uccq OWC quou r p 4JJC J3C!0U 0j UClA

Page 18: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

ELOW y22nwbiou j mc JOJOM ijrni:

E 1)} 1 1 - E{c) ,

qc OLwnufA 0) 91.C FP!IrC2 ! JO, <O J40PA 1.GThLG LGbIcCWCIJl C021 2

9 qc ! I,O 5 O !11Jllt!A JCI (pO,) po 11JC 2C1 OIC2 2flC 1J1 C0UILCI2 M14UCU OU

FC { } pc IJJC 2C °L qc 211CJJ 1JJI COULC12 MI4UCU 011 IJJ q4c 0 WVWL A o c

10 ML1C LGbI9CGUJGIU co mc uccq o qlqqc bLc/on2jA MUff Cu C0ULC2 !UO 22Cf2 uq

11CM COUtLC2 PA1CJJ MC 112C pC0m

!u (g) rn2 ouc cdrwou uq ouc nuaIoMzJ OL ccp bcuoq 2oJuR T2 2A2Gw ocdniou2 RIAG2

jrnAc uo iccpcq urnuaA (uc 14> - w) (NACU uooirnj A11C 9IJq IJJC pC 2X21GW ocdnrou2

Ed11!0U (3) 2A2.1p IJOIOU9j AflG 12 WC 211111 °Lfl CoI4Lc2 muucu w pc b (rca 9 qc2 Ii) pi

= (8)

V22f1uJbi0u I JjOM2 112 10 C14AG 11GM COIJIL9CI2 0W 110110U9J JLG uo!ouI Aj11C

M1JCU 1JA !mc !2 COU291U IJC4!0U opc lOiVj COIUI2CI2 muucu 91 ijrn !WG)

jaonRp iuJc (y22nwbiou j 2iq JJG 211W ojouR uq 2p0L1 CO1111C2 O RIAGU wjnu

22nwb!ou 2A2 WC c!ou oucmiA Mucu souR COU13C2 mqJ wrn4tA 0) couur

=

OL cw ACJA 2cq:

=J2

Page 19: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

ThTCJJ 12 11J6 cdniou mG 112Co juq jou uq 2L1 amb bo2ilioua

= (1Q)

jpcu:

(1?)

mJq qcuc 'ro pe pc icuomu oi. 22tTWC i.pjca ou pc Lp-pmiq 2qc o(J3):

= 'c + \, \&C (j4)

qcjuc jç o pc pc cJ-puq aiqe o(J3):

Ct + = E (J3)

pc 4CUJJ2 'U (j) jrni qo uo qcbcuq ou

1° C2UUJC 1JC me LGEALUG (j) iuccqic , ou1A bbc tu pc jL2 ac o 2numJ!oua puu

= - (13)

fl2iu VaanuJbl!Ou 3 LcbIccuJeu C021 C9U pc mucu:

= >- - (jj)

oL cmuiu:

= - \\ ViC -

2flP2!W1C pT2 !'U° BC

= + (ro)'.3'

Page 20: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

81

sii-iutsm 3111 ;(8) flW bnft 3w 113111W e13flno3 W311 5th (1) floilSLJp3 (Ii 3!dSflV 311T

sldssv s a iii 2b33'I rbirlw '°A 1s1ua1 ns 3w .233nq briod briE ;et3Enno3 w3111o 31u13LrIi2

3(13 idI bevlo2 3d (1S3 (1) id3 8riiaIJ (1>1) moII D51 E3thrrn3Isb noilsrmolni ms 3rIT .(ôl) ni

:8111Ev isfiam vi I = + 0! 3iin3bi 3(13 niw (E) olni 1 3111 riiu1q .01

(VI) ck 0J —

3lqmi2 £ iqobB 8W .anoiri2oq E2 b iivi3i2n3a 3iE1-3sis3ni 8113 ni b3lesistni o21c 31E sW

(Ii 3flEfl3 3(11 21 siiviii2n82 31S1-323131 lErli anurnuas d viti2n 31-sxnu1o noilinft3b

:(l3bom 811133(1132 rrn3 1o331-3no s .3.1) 3V1113 b13i 3(13 111 uIula 13I!ElEq £ mofi 3111Ev i3fiEm

(81) = _____

32313311111311W e3nq aon&b briod noquo £ won no 2bn3q3b qEw2 3(1310 33fl 3113111 3nsIf3 31IT

b13ii 3(11 lii 111(12 !31161Sq £ bo flOilS3iuiIqmie 3dT .uqrno3 ol b1svno13r1iB132 ai 2irlT .eisif3 233E1

.3110 flOfflfflO3 £ 21 3V1U3

u1tV t1inM nibniI io1 ,1ub93o19: Iciiiqma 3dT .V

t.K

1l2U 3VOdS 13b0(fl 8113 ni3s1di1E3 d 23thviIian 33E1-123131n1 bnE 23LJISV i3hBrn brift 3W

bn 3W 23iivi1ian32 81s1-323-191rn bna 23111Ev 13hsm 3361113183 oT .fiiEb 3IdSliEVE

3aO3 ir13m33E!q31 ':D (1)

23tSb noiisniho bris 23iinutfim 3n313fi1b 10 EEW2 1db 283r1q, (ii)

bnE \irIu3sm 'd nsflr w a33613n03 W811 b noi33ft 3(1j ,

0\ (iii)

.boh3q d n 113131w 2135131103 W311 , YA (vi)

lo noilosli 3(13 1 31±xuq 3(13 111 r1i2eirn edT .233hq bns 1203 tn3m3Qslq3l no LiEb 3vErl 3W

.3IJISV Isnoiion no slab fI12u 2136111103 W8fl bnft 1183 8W 1 n3vit) .a1 d3 n33thw 213E13fl03 W311

Page 21: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

'q''O opuIc, v,b boi.qpfro2jo jic cxcu jrna!b2p1c iJjWWJiJC2 o LjCL j.rsu jAC iic nuqcczpujc pc wjcic-ic

ow (j)lITó2iD. E!'J1 !"" WG 1 U qG4AG 'J J°' (J )q !UTGL6LG 2GU2!!1!

()) io iwbo2c 1pG2G COU2L91LJT2 MGU MG c9-jipL9G MG ric dnqLc bI.oL9uJu3u (2cc qJcA

COUTLCt2 JIJ ccp WUIUA PflCICCI W 1O1J O GCp opc wn pc pcMccu o uq j (2cc

(j me qccI.wiuc yc iupc j j uq j, jjic2c cou.c2bouq o JG J.cTioua o

Hi1W OfIL G2 I1JJ9C2 OU€M COULC2 MG cu fl2G (j)o qecuinuc Iou boou p3

q!' TO JjOM IOL UJWL1TIG2 9T !G2T 22 JOIJ 92 AG ?tGL2

urnwuTA o ouc dneL !U TJJG TIL2T drnn4cL OJ I ôô0 JjJfl2 OfIL UGM COUTLCT2 qT U19TCjJ OflL

jow COUTLCT ouyc AcL2 mi.cu !u pc ccouq dn14cL o jg Mij pvc g

J3 jiijc mc ouX JJSAG LcbI9ccwcIu CO2T q9 2TI4!u !u mc cjcnjc ucm COUTLCf2

dnctjA OIJ UOIiOU AjFIG OUJ TPG 2ccouq dncL o TpI.onp Tpc j,onip dnUcL o

QfAGU 2nwbTfou2 OU WflL1TA 2TUTCTflLG3 MG CjCflJUTG IJCM COULCI2 niu ( jc jJAG

wnuTA Tp9u ouc Aci? flT i.c LcdrqLcq 1o pojq cbij JOUGL-TCLIJJ 2m9b2

2pO-TcuJJ 2Mb2 2113cC pUJ2 Lc UOT LcdnLcq o pojq cb! 91U2T 2Mb2 M!TJJ LGW9!IJ!U

To wcp TC Lcboi4cq q ou L6UJ9UJ1U uqA IT !2 uoj 2nLbuaTu pup AG ojpc CfEpLWOU bLoccqnLc IGC2 (T2 TO pGAiJ? MG1JT TJJC Q- j Aesi. WTr1LUA pncJccj 111OLqGL

'c/-22nwbpou f pc urnuiuA 2TUICTfILG oi amb COUTLC12 ! 222ff WCq TO G COU2T9UT OAGL TIUJG

couic o ipc uJbJicq Lcw9!rnu urnTrluTfc2 wcy TG Lcboz4cq Lcwuu UJ9TfIqT!62 fluqeL

AGL uq LG9TGL TJJU OUG AGL OfIL 2TLTGA ! TO C!PLTG TPG LIrnTrIL!TA 2WICWLC oi, UGM

AJ1W O JIJTGLG2T LTC qeuATAc2 (cxcnqu pjnLc2) mp LGUJ9HJIU w9TfluTic2 o rnu ouc

UJWUTA 2TLfICTflLG TIJT P1J1C2 LcbOLç 2!UCc JØ p911Jc2 JJ9AG pecu LcdnLcq io Lcbou TG uOT!ouv

uq AcL2 () fiG GGLUJUC TPG 2 pA C9IipLT!OU fl2!I3 TC ouc bicce OUL0UifOU ou

!uro yc PflCJCCT2 pA 1u1T191 wnuA: -j Aci. (J j- Xcta( Aci. (5) - ACSL2 (L 3Y

Jc 922flWG TPT !'!T!I 2M2b UJTfTL!TIG2 LG PGTMGGU XGLO 9Uq AG AcL2 D/4qc 2Mb2

TG bbLobuTc WflIJTA 2TLnCTIILC

2!UCC TPGLC LG 110 9T OU TjJG WTr14TA 2TLI1CTJILG O UGM CO1JTLCT2 MG (12G !uqLccT WG9IJ2 TO pq

Page 22: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

uü 1UftI%1 (1

-io b3rloq3l is vod b3noin3m as sab 'iiiutam nnismi rf3 bns iaoQ n8m33s1qs$I

ig oT .Ino aqswa iii bta91:th x5 w 1iifw (aiuiJ1 8nibuI3x3) 23v1i5vr19b is ia,in us

in3m3351q31 3tft id! nuO335 o i3dmun btIoq31 3d au1ba 03 b33n SW aqswe b 3a03 inSrnS3sIqSl

srlr bsnimsxs sw sisb sift 3Eu1b5 ol wod snirrrisbb oT .asvi3svhsb s3si iiini qswa-nonbo taO3

mofi sisb ansas-iq sldsT .asuisqrno 8rIiblod 1nsd 001 qol silt bismixoiqqs'bo 2rioqsi Isunri

isilto Esisvsa aulq 1 sldsT iii bsteil aarüb!orl qswa s-isI iltiw aArisd ..U sdtbo atioqsi Isunn.s sift

lcunns lnsd mofi aqswa no stsb sift wor1a sldst sdT .anoiiieoq qswe in&ftinaia ultiw a1nsd sgisl

.sulsv Isrioiiorx 03 3203 insms3slqsibo oiisi silt bna 3203 iflsmS3BIqsl uIsv Isnoi3on :anoqsl

isw1 bns) taO3 insmsaslqsi tioqsi alrisd srWblscl ruods 'lno quoi aiuit iii risys srh soiioTlI

