178 = >7 - ˜ -
Embed Size (px)
TRANSCRIPT
Microsoft Word - tahghig tajrobi ...== - - 489> ?8 / 0.-1. @"
A
- B C. . ./0 12 3 45 2 3 6037 8 5 8
D7 E +FG* 4 1 452 3 6037 2 3 8 58
I" J 4 2 3 0 609 : ;< 8 5 8
45 .- 4= 8 >?@ 0 8 8 5 8 5 60
K
AB0 3. C 3D EE . F?F GE 5H IEJ KE 0 4L E >63 M N O= . J= QNR M
4 O= . 3 G CD. F?F GE60 E H 3. S D@ > E D3 E 8Q . E / TAE I E @ 4 U
;E E OE 8O VKQ . E W O ) E I . 1 J ;K2/2 8/2 @ 4 FX 90 M E Y .:ET
0 8 H8 D Z4 Q O 8O VKQ2/0 T: Q < T:0 [ H8 X VKQ S 8O VKQ13/0
< :E5 .. O T M )= O \ 4 EC Y IEJ W\ E EM N\< : O4. . 4 :] ?< ^3 E 4 80
O O= . S E^ . . Q ^3. S I^ 01 0_ [= [ T< E KL S ^ ` . 4
S ^ ab X E KL O O ?< ^3 E= S ^ X . 4 [ KL S S ^ ab O O ?< ^3 E E=
: H8S S ^ E 1 /\ cBE H 3^ H8 O. 4N ^3 dK4 O . 4 :. E F ?DX 0= <
S ^ ab O E eE E ?DX5 E 4 E HI H H8 E 1 . I. GE dK4 I :E D .= S <^ E eE
O ?DX30 . 4 E H
L.) 4( 4;: E I : O4 O= F?F GE b a .
Experimental investigation of angle of attack effects on aerodynamics characteristics of
delta wing-body-vertical tail combination airplane model in ground effects
Aerospace Engineering, Aerospace Institute, Tehran, Iran A. Ghajar Aerospace Engineering, Aerospace Institute, Tehran, Iran S. A. Seyed Shams Taleghani Department of Aerospace Engineering, University of Sharif, Tehran, Iran M. R. Soltani Faculty of New Sciences and Technologies, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran M. Masdari
Abstract Aerodynamic characteristics of an aircraft with delta wing are considerably affected under the ground effect in take-off and landing phases. In this research, static ground effect of a 60 degrees delta wing with axisymmetric sharp edges in combination of body and vertical tail at low speed wind tunnel are investigated. The wind tunnel is closed type has an opened test section that its dimensions is 2.8 m × 2.2 m and maximum velocity is 90 m/s. In these tests ground effect is simulated using a fixed plane that its height is variable. With decreasing the height from the ground plane, the lift force is increased, induced drag force is decreased, total drag force is increased and nose-down pitching moment is increased nonlinearly. The rate of increasing of lift coefficient in linear regions increased with decreasing of height from ground plane. At the positive angle of attack the most percentage increasing of lift coefficient is due to 5 degrees angle of attack as the result of existence of perfect vortex flow over the whole wing surface. The minimum case is due to 30 degrees of angle of attack. Keywords: Wind tunnel, Ground Simulator, Delta Wing, Aerodynamics Coefficients.
1 - +
E / =O M = 4L E >63 3D3 D3 .
?< D3 J O =O E GE 9A O D .
8 L E I E AB0 =O E 8 H .3
Y = . f E .3D3 . E .
=O M N : 0 4L E .3O ?D@
: =O M .3 J M O H O. ?< 4
=E ?< g 3 J GE = ^3 GE O =
^S 8 M E 8 H Y E / O = H .
