yupoua i• upjc - nber · ia moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3i ol isnoist...

45
ucJnqu © uoicc ! !cu o tp Of1LCG uo o GXCGG Mo b i.sbp urnA Q dnoicq iipofu cxbJ!c bQJ.u!ou bLoiqqQq qrnt njj © pA K''' uq VupouA [ jcuipjc vii up Lc LAGq pou cpou o GXt tpOQ OJ IJ M!oJI BflLfl O ECOUOUJJC Lp cuq ju uiouj jqc mq JJJAQ1WGU yuA obiuou xbLq po o pc fOI2 rnq uoi 1P! b1bGL '4 o MBEK LCCLC bLouJ2 Tu JIUGLIJPOu$J EJUIJC IJq CLOCOUOWTC yb4j c"p'.!q IAIV oi: IOO 1AI2 CPnGU ACUflQ WVIIOL4VF BIIKE VII Oh ECOI4ONIC KE2EVBCH J/OLU bcL M° ?0ô8 yupouA i• upjc IViEflV['LLA Oh MVJJOM2 OI'OBVFISVJJOM VI.ID JHE I4BEff IAOKKIWJ bVbE1 2EIIE2

Upload: others

Post on 28-Feb-2021

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

ucJnqu © uoicc ! !cu o tp Of1LCGuo o GXCGG Mo b i.sbp urnA Q dnoicq iipofu cxbJ!c bQJ.u!ou bLoiqqQq qrnt njj© pA K''' uq VupouA [ jcuipjc vii up Lc LAGq pou cpou o GXt

tpOQ OJ IJ M!oJI BflLfl O ECOUOUJJC Lpcuq ju uiouj jqc mq JJJAQ1WGU yuA obiuou xbLq po o pc fOI2 rnq uoi1P! b1bGL '4 o MBEK LCCLC bLouJ2 Tu JIUGLIJPOu$J EJUIJC IJq CLOCOUOWTC

yb4jc"p'.!q IAIV oi:

IOO 1AI2 CPnGU ACUflQWVIIOL4VF BIIKE VII Oh ECOI4ONIC KE2EVBCH

J/OLU bcL M° ?0ô8

yupouA i• upjc

IViEflV['LLA Oh MVJJOM2OI'OBVFISVJJOM VI.ID JHE

I4BEff IAOKKIWJ bVbE1 2EIIE2

Page 2: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

flYiLLED KIMODONruq I4BEB ouqou kiCW VE

CV flO HOflIUOU 2PG1uoq flUJAQLaA oDGbJT4WCIU O ECOUOW!C DGb14WQU O ECOJOJJ!Cb'I KUIWflJ VIPOIJ uipjc

U!OIJ JU flJq COLG UWOIJ IJJA joc

rucowc w jj fLgu2boJ4 COi tPL ! COUAGLQUCQ OJ LQJj IUCOIJJC u prcp bQubpcLrJ

bournconjA oi.w uq upou ip juq QWj/ u bGubpQr.A 2flUL qGcJJuQ rn L1!

uuriicuiuu pn EtpQU urubo coi ijj pQJo/ cuicj AJflG coLQ-bGubpGi.A bucu

jocou o wuncnuu uq iu jow y pip p.uboi. co cjj conuil psi owc

uq cuqcucA WUflfCW14U JouJL1ou oi qo jopji!ou ccc

counujbou cuq iucu cu9ic nc ci.t co nJq qcurnuq juy p/tcQu

v uouobojiicjjA couJbGAG wunicm.u eqoL bLoqncc ooq flGq OL UJ

YBaLKYCI

ivOnvriix oL wvnoGI'OBVr'IVJJOM V4D uHF

bujI4BEK J]OLjCTU JbcL O8

Page 3: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

I

AICM MS 1JJ1 !U1GI.1I0U 0 MOLJq UJ9IJ(G12 bLoqnccq 1411UCACU

bLoqilce 1J2 0L 0WC t IPC CXbGU2C 0 OIjJCL2 -- P111 IJJC G1JGL9J

1P1 J0pJ!f!0U LfJIPCL 1P9U PCUGIjWU ffJJ U1!0U cuqcq 10

L1JJCL 2f!thUJIJ JJ9UA 0 IPC b91. cibul 'U ipi qepsc c!4cq

IU1CL1J1T0U9J ECOUOIJJIC OLCL qrnu IPC JØ ffJJ 0 IJJJ2 onuq2

10 uAoiic MJJO LCWCWPCI2 we qepe 0AGL IPC 14CM

COIJJbCI!IJOU L0W IJJC JJJJLq oLjq

1JJ1 MC !wbJA CUIJ01 uJlCp1 -- E11L02bC 0L joM-MeCOIIUILJC2 IP&1 IIC0UJbC1C CACU OU OIIL OMU UJ9LJCC12 1 C021 JCAGJ2

nbMq ILCUq JU EULObC9U nucwbjoAwcui IS1C M2 e UG 0

Cjiwcq IPSI IPC 2J1JJC W01 !WbOLWUI LC920U I,0L IPG eCf1JL

urnuncuiuu upou p 9JLGqA pq 2Cu0112 fACL2C iwbct u

EUJbI0AWGU1 TU CCCf 922CL1C qrnl 1PC I.JC 0 JJJJLq M0LJ

bI1GL 01. IJJC EnL0b1J COWW!OU QLOMIp COUJbeIACUC2 uq

LC2bCCWPJC A0ICC L91C HJJIJL C0UCCW iuqccq IPG J3 JJJUC

ncju orniq1, 2 VWC4CU op W0AG 10 NGXICO AGI WOLG

MOLIJJ VWCI4CU hLGC jjsqc VLGGWCU1 orqq jciq 10 ILC1

CXLCWC GXbLC22JOU 0 1P! CL M9? bCL0l M9UJIU 1P1 IPG

WUf1CWLC2 CXb0142 -- MJJJ COUJG 1 MC2IGW CXbCUC IPC W02f

GL 1P1 JjJ!Lq MOLJq L0M1IJ -- jeq pA u cxbuiou oL0M1}J J2 2I1LC !IJ qcAcJob,u COIUJfLJG2 2flCjJ 2 CP!U IJJC2C

I0P9TTS1I0U OU IJJC!L pTI!A 10 211WUJ P!P I!MU uqLq

wuA 0PCLACL2 JU IJJC squccq IJ1J0U OAGL IPG !UJbCl o

IU LCCCIJ1 Aci IJJGLG p2 pcCIJ L0MJU COUCCUJ UJ0U

Page 4: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

f(1 i anoiisn fl3n lo 2bbnEi2 niviI 3rD uI h £ ,"in3mqol3v3b

misb 3rIT .bnuoi 'sw 131130 3111 rtr1i r1iB1 iooq 3rD b 32f13X3

211011511 noms ii1sup3ni n3biw 03 ebn3i 3351q13)hsm Lsdo1 £ is11i

rIoqqJJ2 33nq iibommo3 bits bi.s iol 2bnsm3b 1ii2u1 03 bu asw

bluoo thuo r1i isifi b3uts 2ltho3rIi 1sibst iom ;23m3r132

-113w 001 3rD moil imono33 211 "bAnu1-3b" Ii Ii 1no qol3v3b

.rIiioM br12i1c1si23

Vmob2iw lBnOlifI3vflO3 3111 ifi 16213V31 21113 101 21f1U0335 ISIIW

i2om 3111 :21118v3 2333fl31 '1qmiz ii 321uO3 lo t1sq ju31 uI

3rD 2S .tVQI sib 3qsobns1 in3mqol3v3b 3rD lo 5Iuis1 3iisfns1b

qs r1juo-r1iioT'1 31(3 wonsri ol 21loTl3 in3mqol3v3b 10 5IUIisu

325131103 3rD 2! 13151 21S3 O 311J1531 nb1hi2 iaom 3rD 311(1w

3113 bns 231(11011033 nsiaA i2s3 lo rDwoi biqzi &1i rr33w33d

b33bni 31di22oq 2! II .211011511 b3onsvbs 3113 lo 1duoi1 3!fflOflO33

3113 bus in3mqol3v3b 113V311U luods inno blo 3113 113011 22!rn2ib 03

2b51 Isui33Il3ini 2E rittoM 3111 lo no ifis 132(11(11! Juocls 33ft03 W3fl

13flsm tsoniqrn3 fIB 2S ;2noiii2oqoIq 1S31i15ftE 2U0192 rusrli 131(351

llsino 33nsrrnoIl3q 11iwrn if13l3vib ts11i 3UI6 113w ir1im 3110

Isnoiisn lo 33fl3U32f1O3 3IdSiiV3fli 3113 1011 2l0i351 lsfrI3ln a133fl51

'.rn3i22 3imono33 lSflOiisfll3ifli 3113 111 23101

12uoh32 3)153 01 32O01 3W 'I3qsq 2ifll fli 22313f13311014

.23mo3n1 1srioiisn 1531 no not1ssi1sdo1 lo 2133113 luods 2fI33flO3

in5I3rlni on 31S 313111 113111w fri l3bom £ qol3v3b 111w 3W 02 ob oT

as rI3irlw I 23!m0n033 15noiisrt gnoms 233n513Thb

Page 5: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

hs !wonEinoq brfi3non n iods! lo noiivib !.snoijsrrl3jni

noi2ivib ilfi ibnu 13fl3cJ is1 vjm 2noiisn cno rbiciw iii bn -- monoo bhow di 113111W ru I3bom £ flo w i isriT .irfio n,di

lo 1x311103 341 III .rrl3iisq dqn3q-31o3 £ 03(11 1!3ii 3sJlt61O Em

s uioiisiIsdo1 bas313ni ob won :kB n3uli nii w j3bom 2i(1i

3103 lo 3mo3ni Isr rt1 ie11s ai3hsm bhow lo noiiB13tni 132o13

2iaBizurfin3 3bsIi-3811 s noiisxilscJo1 aoU Vanoiisn vj&Iqh3q brus

134qh3q 3113 flurl ii 23oU Vnoiirt Ifs ifl3n3d awIs fl32zs ir1irn

25 313 3113 fluff ii ob tO V2OVQI di nhub iduor1i rusm 02 as

c3V3il3d WOn ftSffl

anrro rliod isfli ai waru gniaflqlua isrIw3moe mO

iaiiL gninisinism tuods ahiow brus iru3mqol3v3b II3V3IW iuods

nonn3qmo3 bhoW bunT 10 3351 3113 fl abusbrrsia nivi! bhoW

03 bnoqarto 01 us3qqs 3r1i uE11J3thsq iii .noiJ&fiuiau1 moa vsd isfil aoqqu .nojsML6doI lo aaouq nf1 iii sia in5!3Thb