3nsmsoslqsibo oitsi sift I2o3 3nsrns3slqsi tioqsi tsdi alnsd Silt riomA °'(8Ulsv' io*ism tioqsi

.(sldsi sift iii nworla ton si aidi rluortt srnii isvo bits) ainsd aeois asrisv sulsv Istioiion 03 32o3

-flOfi 115 io1 sulsv 15(10130(1 03 3203 trtsms3slqsi 10 oii1 silt no stsb ifls2Siq SW noahsqmoo £

floqsi Isurtns sift 8n133s13du2 d stsbbo asi-isa tasi airft io sW .asvitsviisb Sisi tistiti qawa

asvitsvnsb stsi tasisini ioI stsb smse silt mo-fl aqswa io1 23203 insmsoslqsi bits asulsv Isnoiton

io1 nsdt aqswa idi isr1id 'lIsiris ai oitai silt isili awoda sidsi silT .aDtocis5l haD silt iii bstioqsi

rloulw anoiiqo asbuI3ni '(losts3 "isdio silt ssnia bst3sqxs 21 aiilT .asvitsvhsb stsi iisini isrfto

.iivitins St51-t2SiSifli TISWOI £ SyBil

qswa-non lob oiisi silt nath isdid 10 03 Istips at oitsi qswa Silt taut 232su2 31(1ST

sw ?how tssniqms iuobo taom idi stab i-ioqs$1 IISD no vlsi sw 33fli .asviisvi-isb stsi tasistni

'b stsmitas ns is ot (asvitavhsb stsi tas-istal his idI) 3203 insmsaslqsi bstIOqsl tan jbs

sift nioubsi llsnoirioqoiq avloviti inmt1bs silT .aqswa stsi iaistni io1 3203 iflsms3sIqs-I

stal tasisini b sulsv Isnoiion silt 'b oitsi sift 'd anogs5l haD silt ni 3203 tflsmsDslqsl bstioqsi

rftiw bstrismiisqxs sW ".asiutdI qsxs avitv'iib sun tasisirli hIs b su1v Iarioiioii suit 03 aqswa

tafis ion bib noitqmuaas 335x3 silt tart bnudl md sldsT ni sd bs3sibni snsi silt iii aoitsi isrlto

.atIusi viis1iIup sth

.avi-ib iai tasistni IL o1 3203 Jnsms3a1q1 bshocpi quoi i1J flu 2)IflBd iii3O °' 03 bism sis di aus3sd 3203 3n3m3sIq31 ois a vsñ awitft nia awitftlo uIv 1noi1on 3di 3bubx W

Page 23: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

qcbcuqcq uou ucq) ou -Act uq j-Acut jLcuzml pouq zutcLcEi L9tc2PCVCCU BUICL ILIi 9ug BLOCtOL 9uq O"PW lpc )8JflC OfJJC B9IJICCLE lUIEt-bLOCtOL uq Q9upJC EIA9b

En99GEt tpt qic bLoboU!ou o cxorc visb2 c umq vu cxwbjc oj 9U exotic visb E tpc qcjqic bcccut couijqcucc lcAcj jjic q1ntcq j oqic LGLC2VOU IE Øfl

1IpGLC (aubtof9J)! 2 pc Lso o aiiuba to ujj iugctc wtc qcuA9qAcE OL p9IqCZ iu boi.qpjrn r vu cocwcxciu c

- j (visbtowj)1 -Ot (wb\toti)LCWuTLJ1IJ w9WU = - O (a btog9J)' -oi (v bajoi) - (ai9ba\gotsJ)3

jjrc caqumtcq LGLCEE!OU 2:

bo2itiou2 91-C C02G 0fl G91-JX jO tpc GXtGIJt W91 2M9b2 b02!p0U2 91-C cjoacq buoi. to W9U1I4tA JAG

pip1A !UtGLG2t-L9G 261J21t!AC13 E0flJ1 MC &221IUJG 2M9b2 81-C pcjq tO W8tn14tA 0WC 2M9b

8 2J!pt1A 2POL1CL qfIL9tOu EC01!C 2M9b2 91.C 2I1J9 !" U0t!ou91 Affjf1C prit t}JC2G 2M9b2 UJA pe

STJ 9uJoLt iu jou (2ncp 92 8 powc wo1a9c) qcciuca jC2G 9LC pJc bI9iu A9IJI!!9 2M9b2

2/A9b2 9AC 8 U0t!OIJ9J A91nG tJJ9t GCJfflG2 OAGL tPC JII9 otpc 2M9b wcicp 92 t6 buucJb9j qnc ou

tpc OtJJCL tAbce o 2M9b2 1JJ91 p911Jc2 1L9qG 91-C 8W0L1!ST1J 2M9b2 uq exotic 2/A9b2 vwoI4isiu

2M9b2 91-C 1JJC atL9iJJtOLM9Lq bJ9iu A9fflJJ9 xCq-OLjJ09tiu COU1L9C12 q12Cn226q 9pOAG '1JJOIJ

ccouq c1-Cq!t U2Jc nucconutcq LOL lu 0IIL C9JCflJHt!OIJ' j1L MG 92EflWC 1P91 Ij !U1CI.C21 L91G

I.9tJJCL tJJ9U 1LC92nLA B'll L91C2 rjojc q jLG92IILA L9tC2 91-C Pflt UOt bcq,ccqX coacJ9tCq

!wbllc!t 922flUJbtOJJ2 !u tpE CSJCflj9t!O1i E!1-J 2iA9b COIJ1L9C12 ObjCffJ1A 9LG iuqcxcq to rmoic

bl.1CG2 91-C C9Cf1j91G fI2IJ !utCLC2t L9tG2 0u if 2 0AGUI1JJCUt 2CCfIUtTG2 jC1-G 91-C LOfIL

j9pJG 3)

8 LCUJ9iU1U w9tnuA 0L jCEE tpu ouc AG9L (2cc tpc COJIIUJU pcqcq qn2tGq bcLcGut lu

IJJ9ITILItA L9frO Lo1- 2M9bE jJJG L9t!0 !2 LCJ9tIACIA COU219IJ1 M1IJ 8 WC9tJ 0 33 2o\0 0L2M9b COU1L9C42

2GCt!0U /JG fl2G JJG c2trw9tcq COCWC!Gut2 J0W t}JC LGLC22iOu 10 COU2tLI1Ct tpc LCW9irnu

qrIUJUJIGa L01- tPC L9tIO °L EM9b2 to t0ti !UtGLC2t L94C CUAWAG OLtPC j!C bo.o1ro2 lu CL022-

tpGLcboItGq LCUJ9TIJ1IJ w91rlU1A L9t!0 LOL 9Jj !UtCLC2t L9tG GLA91IAC2 OU 911 !UtGLCGbt VUq a1obc

2MVbE ic 9a2J8ucq to ouc o yc boi.tLoJio2 (92 I2Cfl22G !u tpc 2npEGdncut 2GCIJ0U) pJG 1-GI.G22

1PGLGLOLG MG G21!W91G 1PG 1-9110 L°1- 2M9b2 n2u !uqiAqflVJ qst B9u1c2 poJqu IIUGLG21 L91C

JAonjq 111cC 0 112G JJC [9110 L°'- iutGLG2t LVtG 2IA9b2 L9tPCL tJJ9U L°1- 9 !U1GLG2t 1-9tG qc4AVtiAcw

1-VtC 2M9b2 111911 L°t O1JJCL IU1GLG21 L9tC qcuAVtAc2 UCC MG t912Gt 11112 1-9110 111 OflL CVI!pL9t10u MG

1PC L9t10 °L LCUJV!IJIU WVUIL!tA IeEE tJJ9U ouc XCVI. tO uOt!ouVl AVIfIC 12 JCLGU1 U)1- !U4GI.G21

Page 24: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

b8t3ftB Son sis 'tiviiian tsi-Sas-iini1o aismit2 -iuo v9woH .'thuism isiini 3iEmii13bruJ

.ithd

noi)iw'I qztw sii$I SitnI 'm3t nbtnfl 9d5 b uktV b*iitNl .IV

1t!Vt?A UUTh1 *V1 ( upinrbS noilsidilsa iuO .iocfw s s m.te'a anblnsd r1 is IooI w fIo!i332du suuiS iii

W .(! noiiqmu2aA) irislsrioa ai nflhw 2136151103 wn 1o 3lu13lnia ihu5sm c11 isfil amuas diw aqswa o noirioqoiq biioqi nsm &it daism ot (°1 3d5) elulalni2 'ihuism £ aooda

1115521103 1svii1si si noifioqoiq aids awor1a ( 1dsT aA .-ts no nsrli aflo thuism aninism3l

eupiriu s ion ai 319115 oania 13vo31oM .(sisb 3vsrf ew 113111w ldI boh3q 1rxo 9th) a0Q1 rh nhub

'isv W .'°Ylo arn3iisq idi snimsx3 3W a3ithuism r1inism31 bstIoq3l riliw 511352121103 flo i r1bIs3qa 1r1uoi auboiq OS is no nsd -iia-x a3ithulsm Is11ini aqswa io1 aisbud sf11

Isiflni 1s3-3no 'isvo '10 atasIinoa -idi es-w53Ln52 sihuism bsqsda-U s1eisvni bits bsqsda-U isf1

=:°1 msflsq bsqsr(a-U sift ;81 .0 = = = = "1 bns 8.O =01 ai msflsq is!! r1T .'thtiisrn

= ="1 =°'1 ai rnsflsq bsqsr1a-U1sa-x3vrIi sift bits ;1O.0 = '1 bits L0 = = "1

= = £1 bits I0.0

ioI .aAnsd Isiaisrnrnoa 2.IJIo artoitiaoq qswa s1s31s stlt io'1 atluasi edt awoda sldsT

isrlI 2t3STfIO3 qswa '1o nOL3Efi nssm sr1 2rtoqs1 sidsi sf11 enoiisdiIs3 lrtsifiib ir1t srli 'lo class

niau auIsv 13*ism sluqmoa ot beau sis asiamiias sasdT .(I-°1) 'ihuism Isilini dass io'I no1 31S

assixia sill -io'1 asldahsv sasrl1 '10 u1v nssm sdT .