^3 E ^S [email protected] : GE 8 = / . 1
Y 5 U3 E O 8 : =O M 1H M O
: =O M ] 1 f GE 3 O1 -2 1 KE [
] 4 1 J ;K 3 -6.[ : =O M >S O
AB0 Y 3. l 4 0 Y GE m c
I 0 E 4 = Wa = 8 ` I . 4 GE = O
JE EM GE 8 8 H 8 I0 .DE 0 O I0
4 0 S \ = WD/ = O 4
144
QN
R
E /
O
...
JE EM E ^3 3 @ 4 O = GE =E X .DE
0 ^3 [email protected] ^3 = X =
0 ^3 = O . 1 0S E E 8 G;
4 0 0 ^S . 1 I 4 0 E.
E ^S 8: 0E [email protected] 4 ?@ = 4 m ;.
GE Z4 : 1: =O M . E ^S [email protected] O
: : =O M = ^3 o 4 GE 3 O
. 5@ E . WD/ E E E I. Q .
. 4 O. : 8 H ^H 4 pK< O O
. 1. Q ` I = E 3 GE p 3
0 0 = H / [email protected] H 3. E 1 :
l ^3 GE 3: =O M . GE 3 O
8 H 3. E 1 . =O ?4 E 8 : 5H =E
GE ?< E N 5 TJ =O O 3 : ^3 I E .
E 1 8 H TJ . f E 4 f. 0E GE M
f O. 43 E E .:E 8 f E ZL. I
. Q f E ; . =O M = O .
^3 E. Q / =_D3 8 H 8 Y .:
(O O ^3 [email protected] : bA O ^S [email protected] =
qB0 ?DX O C M GE 1 ^L g 8 .
H mrL E E 5 E Q@ 3. = O 4 @4
^3 E ^S [email protected]. Q : ./ E E
I . S ^ S .^ E S [email protected] E ^
8 S )^ ^3 ( E . 0 O
1.
>63 0 VO 3 GE X. = uE vK4
01. l S 8 / GE = .
D3 ^_ / [email protected] 01 1 8 E 5H = O
0_ 01 \1 : E .. . = 4 >Ou D3
; X E 01G vK4 O \ 4 E wuD; =
E. a Q 84 I<X > : =O M .
0 VO. Y GE = dK4 Y [email protected]
l S ;J GE 1X . OV 0 .
J dK4 Y g D Y [email protected] ;J Y = .
0_ 01 GE Z4 : 1 E 01
E. Y G; X E = : 6 3 ]7 .[
X c I4 GE. Wa cL E =O M.
63 . 4 S6 E ^g E 0_ 01 cBE W\ E
fXr IEJ c E =O M . Y _ I0 =
:O . l S :E : =O M E
.: /EH L O 8 H ;J O Gc >5g C O
@ 4 4 E b a FX C l 6 U5
1 @ 4 =_D3 = 4L E qB0 GE .
E b a FX =O M N VKQ dK4 E E
^3 ^S GE I: I E ]8 UE 4 bH .[
N ^S . E b a FX ^S E / I . xL
=O M O 1 =_D3 . 4 y@ E / =O M
1 =O M D O . J\ : :
1 E . ^3 . 1 E V 4 ` 3 ]9.[
T M O= . D3 E / 8 6 E wuD; E
X c >63 Wa = . W\ I0 / g
lSH T Y uE W\ . Y [email protected] O fXr IEJ . E
1KL [ T M = 0E D3 O E . 3
_ [email protected] = X c 8: : .
8 O T;K. zAL C SC H8 GE
F?F 8 H8 zAL . 4 1 T< O 8E
O T M= E. 5E. F?FQN TQ N. E. GE 3.
F?F EE . O T\ = . 4 1 T< ^37=
O T M ^37= . AB0 3. 4 G
F?F GE 60 ?DX E HS O E ) ( Eb 10 H
J dK4 E 8Q O dK4 = > E 2X E (
D@. E / T< E O E O T M . 4 1 J=
. AB0 3. 4 G F?F GE 60 H
: Z @O O ) uEC U ?8_D3 (= E
D@ > E 8SD3 2X. 0 E. B= E=
E / T< E ^37 QN R . 4 1 J
2 - D) (4 - / -1. NFJA
O T M E W 4 E= 8 M 4 E
4 O= O O W\ 8 )= Y 8O E D M (
O= O O W\ 8 )= Y 8O E (
QU E. Q O >63 G 4 .D 33D. NK4 M
3O . 3O E eE > 4 0 4L E.