.3mri uvo llsubu IlsI 212o3 noils3inumrno3 bnis nollsfloqansIi

bhow niwou b 3sia Frse its ai3ib3uq I3bom uuo rl3nIT

-313 £ uIsv Isoith3 ii wo1d IlsI aiaoo floqansil n3ftw :iilsup3ni

bnil isrli anoiisn bns amuo1 12uo3nsinoq2 nl3iisq vj3rlqn3q

aA .31(103111 1551 ni 3111133b s iflua 13u1qh3q &1i ri 23v132m3113

a3rno3 llsuinv 313(13 13V3WOf1 Hs1 03 311(113(103 23203 floqansli

3(13 431(1W (Ii a3ffl03fli 1531 111 33f1313Vf1O3 1o gia bnoa £ 113w sm anorlsn 3103 rfi bns nis 13iinfl3b anoiisn lsu3dqh3q

.3201

Page 6: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

£ 2131b81q I3bom 8Iqmi2 bviiE1s1 £ tsrii n3th iuo 2n1u1 II

33n3g13v1b to nsd3 3!mono33 Isdo1 lo rrl3nsq b3qEd2-U

lo noiisnBlqx3 1r1i 3isws 31S W .n13vnoo d b3woIIoI

s lo 2m131 iii abn3fl 3imono33 mi-ano1 bns s32-jB1 113U2

iuo) 113 ni '1mifl 3unoi riliw b3111o 3d i2um 321JE3 31nk

.("I 1-iq bhoW 311110 1oi2iH" 2sw i3qBq 21111 iol 1irJ nbhow

fUf1Sf13 2S ff3U2 21013S1 l3riio isril 1Ai1 s1r1iii ei Ii 13vo3IoM

n&1i 3101 inJ-Ioqmi 310w £ b3s1q 3vE11 noii3ubo1q lo o1onI1o3i

Lsnoig5I iii nsth gnivrib ni 21203 noiisfloq2nsIi itills1

lo 3v1123ggu2 21 I3bom rfi isril 3v3113d w 13f1i3noM .3gsfltsvbs

.imonoo3 bhow Isi 3(11 111 *row Is 2331o1 3(11 lo 3mo2

2iffI 10 2(101211131103 ni2nq-uJz 3111 IE111 f1Ii23131fli 021.6 2131

lo 2noiqmlJ22s 3(13 lii 23flEh13 11sm2 13vli5131 moil 3215 iqsq 323111 Isth bits -- 3bsfl lsnoiism3ini lii 2I3bom b15bnsl2 his1

.rn2iIs3l •I3is31 lo noiiiib 3(11 111 g11D163q2 llS13n3 315 23ftBd3

-113w owl lo bhdr1 lo tlo2 £ s 11332 3d sm l3bom iuo b33bnI

3111 21 3110 .noliti8qmo3 3i2iloqonom l3bfw 3bJ$1J lo 2I3bom nwonA

ni b&uboilrn 2b00 16(111 b3iElift3l3lIib ni 3bsIi 1I2o3 lo l3bOfft

lii 3bsli -- 11s3ii2i1s31 -- bbs 3W 2i111 oT .[08Q1] nsmuiN

2231120310 I3bom 3111 moil 2irI3ib311Ii gfllwslb 2b00 3ISlbeffrI3ifll

l3iIfIar sd b33ubolIni 2b00 3isib3fffl3ifli b3tsiIn3l3Thb ni 3bffli

113r12-3111-lIo moll sw 21(11 111 btxr1i2no3 gni3d 3iiq23U .[8Q1]

lo isdi moil 1n31311ib loiv&13d 2iidifLx3 I3bom iuo 2in3noqmo3

3bslI bits 21203 rtoqartsii 1133w13d fl01i3fi13I111 341 :11131)3331115 134113

Page 7: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

f13!flw 2imono3 1sm31x3 3fi133q2-'(ttfluo3 231S313 2ithborni3ith iii

323fIT .siivii3E tthiwbni 10 noiiEmo1E 01 bs1 sm nori3sl3ini 3r11 mciii hs thiriw offt 01 lfihimi2 51S 23iiilfIffl3ix3

10 1bom inoi lii ii1idom lodEt briE 21203 1Ioq2nsli n33w13d

l3bom mo l3v3woH .([IQQI] nsmiriA ..9) dqE1o 3f0033 3r11 r1fls5r3 m2inBfI33m 3fIT .w inEtIoqmi m di moil 213Thb

iuqiuo-iuqni 3f11 r1uoiifi) urnfl nwi8d 23s)1nu1 ai 2311i1sfr131x3

bn.s arrriii nwi3d 2Anu1 nrIi i3rftsi (31ui3u1i2

mus tori ob w oni .([IQQI] nsmtriA ni as) 213moiau3\how

01 25 113w 26 16110 rjsrrl3jni 01 3Ids3llqqs ai I3bom 3111 iilidorn iodsl

aiIua3l a3guIEd3 0215 ods1 io ii1idommI .a3irnonooe 1snoi5n8ini

[IQQI] nsmufA 3)111 al3bom r1qzIo3 31qmi .2'sw insrioqmi flu

n3rlw :21203 tIoqensil ninu133b 01 sw 3noionom £ tiu bnoqa3I

3110 rij isiinsono3 vIi2ubni jsvsl Isoilh3 £ woisci ilsi 212o3 323111

sw will bits) 3lidommi al todsi 32usosd 3I3H .f1Oi31

ni aito 113ub3t niunuino3 (3t3m3 2noit nwi&J 216i1n8t3Thb

&li 10 noiissil.shiaubni3l 5 01 bs1 llsIJin3v9 21203 nojistioqansti

3111 lo bslths 115 i2iJ ion ai 21(11 isrti 3v3113d 3W .flO131 sw-wo1

bns thnoig5n3ini n33w13d noii3rtiiaib ls s 21n3251q3t ii :l3born

3lidom 2231 tEl 135i (Ii 21 todsl 321J533d airnono lsnoiisrri3ini

.arioisn niiiiiw risrli n33wi3d

213110 I ftoii33 .ansq X12 fil 21 tqsq 21(11 io l3bfllEfll5I 311T

3111 1110 2132 II noxi33 .3iO1 a'I3bOm r1l lo noiiiaoqx3 Ismioini as ai miihdiliup3 won 2Wof12 III 11013332 31111W 13b0rfl Ismiol

Page 8: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

bhow rIt as nsib muhcliliup8 aiili won bns b3riim13i3b

awoda II3fLt VI flO!i33 .b3i53if1i fIiaB513fli amoo3d monoo V noii2 .abs33olq noiisilsdo! as anisth 516113w lsnoiisn wonl

al3Ilo IV noiio3a 11snfl bnis 3i1oq 3bs1 b ai11e 3d3 a3loIqx3

.thls3asi i3nfruñ iol anoiia3ua bits antoiauI3no3 3moa

c'p 3iasfl 31ff .1

bns nirtoT4 anIoi5I owl lo nLtaiano3 bhow s 3ni1S! 3W

'Lsmflu3hs" :aboo lo abnib! owi iboiq ns noist d .iiiuo

bits !soa 01 anrtui3l 1n512n03 nIliw b33uboiq 316 Isrll boo 3rIT .arrtUl3l fliaS31ni 01 l33jdua 316 Isill abOO "bSttJl3sIUfIsffl"

ai3mtJano3 ol bloa aboo Isnil diod a33ubolq lob3a nnul3s1un6rn

l3rIlo lo non3ubrnq nil aluqni as b3au aboo 3lsib3miolni bits

-- aloIo3a diod nil 1r13!3ftolq 11sup3 316 23 inuo3 HA .a3lui3slunsm

flu 3gslnsVbs 3VLis16qrno3 uflSr3dfll (flB asri fl0!51 13f11!3fl

.rthu13s1ur1srn

3111 n33w13d aleoo noilsrioqansfl 11silini Isril aoqqua 3W

3d 111w flOi31 (1353 3253 airil nil hs31D .d3inf V13V 316 2(101331 owl

diod ouboiq 111w f101331 11353 bris lfl3!3i11U2-113a 11s1lfl32a3

.aboo3 lsuiiliJoh3s bits bsllJl3sIurIsm

313f1T .21203 flollsilOqaftsIl 3fll3UbOl SllSUb613 3(11361(11 woM

3W as) Ii ;2no1331 3111 n33w'13d 3bsn lo li1idiaaoq 311) 3d WOfl Iliw

b3lsUn3l3IIlb nsm 316 5!3f11 (32s3 3111 3d 01 3U225 11kw

111w a3lul3slunsm nil 3b511 'sw-owl moa a13ubrnq bstul3slurism

Page 9: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

513th I3v5wof1 rfguon3 cIii1 sis 212o3 t1oqnsi1 as no1 aA .aris .13v31 3vii siggs 9111 is noiissi1shqa on d Iliw