(81) 8111w asitiviiians sisi-Sasisini bits (VI)

.iivi1iansa 123155111 sf15 'lo noiisivsb biabnsi 3(11 1111w isc113oj nworla sis EQQ I -OQQ I alstIsup b 2(153(11 £ 21 msiaya gnblnsd sth ni iiiip3 IsioS 5111 oi iiviiisnsa jasisiffi sdlbo oiiai sdT

Isnfl srli ni gsvi ai oiisi silT .'flviiiaria 12513111i sili b 53fl631uu1812 31111011033 5111 ninicrnsisb

.s1ds 5± 'lo woi

no! sill is rioda lud asiihuism 5-toda is 8nol tsn no sis alnsd isdi awode sidsl silT

'io'1 o-ts ol saola ci 1 31111w 5110 Isups II bns 0j SsdS baIl sw ertoiisidilsa ssidi ils ioI .asiihuisrn

qswa s1ssis sill -to'! sulsv Sshsm £ sisisns 1 sift bits I silT .25263 351111 ili'1o owl

Ci iaoa irismsaslqsi OS sulsv islism bstsmilcs '!o olisi nssm srh eslqm.sxs 351(11 silt nI .oi!o'thoq

Page 25: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

bria 2rs iftod isth qwa bloc! thiad aucJ el 2111T .tn313q tiic1i bns ni rI33wi3d

.23iii1idi1 3(11 iuo in ion aob 1203 1113m33Elq31 bn.s 23iiilidsil

e)1nd 2i3Sflno3 3rifIo iaom t&fi nssm a3ithu.tm tIod2 3(11 iii no1 is 2And i&fi Iâ1 2111T

sihuiam b3qEd2-U 3111 io1 .3nol a in3mom im i bloc! di a131ino3 3rlflo leom brIE ihw 1o woi I2EI 3111 ) i1o112 ai3anno3 anui2ixs 3111 b l3tIEup-3no (tEch 2231 31qmsx3 io1 31ui3i.rtia

123131(11 diiw e3gnBrI3 noiiiaoq 113(13 b 3ulsv io*zsm &h woif au 1133 ion 23ob 2i113 iua .( 3ldsT

33E1-123181n1 3rIT .at3ElinoQ rlod2 113111 (tEch 'inui&n (Ii 19r1or1e 31E 233s13r103 rto1 113(11 33(112 231E1

13no1 3111 331112 ithutEm ,8rto1 di b cIoita3lib 5rli no 1ivs3d iom 2bn3q3b i1Viii2fl32

.23W1&l3 elsi 123133ff! 01 3v1312n32 iom 915 23tinutsm

123193(1! (11 325313(1! (15 28iifluiSffl isrtol 3(13 ff1 tiode 33(1 21 m8t2\2 3nblnsd eth 32u539H

'd noii29up 21111 2231bb5 Ii33iib ns W .rr13i2'2 nb1nsd di ru iiup3 3bo13 '12U0fl82 bluo3 23151

V ivo 81311w 3-1uiomi2 'ihuism b3qsda-U 8(13 idi n3vI .i1viii2r132 3351-325133(11 fluiS1U3IE3

3(13 isrh iiis3xbni 8vi3s88f1 21 3wi3i2n82 8151-323183ni noI sis 233513(103 3(13 b 3f19313q

'3wiiian32 33s-I-328133n1 2noirs-Idi1s3 osufi 8(11 io1 .oda in s13vii33fl3 21 310(1w 5 25 oilo'Iiioq

IniOi 2331Jb81 23151 325133(1! (Ii 825313(11 itIiOq 2i2Sd 001 £ isth 2fl53(fl aIIIT .3.0- ol E- mo-fl 23W151

3351-325133(11 b3rtoq9-i 8th id woif s oT .noillid £Z bns noililin 0$ n33w33d d iiup3

sulsv 3lEib3crrl3ini 3(11 niU .m3i2'a nthisd d3 ft (flup8 1iot 3(13 0311 31Effl03 2i 'iiVi3i2fl32

iiup3 )lnsd 283ub31 29361 323133(11 ni 825313(11 inioq aia&d 001 s 1-bo 3iviii2n32 3361-125133(11 10

3sdi nu3s3ibni 23rnoq 2125d OOE bris 00 n33wisd d qu 3(13w IQQ1 ru 23351 328133(11 .o\° d .iiup3 23ib0 o\0IO( 1i1guoi lEol 3vsrl bluoa m3i€'2 nb1nsd 8(11 noiislo2i LI! 25W2 16 flDI00l

)1nsd isdi '1qmi ion a3ob 2mb1od qsw no 3JAv ins3FhnBi2 3201 e)Irlsd df isrli nibnfl 311T

3(1102 dauorliIA aaniblod lnsd 13(110 b38b311 ovart 'sm 2noiIi2oq qsw .QQ1 nhub 11s1 'tiup3

-m3122 a3vi3svn3b no 282201 O 32t1633d 1iup3 i2n1585 arlwob-3ii-Iw 1rIs3flinie 113)163 3vsrl dnsd

no11332 uI .231111 fluiflU033E '(I0iSlLJ8i d bsuu2s3m 25 32681 is b8rui133b ion asri 3iup3 8b1w

.b3ab3cl 315 2noiiIaoq qsw 1131(1w 03 3n3ix8 8111 eioIqx3 3W llV

b3rqx usuit woI b3tIoq-i ailnsd Is3b t81E1 miii isdi bots3ibni 2floq1 wn b irtsv £ 4QQ1 IriqA 8vcd ainsd iau-bti ifio bus no!!3M nO nEa ni ioM .232201 nibsii 23viiEvhb lo 32iJ533d aciicns,

.añisvhb no 2o1 b3tIoq3l 0215

Page 26: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

LCffJ9(OL2 qnLJu WIICJJ O (p12 bcuoq (2cc oowofc 1! o wc 2CAGU OWCL pqcJJJ 2fU. LCb014 J!2 CJU W!OL qCL P3UP PfU ' cXCI1qC CU(!UCU1 BU1C pccn2c u iis couj1ojcq pA

pujc Lu boi.ojio Q)

() 4pC 40b 41JIL4A pgujc) pA getg 22C42 ow jj-j cxcjnqiu 4G qcjct

JçcboI4 (roo3)12.

(I) 4J1G 2GAGU jgtc qC9JGL pUJC2 LU g H0(12G UJC1IJ COWIJJ!44GG .pU0L14A

MG O1.UJ C1}J4 bot4LoLro2:

pCqiu bntboae 10 GXWUC qJ2 MG q14qc pujca !u4o bo1oj!o2 pA 21sC uq amb c4iAA

20WC JLC puc 2bccJC !U u4CuJJCqr4iu U4cLG24-L4C U,2C M!JIIG 04CL p9ujc2 1126 2M9b2 0L

wA 112G 2Mb2 OL qicLcu4 LG20U2 4JJU O4pGL pujc2 joi. cxgwbjc' 2Mb bo2j4iou2 wA qici. q

2mb c4ui4A 12 C0UCGU4L4G s g ujgjj unwpcl. opujc2 JjJ12 2(18G242 4P4 4JJG2G pup

1Y %WOU %U-U Zt '4IO1? 'iuz

C024 AC4 0111 bLoccqnLc AJCJq2 g SCLO UJLJCG4 jflC OL uA iucLpgujc 2mgb2

g UC4 SGLO LGbfCCWGU4 C024 B4 0(11. &G4iou bioccqriic A16jq2 g bo2!41Ac 1.CbjCGUJGU4

9&c4c LcbJccwcu4 C024 A!GM!U8 4JJG iuqn24LA g g MpOJc uA C0U1.gC4 pG4MGGU 4M0 puc

4JJG 4O49J .0Z2 gC4IM5A 1P12 qOG2 U04 ru4toqnce IJA btopjcw2 11140 0(11 gUgJA2I2 pccnc Mc

iu4cLpujc 2Mb2 1P(2 4J1G MC (126 LG 1104 4JJG bo2ou 04G pujqu 2A24C11? J14 1.4pCL

ouc rI.wcL bo!u4 coucGw2 !U4CLPJ1c 2Mgb2 JU 0(11. MC qo U04 UC5 0(14

dnjiwiACJA cpuc 0(11. Lc2nj42

(121U 04GL wg4f1L1A 24IJICWLG2 Cj!pL4Gq ou 4$IG LGboL4Gq LGIJJ91U1U IJJ9UIU4A q062 U04

2!wbj!4 LGb014!1J JJGUCCLOL4J? MG 2JJOM oujA 4C J4 W9411UA 24Lf1C411LC H0MGACL

UJflU4A 24LITC4fILC 1116 tG2flJ42 gte dnj,4g4iAGJA 2iUnj91. 0L gjj 4JJLGG WUTU4A 24111C411LC2 1°

4G L0fl241JG22 0 0111. g2nwb4i0u2 !2 40 2CC JIOM oni. LC211j42 cpuc g2 MG AgI.A 5116 922nwCq

IJJgnIJA 2SIJTCIJ1LC 0 UGM C0114L9C42 01. GLLOL2 U OflL 9q1112SUJGUS2 50 4C qsw OUG mA 40

pujc2) yuA CLLOL2 LU 0(11. LCboLsGq Ag1r102 cowe ow GI.L0L2 HI 0(11. g22nwb5rou2 poris spe

cjipL5iou OU 4J1G CUS!LG bobnj&4!ou 0pSUjC2 JJJGLC 12110 2UJbjpJ CLLOL (!c MG 112G ou

J.4051C6 SJrnS MC LCbOL4 110 241J9L CLL0L2 HI !pJC 11112 !2 pcnac MC 112C g

Page 27: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

iii ton tud noit[id ?Z nzill 18tz1 al8aas 8i3V5 if tiw aqswa nibIod alnsd () () io (1) aoitoThoq

noiIlid bns rioillid I risswtsd at aas ssisvs ci 11w aqswa aniblocf aAnscf () ;noillid IZ bits noillim OOZ nsswisd atsaas esisvs rliiw aqswe niblod thisd ()

cii tori tud noi11id Z risrlt is1ssi atsas ssisvs dtiw aqswa nib1od ot a*iad (ô)

io (I) aoildihoq

;noillid bits noillid t nsswtsd atsaas sgsisvs iftiw aqswa riibIorl otc alnsd (V)

I bits noillirn OO?. nsswisd atsaas ssisvs if 11w aqswa niblod alnsd (8)

.noillid

aiiIt ob oT .aqswa sbul3ni isrlt aoiloThoq svft silt id! a,ithutsm qswa silt sisidils3 01 irtsw sW

gninismsi bsi-ioqsi rI3ism oX (oitoThoq d3ss idi) atositno3 wsn id! siuiinia thu1sm z 8200113 SW

fistIriw sis 2t3511n03 wsn 1o noitioqoiq tnsJano3 £ isdI asmuaas Isbom silT .sv'ods as thuisrn

wsri niti-iw sis thtsd isilt rrnflnO3 01 svsd sw noiismidlrü 1no silT .1hutsm rbss iliiw

iss sno nsdt aasl ii 11w 2135-iino3 qswe 1o oitai bstsmitao 811 1 21 anoitioqrnq iflEtafIo3 (Ii 213511fl03

- OQQ I silt io'I 'thuism riinism,i aworla V sldsT 1.at3s1ino3 qswa Istot 01 'thutsrn nnisrnsi

sno risrlt aasl ihuism ninismsi1o noitioqoiq silt C - I aoiloThoq io9 .oiloThoq d bohsq QQ1

ssa) aqswa ws1 blod equoi saoth tud - aoiloThoq silt id! oa aasl aitI .sldsta 1svitslsi al iss' g sldsT

sw isdi ta-ifi sioM .aqswa btorl isrIt a?lrlsdIo aoil6thoq svft silt id! i1usi ainsasiq 8 sldsT