3 0 4L E3D. {\ G T M uD; .
=OR c O 3. O . ]10 -14 [R c O 3. I
] E15 -194 E [ J 1 E ; .3D3 . E .
W 4E . T\ =O T M :EX c .
( H .3D3 E I .3 . E .O .3
O T M RJ =DB= ;4 GX :E.
T M ( E =O 3. E / O 9? BE J 1 .
= ( I: 3 3. O . 3. E E I.
33D. G :E O W\ 8 J VH E 8
O= O T M GE Gc E = 4 E J 1 .
( 6 E. 33D. NK4 M S ?< C dK4 E
O O W\ 8 J VH E= GE E
O T M= ;K 1 .uD; 3. E E I. 4 E
W\ EM G C O =O T M EM N\< O 9? B .3
\ 4 =O 1 E .= \1 =O M 4 ;K (
.: O 4E .3= S D3 O (
: EM W\ C =O .O4 X .
: ;< .O4 3 GSD ( O :E f .3
O M = E \ 4 .D = ` E G T<
AB0 CS =O N\< E ( = O \ 4 E .:
145
4
;< ` : GS .O4 1]20 -23[ .Z : 4
NK4 M O E I D3 . E =O T M E
;< K : . 4 T\ 4
.E 4 1 J ;K 9? B .3]24 -32[ .
VH ]33 -34 [.3 C GE F?F E O 6Q@
E b 80 H 45 H O . 1 : .] 80 E
^3 ?< O =O . E ^3 E . G4 1966
T M =O E . .3D3 . GE E . f = GE
F?F E .O 55 H 70 H O R c .3 I E
Z4 |D u ]35 [T< ). G4 1969 .3
I E G C D3 E GE F?F N M =O Z4
?64 } ]36 [>/ 1 ]
O . 1 3 E ] . f Q 1. }g ^D3 E
H >@ E0 T r L 8 .3 : O .3
4 E ]37 -38 .[5 E D33 E GE .3
F?F E 8S O 6Q@ 60 70 75 H XB-70 F-104
U3 E T< U3 E T< 4 L .5 >6D3
E E ^D3 E = / 4 T@\ h/b ≤ /0.4
] 4 I E .D3 . GE .3 F?F XB-70 M
=O ^E O 8S ^E E : . E Y . E E 4
]39 .[ =@ GX 8S mr L =E ] 4
E ^S . f ^3 . G4 1987 8u
3 ]40 [ .3 M 4 M =O E .
GE F?F 60 H G .D3 F-106B G .D3 XB-70
I E @ 4 = >/ .5 E = / 4
8S T Y b a E M =O D O Q
M 4 =O :E. C C . E ;K T M =O
Z4 8 D ]41 [ G4 1989 WE 1 . =
C ` GS E X Q G . C N\< =O b:
: .O4 : .] 4E E T M 4 =O X
N\< EM N\< p N Q 1 .] 80 N\<
p N M D . T M 4 =O .E c ? `
GS [email protected] ^3 M =O Q E X 4 Z :
1.