abs3I isdi aahs aasxnq 151u313 £ v3wod inioq moa IA

moa iol noisr no isili aoqqu .noiithnsrThb Isnoist ol Iliw aifiT .ii1io 3113 nsrli ioioa nhui3s1urrsm 13ls1 s asri noassi

aboog 3isib3mini iol 13)hsm iis1 s ai11o noist isfil nsm 3v[13sIfls stom s 1sup3 anic1i 131110 noig1 isril a3Lsm auffi bits

abnoqasnoo 139113 aiflT) .aboo ff3ua 10 noii3ubrnq 315301 ol 33s1q

.("asAni1 b15w!3sd" 10 iq33noa in3mqol3v3b Isnoiiibsii 3fli ol

aboo 3isib3ml3ini lo i3sv 13is31 s a33ubolq noisr 3no ii iua

131110 niss -- 111w aboo 3adi 01 aaoos 13fl3d 13r1io &fi nsdi

its) aboo tsnfl lo noii3ulxnq lo aiaoo l3woI ns3m -- lsup3 agnidi

nibs31 ("sAni1 bisvnol" lo iqnoa 3111 ol 1ribnoqasno3 139Th

.no oa bits noist isrli 01 nnuios1uitsm 10 hula l3fIflul 5 01

inioq 1siiho moa wol,d ilsi aiao3 noiisttoqansli 11311W

ns olni 11aii 3insg1o 1auo9nsrnoqa 111w mono bhow 3111 n3th

.çI3fIqrt3q biIshiwbni3b s bits stoo bosilshiaubni

airli rIuon3 31sI ai loia3a nnuias1urtsm 3(11 11

Issi iii 33n313v!b s illiw b3isi3oaas 3(1 111w 231o1 lo noiisiinsi3IIib

biswlosd d b31ssr 3gsiffsvbB fu51o1ni51-1I3a 3rlT .113w as asw th iii iodsl 101 bnsm3b qu 3vrib 111w as1ni1 biswiol bns

131110 3111 iii iiaubni 10 nibb 3113 31111w noisi gnisilshiaubni

111w asw Isst audi ;bnsm3b ioclsl rnlls1 01 b531 111w noisr isili ff1 ilsI bits sioo 3113 a3rno39d lsrli rioipi th ni ah 1Is31q\i

V

Page 10: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

bs1 noiiiini imono !ido1D .1(I3ufqh3q 3th mood thulw

.inmnqobv3b nvnu o .1I1 oi 3unujno3 io3 noiisiIoqnE1i isfli oqqu won iuH

bn t3hEm oi o13 ni3d 10 nfiiioqmi 311i ob r1i A blJ3wl3Ed bnE bwio1 10 snBttoqmi rfi will bits -- 2I3i1qqu

noisi IsI3rtqh3q 3111 81irIwnsM .113w 2s 9nib3b Iliw -- 3E)1f1i1

.31z1 3gsw 13w01 s lo 3gsinsvbs 8111 21ubo1q I6iin3ioq i11o 11kw

tn3i3fflu2 3d Iliw io3 noitsttoq2nsii ni ni1b r1l inioq mo IA

8f11 ai3iIIo nsrii stom vI3dqhoq 3111 111 31si sw wo1 3111 isrIl

Is bits ;13i1qque bns 2i11srn mon 8iom3 gni3d 10 3gsinsvbsib

moil tuo 3VO 01 3viin3oni its 3vsrI 111w nnuI3s1unsm tnioq 1c1i

lo 33fl3g13Vfl03 £ fli3101 fl1figE 33110 (I3r1qr13q 3111 01 5103 3f11

231ff 3SW

-- iso 31ni s Psill n3di iguz toI2 oviliulni thIT

niwoig 01 nibs31 2I2o3 noiisfloq2nsli 111 3n1133b m131-gnol

3111 lo noi2ivib s irfl suboiq fIE3 -- i1ism bhow 10 noiJsiini

3ffl0311i Iii 33113t3V3 s n3111 2floi51 iooq bits rbh olni bFrow

.anoig3i oth nwI3d 51u131r112 3imono33 bits

3w 13v3wor1 1oi2 3viIiuini audi i aIrfiani 3111 'buia oT

.l3bom Ismtol s nib1iud 01 ix3n niul laum

8

Page 11: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

bboM !rrnoI A .11

this fihoM 23imonoo3 Owi lo 33f13iix3 3ff) 3fflU2S 3W

this aocr3i3131q zin3mwobn3 lii L&iinbi is rf3icfw rfiuo riiiori (Iqmi2 mono rifrtoT4 3rfi dhb 3W .o1orIr!331

.diuo ni blorl 2noiiibno3 zuooIsns isril

.w 3isI 3gBw fliiw iods! lo iinu J i!iiw b3wobn3 2i fitloM

811T .nhuios1irnsrn bits 31uiIu3hs z1oi33 owl 2fuSino3 II

iodsl 1no vioi vJinhJo3 fbs3 ni 18fflU2fl03 3viisin32sq3I

31IJi1U3riS f133w33d 33n313131q s!uoC[-ddoD siI bits 3mo3ni

as d b3in3Iq5I 3d ris 2n5r9181q 33dT .gnnui3slunsm bits

8(11 2i AP iiIiiij i V fbiffW (Ii flO!i3flUI 5iIJiibfI3qX3

;5Iut3s1unsm iol X3bn! 3onq 341 i MO bits 31uiIu3rIs lo 33flq

311T .3luiibnoqxs I3fflUflO3 it! 31ui3s1urIsm lo 515fk 3(11

miol 341 3)ISi inS1lf1O3 i3bUd

= (1)

lo 28IJ8nSV lo L3dmUn S 233UboIq I0l33 nrHJi3s1ufIsm 3flT

ii1ilu-du 2D s d b3is31s 315 ttii1w zi3ubo1q b3151111513Thb

ir1i lo x3bn! 8oriq 8riT .boog 8ii2oqrnoo s oini noii3nul

mio1 rIi Isi bits MO 3iioqmo3 nhui3thunsm

+ o-1

= ()

Page 12: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

ni ;ritioT4 iii b&uboiq iithsv lo l3dmun 3111 1 ft 31311w

n hslimi .q 33nq 352 3(11 is bIo2 Its 5t5 33f1i mundiliup3

m&1iuo .q hq is bIo2 bits r1iuo iii b&uboiq l8dmun 3(11

i 3151 £ is ai03 tIoqns1i gI3d3oi 1u3n1 ditoM iii bIos ai3ubolq

18Ufl3 £ niIqmi avFns boos rff lo i\I noifloqotq s , .3.i

.l3sv 3Ini s tol bnsm3b 10 (1i3iiasI3 3(11 i I < b .1q 33nq i 3Iui1u3nE isril muas w bi2 sIqqu2 iI1 01 nimuT

01 21r1u151 if1nir103 diiw todsi Ino au bits vffii8qmo3 Iio1I3q

muas bits (I = 9) 31J6I3Ufl 3(11 3d 3tu1Iuons 181 3W .3Is3

linu no IsfIl rku iinu gni2ooilD .b3bz11 Ia3Iiao3 3d ns ii isdi

mundiliup8 Ii vi iuqiuo 1o iiriu 3110 3ubcnq todsi lo noiiibrto3

(F)

bits 3tulIu3hs 33ubotq smono 3(1111 1 215up3 3151 sw 3rlT

.013 1 floli3ubOlq 1ffIUi11J3hS Ii Irro Ii be&x8

3ii2oqmo3 s bits todsi w nhui3s1unsm iii rnTH

3(11 8)Ism 3W .iuqiuo 8oubolq ol boos 3lsib3fnt31n1 nhuiunsm boos 3151b3mt31n1 3ii2oqmo3 3111 isdi noi1qmuzs nivuilqmi toism

33nq 3(11 2ur1T .boo noiiqmunoo 31ioqmo3 3(11 as 3ffl5 3(11 1 bits iod&I .3vods () itt bnftb as ) i isibemtini 3(11 lo x3bfll

oIonIb31 as1uoU-ddoD s (111w b3nidmoo 315 3istb3rrrl3lni i1i

31123mob tol iuqiuo 33ubo1q mift 1135E1 . 31Br1 3if3ib3fnl3iffl (111w

iuqni 3(11 lo linu nu noii3ubotq illiw (x) rIOqX3 bits (vJ 3IR

01

Page 13: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

II

() = 'c,t-QIJ

191CG IJJG OLW

140M UO1 IJJ1 W014}JCUJ uq OfIJJGUJ qcuJ9uq OL !UJG A9UC1)