- aojlomoq .asithuisrn aninisms-i bstrlisw-u1sv silt no bsasd '1srsisqsa eoiloThoq silt sisidiIs3

sift cI bSts3thni at thft) aislssb as bits atsau-bns as itiod '(1 vU35 qswa 13UblI03 oilomoq iii a)Iflsd silt 1o 'nsM sasdi lgisns ni isvswoH .(nolisi3oa2A isIsCI qsw2 Isnoitsirisinl silt 10 aiscjrnsrn Sis aAnsd sasifi Isifi 1351 1I 1ut .oilnoM apsw2 slqmsxs öì ssa) I oilolnoq ni alnsd nwlt tivii3s slsb aas! 1vi1b vil alnsd

.( .q ssa) asviisvhb sisi 12515rn1 ioI irw1sm twiismsi bsi-ioqsi sill lo enoiisnndlansii issitil taul sin aIUfluIo3 aiiiT

.(noiezsisi Instniaulbs silt io1 I ionioo1 aLncd [nubivthni io1 instano3 21 213silno3 WsnIo swtin3z ihwsm sill mill asinuzas siiJbsoiq no mill sloM

slsIdils3 ol nimqmsnn wrfT .tnstano3 Ion nsflo al iss sno nsdi aesi Iiiuistn ninismsi b nolfloqoiq silt snoai aiifT .noiisrrrzdlni lnnoiiibbs lilIninssm svhsb ol salon tbum ooi 25311b0ilni anoiliaoq Ansd lsublvibni

.2iasd Lnsd-d-Lnsds no nilidilss nzilj isibsi aoiloThoq nno'1 sw noassi

Page 28: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

thuisrn bsmuaas smsa sth su 5w oa asithuism ninismsi sm rf I 1stsmixoiqqs svsrf 4

.511u13mi2

nod2 iud 1 bits 1 '1 0I) asithuisrri 3-toria sth cu 8noI 515 a[rtsd sgisl tsrLt 2worIa sidsi sifT

oiloThoq sifT .a,isvsi 1ifuoi rnsflsq airfi asassiosb sia alrisd aA .(1) thuism Iasno1 sri I ni

no1 sri I iii nol bits ('I brts 01) asiihuism oda sill iii horla ai oiloThoq thisd lesllsrn2 sill duiw

qswa slnil svsd alnsd islisma sri larli bairn ni qssl ol insl-ioqmi 2i II •(l bits I) 2siifluism

.1th slsi-las-islni sabsd at alnsd Llsrna 101 rn2uclsrf3sm ismhq sill ion sis 1iss1o 2qsw .'livi1as

si 'ivi1ians2 lasisinilo ulsv -isllob sill qsw l2orn nib1or1 thid sisI illiw Iii1iaiioD

islssblo SUIEV sill asaubs sist l2elSini ni 525513(11 inioq iasd 001 A .1 ojloThoq idi iasilic1

bluow oiloThoq ni alnsd silT .(nibsr1 mall anis lsilnsloq ns ol iohq) noillid fl 'd alrtsd

sd bluow aoiloThoq lsI!SrnE silT .25151 ni sassl3fli inioq aid 001 s moil noillid EZ 1ruo saol

sill 111Bi3sq23 bits -- elnsd no i3aqmi sill aeseas ol 1svswoH esnsrb sisi 'd aesl cbum b5133fis

25151 nsrtw icol iiups lrtsd b noit3s-fl sill ci siuassm insvsfsi sill -- siulisI lcusd io1 1siinsioq

2325313fli 5161 01 bseoqxs siom il3um sis I oiloItioq ni c)lrtsd islasb sill siuessm irl1 'I .sansrb

mo_fl 'iiups iisrliIo ins3lsq C ecol 2)liisd isIsb sib ;aoiloThoq 13db sift 10 'ns iii alriscl ctsrll

sliups iisrlllo irisoisq nsrli aesi seol coiloThoq lsrIio sliilw aslsi iii srtSf13 inioq ied 001 iIcss

.(nibod rthoni niss s3no)

aqsw moi"I Iai$I shri-lasislul nibsH .1W

)I slsi-lasisini 01 bseoqxs sis esno sis1 11si3sqas a1nsd sill isrli wocIe S3itsbivs iuO

$15 26W2 il3111W 01 ssisb sir snirnsxs sW .noii1oai iii bswsiv eoi1olt-ioq qswa uisill mofi

sis alnsdbo anoiliaoq issrie s3ilsIsd-no sift isdlsilw snirrusxs sw (12111 .c'sw owl ni bsbsil

.noiiieoq qswc sill d bs3ubrui 1iviiiensc sift iscfio 01 as sw £ rlauie ni esisi lesisini at sviii2ti52

sift is Aoo sw (bno3s .lah issila sona!sd-no e3bsrI 01 eqswa niau alnsd ultiw insieiano3 ci aidT

no ciluesi 1110 01 ciii sisqmo bits cslsi lcslsini rfiiw ashsv smoorn isa bsrioqsi 113111W 01 iiitxs

.cnoriicoq qswelo iiviiiana stsl-la5islni Sill

Page 29: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

%:I fl& (K

ii&li n3dw a3ii vxta i3r1a eanslsd-no ii3di moll 1th si-laeielni ol beaoqxe ais dnsH

eiS1-155leirn erfio eiuasem enO .aeiiilidsil iiedt as emil emsa erli is eanqei ion ob aieaas

edt ai qs '(thuism ise-eno edT .qs inuism ise-eno aft at ieeda eanalsd a1nsd sb iiviiiariea

isdi aeililidsil bo eulsv edt bus ise' erio nidfiw &thqei isrif afeaas b eulsv edi neewied earieifiib

eieaasbo noillim OZ asd )lnsd sli eIqrnsxe ioI ieaas Isiof d bebivib ise' ono nirifiw eariqei

-eno edi riedt ise eno niiftiw eaiiqei isdi seifilidsiflo noiIIim OEZ bus 1S3 eno uhf 11w eanqei 15111

noillim 0 Z all no aetsi ierfiif sq of evsd 111w tnsd edt eah aeisl iaeieini II .eviisen ai qs ise e1qrnsxe aidi ui audT .afeaas bo noillim O s1no no seisi iedid evieae 111w baa aeiiilidsil eli b

-no *rsdbo 5wfamia ihuism edi no stsb te eW .eulav iiupe beaubei 1qmi aetsi ieI1II1

.thoge5l haD edt moil eoiloThoq ieerfa eanslsd

10 aneupafi nianq51 ecu iuods anoifqmueaa aeliupe-! qs thuism ise-eno ecu nibniI 1woeristnstani ed nsa aiiaoqeb bnsrrxsCl .eiernuenoa 'd bled aeiiilidsil iedfo baa eiiaoqeb busmeb

neciw eiieoqeb no ceisi iceleini iierhi erisda tori ob thisd tsdt aiaeua eanebive iud nwsibrhiiw

aeiihuism eviiaefie evsrl oats ainuoaas WOM ievoeioM .((1QQ 1) neeo5l eec) ensda ceisi i3)hsm

a3ismui2 owl ecu eW .((IQQf) iiloasnn&I bus rioaidaiuH eec) ceithutarri beisia iir1i nsrhi ierio1

evilaeibe evsrl aeilihidsil baa eleecs us tadi aemucas laifi edT .qs 'ihuism ise-orio edI b

bus ciieoqeb bnismeb ctaujbs bnoaea edT .(qADTAM) eeiihuism belsia 113111 01 Isupe aeiihuism

(*COTAM) ainemirilani ecerli bo aefihuism eviiae'fle 38n01 edt ioI inuoaas 01 afriuoaas WOM

eahqei font ob ainuoaas W014bo fnealeq 01 baa aiiaoqsb brtsmebbo inleaeq 0 isrlf emucas eW

edo niclliw

tasb nb1hte edT .exie Insd baa ise d qs sinuiambo aeiuasem owi iuo atloqel Q eldsT

qs iedfie 'd qa ihu.tsm evitiaoq egial £ evsrl ,

I oiloThoq (a)lnsd ,elseb 151ff ci eldsl edi ui neec

isdi aieeua chIT .aqs 'thuisrn eviia,n evsd of brief 1tneieianoa 1nad iehlsrna ehidw $luaS3frI

nedW oiloThoq leede eanstad-no edf d ieifio eis alnsd ielsebbo anoilieoq qswa tioda erli

.eulsv ui nis acneii ieerla eanslad-no edt ehirlw eulsv ecol enoifiaoq qswa edi eaii aetsi iceleini

.biuqmoei 21 elsi 1aieisii niisofl u1i islif aneupii cdi Is c3nqcl ansol cisi niisoFI 2

cli ni bcnoqei as CceU cnO ansa miii "thlcnhXauLbs lncmcsnsm crlf cliiw tncleiano3 2lscqqs IncffiiEiilbE emiT ° .fioqc5l IunnA Qf

Page 30: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

8 -rai3tni in 5th snim-isisb oi eiuassm £ 5-I5O3 ooi ai qs 'thujsm iss'-sno srh 1sranurio1nU

.quo1 s as alnsd isIsb 10 iivitiansa ssi

.eqa sthuicm (ebuiinsm ni) lisma 1svits1si svad ( oiloTho1) alnsd zs!ssbnon sis1 silT

al ant tud oiIoThoq qawa stub sulsv silt asaubsi astal tasistni iii seasiam na taut eteeue culT

svsul ol bnst alrisd isllem .amsti isode sanislsd-no b ulsv silt iii esnsda sd isallo sd ton

.esiuaoqxs qswe llama hia1 tud aqs 'thuiam svitssn

tt c smonI Mz13 QI

silt b 81U253ffl t3SX3 SlOffi S svnsb ot asititrisbi aflItfIUOa3s 1o satnavbs s1at nsa sW

alrisa .aoiloThoq 'dnsd silt iii sistuwsals eiueoqxs tsfio esiueoqxs qawe 'alnsd dairlw ot ssisb sd or eqawe smoe 5IsIasb ot eioislusi d bswolls 315 elna8 .anw owt iii 'twit3 qswe rioqsl

sbeil sw elnsH .(esiutth stsl-tasisini •io ansol stsi-bsxft as dauc) asitivitas lnsd isrlto riibsr1

sbsrl suit iii eqswa no esaaol bns enisO .esbsrl as bsislasb sis isrit eqswe 9L1l5v ot "nitnuo33S

sis sbsrl aqswe suit isrit atnsmu-itani suit no esecol bns enis nsrlw bsinoasi 815 ifluoaaa

atnsmintani suit bris aqswa tnuoaas-sgbsrl rio smoani tsn bstioqsi silt cbiow isrho iii .bsinoaei

r1t iii eqsw .iriuoaos ariibsit c3lnsd sth ni sd ot bsisbienoa sis aqswe isritO .ois ci sbsd 'stli

sulsv iii snsrIa suit 'lno svorn cstsi tcsistni nsrlW .uIsv is*ism ta bsrioqsi sis inuoas nibEIt

.smoani tsti as bsiioqsi ci cqswc ifIUo335-fIIbs1tbo

:titnsbi niinuoa3s silt ab1sii culT

asitivibA qswenoM bsbsilnU silt b smoanl tsM = smoanl isM

eqaw bsbsrlnTY1o sulV (is*iaM) iii snsdD +

aqsw2 bsgbsHbo smoanl isM +

.asitiviiaA qswenoM bsbsHbo smoanl tsM +

SW noit3sc auoivsiq silt nI .ois ot mue amisI owt teal silt 23lLfl gnirnuoaas suit b euisasH

ob sW .snsrIa asisi tasisini nsrlw anoitieoq qawe lnsdbo sulsv tsthsm ni snsda sth stslualsa

sW .astsi tesistni ritiw asitivitas qawerion bsbsrInu silt Io SfflO3fli tsn silt won Wofl)I ton