TQQN : >/ E .3D3 . E 4 80
=DB uE 6Q@ O = . f .3. f .3
4 E I J IEJ 8S E EM W\ .O .3
. 3 8BD3 ( O 3. ?< QNR O O M= E
. GE 3. F?F E I ( :E . = ^37
O T M= . AB0 3. 4
F?F GE G 60 D@ > E 2X E H. E / T< E
O uE O @ 5/1 8?O E 4 1 J
3 - O2/7 0.P ? @ 4 U E I 3 E I . 4 : >/
OE 8O VKQ E 4 8 H E E E I C )
:E I: .1 D. SC ? @ 4 U E I 80
8O VKQ . 4 : . ;E2/2 8/2 Gc E
4 .:E H8 H = C Z4 E I 38
N. / 1 = KJ .5/4 A 8 FX 2/1
T6 :E @ 4 . O = 60 560 J Q IEJ
Y H @ 4 . 48 O 8O VKQ 10 90 M E
Y IEJ :E E .. 5E\ H8 f\N 8O VKQ
O ^C GO ~Q E ~Q1 E9 C 9
O u. G?4 Gc E16 4 D 2 @. 3
E . 4 : \ 4 T:0 [. 1?H . T OS VKQ E
O u O IJ 8O. C @. ^ E; S . 4 :
8S H @ 48 S E 8O VKQ^ KL T< E =
Y 4 E .] 4 8 H8 (0 [ T: VKQ
O D 8O VKQ . E 1/0 < E X E :E
X E (0 [ T: 8O VKQ .5 D43/0 <
: .4T O D 8O VKQ S T:0 [13/0 <
@ 4 .:E X .316 32 M E E (0 [ T:
O ^E1 < C 4 O : wuD X 4
E I = y .:E O E .3
H @ 4 = D3O T:0 [ T: .. H8
S 8O VKQ O^ E .] 4 8 H8 VKQ
80 E I 8O 3 \ H8 D VKQ G
b4 8O :E .G ^O G GE F?F 60 H
E D3 E > .D@ I: 2 80 : 4 .GE
TAE EM E ^BE E IA : 4 .O 6Q@ GE
60 H Gc E KJ E 29/10 :E .E E T<
L4 : 4 .C [ p S E U O 20 H Gc
256/0 C VKQ KJ EM E Gc 836/0 .GE O N\<
B E .3 p S ?DX L4 : 4 .
.S 3 TAE 8Q E Q O 1 . ?DX 20
H 10 H :E .Gc 0 GE 781/0
Gc I GE 1 :E . X GE VH 433/0 VE
Gc Z4 577/0 E .3 01
E ;J c 25 < Z4
O . 1 : 4.
. E J 8 G VKQ 8O O C 4 4
\ 4 : 4 8 8 Y O ?DX O 10 - H
40 +H O ( 4 H O 90 - H 90 +H :E
)I: 3 .(G E \ 4 O C O ^: \ ^ /4
TAE } 4 E 4 56 G IA 1 .O ?DX
O ( 4 H E \ 4 O 3 E . 4
bA : 4 3 .3 01 E \ 4 O
O ^: \ ^ /4 O . 1 1 .0
Z4 C T -C 4 . E VKQ 8O bA :
4 O . 1 1 .? O 0 3
.3 01 TAE H L .34
O . 1 :E Z4 U 4 )L [email protected] 30 E y
146
QN
R
E /
O
30 S 3? (O : E \ 4 O b a
84 4E .3 84 TS5/ E
D .3 S I 1 . E 4 ] 84
TS5/ FX .KL O . 1 . E . H
E E . FX E b G; 13/0 < 3/0 < 4/0
< FX .KL .3 01 0_ H ?[ E b
4/0 < 4/0 < 7/0 < :E . FX .KL
O . 1 O . ?DX ( 4 H 20 QJ :E. VE
O E eE .KL I: .3 01 3 . 1
O 8O .KL X yuE 84 .)1E .3
63 G E .3E M N yuE
O4 X c 4 =: E I .8O bA J >@
]4 ^ 3 .:E VE .KL eE E O ?DX .O . 1
H ( 4 O .3 J . 1 >S O
G E yuE GA . E E8O 56 ? E
.3E N yuE X ^DL 8O 8O N
G .:E
M =O E \ 4 O C N\< EM W\ 8 E G
IEJ Y :E ;K J 1 4 .N\< : O4
=O I< 9? B O G J 1 )I: .3 4 5 ( y O
=: 8 I E 84 @ 4 8 H VKQ 8O E @ 4
f G .O ?DX ( 4 H 9? B
J 1 4 .@ O 3 G; 106×5/1 ) E Gc
Z4 (E 4 E E L E 4 E
=g @ O 0 AN \E E 4.