(Q) - J\Q) =

COL 1\(ck-J) o bucc2 lc ci sccoLqiu o pc couq!iou

I4CX UO1C pf ULW urnqc nb bucc OAGL wgLurj co pA

bLoU O LGAGIJfIC) i bcu ou IUIGUJJcqIC

ncq pc ic p& bLobol4iou c oj co (uq iucc fGLG rLc uo

UrnIJnCWLc2 uq wc 2ccoliq JJJIGLIJJGq!C qcwmrq MLC MG pic

JjJG IJI2 GUII OU IIJC puq 2 !2 COIJ2flhJJGL2 GXbGUqJfflLG ou

() = +

ccouowA 9 F JjJGU MG JJAG

AJflG O GXbGuqifflLG Oil W1JflCtflLG ooq2 in tpc WøLIPGW

UOM CjrnLCGUG GdfUJ!pLflW 92 OJjOM jI21 qcuc JJG 1019J

ijn qc2cubflou oj bLccLcucc2 uq icpuojoA MG csu

(1) = ' + t +x)]

coi nucuou JJGLGOLG

92 xcq co uq k3 bcL f1U! onibn JCLCTjG cp ULUJ2 1Oi1j

Page 14: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

noiiibno3 iiloiq o £ 21 313(11 mifl lo tix3 bn.s 1if!3 3511 (111W

lo 3Xi2 3UpifW £ 23r12i1(M123 j3bom b qi 21(11 if' Isuau as (1311w

miii

.q'(1-)= x+ (8)

b 3b12 bnst1 ir1Fi 3(11 isdI f13U2 in3m3Iuas3m b 211(111 3200(13 3W

3111 2231X3 01(8) iii (V) 3211 bns '(iif1U 01 !5up3 21 floiiSup3 21111

as noiiibnoo iiloiq oi [* )o-i

+ = i ()

(ô) ) ) ) anoiisup d b32h3is1sr1 WO 21 mundiliupd

(153 (13111w (noi31 l3rIio 3rIi iol anoiisup3 auootsrts bits) () bits

.J bits it q W MQ a3ldshsv lo 23u16v muhdiliup3 bruii 01 beau ed

tnstloqmi ai ii I3bom 3(11 10 iiotiuloa 3(11 11122U32ib 31013a

Iii amifi lo l3dmun 3(11 n 113111w ni sw 3(11 brrsiai3bnu 01

r1uoiiii aidi aeob tI .iilids1floiq 'amii ai11s ,gnrluiQsIunsm

it iii 3as313111 nA .3n0 bisbitsia 3(11 2i 12111 3rlT .alennsdo 331(11

3111 gniflirla airli (() noilsupe) MQ xebni eonq 3111 aeaubei

rnoubst bits ((V) noiisup3) nwob miii ibse ioi 3v1113 brism3b

aI3nnsrl3 blifli bits bno 311T .((Q) noiisupe) 1i1idsufloiq 'arnhll

aeaii nhui3s1unsm ,.3.i ,3VliiaOq 2i Ii Ino 311n3q0

illiw b3isi3oeas MQ 111

fIOii3IJb5t 3(IT .iuqni its as fIflUt351UftSm

Page 15: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

((ô) bns (b)) aiao 1snism bns Isiol as3ubol won n iii sesstni ns

ss!ni1 biswio to �2 £ 21 aiciT .alflrnq amifl grriaisi idl siulibnsqxs Isloi 2SZsSlOni oaLs n ni 326313fl1 nA .amiñ nsswisd

bnsmsb niaisi aidi (() noiisups) d aluboiq bSlul3sIunsm no

sth ai airiT .((Q) bns (V) anoilsups) trnfl rbss 10 alfloiq bits

10 snsasiq sill ai II .afnlfl nsswlsd ssAnil biswbsd io bnsrnsb

.isqsq aicll ni sdh3asb sw 2133113 Sf11 23S13fl3 Isill assAruI sasiiI

insmo1gm3 bits luqluO .VI

IJ$dw ssa laiil sw a* tow Isbom sill woif 332 01 isbo it!

owl sill nsswlsd rthul3s1unsm b noiisoolls sf11 asnimislsb

rrsswisd (rlnuo3 r1353 iii tocfsi lo noils3oILs sill bits asrrinuoo

11iztdsIs ai inuncliliups sill lo bula !ssth1snA .2silivil3S

sf11 lo asirisqoIq sift lo noiliaoqxs tol lool nism tuo 02 xs1qmoa

ni bsvhsb 316 11ust 153 1snA .noiislumia lsonsmun ai Isbom

.xibnsqqs sill

!si3n3 ns ni as bits 1sbom muhdiliups 1sisns £ 2 airlT

sisqfno3 loslIs ni laum vtiaubni iloss sbsii lo Isbom mundiliups

dliw ais*ism tol sisqmoo laum Ii sbiz sno nO .alnot1 owl no

laurn ii sbia isillo sill no ;ilaubni smsa sill cit amti1 nisio1

sldiaaoq ai II .aiuqni tol vilaubni 3zjasmob tscllo sill illiw slsqmoo

lass! Is lo amtsl ni muhdiliups lo noijsniirnslsb sill lnsaslqst 01

sasill lo sno no noitnslls asauool ft3ufW lo doss amssib owl

alnoti sVililsqrno3

U

Page 16: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

lo axs di nO .1 5uJH iii b3lgti2uffi 21 mtskb d3u2 nO S bits n 2m1fl gnhiis1insm lo dmun r!i is iufl 21(11

3is3ibni bits MM 231ub3r132 i1T .!3vibq21 thuo bits ilitoM

nO .2ffiotq oix nis druo bits ffrroM ni 2mtfl iloiilw noIs ioo!

c1i i iix3 3vin2oq 515 2iflolq ii t31113 2mtfl 15(11 noiiqmu22s 3(11

if1 to1 .ewons 3(11 d b3isoibni 515 a3imsnb 3(11 3vi1sg3n 315

31ds12 3UU £ 21 313111 srui1 2ith wsib ol bu 21313m5ISq

r1i rnvsrt (ilfliio3 f13s3 illiw 3fl13mm2 21 ft3ifIW mufldiliup3

oti1 gni!t3bnu 21313fn51sq lo 23U15V) .2mliI lo l3dmun 3m52

.(xibn3qqs 3111 (H n3vi 315 251IJi1

doiilw as ms d1 lo noi1stn3tq31 3vilsm3iIs nA

3(11 to 1(1511EV 3111 21 21Oi351 iol fIOliii3qmO3 3(11 23i2sf1qm3

ioi1i mundiliup3 si3ng to1 owl lo msigsib "21022132"

Js11i nI .11 siui1 (H fIWOtI2 (!3bOffl 2101311 31h33q2 3111 IIsiqa3) .oto1 todsi Isiot 3(11 J 21 21X5 Is1noFioi1 di b r1in3I 3(11 31iJ11

5tul1u3hs ni bits J nhu13s1unsm (1! 1n3mo!qm3 m3(IrloM

.(I3v1i33q231 abfl3 bnsi1 1dh bits 1131 3111 moil b3tuas3m J .W 35W 3(11 21 ZiXE 153i113v 3fIT

i61 noii3njil bnsm8b 8111 21 8ni1 n3Aotd 8rfT

3Iqrni2 tuo bits ) noiisup3 2111323tq3t ii tods1 L6tui1u3i1s

bilo2 3rIT .linu 1rti3r1 is Lsinothoi1 21 ii Isiti 231u2it3 3t1J13u112

3(11 23vig ii .nhui3s11rnsm ni ods1 tol bnsrn3b 2i 3nh1

£ s fl3V3 Assid bits sq nso 2ffnfl rrI311tIoM Isdi osw mumixsrn

Isili n3vig J in3mo1qm3 gnhulosbuism m3rlttoM lo noii3nuI

M

Page 17: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

ii iuq oT) .1 = e riliw mundiliup3 ui 21 flruui3s1unsm m3111u02

nibik sd 31ub3r132 21(11 nivh3b b Aniufi sm 3(10 sw i3rlions

3sw mumixsm 3111 ruisIu3Is3 bus ,

I tuiI ni 2 nwob

is nnui3s1unsm (rt3fIflol4 ni 2iflrnq 3viis3nnon rliiw 1n312i2 (103

1n3(ItIoM .2woIIol 2S b3iuqmo3 21 31ub3f132 3rlT .inioq f1353

d iuqiuo 10 911L6v 8111 01 b31s131 21 nnuias1unsm ui in3mo1qm3

flOiiSJJp3 3(11

(01)

3111 ol b3iov3b 21 311fl3V31 mifl b (-I) noitloqolq £ 2! isr1T

ic1io 3111 (Ii 3V1135 21 31tJi1U3flS isiii 3111U225 3W .111(1 sw bus) (Q) bus ((() 2noiisup3 u nu1i bus I = 02 (Iif1uo3

2S mundiliup3 nnui3s1unsm iuo sfl ol (z3uo1sns f1i5Io1 113111

b8isli2u!1i 8(11 28Vig (01) noiisup3 (111w 21111 3ni2U .W 10 (Ioii3fltit £

•M bus w nwi3d qiri2rtoiisl3I

inioq 23VIu3 owl 3111 lo noii332l3ini 3111 15 i mundiliupd

3(1111 31uiI bits I 3HJ rliod ui b3isfl2uIIi 3253 3111 nI .

35W £ gruvsrl 23iffl0fl033 iliod diiw 3rti3mm2 2i mundiliup3

nhuios1unsm bus 1siuiIu3hs ufiod ni3ubo1q bus iinu 01 Isup3

'-I bits ' 01 Isup3 515 J\ 4 bus J\,J 2noltloqoIq 311T .iuqflio

(Il2ubu1i-s1ini 21 513111 r1uodiIs) 3b511 i3n Oit 2! st3rlT .!3v1i33q231

d b3niml3i8b 315 2315112 1 n3mo1qm3 02 31ui3s1unsm ru 3bsli

.noilqmu2no3 tsnfl (Ii 2101382 OWl 3(11 lo 231sr12

Page 18: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

3bsii lo 13v31 (I1f1 £ iliiW b3i3LJii2fl03 is II bits I uiI rf3um s ifiiw msIgsib woo1sns th 21111 ,wiT .( = 1)1203

3111 isrIl 21 lnioq nb!r112 311T .