Page 31: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

odi 'd nvi al iivi1i2n ts1-ia13ini qsw bn 3ffl03f11 in nwid qidenoiisI3l 3r11 isrfi &11U2.2S

(Q1)

tn3bn3qbni idio lo 10133V £ 21 qX ,q oiloThoq iol i isb iE mo3ni in b3i-Ioq1 21 qjIM 31r1W

3210fi5tidW B 21 3 briE 2ii1vti3E qwnon b3abdnu1o moni iri br1oq31 i33Tth i&Ii a!dBhfiv

2! isdi oiloThoq qsw &fi1o noitioqolq di aiuam in3x31floa noiaii r1T .rrr1.t lor19

bb3rLr1u

ion 'sm lErfi lud ais-i ia3l3ini d biafls is i&fi 2in3mLrliani qswanon vsd lnsd 33fl!

a nail i isrf 10 a10t3Ei mofi isi 125131(1! dhiw sarIsd3 nso 3ffl03fl1 13n b3tioq8l aqswa d bb3d 3d

123131ni fit 33(16113 8th ebuI3rIi w li1f io1 1c1u0336 oT .oiloThoq qawe 31l1lo 3111Ev 3111 cit n&k)

no 3151 i1u13b 8cfT .anaol no 31s1 11usl3b 3111 'd b313&fts oels 2! 31fl03fi1 13M .qjXI0 i-1aq as eisi 3W 02 (e1oi3âl monooism no brl3q3b rllod 33(112) 23121 125181111 diiw b3islsno3 3d sm ansol

d b3blvib 316 23121 128131(11 (II 33(15(13 8th 1q83x3 e3IdsflsV 8(11 hA .qjX cii 21loisr13 naol 3buI3ni

.'ii3ii26b3)12O18t3f1 33Ub31 01 21322E Isioi

ni eno!a23-1331 3(11 cii eoiloThoq 1(1313 3(11 Iooq 3W .21111281 (1012281331 3(11 ein3e3lq 01 3IdaT

11 11w 1ina3iIin3ie iliod is iflo16r13 bns 23151 123131n1 ni nad3 3111 isrli 33iioM - I CffffIU!03

io 231 rnrrxub sie cad nmuIo3 ni (IO1223138I f rfT .( bns 1 enmulo3 332) 211312 b8133qx3 3111

b3161u3153 3Idsrlsv i1vi1i2n32 3121-125131(11 srli iliiw b3136131ni a3lrnmub 3i2 bns oiloThoq d3a 8(11 no 21n313ff13o3 3111110 2113(11 ew nOi2231331 21111 ff1 .aqswe rIlw eoiloThoq 3vfl r11 io1 3vods

3d1'lo 1n33-ieq enin isth ariam airlT .Q0.O ci 1n313ff13o3 8(11 a1nad 131s3b 3(11 -1oI cr1191 noit3sl3ini

-rio 113111 bris I-ion 2 3n13d cioiiicoq qawa 113(11 rlliw in3ieieno3 at CulT .b33b9rInu ci siueoqx qawe

oi1oThoi) elnsd l9Isebnon e-is1 edT .(qs 1huiam 3vincoq) 311o1 3ni3d noifleoq 133(12 33f1516d

qawe li3dflo (10113611 13116m2 nf3um £ 12(11 212333112 ur1T .1n3313q Wlo 31LJ20X3 lIE 3vad ( 323111 'd aqae no 232201 b 21-loq51 1(13331 1111w 11131212003 21 21111 fliS3S 33n0 .b33b311 21 oil6thoq

OV I 10 232201 be3nuonna 113111w 3n0 lnsa 3buI3m 2Q I b i-iaup dtiuol 3111 ni e3IqrrIsXa .2)1flSd

13V03 01 3316(13 noillirn 0 I £ Aool 113111w lnaH noII3M ;a13d 3tS1-1e313ini no noilhirn

'isuns1 .1srnuo1 1sii I1aW) 3316113 noilliin 00f £ looi rlairlw qioD)1 bns ;ccco1 c3viiavrI3b

Page 32: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

ot

1rw3ftini2ni - t 2oildthoq idi rrn1 norj3Bl3lrn 5r11 ito e1f18131f1303 ,iff .(QA .q QQ1 Q

.aqw blorl 2tnEd 3asrlr uE3,d Idiaaoq

sill 2I3fis 'iwii3E qwa on io lfli1 rliiw elnBd 10 noiwbni srli isd3srlw lsI oT

1o a3Iusi sift arnsas-Iq 01 sldT1o nmulo3 rl1iw alnsd sisl silt io tnsi3ffl3o3

ni sodt ot 11icni2 lsvitEti1up s-is an3i3ff1so3 srlT . bns I 2oiloThoq !no nibu1sni fl0i25131 silt'to nOieuI3n! silt isrlt 2sts3ibni noiassi ol I bits t 2noi225i3i r sqrnoD .E flfflUIO3

svlswt luods d iswoq svitsibsiq sass13ni 2sirnmub oiloThoq silt bits 2sldshsv tfviii2rI82 125191(11

.2tnioq sstns31sq

no 2brIsqsb estsi l2slstni iii 2snsrf 3 01 oiloThoq qsW2 ti molt lnsd £ 1o siuaoqxs isn silT

ol svitslsi oiloThoq qsw au 1o sia sill bits bsbsil i oiloThoq qswe 211 1I3u(W 01 3313b silt

ni 2)lnsd 2inioq 2iasd 001 'd sth astsi 123151n1 nsrlw isrll worD! sw 8 sldsT moiI .tiup3

tsrlt isvswod 2s1s3ibrn 01 sicisT .aqswe molt sulsv iliups iisrfi b tno3lsq seol I oi1oThoT

£ nivas1 oi1oThoq 1nsd silt iii sisdwsals nis 1n3313q I 1stsmixoiqqs its 'd t32!flo ai 22o1 aiilt

1Io tnssisq V 292o1 oiloThoq hslimi .noillim 008 21 tsf!t flup5bO tnsolsq lo 22o1 tsri

.noillid 0. a! tsdt tiupsbo irtsoisq ai isrlt uiupsbo tfIO3lSq

'tku11 XU'tu iMtmi11 thTh1 ciV* ()

.aqswa iii anoitiaoq bsgbsrlnu blorl a)hrisd islssb lls3fibsqa bits rnsia'a nb1imd silt lsn itO

2)hISd 331112 bno3s2 bnA c'asbsit qswa sdlbo bi isifto sill s1al orlw 1aiI .asuaai owl asaisi aidT

bluow anoitasup sesth 01 alsWans silT Vrliiw nibsd srfi sis orlw anoiiiaoq qswa iisth arnberf sis .asob ii midi sill it! atxs lshsm qswa silt 'rlw no irlll trtstioqmi bsda

S1S aAnsd 2.Ubo sbiaiuo aqswabo aisbiorl tasid silt , iloiiasup laift sill 01 t3sqasl rIliW

.thisd 2.U-non sd bisif sis anoitieoq qswa l291B1 sdfbo nsrn j sidaT th nworla aA .thisd niio1 io noI tsn S1E thisd .2.U-non sill isdtsdw worn! 01 noii&rno1ni rluons svsrl Ion ob sW

silt it! anoiliaoq nol islsiq 01 '!slil mssa aqswa bo aisau bits isdio smoa tsrf I worD! ob sw isvswoH

aqswa it! anoitiaoq no1 slst 01 asrsbibnss sd 01 bisa sis anoilsiocpo3 2.U Lsbnsrthno .1s*tsm qswa

ashnss tnsmmsvo .2.U rioitibbs iii .(E .q 1Q1 'Iu1 io1inoM agsw slqmsxs idi ssa)

lna3flur1i2 sis oaiansiI ns1o ?lnsH risoj smoH Iwisbs1 sift bits ssM sills ssM sinnsll nibubni

Page 33: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

IE

m3dt nbtLrn s1iom 3moff a d3uE tsaas i1-b3xft m13i-noI 3vLlI a3i3fl3E 3&1T bn tioda isn 3d1 nivhb i&ft amotau3 3adi ai ii 13dtdw womf ion ob 3W .2LW2 ni no! 3d 01 11i1

.thiadIo acxoxi!aoq qswa

3f11 mofi Jah i1-ia313ini 3d1 Asi ol 8nilliw ai odwIo noiiaup bnoa di ot crxui w woM

n3rli nib3d 31S thsd1i oa 3Idsfli213vibnon ai 1th 3iI-ia13inJ .anib3d si thlEd isdi iivii.s qswa

bloa '!diaeoq bn bsbsqei ni3d wod&noa ai al3moiau3 d thtsd 01 b5n3iansli asw d3IfIW Iah sdt

e3llJiüI Liv ?lth 3rii )bsd ni'ud 81L ai3moiau3 msa 3rD i3it th 11 .al3cnoiau3 rrisa 3rD ol bsd

.3qoa lo 3L8a1o 2thnono ai i*ism qswa 311110 33n312x3 3rD iol noasei 3rD (13111 arioiiiaoq ishzm

.blorl 01 13l$1 aismoiauo isrli a'sw n 1th 3sl3Sq31 01 31d 3ISthIBH

-31512 51S a,kisd a3r1i1o smo2 .alnsd ni3161 ai thid idi 'tIsq13inuo3 3Idiaaoq loffionA

sd 'sm a1nsd ni31o1 3adi 'd nbIsi-1th isdi ansrn aidT .siuliáI mofi b3b3iolq 321w131Do 10 b3nwo

31dfh213VibflOfl 'ff15 iol vioiieoqi LBlUisfl £ m3di 3)lflm bluow aidT .ain3mrr13vo 1i3d1 d b8sibi2du2

ii hs1 01 id oof 31E a13123b qswa *isd 2.U gs1 8(1110 iaom ni oisi-iaini nibubni Aah

.Iah 31s-i 1a3-x3ini Iszjbia3l 3rD blori blijorla a*isd 2.U ion k,d aAnsd r1i5IO1 rIw 1E313 ion ai

aiIusi noi223I31 IUO rtsrh bb3d 2231515 anoiii2oq qswa a1nsd isdi ai 'iilidiaeoq rnciismsi A

eismhia3l3brlu thisdIi iii1 .nib3d 3ism i2313vo ris 211u231 iuo is11i sw owl 516 31311T .'Iqmi

23aEOI iib3l3 1siin3ioq 3isrri23l3bnu dr 32u833d aqsdl3q aqswa -u3r11 b 3u1sv i3thsm 3rD ni 23n1133b

-rtsr1i-edtrflo ai-Ioq8l) aoio11-ioq qsw 1 311110 iivIii2n32 31s1-i23-131r11 3rD 3ifimxia3l3brlu iliw 8W ff3111

3rD nr1T .(Ismuo1 i331i flaW boiaqqa 1in3381 3v511 a3viisvh3b rio 232201 iibol3 b3i33qX3