Q 1- : 2-)P2. 4 8 Q9 4/
Q 2- .93-G == : 4.9( :60 8
Q 3- S . 4) - == : 4.9( : <5 A/ /
Q 4- F-; : <5 ) -4 . . S 8 A/ /
H/b=1.7
H/b=0.2
4 - T2 @ ( ) U" E . 4 ) T< . ) E eE .3
3 O 3 G E T< D; VKQ 8O bA :
4 4 6 G E T< ; bA : 4 .
] 80 4 3 O . ) 4 L E
4 . J O . 1 E \ 4 O 4N m N =6 VE
b a .3 . ) 4E 4 . . E
] . ;KJ >@ I?N C E J ;KJ >@ =;
I: ;KJ >@ M .3 . 4 1 T< ^O
U 4 J yuE TrL y O .3 Y . 1
Z : .3 Y .:E U 4 ;KJ >@ . 63O . E
S C . 1 O 1 T< .3 . y
G64 l ; 4 E 1 I<X 8Dc .3
b4 yuE 3 4 O .:E D y Q . E
30 S 3 ? .:E U 4 J 8S N . E
O . 1± )V/bit ( ×/ :E . Q
O \ 4 E ; m N Z4 60 O 3000
D O D 3 . E : . E . 4 : . 1 E
) D Z4 =E mr L60 ;DH Z4 Q E ( 3
)3000 (KQ .:E E 4 = ] N .O ?DX
10 - 10 +H J O . 1 b a 004/0 b a E
025/0 b a 01 0_ 02/0 4E 4 . N
.O ?DX 10 + 30 +H J O . 1 b a 006/0
b a E 035/0 b a 01 0_ 025/0 4E 4.
I: 6 N b a E. G GE F?F 60 H E
bX O ?DX 8E 2X N\< =O .3 . )
U4 /4 @ f E . 4 : O I<X .3 .3
. ) VH .3]20[ E eE C F?F GE60
l 4 H: 4. ) G.S . 3 TAE
8Q E Q O 1 . ?DX 15 H
4. E ] 4 . ) .3b: b a E E
O ?DX X KL G; 49/2 E 8 :E .N
b a E O ?DX 25 H TAE KL E E ^S
0E O ?DX E I GQ E .?H KQ /\ E 1 3 O
bQ@ E D4 GE F?F N O X KL xL :
/ b: N ^3 5 O ?DX X
35 H 1 {\ .Q FX b a E G; 3/1
:E . I: 7 N b a 01 0_ bX E O
?DX 8E 2X N\< =O .3 . ) 80
: 4 .Q 01 0_ E KQ 25 < Z4
O . 1 : 4 .N b a 01 0_
O 1 TAE KL :E .Q b: N X
KL G; 2345/0 - :E .b: N b a 01 0_
E b a E G; 3/0 - E = EE S
I ;J 55 < Z4 J . I:
8 b a bX E O ?DX 8E 2X N\< =O
.3 . ) : 4 .Q 5H .3 VH
]20 [I: l : 4 .Q IJX b a G;
0095/0 :E. N b a \ )L/D (bX E
O ?DX 8E 2X N\< =O I: 9 80 :
4 . FX Q E E X 8 O ?DX 5/3
H{\ .I: 10 T Y b a E E bX ?< O
=O .O ?DX 9? B U4 : 4 .KD3 O I:
4 J ?< G N\< =O D O 9A Gc GE
1 b: N E T< KL [ E ` uE ^S
. .O ?DX \ = M ; E ^3 ?< O
N\< =O [email protected] ^3 Q b a E 1 . O ?DX
X 5/3 H Y Q ?< O =O Y g . Q
b a E / D . E H E 3 O ^3 E ?DX
=O N\< O ?< ^S E b a ?< ^3 = EE E
E N b: ^S [email protected] =O O . 1 I: 11 N
8S ^S b a E E bX ?< O =O 80 : 4 .