(.1 = I) 212o3 3bz11 lo 13v31 i3wol

o2 viIioq won 2! 'nJJ3 bnsfn3b iodsl nhuiunr3m 3111 lo 3qo12

iffions 21 513r11 bits 1dsi2nu 21 U is mundiliup3 3111 IsrIl

iii i1sbq ithoM inioq 2ith IA . inioq is mundiliup3

iouboiq 1sniism 3ulsv 3111 3vods sw s 2sif bits gnhul3slunsm

iii bouboiq 21 iuqiuo Is1ui1u3FIs hA .3iui1u3hs iii iodsl lo

2! 3iufl 3(IT 3mi3s1unsrn 33ubolq o2Ls sm fL3ifIW rfluo Is1uu1u3ns 3(11 23mo33d thuo isrIl noriqmu2as 3(11 1111w b3ouboiq

is 51311T .b32i3v31 3d 321U03 lo sm al3dsi lud i3tIoqx3

mundiliup3 31ds12 irfriu1 £ bits U -- sndiliup3 trhi 31oldi b315Iin9ono3 nhuislunsm brw rlttoM ff1 nhisI3qo 3WI1u3rIE 1111w

.b3toni 3d 11kw 3253 thu no122u321b luo nI .thuo ni

gnnui3slunsm 3(11 lo 3qo12 lo 1si8vi i1i iol it02591 3rlT

n33w13d E3gsAnuI lo 3111 21 31ubd32 brtsm3b todsl

01 ihiuo mon mill £ fIiis3o13t 3nismI .2 mill nhui3slunsm

3111 Liv iuqiuo '2mtfl rnithoM tol bnsm3b a3is1 2irIT .rIitoi4

tol bnsm3b '2mlfl 232o3 3bsti 3viii2oq Is oni 3s1nu1 bnsrn3b

.nofls3ol 3S2 3(1115 arrnll no 15isnoinoqo1q2ib 21151 isibomt3ith

25 35ii1i1 1203 3(11 5!V 2i203 2mifl ffl3fthOfrI 2oub3t 0215 II

.21203 sbsii t53d 01 3vsIi ion a3ob 31s!b3rnt3irIi lo (i3sv 13(110115

lo no1Jst3mo1gs tot 233101 315313 23SAf1i1 323(11 11iofl

I 231ui1) 2i2o3 3bsti (1gid IA .noiis3ol 31gn12 £ fll nnu1oslunsm

Page 19: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

I&nfl 01 isn 3d ol bn (1I d b8isnimob is o101 di (II bns

Iuh3woq is vr1i ioo 3bsiJ T3wo! tA .bnEm3b 13fflU2ff03

3US3 bn 3IdEi2nu rnuhdiliup3 313mm 3(11 3)iEm 01 (1U0n3

fl0iiS18ffl0Ifi flflUi3S1UflEm

2231 i (c) noiiqmu2no3 Isnhl ni iuis1unsrn lo 31Bf12 3(1111

ff1 231s13mo1s nnu1os1uri.sm Ifs (13111 \1 01 I511p3 io n&11

3253 2ifIi nI .1 = = w 2511 muhdlliupo 3t1i bilE (i1nuo3 3IniE

s moil 13m 3(1 01 r1uon3 llsmz i bnsm3b gnFuJI3sIunsm bhow

3d1 ff3111 (b1ziiilli s) \I < Ii luH .noitsoI 3In12

lii 232i15133q2 (!1nuo3 3(10 .'W < w 9vlovni Iwm muhdiliup3

1rn 21 nhu13s1unEm iol bnsm3b 13(111111 ns gnhui3E1unsm

3(11 2132110 IsiIn3l3Thb 3SW Isnoilsmolni 3111 bns 13rtio 3(11

moil Ins1ib 2m111 rn3rIiuo d b313ThJ2 31nEVbszib lsnoils3oI

.213i1qq112 bns 213*IEm 113(11

ns :111 srldiIiup3 lo 31u131n12 3111 231H112u111 VI 31ujq

315 ErIdiIiup8 moI .( = 1) 21203 3bsli lo 13v31 3151b3m131ru

.(nwo(12 Ion 21 3wi1u3ns on asrl rftuo rloiclw m 111111 s) b3lslIwIli

Ion 515 23E)!n1I 2131T15d sbsii lo 13V31 3IEib3rIrI3inl 21111 tA

Ii IuH .muhdiliuip3 3i3mm2 3(11 i1idsi23b 01 1iuon3 ILJh3woq

23s)InhI (13111 nnu13s1unsm ru b3oIqm3 iodsl ii ils 2s(1 d1ioi4

.muhdiliup3 ns 21 21(11 is(11 31112(13 01 1(1313111112 SIB

21 21203 3b511 lo 13V31 3(11 as isili 1a3u2 VI - I 231LJiI

lo 1313B1&to 3V115111sup 3(11 (131(1w is arnioq owl 315 313(11 bo3ub31

3111 212o3 3bsli 1o 213v31 r1icf IA .23ns43 sndiIiup3 lo 132 3(11

VI

Page 20: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

1L6IJp3 i nnui3s1unsm 113111w iii 3110 21 muhdiliup3 31ds1 3upinu

jsnoiiibbs tnioq mo IA .hinuo3 3111 nwi3d b3bivib

01 ilsI 21203 tioqnsi1 113(1W llsrn1 .3g13m3 sndilnipe 3ni3mm2s

w 1! .31ds12nu 23mod mundiliup3 3nj3mm2 3111 13v31 16311n3 £ ilsi 11subs 21203 8bSfl 113111W lii 33fl311p32 1E3rIOi2ifI £ Io )lflifti

bits nAoid ai I13mm doidw is 13v31 1311sf 21111 2111 3mui 13V0

isdi work w xibn3qqs rli iii .23gr3m3 frl3iisq (13f1qr13q-31o3 3111

'd b3nfl3b 211 1 13v31 1s311h3 f1i

(1 —(÷ 1)0 (÷i = (H)

I1—(—1)o q—1)

lo noiio3q2ni moi1 V13v31 1s311h3 2icti 29n1m1913b is11W

£ 21 513111 11 ths 1no 1i3mm's isth 3311011 121fl w (1 1)

313W II .23151b3m131111 2S thoo b3lui3sIunsm lo 3101 in53fiifii2

;23E)1ni1 b15w135d brrs biswiol w31 3d bluow 313111 O13s 01 32013

£ 1qmi bluow 0 = is4i (11) mon ns w b33bni bns

bluow (21203 3b511 3viiiaoq ns) I < I rts .3.i I Io I 1s311h3

.3imono30 3111 nowid vJi3mmv 1qmi

no12231qx3 0111 1 > (J\-I)b ii om3I1x3 oii2oqqo odi iA

-5(03 £ IsrIl 21 2ifIi Io nOusIoIqloirIi 311T .3VIIS31I 23m033d

.315 21203 3b511 r1ir1 woil 15115(11 011 313ffl3 Iliw rrI3flsq 13r1qn3q

iloidw -- 3151 VIOV 815 81S32 lo 281ffl0f1035 Ii idiis 111330 iliw 2IffT

Io 315(12 3111 Ii 10 -- llsm2 21 o ii mundiliup3 111 31r11 3d 11kw

bns blswI3sd 10 o3nsttoqmi 3(11 211(11 bits 2i2o3 (Ii 23151b3m131n1

81

Page 21: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

3b Ii Asm 01 bn3i 2103351 cIba .IiI v13v i sIni! biswiol

.iis1 nhuis1un&n fit 23imono33 ISfrI3Ix3 013th

Inisi 21 ii [\(I-) O] !sv133fl1 3(11 In i. lo 23u15v ioI 13is l3CImhJfl 3ffl02 Is I lo 3U1Sv 153 iri3 s 2! 513(11 IscIl 3253 3111

21313ms15q ninsf13 lo 2138T13 3111 3vri3b 01 s3m 2111 .Iinu n&fi

.3Idsj £ 3151u3153 ol (E8 lud at2o3 11oq2nn lo 18v31 15311n3 3(11 no

bns t lo uIsv b snsi £ iol I lo 3ulsv lsoiiFI3 3(11 vi I sldsT

brrs -- 13r1ifI 21 3ulsv 153i1h3 1T .(11) noiisup3 (12iis2 113111w i bns t i l3woI 3111 -- iIs31 sFidffiup3 3!qiIIum 10 fiOi31 3(11 33(13(1

12o3 3onq mifl sis 13iss1 11 biow 13db nI . 21 13fLi11 3(11

ni 23isib3frfl3ini b 31B112 3r11 21 i3is5i 3111 bns 2qu-*Ism

.noiisl3mo!ggs iol 233io1 3111 sis !ull3woq stom 3d1 noiiauboiq

ohiomm c11 o j > (-I)i bns V.0 = 3. IA)

l3bnu n3v3 ;212o3 3b5I1 10 213v31 ils Is 3Idsi2nu i muhdiIiup3

233IJb31 ii (Isfil 2231 33flq 233Ub31 mifl l3dtiuI s nibbs hsius (21203

:1 3IdsT .1 1o 231J15V LG3linD

V b

0.1 OQI

Q1 V.0

Q1

Page 22: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

.31stbW bus 3b5IT .VI

iol sndiliup3 to 31ui3U1t 2ifli 1o 2noils3iIqmi 3(11 srs lsrIW

lo 33(13bn3q3b Ii 1r1wlli V sruiI cs11I3w bits 3mO3fli 1651

,i1i rn aviu r1T .2io3 3bSIi no 11flU03 (1353 (Ii 23SW Isst

(1353 n x3bni s*iq murioo 3rD d b3bivib 3SW 515 3Thfl

bi1o 311T .((I) noisup3 flu 113vi 25 V Ji1iiu 315 , .3.1) IiniJo3

Issi CV) 3flu! b3dasb di brts r1floM iii asw 1651 vi (V) 3fluI

.b3lsli2uIIi 515 shdiIiup 31d512 1nO .u1iuo (Ii 23SW

ln3rnqol3v3b lo sia srr11 &11 23JzflwIIi srugfl 3rlT

21203 3b51i 10 213v3! r1ir1 IA .ff011332 nibsrq 3111 ff1 b3Isns bns 51tJi11J3flS nhizI3qo (1353 3ni3mm2 sis r1iuo bins rIiiol4