.b3isrniiz3l3bnu 2i 2n01223181 3(11111 ([ff31 'iiviii2fl32 3151-123131r1! 3111(10 1(1313111303

125181w 01 3viiLbl b3rDooma 2131(103w 33(11121 nib3d 3isrnii2313Vo ff83 w isdi 'BW bnoa A

.((88Q1) 'Lni bris i1swniO a) 3(1103(11 dioorne aAnsd isdi nwoml 113w alil .23151

II .a3vilsvfl3b no anis bria 232201 bb3r1nu 3rD b8ismlia3l3bnu thiadli 1u330 bluow rtidioom

3(11 ff1 (1fl31 31vLiian32 3iS1-125131111 3(11 no ifl3f33O3 8111 flt838 fI3d1 msldoiq iosms2i nidioorna

idicn 231g1 123131W (18th 1113331 3111113(11 rn31do1q £ 21 aidili is,1i 31014 .b3iLrnil23lebnu 21 2flo1223131

.thiad sgisl is esaaol b3tIoq3lnu isl b82us3 3vsrl

Page 34: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

LE

noizubnoD .fflV

no notisrnioini o1dstivs sI3iLduq 3Iflil v13v ei 31311T .noii&rndIni iup5I 1th ania32A

2)lrlsdIo iuoqx 3rIi simii23 03 11u31Thb vI3v ii &11 nm aidT .a!nd1o anoin2oq qw2 3rL

luodliw elnsd no snilqi3eib oqmi 1onn 21o1a3v111 3bieluO .1n3m3vom 31s1 123133r1i 01

ion lud Ids1isvB ai aLth 3d1 18333d 01 '0s22335n noiiErrnoIni 311T .noi3rrno1ni thnoi3ibb

.isnrnsxs bns 21ois1u1 lnsd no sfi 01 3!odw £ 2S 'i33o2 bna alOi23Vfli 233101 2111T .b3rloq3l

3(11 ioiinorn 'ri3 ndw noiisrrridini 3nv3131 ,rf I ol 23)3 3vd 13nimsx3 bn 1oiEfu3SI

on i sis(1t anoiiiaoq nEol 1nsd1o noii!ui IiInU atnd IsubivibnFlo noi1i2oq vi3vh3b

noi3i2oq qwa o h 3111 iuod el3dlo bn alnsd n33w13d noiisnnolni on33mrn'2s in3l3rlni

3bErn i noi1anrio1ni irI3i3iffu 1i iarIl 2flE3 thIT .(s3iIsup 3ib513 luods fl193flO3 io 3q3x3)

213flL2X8 bns al3biani &isd 25 '1eizws as lah saas bhio3 aio1vni oitduq

.woml ion ob oW ctioqai 13z1duq 03 boiiupoi od a1nsd bluod2 noiisrrnoucxi rbum woH

lnsd'Io ulsv 33)hsm oismzI2O 'b3s1u33a 01 2lois3vni riiIiirin3q 2i onO .au22i owl 315 eiifT

Iii lsii am33a'2 223225 03 si oussi bno3oS A .anoiaia3b 2inrn123vni 31sm 03 anoiiisoq qsws

£ as m3is's nthisd odi is nb1oo1 231wp31 an 31In312 .1th noiiuiii2ni-1subivibni 01 noiiibbs

o-xs1 r3fiu2 Iliw aIrxsdo lodmun £ isdi 'iilidiasoq out si III1W bomo3no3 815 3W ISdW .3Iodw

bns aqswaIo oluloLnia thu1sm oril niaso!31 muminiin £ IA .omit 3ffl62 3111 is eqswa no

luods oasoloi '(Itnonu3 aAnsd lsrlw ol oIdslsqrno3 -- aiasd s1iotisup £ no arloiiiaoq oviisvhob 13(110

.1203 1fliI is )1üì 1o noiisrnite3 b311s33b 310ffl £ wolls bluow -- 2OiiiviI3s 333112 33nsIsd-no

is Jool 03 ihutsm iuods enoiiqmuaas !513V32 o)lsm 01 bo31o olfi ow 1oqsq ii1t nI

231flV11t2n32 3151-taOlstni bits 23U[SV 13*IBm 81SkJ31Z3 3W anoiiqrnuaaz iuo illiW .aouaai noiaa

13153b bns 31odW £ as m33a'a nblnsd od3 isrli bnft 3W .aubni nb1nsd 3(13 ni anoiiiaoq qswa 1o

2)lnsd lsrf I bniI oels ow 13vew0H .asasol3nz 3151 Iaoleini 03 b3aoqxo 31E is1uairisq iii a)1nsd

tuods (11931103 tl1i[ od bluorla 313(11 isdi t23U2 ai1ui iuO .)lafl 3f(i0 iaom bogborl 3vs11 03

.sisb 1110 b anoilslirnil 3(13 01 133dua aqsws moil )1ah oirno3aa

mloi-tlorIa 211133(103 sisb oldslisvs 13ifduq 3(11 (131w 223225 03 o!dsnu OlE ow isdi )1th A ni snoilsnsds m-iot-11orts 25 ooa 1 tsrtw mofi iftoiq 01 iqm3tis aLnsfl .3)1s3 a1nsd isdi ao1dms

otsi iai3ni 3fli33q2 no anoiiiaoq 3viisluOOqa miot-tioda 3)153 2)lnsd ffioiq oT .33i1q io)hsm

Page 35: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

puIc2 urnA pGtu o nc cw ctCflJOL2 uq 0CL2 Wfl pc MLC JJ 011CC 2Hb 91.C 110 tO1JCL 9 bLoUWp,c i'

pc J1JqnLA w9A pc ctUGuu v ucti jca bLoUpJ6 bpc iucc aiib 9LC obdnG

W9U9WGU o jcc ou u2Jc (cc G0LOU vuq jocu (J2)) jçccciu bLopIGw2 Yi

OL qCJGL pvIJJc MJJC UIA pAC icq WC !UCU!ACa LOL 9Uc2 Thp cucucpcq

WLJCC um8ju cpu8c wcc tc LCI!ACIA UGH bLoqr1c1 2Mb2 pic pcu AcI.A bLoW9pjG

OUC 1UI C01111 flJ9I OIIL C0UCjflJ0IJ2 WA pc bLCUJSmLG pG UWLC oipc aPAb

cjiwiutu pc bcLcciAcq bLoU obbounuiA

gcwb 40 W9JCG 4J1C UJG p64 011 2bCc!IJc 6AGU4 4pGA J11JJdrncjqA WOAG WtJCG4 b4cc2

JIJCCJA qW4 4GC 4AbC OL 4L4C!C onjq CoUrupcuc 1J!UC1U!A o A4cunC L!21C IL "" P"r

ij.cdnciu bcLJrnb qtjA P2!2 conq 4G6 boa,4!ou PC WOU150LC pA orivqcw B4 !4 aCCW ica

dntcjqA c2bCcitA !L 4C UJ4CG4 WOAC2 U24 4pcur OUIA !UI0uJrn4fOU !iCLC LCC2G 011

6A6U42 ncp MICUU OL4PC ffiOiç-buwc 2bLGq B91'12 bl9u 40 CJOC 4}JCZG bo2!41ou2

Page 36: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

HOfl2C BSU1C!Ucow puouA EiuucJI DGA!AG 4OACWpGL J3

0 (JQtY J40UJ!U6Luq DW!C bLOLUJUJ!U (yqqiou-c2Jc? Wpjp1ubbGuqrx II: f1LAGA oJuqn2I.A LC1iCG)GLOfib otjniA jopj DG4A9!AC2 urqA y.onb (tY DG4!l: bL9C!C€2 uq b4UC!b1G

ybbGuqix j: MoLJcIu bbcL iriiAGLOnb OL1pLA 01op9J Dc4/W utq? i.orib (Ja3BY DcL!AAc2: LCPCC2 uq BU1JC!bIC

buucibICa 1njX.onb oLIpTxA 01°P1 DG4/ AC lnqA yonb (mvY DC4AAC: bi.c4icc uqJC2CLC j) ________________________UJOOljJIU HAboW!: VU EUib!9CI J9JA2! JôXQ-!84 1O1u1Oj!ugIJCTJ acuiccaQLCGU/AJI y'TA LqA 9uq ioacbp E 2!IJJCCAB11IC rou-ro2abLo/u2!ou uq pc iucoi-DGCJ!UG oujauW MoIjqu bbcL flu ACL2!1A oAiiuwQOI4Ou yrLA uq jçcjrnq 1 jçocu (J?Y Cotho COuLOI oioo uq pcECOUOUJTC J GJLG) J41OIJJ BflLG11 OECOUOUJ1C JGCLC JOLJCILJ bbGL J40 438DOM i1JJ uq °'°' (j'y J4Oi2G jisqw DJfq b°'°I!° ui?uj€tu uqjcbou oupc cowwoqA EflLC2 jLqw COuu!OIJ spiuOu DC OoLIJuJoqA EflLC2 1Lqru COI 0L? OIC DCI4A!AG 1JCl2 911q LP'.'- ff(1!OUoqnc Jp1u4ou DCi' J31oiu wqA ouqnccq !u JçG2bou2c o pnC2OU2 jocq pA 2C1JOL I�1GJG oUOIJICC O IJJC C0WbL011CL °T. PC C11C DGL!A!AG joqnc VC1i/tWC O C0UWGLC!I B-"1otq OJQOAUJOL2 OPC Eq'I '-'2t' EqI DGb0 P12flLUCG COthOL!OI? uq

11J1CLC21 JC B1 COU2nI!AG bL0b0I buji1c couu uqu rIbcLtq2ou (Jo3DY nLcwcu LBUJC ExboanLG oJ�i2P COUnI!AG bLObO2 bqjBIC Col W!UCC ° B9UNU 2nbCUUtoU (ioicY ipc nbcijuoQ ILGWGU OU9LJCG

Cb!J qcdn9cA bn boc2 Coun1w!AG bLoboJ ybl.!1B21C C0111111!U B9f!U 2r1bCW21011 (JoBY pc 2nbcw2oiA jçccoumou OLk1c!u OL

[4( K!2P uq I1UCLC JçC Jç12JCJ,I.CCC O C0U2fl!f!AG BLObO2 VbI1FBIC couJunucc ou ujau 2nbcIJ 21ou (J3y)) JjJG j,i.r1qciui rxbcu iou OCUIIJ

jçcsq LLcWB9U1C oujJq (T8XY OC1UJ C'1! ExboanLc U IIUCLa BG uq EOLCJ EXCPIJG

BUJ( oujuq (Jô3Y DcI4A9!Ac2: IcGboi4 ou iucujj JoLJcnJ 0Lonb Vb41

OjCU COflUUG2 [JJJG bLOUJ2G! jçcbo] PAucLJuq3 0ccKCIiOIJ JçGbOI4 Lcb91cq pA jjoqu &onb EpJ2pGq p pc CCUL1 B9U1 OUPG QtocibBUJC pL IIucwzou9I 2CU1GWCU12 (jy jçcccu DCAGI0bWC1U2 !u PUCI.11i!0U1 IIUCLPUJC