M ; N\< =O O. ?DX \ I: 4 .
O ?DX 30 H cBE /\ 8 H E 1 . . GE 2X
N\< =O uE .. E Q 5/0 < H/b `
T Y uE :E . I: 12 N < ^S b a E E
bX ?< O =O : 4 .< ^S O ?DX 5
H IE I 8E 8 H E 1 . . I dK4 J GE
IEJ H :E Q = ^S N\< O ?< = D
=O X 40 < 4 . I:13 T Y b a
01 0_ E ?< O =O l : 4 . .O
?DX F / [email protected] =O N\< O ?< ^3 01 C
c 4 . / E G rD@ : \ 0_
. 1 GQ [email protected] =O N\< O ?< ^3 VJ
. / : bQ@ E G I S
^S G 4 c .E T M = \ ?DX .O
; .:E I: 14 0_ 01 b a Y 8S
: 80 F ?DH .O . 4 8S uE ?DX .O
0E \ 0_ 01 . 1 b a Y <
I: =O N\< O ?< bX E 0_ 0115 80
. 4 : .O ?DX F Q b a 01 0_ [
148
QN
R
E /
O
= E ^3 ?< O =O ^S Q = ^S
X 50 < 4 . .O ?DX \ = T M ;
: 4 . I: 16 N\< O ?< bX E b a N
E 8: CS E F ?DX .O . 4 : 80 =O
E ^3 I . b a GE Gc E E C =O N\<
0ECS ^S I . b a / =O N\< E 8:
I: .E17 ?< bX E b a ^S 8S N
^3 8S ?< ^S E . 4 : 80 =O N\< O
I:) b a ^S < I . b a18 ^3 (
. 4
Q 7- 3 2)./ <3 - 'W )'X <2-I
Q 8- 3 2)./ <3 - <2-I
Q 9- <2-IL/D 3 2)./ <3 -
Q 10 - A/ /. $Z <3 - 7- <2-I 0.-[
149
4
Q 13- A/ /. $Z <3 - 'W )'X <2-I
Q 14 - O2.PZ. <2-IA/ /. $Z <3 - 'W )'X
Q 15- /. $Z <3 - 'W )'X <2-I O2.PZ. $8
A/
150
QN
R
E /
O
Q 17- A/ /. $Z <3 - <2-I O2.PZ. .P "
Q 18- A/ /. $Z <3 - <2-I O2.PZ. $8 "
5 - 4-X = RQN T M =O .O ?DX U uE E .
AB0 .3 C G .D3 GE F?F 60 H E
2X E > .D@ E T< E / I E U @ 4
@ O O C U 8? 4 E J 1 .]
= RQN 80 4 T M =O ;E O ?< O =O
O ?DX :E . .O ?DX Z4 uE J ?< GE
F?F =O D O 9A Gc GE 1 b: N E E
T< KL [ E ` uE ^S . .O ?DX
\ = M ; E ^3 ?< O N\< =O [email protected] ^3
Q b a E 1 .. E Q 5/0< H/b ` T Y uE
:E. .O ?DX F 1SE O 5/3 H Q b a
01 0_ [ = E ^3 ?< O =O ^S
S I E D4 bQ@ /EH 0 =
bH ^S . 4 1 . .O ?DX
g O 5/3 H .O ?DX \ = T M ; :
4. E ^3 ?< O N\< =O Q b a . I ^S
< ^S 8 E ^3 ?< ^3 4.