= w) 51uI1IJ3ns 01 3v115131 Ew 3S2 3111 nivsit 5101313(11

.(V) x3bni 33flq 18U2fIO3 3111 01 3V115131 bits

3IqiiIum sis 513(111131(1w ni 1svini (IS 2315313 1 fl13Ub35I

3n13mm(a &fl inioq 3(1102 bnofl .(VI 31tJfl fri s) shdiliup3

its 2qoI3v3b mono bhow 3(11 bus s1dsi2nu moood muhdiliup3

311(1W r1iio4 ni 32fl 23SW 1531 lruoq ai(1l IA .31u131n12 3n13mmas

.21u330 in3mqol3v3b fl3V3flU lo aaooiq £ 4 tsrIi -- rfJuo ni gnillsl

10 2m131 ff1 3SW 3(11 ifluo fiT V11J330 33fI313Vib 21(11 23ob r1W

rigid £ usod IlsI 23SW 16ei lud iinu is 2si2 31u11u311g5

2irli b3tIoqmi 3d 01 3vsiI won 23lui3sIIrnsm lo noifloqoiq

Owl 101 3211 23SW 1631 rltio'frI nI .21203 nOq2nsIi gnrnu3fll

3(11 flI 325313fl1 115 232U53 brlsm3b iodsl gnhuioslunsM .2no2s31

13116(112 £ bnA .(\1 < h) 31U11lJ3flgS 01 3VttS151 3EW

Page 23: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

12o3 3bIi 01 1dua bns b3tloqmi 5iui3itunsm lo noifloqoiq

.l3rIflul V niti bru3 x3bni snq 1m1Jno3 3r11 ni3Ub5I airti

3bsTI aA .noiisiLsup3 ohq 1o13s1 10 no ai gita biiñi 3ff!'

abloff rioniw Isiin3l3Thb sw rt1 fIuon3 llsfna 3mo33d 21203

.aworisn (IofIqn3q brn 5103 ill niisoo1 n3swi3d insr11ibni arrniI

&Ii ni 8nuJo3b di bn thuo ol rIFIi1 lo noils3oI3l if diofi

rri3diuo 3(11 33ub51 sluiIu3ngs 1o aml3i flu gsw rn&lfloM

lo in3m3vom 311T .2sw !ssi niaizi x3bni 33r1q muano arnii 1o noiIEooI3$I .auouidms siom ai a3sw Isst nl3fthoM

x3bni 3onq 13fflU2fl03 3dT .51uiIu3hs lo 2111181 ii 23BW 2331Jb31

ni2E5I3ni n bia no no :rioiistib 13(1113 fit 3vom 13v3worI srn i1dua audi ai brrs b3tloqmi niscJ ai gnhui3sIIrnsm lo noifloqrnq

31S 23v!32m3d1 21203 3bs11 arfi bnBrl 131110 3111 flO ;aiao3 3bsli oi

wriT .x3bni shq i1i sub3l ol nibn3i 1i331ib b33ub5l fti3d siugiI flu b3iiiauIIi 323 3111 ii! .sw wr1ii3 3VOITI (ISO 23fiW 1591

wol 'i3V 01 nwob iiIuoid 315 ziaoo sbii as 11s1 asw 1591 V .213v31

s a3uIJiv 1313m5'Isq 352 8(11 lol boiotrxianoo asw V stug

ninsrf o lo aio113 r1i 3isoibni liv bns IV astui1 .VI - I asiugiI

fIi bns bnsmob rh 231u1351un51n lo sisrla 3111 213i3ms1sq owl

sisda 3(11 IV 8lui1 ti! .gnnuioslunsm ni a3isib3ml3ini 1o isr1a

3111 2325313fl1 airiT .b8a59loni ai bnsm3b flu asiuioslunsm 1o

a3oubst d313rti bris r1iuo ni (iiv113s nFiuios1unsm 1o inuoms

230b 3asdq 'noiisiIsdoI' 3111 3259 aitli nI .2on31311ib sw Issi

Page 24: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

.r1tio4 ni esw Ii niI1s1 3v!ovni ion

1o 51S(f2 3(11 (13(1W 32S3 3(11 231112IJJ1i IIV 31UiI

233101 noiis13mo1A .bwi ei nhuiounBm (Ii 23iib3m13ini

2ii313f!W .1si1n31311!b sw 1i l3biw £ f1I1B513 13noT12 won SIB

ifrioVi (110(1 (1! iiVii3S nnui3s1unBm 2i 313(11 231Ui1 auoivSTq (11

LsVl3in! 3111 -- 21203 iIoq2flzIi b 3flR1 S WOfl 21 313111 4iuo bns

bSisiln33no3 21 nnu13s1unsm Its rbidw ivo -- [8. I ,

8.I] I

3(11 15(11 noiiibno3 3,11 d bonimistsb 3is 23Bw ffl3rtilOT4 .dttoM ru

21(11 ;51u11bn3qx3 lo 3uIsV 3(11 2Ls1Jp8 luqiuo nh l3sIunBm to 3uIsv

ioI f1UOII3 31BI ion ILJd qs 3SW thuo-r1JioM 3g161 £ 23jsff13n3

1131(1w l3bnu 2noiJibnoD .3IdSiflolq 3d 01 rinijiosIunsrri fr13(thJO

.D xibn3qqs fli (l3Vlg 316 11J330 f1flhJ13fiiUflSm lo (1011611(133(103 21(11

3b511 2S 8fIE1 21(11 (II 1(1612(103316 E86W 1631 (fl3(flIOM isdi 33rIoM

.231Ui3S1uflBm (If1O 13311S 01 b3mu225 316 21203

23Iqmsx3 Lsonsmun no be2sd 3211J03 lo 316 2J1u251 sesdT

IIfl3f13 3(11 223I3f1i3f1OM .23U16V 1313m61.6q islu3iflsq no i isdi

IJ$iilni rlliw 232sf1q to 33(l3IJ32 3(11 lBIu3iilEq ill -- 5tuioiq

101351 01 rnul3l s d b3W01I01 'iss1qhsq bus 8103 olni nonslsqsa

313(11 25 noI 2A .Isbom eidi nvig 1.613n3 21 -- noi1si[sups 33r1q

< (-I)) fl01i2 001 Ion 316 323(11 IIJCI (0 < 1&) 23S)1mIII 3m02 316

3EW-IBIJp3 3(11 rI3iIIw W013d I lo Isvsl 1.6311113 £ 2SW1s 21 313111 (1

3(11 1 — I 25 IsdI 3253 8(11 swIs 2111 bnA .31d612nu 21 muhdiliup3

wriT .tB3qqs2ib 0215 i2Uffl 28r1iruJ03 fl33wi3d lSiin3lSIllb 3SW

-U sb 31u131q IS13n3 3(11 21313ms1sq (10 bnqb 211613b 3(11 1ir1w

Page 25: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

ion ob io3 ttoqznii 01 23gsw 3v11s!31 lo 3noqi b3qsci2

3j1oq 3bzTT no 2eioM .V

'd b3dhoa3b noiisi1sdoI 10 aooiq 311110 3asdq Isnfl 11T

ub31 i11uo i1 oi 10 biq 31f1 (131(1W ni jsborn mo kuoivdo methiol4 3luIo&1s 2qEth3q bns 3vi3E13I

bhow f1i no 1oiin3mmo3 nm lo is31 3113 01 bnoqno3 iibnuq-b3mui-3lisnoiIIid as dau -- mo r11 nomA .mono3o

nd asrl [4QI] qstT 3111' Aood ini or1w diimzbIoO mst ii ln3vsIq 01 3i3i1oq iinoi133io1q 3is3ovbs -- ll-3d ns3qoiu3 s

.gsw ni51q3b mon noinl3qmo3 Isdo1

.sw owl ni i1ubni lo noi1so1 311s iuiisl m3IlfloT4 A

3tS! 3(13 03 223335 '133uboIq mdino niniow d 1iiI ir1i lenisgA .dtioM 1i ol ernfl wi3ib 03 ebn3i ii ihsm nLtioM

b1ioqmi eboog 33s1b3m131n1 iol srnm sq won emiiI rrI3dtloi4

r1iuo mail ithoT4 01 emifi isi1ts 01 ci il13 33n 3111' .f1juo mrnl

JHV 311Ji1 ni b3isfleuIIi ci ci(1T .cIsiin513Tlib sw ninn3biw

C3nu133b 1 as csw 1s31 m3l11uo bns rn3lItioll eisqmo fbi11w

s bns 3bs11 3311 :eohsn33e 1nsi11ib owl I3bnU 1inu ebtswoi

C13i3mS1B .arloqmi e51u1313111115m no in33I3q & 1o IIiisl frl3ffrlOM

.V siuiI ni as SIB (e3niI 13il1i1 3113) csw Ithi 3b5fl 33ñ bits

3C311T .Iliisl m3fttIoM 3(13 (111w C36W 1551 3Vi C3fluI VS311 3fIT

3511 3fflOC lo af111S13 3(11 wIll ;3bsIi 3311 I3bftlJ nsiil 13I1u1 315

SIB 3I1Oq nhis313b-1I3e s s1hsee338n ci mcinoii33Iolq 15113 el3bfrti

Page 26: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

1131(1w Ufl3V3i Thisl vioi dilioM I1srtoilibbA .iuo 3rnod ion

.31uiI fi ni b3bul3ni ion i 33r1i luods 3bsm 3d v3wod bIuoi1 &ioiiuso Isi3zrIo owT