34

Page 37: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

E!UUC!! 2W OVO/GGD-ô4-T33 __________________________________________fl2 GOA11111CU Vccornu!u OW (JÔÔ4Y E!UUC!I DcI!/!Ac2: V!0U J4GGqGq jO bLOGC1 pc

(oc4opGL jj) cuj jo-gg2LGA uq OfltJLJG22 J22flC2 JC!!U i0 B"1 DGI4A!AC2 VC!/!G J03q COUL J1 G2OUif 2 C0ULC H0flG COIIJJ!U OU uqu E!UUCC uq flLU VILV!L2(JooY CI4U 011

BC-X3 OCC O 3 j 3 ______________fl2 C0WbL0HCL OfJJG CnCUCA iJ8GWCIJI OJflJUCi9j DG!AG? B11!U C!LCflWL

Eoq B1JJq C!LIL BC- ( iccY occ ybu1fl? COWbLOllGL OpC CnLIIJC !°"I B"I 1!C!b!OU !U tJJC E!UUC!I EflUILG2 iiq

o9LqB911 D6b0 I1UCLG24 G2' !AOLJC1U bbcL flUTACL11A OU1JAAIJ9uq C GGLJJço2cIf jçTcjrniq (j jjrnj QOC2 b na c° DoMIJ vAuiwcuc uq bcLaicucc wJJpuO!jwbci.ccpuuc 4cc2: JJJG c ojçci DGbo2! MO4U bvbcL flLIIAGL2IA oH1UCP!20IJ D! E uq QG0LCbGUUCCIJ! (J jpcnqu j-ciu uq juicic jçG icajc iii

Page 38: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

42o\O 52o\0

X ACOflU4GLbØI4A ______________ RSU1( COflUiGLb9I47

___________ e-wouw IBOK ___________ e-wouit riBoi� ___________

B9LJ1( !U eqaeq boe!!ou

AB9UI( C0flU6Lb9I4A

___________ e-wouns rIBOI� ___________

BSUI( !LJ 2IJOLI boe!!ou: bSA2 E,O9ua suq GCG!AG2 Ixeq

xC0fl1i6Lb9I4X _______________

___________ e-woun, IIBOK ___________

BSUI( !U roua bO2!!OU b1 lxeq suq GCG!AG2 EIO9!Ud

2M9b EXSWbIG2E!anLe

Page 39: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

Ci aa3)3oflLce: JJJG Moqq1e IAIS!oL DGL!As!AG2 DG9IGL2' 2MSb2 JOU!OL bflPI!C9!OU2

ioisi o job 0 ctf 4 a50 BSudflG BLflXGUS2 ISWPGLf 288

— a B9U)< O 4OA9 2C0P9 .3•8.18 E!L Cp!csäo4. C9!226 q62 D6bO 144•848 2OWOU BOflJG12 4N042 M92bSC 4%9.i Bsudns IlSf!OUSIG qe bSL!2 480443 BSUdne uqone45 CLe!LIcoIe .18444 B9UO'W$LIC9 4a44'JO C!flC01b 5U.o6 CP92GIJ9UP99U 5558 BSLcIaA2 BSUk sa.S B9UKGL2 jW2 3228 AJGLL!II IAUCP 582'O2 CLGq! rouus 58' C0Wb90U!e ILJUCieLe qe bSL!Pfl2 345k3 2OC!Ge CGUGL9IG 3'42'6S ib' JOLd9U 3e4 CPGW!C9I BSUV Z3881

su gliw (p!II!ou2)On2f9uq!u02

(AG9 euq . aes)MOLI2 I9IOL IUGLG2I bgio 2M9b E!Lw2

.L9PIG 4

Page 40: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

eIdT elnsa 1si3IommoO ..U o anoifieoq qsw2 ets5l i2eletnI

(Cee r-e8e t brie iseY)

e1fl68 HA :A Iens

qsw2 lo oifsI qsw8 lo oisI qsw2 IsoT alns8 lo \0 lo iedmut.1 issY 01 eulsV IsnoiloM sulsV IsnoiloM sulsV Isnoiiol'l ni begspn ans8

ytiup3 lo eulsV ,Ioo8 tsaeA IsloT 01 (enoiflid 3) eqsw2 egstne3,eg) (egstnsoieq)

o\°.ttt o\09.8 F.88F 0\°4.F CO,FF 889F 8.F C8.86e V. F____ 8t8,ot 889F

£.90C 0..2 02FV 8. F____ 1VF,0F V89F .VVtI 9.9 FkOC9 9. F____ 9V,9 889F 8.t86 &.F1 C.91CF 9. F____ tae 989F ec F.Fe 8V.8tVF 0& 489 099F a.aev .re e8.aev.r 08F,9 Feet £.CF8 0.t8 V9.FF, CC8,8 99F

0.C00,F .08 aee,8 C9F

elris8 islsea :8 Iensq

qsw2 lo oi1sl qsw2 10 oifs1 qsw8 IsloT elna8 lo \0 lo iedmM iseY of eulsV Isnoifoki eulsV Isnoiiol'l eulsV Isnoiloki ni begsgn3 e1ns8

fiup3 lo eulsV ,Iooa efeceA IsioT 01 (anoillid 3) eqsw2 quoi ni (egsfns3leq) (epstne3leg)

o\°V.t o\08. FC.VCF o\°OOF V 89F 0.F8V V.C F8.9V OOF

oor V 889F

O.V8VF 9.88 ao.ee V89F 299F 9.0FF 9.CFV 00 F 889F 8.FC 0.F V.8F0t 00 F 989F F.85C 0.89F ea.e8t 00 F

F

V 09@F V.FCaC 8.aet .88t 00 V 8.1VC e.re 4F8F 00 F V 99 F

8.F8f .8FC 0C.8S DOt V C99F_

e)Ins8 isissO pnibubxB eAns8 DC qoT :3

qsw2 lo oiis qsw2 lo oiisl qsw2 s1oT ens8 lo o\0 lo iedmuM seY of sulsV Isnoiiot,1 eulsV IsnolioM eulsV IsnoifoM iii begspn3 ni elns8

yiiup3 lo eulsV 1oo8 aleacA IstoT of (enoillid 3) aqsw2 quoiO (egsfneoeg) (esfneoieq)

o\°.0V o\°8.C oe.tc OOF C 89F 0.V 9f.F8 89 C 889F

F_____ VF.OF F 89 C V89 F_ V.COC F.V F_____ F 89 C 889 F_

V.C 88.C€ OUF C 989 F

e.eei e.e s.aoC oor c oee r_ 8.8f 0JC

9.4.C

Ce.8C CC.18C

DOt DOt

C C

F9QF_ 99F

V.ree 80.f9 OOF C C99 F

Page 41: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

bennitno3 eIdT

aAns8 OC qoT iii ton tud ,noiIIi8 33 riibesox3 teaaA IstoT illiW aIns8 :a J9fl5q

qsw2 lo oits qswe lo oiIsI qsw2 IsioT ens8 lo o\0 lo sdmuk1 seY off sulsV Isnoifoki sulsV Isnoitoki sulsV Isnoitoki ni bepsgn3 iii a,lns8

tiup3 lo 9utsV oo8 tseA (stoT off (enoWid 3) aqsw8 quoiO (egstne3leq) (egsln&rieg)

0\°8.C o\08. 8.Ft 69 V3 389F 3 F.C 6C.3F 69 V3 889t r.eor c.e ea.c e ea V8@F

82F F_______ OS 8I.9C Ve 98 889F 0.8F F_______ S £0.C1 ce ea o.Fa F_______ 0.9 F8.88 e ea oee r_

F.88F 8.OF 0828 V9 08 F99 F

O2VF 1F 0F.08 \9 F6 99 F_ a.F 8.8F eV.eFF Ve 98 £99 F_

noilli6 83 bns noilli8 F3 nsewte8 eteA IsloT iltiw vlns8 :3 Iens

qsw2 10 oitsl qsw2 lo oiffsR qsw2 IsioT ensa lo \0 lo iedmukl iseY off eulsV Isnoitoki sulsV snoiioL1 eulsV Isnoiloki ni bssgn3 iii eAns8

tiup3 lo eulsV oo8 eteeA IsioT off (enoillid 3) eqsw2 quoiO (epstneoieg) (egsineoieg) — o\°F.8 °a.o 8C.F 8 0F 389 F

4.Ft V.0 C8 0t 689 F_ 0.M 0.t 8V& £8 8F V89 F_ 8.CC S. F8.6 £8 08F 889 t_ t.8C 'c. 0t.8 £8 08F 8.ffC e OV.'r Ca oar 0.C C. 8.V £8 84t F99 F

c.rc 4 [email protected] a Vt 9e F

V.VI 9.C F8.2r S 8Ct £99 F_ riolilia F3 bns noilliM 0033 neewisO affseaA IsioT ritiw ensa :R Iens

qswe lo oiis qsw2 lo oits qsw2 IstoT Ins8 10 o\O lo iedmukl iseY off eulsV Isnoiffoki eulsV Isnoitoll eulsV Isnoitoki ni begspn3 ni eAris8

tiup3 lo eulsV IooB aJeaA IstoT off (enoi!Iid 3) qsw8 quoiO epstne3ieg) (egsineoisg)

889t_ o\°8. o\0.0 8r.0 0.0 9t____ V.6 8.0 F1.0 0.0 08 F____ 889t_ 9.8 V.0 8.0 .0 £8 F____ 8.t 9.0 8.0 .0 48 F 889F_ 92F . F_____ tF.F C.0 aaF 989t_ V.VF C. F_____ 1C.F .0 38F 099 F

F. F______ 80.F £.0 VIF F99F_ F.F 0. F______ '0.F .0 08F 99F_ 8.1F . F______ 9C.F F.0 F3F £99F_

noiffibnoO bns emon lo thOQ9 USO :931u08

Page 42: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

C 9IdBT aes$I ta919nI 1ythutaM pninismo$1 1euIsV ineme3sIq9$1 ouIsV Isnoiioll

(alns8 hA)

rttnoM esiriT 0i8 yiussiT

eJs5

to 1n5319q betaubA eulsv lsnoIon Istot

isey t nsiit aael riliw thutsm gninismsl

Islol to 1n93,sq ritiw eulsv Isnoiton

ise F nsrlt eeol thutsm pninismei

1nemsosIqsR tao3

(enoiIlid)

eulsV Isnoifoki qsw2 (anoilIid)

isiisuO

'seY 8a.8 .oc e.ei r oeer_ 8C.8 I.IC e. a&eir oeer_

a.oc e.arar c oeer €.'V e.c a.ei 8.err t oeer_ 8.a toc .'ct o.e r.aer r reer_ oe. 0.0€ ct O.8 a.'c'car reer re.a c.rc c.e .8C r.ar8r e reer t2J o:c a.8 r.ta eecr reer

a.e2 r. 8.er8r r seer 08.C 0.0€ o.oe 8.oe aer seer oo.e r.o e.ra .eao2 c seer cc.c .oc c.oe aa seer 1O.€ .OC .oa a&a r ceer 'r.C r.Oc 8.ra .aa C&8a ceer 0.C 0.0€ 8.re r.a8 C CGGt_ ar.c a.oc e.re r.a c.ate t ceer

noifibno3 bns emooni o ehoaeI 11s3 :eo,uo2

Page 43: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

I9Id8T aelqmsx3 :sulsV tneme3BtqoFi bns sulsV Isnoitoll

= eisI QnifsolR :A Iens

,9q hq Isnoitoll horl2 gnoJ eis5R bexR noiieoq

tsnoiiol'l at3sltnoO ei3sltnOO eulsV eulsV () () eOO.O- 0 noiUimC o\° gnoJ noillimC$ eoo.o noiHim 0 o\08 hori2 noillim r O.0- noillim t$ 0 o\08 hori2 noillim