6 - (8
L E . (N)
α ) ?DX ODegree(
7 - \.- [1] Qu Q., Jia X., Wang W., Liu P., Agarwal R.K., Numerical Study of the Aerodynamics of a NACA 4412 Airfoil in Dynamic Ground Effect, Aerospace Science Technology, Vol. 38, pp. 56– 63, 2014. [2] Rozhdestvensky K.V., Wing-In-Ground Effect Vehicles, Progress Aerospace Science, Vol. 42, pp. 211–283, 2006. [3] Ahmed M.R., Takasaki T., Kohama Y., Aerodynamics of a NACA4412 Airfoil in Ground Effect, AIAA J., Vol. 45, pp. 37– 47, 2007. [4] Ciffone D.L., Pedley B., Measured Wake-Vortex Characteristics of Aircraft in Ground Effect, Journal of Aircraft, Vol. 16, pp. 102–109, 1979. [5] Han C., Cho J., Unsteady Trailing Vortex Evolution behind a Wing in Ground Effect, Journal of Aircraft, Vol. 42, pp. 429– 434, 2005. [6] Harvey J.K., Perry F.J., Flowfield Produced By Trailing Vortices in The Vicinity of the Ground, AIAA J., Vol. 9, pp. 1659–1660,1971. [7] Halloran, M. O. Meara, S., Wing in Ground Effect Craft Review, DSTO-GD-0201, Aeronautical and Maritime Research Laboratory, Australia. 1999. [8] Advanced Research Projects Agency, Wingship Investigation, Vol. 3, Technology Roadmap, Advanced Research Projects Agency (ARPA) Report, 30 September 1994. [9] Carter A., Effects of Ground Proximity on the Longitudinal Aerodynamic Characteristics of an Unswept AR 10 Wing, NASA TN D-5662, February 1970. [10] Baker P.A., Schweikhard W.G., Young W.R., Flight Evaluation of Ground Effect on Several Low-Aspect-Ratio Airplanes, NASA-TN-D-6053, 1970. [11] Corda S., Stephenson M.T., Burcham F.W., Curry R.E., Dynamic Ground Effects Flight Test of an F-15 Aircraft, NASA- TM-4604, 1970. [12] Curry R.E., Dynamic Ground Effect for a Cranked Arrow Wing Airplane, NASA-TM-4799, 1997. [13] Curry R.E., Owens L.R., Ground-Effect Characteristics of the Tu-144 Supersonic Transport Airplane, NASA/TM-2003- 212035, 2003. [14] Schweikhard W., A Method For In-Flight Measurement of Ground Effect on Fixed-Wing Aircraft, Journal of Aircraft, Vol. 4, pp. 101–104, 1967. [15] Chang R.C., Muirhead V.U., Investigation of Dynamic Ground Effect, in: Proceedings of the 1985 NASA Ames Research Center’s Ground-Effects Workshop, NASA, Ames Research Center, pp.363–393, 1970 [16] Chang R.C., An Experimental Investigation of Dynamic Ground Effect, Ph.D. Thesis, Department of Aerospace Engineering, University of Kansas, Lawrence, KS, 1985. [17] Jones B.L., Experimental Investigation into the Aerodynamic Ground Effect of a Tailless Chevron-Shaped UCAV, Master Thesis, School of Engineering and Management, Air Force Institute of Technology, Wright-Patterson Air Force Base, OH, 2005. [18] Katz J., Levin D., Measurements of Ground Effect for Delta Wings, Journal of Aircraft, Vol. 21, pp. 441–443, 1984. [19] Lee P. H., Lan C.E., Muirhead V.U., Experimental Investigation of Dynamic Ground Effect, Journal of Aircraft, Vol. 26, pp. 497–498, 1989. [20] Chang Ray C. and Muirhead Vincent U. Investigation of Dynamic Ground Effect, Proceedings of the 1985 NASA Ames Research Center's Ground-Effects Workshop, NASA CP-2462, pp. 363– 393, 20 August 1985. [21] Lee P. H., Lan C. E. and Muirhead V. U., An Experimental Investigation of Dynamic Ground Effect, NASA CR-4105, 1987.