Tlhsi s 23oqmi 3Iortw s s rfhoM isrIl nioqqu iii ieiiI .2i!1J5I

bris rltioM nibIs31 bno3d no 133113 ru 3vSff 3w rfiuo i2niss

is31 is io jinu Isiii1oq s m341 b3is1l brus noii s diuo 113111w ni mzinothtoiq lo Asudiuo 1E13n A .noinu 2mo3uo

s 113w s T3f13o r1s3 molt artoqmi b313n1231 2norisn 3sw-(1if1

;3mooluo 111313Thb v,ti s iibouq hs13 bluow noiisn 3sw-wo1

rfl3fIlloM ftfloM-shin1 b3bsii 3js1b8m13irn lo 233nq 3111 gnizisi d \3i1oq 3b5Ii 3(11 1ln3u311ib ii iuq oT .1311u bluow vu1ubni

311Oq 3bzr1 f!3i11W ni 3fl0 i 11W 31ui1 d b3dh3b in3mh3qx3

21(15w o(1w f1iim2b1oO b z3Iqi3ath d 13V0 n3)ISi n33d 133113 (U 25(1

81111W 2fIOliSfl 3gsw-f1if1 flom5 23lul3sIunsm (Ii 3b511 3311

.2loiii3qmo3 3sw-wo1 molt 2noqmi gnhirl3V3Iq

I3bom 3(11 Isili iuo lnioq of insfloqmi 21 ii 81om13r1tIu1

2i2inori33lrnq m3bom 3ffl02 lo 2misla 3(11 luo ised ils is ion eob 11 11w 2eninuo3 nev,ied 1no ebsil 2wolls H3irlw 3m1g31 5 isrIl

iodsl lo 2123131ni 3111 ni worlemo2 21 23151 335W lslimi2

31u311 d bedh32eb ohsruee 3113 flI :(1uino3 ecu nO .313f1w(Ievo

d 1no 3n1133b 335W molt b31331oIq 315 213)hOW mediloM IIIV

0215 deie11f bns noiisi1shl2ubni mediuo ineiqioni 3n12231qqu2

.wol 2335W 1531 mer1iuo 3niqeeA

Page 27: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

.I$1 irifluL 101 noi1au bris tsmmu .IV

31111w 161(1 2i 2i lsns 31ffl0fl033 lo mob2iW tsrIoiln8vrloo 3rfT

Ii quoi 125131ni lsIu3mBq tiud sm noiis3ni 1sdo1 13iS31

i33 ftiods 121,1 lo 3fn03fl1 1631 IIBl8vo 3(11 3isi Hsrrnon Iliw

120m 3(11 (Ii fl3V3 3liJl 21(11 01 2no11q33x3 316 313f1T .noiisn

jEi3flinS s 113w 26 IffwiBn 3bs1i 01 21316(1 :l3bofn lfinoiifr3vno3

1svom3l li3rti bits 11hsi 1smiiqo 01361 3b 26 13s a3mibmo2 sm 223I3r1i3noM .llo iow z3hlnuo3 31(102 3v531 3101513f11 5ffl

15(11 rIoliqrruJa3lq s i23gu2 01 332 ob 2l3bom 3b6fl bisbnsi2

.niif1 boos bnuoi-lls ns 2i flOiiSlg3ifli

is± biigis no1 3V511 mob2iw 1EflOiifl3VfiOO 21111 lo 3i1hD

1snoiisn oiboiq 116u21J noi1Ei8ini 131631g 1s11rto3 3(11 no b3ut6 3V6(1 2311fl3 X0b0131311 11snoiiibsiT .213201 bns 2l3flfllW

bhow b8iElg3irIi its 15(11 -- iiL6up3ni 2131201 noi1613ini isril

ooq s bits 3103 rbn £ olni 23b1v!b 12uo3nsinoq2 \fflOfl033

3(11 15 231(103 131(133 3111 1 1(11.63w r1i isrIi bits vI3rfqn3q

isth in3mugIs (Isnno3 3(11 26(1 (1ifl3331 1nO .32n3qX3 2'(13r1qn3q

b3nis 32fl3X3 2'3103 311116 (t3f1qn8q 3(11 21fl3n3d noiisiLsdo1

.bnuo1

l3bom 31qm12 5 IsfIl 2i iqsq 21(11 (ii flWO(12 3V511 3W 16(1W

nOii3s131n1 3(11 d fl3Vflb i noiisiln3l&Ilib LRno15I 1131(1W (11

riiod lo 32(132 23)tSffl 21203 tIOq2nsli bits 2311(10(1033 31632 fl33Wi3d

£ 3v3ifbs leurn mono bhow 311T .e1n3rnuls W311 bits blo

32U63 15(11 233101 3(11 31o13d noilstg3ini lo 13v31 15313 (1151133

Page 28: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

risilw brt ;biorl sAst ass visdqhsq bits 3103 olni noiithlnsisThb

is Ittsq 2i smosni 3103 (II sth sill iusso noiisiinsisThb isril

sill isvswoil isiltiu1 2bessolq noiiEI3lni aA .s2nsqxs is1s(lqnsq

ni sth nul1u231 3(11 bits bsbois S1E oo sill lo esgsinsvbs

.sznsqxs 'sioo sill is thsq sd sm smosni Isisilqhsq

bluos 2i2\LS11E 211111131(1W 111 25W snsm (i2uo1vdo SIB 513f1T

iii 2noilsslib ssirll si2sffqms isvswod bIuow sW .bsbnslxs sd

.lsiu3rnsq

aiift olni rtqsios siom is ol sIdsliasb sd bluow ii 4etiL

I2uonsoxs owl lo niixs 3(11 slsiuieoq sw ebngt2 ii A .Isbom

.23101 bsvhsb i2uonsobrIs no s)IBI ascIi ilsulw ,2nois1 bsriilsb

sill asw isciw olni bsslq2 ilsubs 2s11 "3103" sill sslissIq nI

rfsum sisi bslinU msiIluo sill 2S 25315 113u2 rliiw "zsclqhsq"

1sviiss11s si2A iesd lo smog won bits rtsqs1 sqO1ua trtsrliiio lo

nnuiss1unsm 01 2lsiiqque Isluilusngs moil noii2fIl3Ii ii nbism

-ilium s 01 2i21sns sill brtslxs 01 slii bluow sw o .2lstIoqxs

.53sq2 2LJOUnhiflo3 illiW 3110 nsvs 2qsthsq nifls2 nois1 ii bssbni -- iiIidom Isliqss 2sbulsxs lsbom mo bnoss

noilsisini 13V0 slsdsb isaililoq sill lo ibum IsY .Isiiqss on 25(1

10) ascIi 1sfl1I lnsmsvom iliqss lo 2issqmi bsslls sill no zs2usoI

bbs 01 sd bluow qsie Isiuisn £ 2uriT .2wofl sbsli (ilhiw no1s

.2insmsvom 1511(453

ei2[snB 21(11 snilqis2ib 01 insttoqmi Iauoivdo 21 ii ,llsnH

ioiosl-srro )hsi2 5 1)313110 svsfl sW .aisdmun Lssi smog dliw

Page 29: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

snoW .niriow 111i rh ii1T .2bn3i IsdoI iasv 10 noisnsIqx3

\rhEffl b 33ibu31q 3th 01 Is3qqs Iliw isth noIlsnslqx3 fiB 1 ii

01 *iow ls3hiqrn3 duoi is1 is ob 01 !5131n3 i ii wriT .3Iqo3q

3d ol IIi! us is i 31r1 bodh3b ioi2 lo bribl 3di irIii1w

W .bnii 3imonoo !sdolg 1si lo noilsrIsIqx3 3ffi lo iisq gu1 s 3rti rliiw fl0iist3ini fliwO l3flsm L531i351q £ 2E i&Ii i33qw

rIflo'fr1 rIi lo ow 3imonoz r1i ni 1o13s1 iomm s i3d is i rthio

tuods !uh153 3d bluod2 no isrti ai inioq insfloqmi r1i iud

1[sui3s 3lqi3nnq ni 3Idi22oq i isnil ninIi3mo 15111 3fhimuB

.33ii351q ni wqqsnI

3i313x3 1u1u £ S ii bls3I w enoiius3 323fft lo 3iiq2 nil

bas -- 51311 b&Jh3b bnb! rfi lo lsbom izilsmnunim £ iIrIino3 01

fbu oi h vi niso 3luioIrli2 £ 31qmi o isrii 3ldshsmsi ii bni1

1sdoI tfi nil oniivnoo bnis 3onI3gI3vib lo 3luioiq niiq5w £

monoo

Page 30: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

El! W!U11U ? uq E !AG

I

(v) + ,

(vt) J-T

A(j-h)y' +(va) '=- A(I_h)V +

,tvYJj_Q(vs) =

+

0f11pGUJ GxbLG22!01J2 ( ( () 9uq () 9fl2JU cdniou (Jo) MG C9U GXbLG22 IPG L1J0 Oj J40L1p6uJ uq

Th*(vi) ---GUcj0GIJ0112 AffUJG 0jJ0MDGIJUC . i suq IJJG LH0 0 J4OLIJJGW 10 0fllGUJ A9JflG 0

ybbcugix v: JJJG 9JcpLs o 2AwwG1LA-pLcIJau

Page 31: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

01. JG22 1p9U IJJG AJnG iwbpcq pA cdnou (jj) o IJJG 1Gx1

UT1WG11OL !2 b02!pAG 01. UGS1TAG 9ccoLqIu 10 MPGIJJGL I !2 LCfCL

qG1J0UJUJ1OL 0I TJJ!2 GXbLG22IOU TO G bO2iTJAG 12 (1-t) > J JJJG

GdIUJJpLJflW QMGU IPT (Ø J) 2flIJJCIGIJI couqiou 0L I}JG

JJJI2 qGLIMITIAG !2 IJJG 2J0bC O fIG 1'JN CIILAG T fIG 2AUJWGTUC

Q(Q -iXi _h) + (,_1)[a(h +1) - j](V8)-— = Tj + — (h+J)[Q(h+j) —

TI

jojjA uq 9bbJAJU CLGWGL2 WJG A16Jq2:

220C!Tcq C}J9UG ...qçN !U fIG UG }JPOL}JOO O IIJG2G A9jffG2

M1IJJ = i uq = cOU2qGL 2UJJJ Cp9IJG q[' MJfJ

BA JU2bGC11OU = J IJJGLG 12 2OJflPOU 10 TPG2G Gdflp0U2

JJJG2G IMO GdfNfJOU2 GXbLG22 uq 2 JWCI10U O 9Uq 14:.