= ets gnitsolR :8 Ien&R

,9c1 93j1q hofl8 gnoi efs1 bexiR noiiao9 Isnoifoki

snoiok1 ebsitno3 aositno3 eul sV eulsV ($) () ero.o- 0 noillim C o\°' gnoJ noillim C$

0.0 noillim t 0 0\° hori2 noillim rs eo.o- noillim t 0 o\08 horl2 noiflim

s iiiiw bnod ise-eno s lo eulsv fneiiuo erft ai 1 91911W (1 - I) e3h9 :efokl .eis, bexit silt ot Isupe etsi noquoo

Page 44: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

a eldsT ahoq9l IsunnA 1ns8 moiR tao3 rIeme3s1qe bns eulsV qsw8 Isnoitoll

ceer io ssO)

to oitaF tnsms3sIqeI

ot iaoO eulsV Isnoitoll

11s3 io thoqeI

behoqsl lo oitsi tnsms3sIqsI qsw2 bsiioqs o to3

eulsV Isnolioll qsw8

nemso&qs5I taoO (2noiflid )

qsw8 Isnoiloll eulsV (anoillid ) miiR

0.t Q2.I 6.8 e.caa 1ns8 Isoimerl3 AWl A\L1 AWl S8 aspioM .dlL e.t 'c cee c.eic iau,T a,ensa 8II.I 8'V& 8.6 C.N giooiii3

0 0.C C8.8 to lns8

s3ilemA

VVt Ct.C ae eesil3 nsflsrlnsM

AWl AWl AWl e.Mr oQs3irlOfaliR

vc.r i.o.c NI Istrienifno3 alonilli

C8.0 08.0 e..0 t.8C enO ons8 e8. r to& ceo e.e lns8 oiIduge

t8.0 ca.r rc.o 8.8I noinU iaiR AWl A\I1 AWl a.cr ns8 nolisM

AWl AWl AWl 8.0 we1 to ?lnsS

ioY

AWl AWl AWl .0F noisoS o lns8

AWl AWl AWl ce elstaietnl ta,R A\I1 AWl A\I1 1.2 o,sR alleW

ahoqe$ IsunnA 1ns8 Isubivibni :eoiuo8

Page 45: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

a eldsT e,lnsO HA :yiiviiiarie8 tae19nI bns eulsV ie*isM to e9t6miie3

a3B1rlOO well o eiutouit8 YthUISM

bsqsrl2-U eaievnl

8.O =° FO.O == r1

ae.o=tt=i

beqsrla-U

8.O ° C.O =I=

ro.o=t=

IR 8.O °l

8 F.o=t = ==

r1 =0j 00...b1...C1

F=tI =I ='I =°l e.o=i

r= =°i

T8.D =I o.o=I

I ,I •I 'I °I betsmie3

ae.rver ea.rcet 88.tV9l reuIBV Isrioltoki qsw2 (anoiIIid)

OO.81 OO.6 OO.8 fnemsoslqesR b9ujbA (enoiIlid) reulsV

.CF 88.8 rOUISV ie,hsM boismiea (enoHlid3)

.CC- ,

8.FF- taeeIn1 bstsmiI3

iviJiane2 (&ioiIIid)

8.V F1 r.c o noisive1 bisbnsi2

tiviflne2 Jasiethi (anoiIIid)

F.CF- 1r.o- 8i- ni eQnsrlO OUr ieq r91i viiupB

erit ni egnsrl3 tnioq aiesd (J)_sisi_faeislrii

O. VF V.8C !o noibsiR betsmia2

tsslt stosiJno3 gnileix3 (\O)_riorla_es

- t:Oe 1eiehsup 81 io eulsv nseM . F

.ets, tasielni sill ni saseini lnioq aiesd 001 isq (enoillid 3) sulsv ls*ism ni sgnsti3 .

Page 46: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

V eldsT quoiD lns8 yd ninism3H 169Y enO nsr1 aaei iltiW eqsw2 o noinoqoi

(eg6rn93.ledI)

2 oilothoq aleaaA IsioT

.Iim ooa n9owed .Iid r*-

.f oilotho9 asaas IsoT

.Iid 2-F* neewed

C oilotho9 2 < aieaaA IsioT io F ron bns .Iid

oilothodl on OC qoT

al9Isob

F oilotnodl e,lns8 ielsoa

l9rIsuO 163Y

o.cs e.8c 2.FC O.8 e.Fc r oeer e.as

. 2.C o.c e.a o. e..ric c.a .rc C

8.aP e..rc &e .c V.fF e.vr a.c 8.OC F reer o.er c.e. .2C v.a a.oc

o.o e.rc e.a .,c C

O.F O.V.P 8.P'C 8.8r C.OC i a.o e.ri o.CC 8.8 o.oC r seer 8.8 F______ C.2I a.c 8.V .OC a.e I______ 8.t C.CC c.c C

8.8 F______ 8. 2SC e.v a.oc F______ r.OI e.c r. 2.oc F ceer

.8F O.eI 8.FC S.V 1.OC C.F O.2F 8.C F.V C.OC C

C.F I.FC 8.8 o.rc I

Page 47: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

8 oldsT quoiO 1ns8 yd anoijiaoq q&w2 to eoiiviienea ie9lstrlI brui suIBV i9*IBM

a oilomoq ateaas Isiot rthW e,ns8

00i ensi silt ni noilli8_t-noillim

t oiloThoq teaas Istot ritiw a)lns8 noilli8 a-ti snsi silt ni

C oilothoq <ateaas Istot ritiw alns8

OC qot ni ton tud ,noilli8 ei

2 oilothoq l9Iseb Onibubxe OC qoT

a'lnsd

F oilothoq e)1n88 ielssC

Ot.0=°? t2.0 T T 8c.o=°t

0O.0 T T T 8C.0°t

t.0 T T VT =T 82.0=°t

8t.0 .. V 82 .0=°

8t.0 T =t =VT =FT yfhutsM betsidils3

eiutouit8

0.0=01

eo.o=i 0.t=€l=VI io =l

o.r=°I 0.0 == ='i

ee.o =i o.r =I=°I

= o,o=dI

ea.o =i

....S

0.0 =I o.t =V1=1=1 .o =

0.0 =I

,I ,V1 ,r1 01 betsmiia3

62.t V8.8 2t.C'V r.2ec tO.Q'VP.F rSUISV Isnoitol.l qsw8 (anoillidi)

tO.0 t2.0 ec.r r.e .

ao.r$ tnemesIqe1 betaubA (anoillidi) 'sUIsV

t0.0- P.0.0 CP..0 C8.t rca r9UISVtS,115M beismita3 (anoillidi)

C0.0 Ft.0- 2.F- 08.2- 89.8- tasiatni beismita3

Vtivitiene8 (enoillidi)

0t.0 C8.0 e2.a aa.8 $0.0 To noitsivea bisbnst8

tytivitiane2 taeetnI (anoillidi)

P.0.t Q.0- P.9.2- 9O.P.- P.V.22- ytiup3 iii epnsrl3 tfl93199

e9nsd3 qd Dot ieq tsuIsV (J)etsi_.tni_ni

08.CC 02.08 02.VC 88.CC 29.CC To noitosiR betsmiia3

els tsrtt atositno3 niteix3 ()tioda

- t:09 ,aiehsup OF ioT sulsv nseM . F

.etsi taeistni iii egnsrlo inioq aiasd Dot ieq (.Iidi) eulsv tehsm ni ognsrt3 .

Page 48: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

e 9IdsT quoiD 1fl6a yd eqsD yiiusM

a oilotnodl 4 ollothodi C oilothodi oilothodi F oilothodi

qAOTAM diAOTAM diADTAM d1AOTAM *cIAOTAM d1AOTAM *9ATAM diADTAM diADTAM diADTAM 1SBY

e.c- v.ar- 8.1- c.r- e.r .v- .r c.8- V.8 oeer

e.a- a.er- a.a- .vr- a.r- o.r- .r- c.rr- o.' reei

t.8- vs- .a- a.er- c.- a.ir- s..r- .cr- e.a v.er seer

8.V- a.- c.a- e.8r- 1.0 Ir- r e.e- a.a ceer

v.a- r.o- v.p- r.cr- 2.0- a.rr- rc.o e.or- o.c C.1 n69M

.a9inusm b9&Th iietir or SUP9 e9ithul6m evit399 evsil 9iriIid6iI bns ar9eas us rsdr gnimueas q&g yrhursm 16ev no erir ai diADTAM .169V 9fl0 nitlriw e3iiqei 1011 ob alnuooos WOL'l o rne3leq O1 bris ariaoqeb bnsmeb o 1neisq O.1 sr1t aemueas diADTAM

noitibrio3 bns emooril to anocieA IIs :eoiuo2

Page 49: DEJWV1IAE2 - NBER

01 sIdsT anoiiiao9 qsw2 ot 9m03fl1 9M to ytivitiane2

()___________ bisbnst2

ion3 betsmila3 InebitIeoO

bisbnsl8 ioiiJ

bstsmifa3 trisioilleo3

bisbnst8 ioii3

b9tBmiIa3 tnsioiflsoO

bisbnsl8 ioiiJ

betsmita3 Inoi3flteo3

Inebnoqebnl &dshsV

*eeo.o .F *3• 0.F IgeOl9tflI c.o cc.o &o *8800 £C.O $jt

*F800 8F.0- *c £.0- 8C.0- aYIo-9p,sI1O CO.0 01.0 eC0.0 eo.o 11*FWVMA F.0 £8.0 'V.0 *tVMA

88C.0 08.0 *CVM CC. F 8. F *AVM

8V.0 8.0- *cvM 9V00 F.F F.F____ F olomoq *4D F.F 90.0 tF.F____ oiiomoq

*F800 £0.1____ £ oilomoq 00 80.F____ oiloThoq 00.1 8 oilomoq

*0800 88. F____ 8 oiloTho9 *8800 81.1 oilomoq *8O0 C. F_____ 8 oilomoq

1000.0 1000.0 1000.0 F000.0 1<do,R 88V8.O 'VoOe.o C8VI.0 888F.0 l .LbA

o ytivifianee Jasietni eiit ai *iEVMt ;etsi IIid-T rltnom-E erit nl eQnsrl3 edt a, .atsaas Istot yd bebivib emo3ni ten ai eldsrisv tnebneqeO eiit is tnsoiiingia eeIs3ibni • i oiloThoq ioi &dshsv ymmub 6 ai I oilomoq ;eim flid-T rftnom- Silt 1)1 eQflSfI3 et11 aemii oiloThoq qswa ei oiloThoq

.Isvel 80. silt is eonsoitingia aetsoibni ;Isvel FO.