A(j_h) + -(vbx) . =

A" h\" h-Yk ,ta-I (h-jXa-1) J— J +

suq

'�Q +\(vQ) =

i-:i- (h-JXJ-a) Xt�-Q

Page 32: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

u1sv 1i3rnff1s :fl xibnqgA

= = ' = J is V-I iuiI 10 2noiJsIIJmi2 srIT

= 3 = 3 VI-II ufl iii briE = 31 iuiI nI 2 = o

nI .V.O oi b32s513ni 21 ' IV 5llJi iii .13vi33q231 = 3 . I

.ô.ø oi bmui31 21 bns .O oi bs3ioni 21 IIV siuiT

noii&i1si3q2 lo fnflsq 3fiT :D xibn3qgA

bnsmb lsnfl ni 231ui3E1Un&n lo 31Sf12 8± 2E no1 2A

8vlovni 32um muhdililJp3 3rIJ3mm2s 'ens \I 2b3x3 3111 230b Wfl .23luI3EhiJnsrn flu (iirruo3 "3103" 3(10 d no1is1Isiooq2

2i II V2m13s1unBm 3ffl02 3ouboiq o21s iinuo3 "dqh3q" r1io .llB3i61dIs f101123up 211(3 (10 1r(i1 3(1102 b3f12 03 3111122oq

= w 3101513(13 bns rltioT4 ni i gnhui3slunsm ils oqqu :3vB11 (13(13 3W .1 ()

+ = a = * a = * a + a

10 u!sv 3113 215up3 3luribn3qx3 Isiol 111(11 2E2 323(11 IO 12111 3liT

311T .(31Br12 iodsI rti d b3bivib hid 3EW 3(11 21113111w) luqluo

noilE3oI c1o ni 3luhibn3qx3 nhul3s1unsm 3v1 biidl bris bno nifl3 .bnsm3b 3151b3m151rn gnIbul3rn 3lIJlibrI3qx3 m3(lfloM 1131w

fliV102 bns I = J = J

+ = a = = 'K (OIA) I4-I )y'-I y-1

o

Page 33: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

isili i mundiliup3 ifs 3d 01 2ith o1 noiiibno3 A

2!f!T .iI1uo ni 3niaubolq lisle 01 rrniI ns tol 3!dsiiIotq ton ciii

3d1 no bnuod tqqu its gnieoqmi noiiibno3 £ as 1191w 3d 1153

gniion bits () bits () illiw t3dioi (Q) rtieU .w sw ni8rifloM

:ei noiiibno3 3f11 ,Qi = Q ni1l O = ' ni1w isrli

o-1 a j- + D4 (hA)

di tol) XI 3tufl iii nit 9V1u3 as b9isttau!Ii ci qiilcnoiisl3t chiT

inslcno3 tol bits JIV 3lIJgft ni bcu as et3i3mslsq 1o 23u!Sv 311152

fli3ffliO'frI 3fIi nit 311i1 3111 3VOdA .((OIA) mofi 'El bits El lo cu1sv

ol rn-ill £ o1 3ldsiflolq 3d bluow ii isrli rLuon3 rIir1 ci gsw culT .3ldsifloiqnu ci cull ii wol3d bits itho ni rIciIdsic3

t31s1 ci bits i 10 c3u15v 3isibOfTfl3lfli is cAf33q qsg 3EW mumixsm

.3 fli3fliUO 01 3VIiS13i El 51unbn3qx3 frI3ffiiOM Ci 3g151 3111

3fIT .cnoilst3bicno3 noils3ol Ishicubiti d n3vi ci nit 3'au3 3fIT

.31111 b3rIasb 3111 d b3islicuffi bits (OIA) d fl3Vi CS Ci 3EW 151J135

r1i rloirlw ni ,

22 Is'rnini 3111 ii b3ci1siqe h1u1 ci rnithdiliupEl

13c 01 elrtsw mill on isili f1uon3 wol ci rIliol4 iii gsw muhdiliupo

.diuo iii qu

lici3VifrU bto1nsi .c3imono3El lo 1ooib nobnoj

Page 34: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

j (jKUtWU b0! uq JOfG!4 MLIJCG 1J)2q Oj uq\Mt& (ioiY i n- i j

ipc JpjLq joqq s JjJLGU

\O%owcc1 touoiT XCIX (iôôiY -ioKthWSU &f1J 11JUCLC2!U GffJW2 suq ECOIJOWIC cosbp)1.

(iooY oo-obCW o LLq1 4C3$ FXX

nwu jnj ECOUOUflC joqnc D CLculJpou uq pc

eoJq2uJ!w iw (['ouqou nK: yccw!JJu2

C°'U Q\I (ii)ouq o rpc j2 ccuu.A i#pr bbcL1

COWbG!AGUG22 uq EUJbJOAWGU1 IJG CpJJcuc2 uq M1A2

COWW!!OU O IJJC nLObCU Cowwnucrxxii (iY go-o

OGLU jpcoLA O IUGWIOUJ jLqc1, 'csciupci. JLGq 1M!OU1 uq IU1CW!OIJ9! KCWLIJ 10 CJC !U

FXAII (ioxY

ObPWIIW LOflC1 D!AG12!ÜtU

DJ)UI V/4JJP uq lo2cbp 2PJU .1NOUObOJ!flC cowbcrnou uq

JEEEI�EMCE2

Page 35: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

qcnarou bbcL uo g (jrUjGq IufIP4c CCUP. OL ECOUOUJ!C bOT!CA jccp

upjca yuouA i 41jdriippunw rocqou o IGWCIJ?

Page 36: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

SUIJ t[JSU J4OI4pCUJ 0UC2

2 J9LCL tpSU tpC JSttCL 20 2OfrIJJcw jLW2 9LC P!' psiqc pA tpc

(anjcc psjomicwcqwtc SLC iwboi.tcq) JJJC OLWCL CJCC

tpcp asjca pA q it imaca j,joupcw w2 coata ou sjj ua asjca pA

L4OLtIJ suq 2°fltp ip wutj raca onpcw twa, coat ou psjcjoac to t = j St Mp!Cp UJSUflSCWUIJ Ta qiqcq cdrisjjA pCUCCU

jO 2CC tP2 couaiqcz. S 2UJ9JJ MOLIPGUJ WUJ. p- Sf S bOIU

qJacnaa It ffLtCL JU ybbcuqix c

MCJJ pJ2 12 s 2OWGMS1 qqcnj1 dncaqoua to ujAc MG

abccwpc rn 9t4CnJtnLC 01. qoca t bLoqncc aowc wsunscnca sa

MOLfIJ !2 abccScq !U WSI1SCWLG2 pflt qoca 2°tp

r'SMLCUCC [j] suq KurwSu [io*]

qcAcJobTu cornuLA cxboi.a ou sqiuccq uSnoua 2CC KUIWSU uq

j EOL ajccbpcsj saacaawcua o c anbboacq jwbsc o

EUU0tG2

Page 37: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

GL0 bL0J4 F0C! TU J/1OLI:p iq 2011W

2

EICflT�E I

III

Ti

6'///

/II

S

I

I

Page 38: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

T5

H!P L9G COfBEICflJ�E II

0

o\0 OLCG JTJ wguflgcg1LJJJ0 TOO

T

Page 39: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

I'POL Dq f'OM Lq COEICnJcE III

0 50\° ]OLCG JU mgungcSILTTJ

0

08

TOO

T5

n

V\T

Page 40: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

JpoL JTJJGLJJJGG jLgqG COEICflKE JJ\

\O OLCG lB JJJ9UITTTJC4S1LTJJ

0 SO TOO

Page 41: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

jgq C0212 iqEICflI A

1 T•3 3 35 3.8

Of-I

// ______

I,'

Page 42: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

HTP k

EICflJ�E AT

I 1Q

0Q-— — —

'.9/ A A

, 1I1*

1•5

Page 43: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

I

'.3

H!P hEICflKE All

I 15 18 S 5.5 5.f

I

Page 44: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

C.)

1

'.5

J�J M!11J g J,4OLJJGLU 1gLjEICfl1�E AlIT

I I.Q 5

08

T

Page 45: yupouA i• upjc - NBER · IA moa inioq v3wod £ 151u313 aasxnq aahs isdi abs3I ol Isnoist .noiithnsrThb aoqqu isili no noisr iol moa noassi asri s 13ls1 nhui3s1urrsm ioioa nsrli

I

2onq.rnLu 2bGcJT9ouEICf1I�E IX

1 T•3

I3 3.3