151
4
.
- B C. . ./0 12 3 45 2 3 6037 8 5 8
D7 E +FG* 4 1 452 3 6037 2 3 8 58
I" J 4 2 3 0 609 : ;< 8 5 8
45 .- 4= 8 >?@ 0 8 8 5 8 5 60
K
AB0 3. C 3D EE . F?F GE 5H IEJ KE 0 4L E >63 M N O= . J= QNR M
4 O= . 3 G CD. F?F GE60 E H 3. S D@ > E D3 E 8Q . E / TAE I E @ 4 U
;E E OE 8O VKQ . E W O ) E I . 1 J ;K2/2 8/2 @ 4 FX 90 M E Y .:ET
0 8 H8 D Z4 Q O 8O VKQ2/0 T: Q < T:0 [ H8 X VKQ S 8O VKQ13/0
< :E5 .. O T M )= O \ 4 EC Y IEJ W\ E EM N\< : O4. . 4 :] ?< ^3 E 4 80
O O= . S E^ . . Q ^3. S I^ 01 0_ [= [ T< E KL S ^ ` . 4
S ^ ab X E KL O O ?< ^3 E= S ^ X . 4 [ KL S S ^ ab O O ?< ^3 E E=
: H8S S ^ E 1 /\ cBE H 3^ H8 O. 4N ^3 dK4 O . 4 :. E F ?DX 0= <
S ^ ab O E eE E ?DX5 E 4 E HI H H8 E 1 . I. GE dK4 I :E D .= S <^ E eE
O ?DX30 . 4 E H
L.) 4( 4;: E I : O4 O= F?F GE b a .
Experimental investigation of angle of attack effects on aerodynamics characteristics of
delta wing-body-vertical tail combination airplane model in ground effects
Aerospace Engineering, Aerospace Institute, Tehran, Iran A. Ghajar Aerospace Engineering, Aerospace Institute, Tehran, Iran S. A. Seyed Shams Taleghani Department of Aerospace Engineering, University of Sharif, Tehran, Iran M. R. Soltani Faculty of New Sciences and Technologies, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran M. Masdari
Abstract Aerodynamic characteristics of an aircraft with delta wing are considerably affected under the ground effect in take-off and landing phases. In this research, static ground effect of a 60 degrees delta wing with axisymmetric sharp edges in combination of body and vertical tail at low speed wind tunnel are investigated. The wind tunnel is closed type has an opened test section that its dimensions is 2.8 m × 2.2 m and maximum velocity is 90 m/s. In these tests ground effect is simulated using a fixed plane that its height is variable. With decreasing the height from the ground plane, the lift force is increased, induced drag force is decreased, total drag force is increased and nose-down pitching moment is increased nonlinearly. The rate of increasing of lift coefficient in linear regions increased with decreasing of height from ground plane. At the positive angle of attack the most percentage increasing of lift coefficient is due to 5 degrees angle of attack as the result of existence of perfect vortex flow over the whole wing surface. The minimum case is due to 30 degrees of angle of attack. Keywords: Wind tunnel, Ground Simulator, Delta Wing, Aerodynamics Coefficients.
1 - +
E / =O M = 4L E >63 3D3 D3 .
?< D3 J O =O E GE 9A O D .
8 L E I E AB0 =O E 8 H .3
Y = . f E .3D3 . E .
=O M N : 0 4L E .3O ?D@
: =O M .3 J M O H O. ?< 4
=E ?< g 3 J GE = ^3 GE O =
^S 8 M E 8 H Y E / O = H .
^3 E ^S [email protected] : GE 8 = / . 1
Y 5 U3 E O 8 : =O M 1H M O
: =O M ] 1 f GE 3 O1 -2 1 KE [
] 4 1 J ;K 3 -6.[ : =O M >S O
AB0 Y 3. l 4 0 Y GE m c
I 0 E 4 = Wa = 8 ` I . 4 GE = O
JE EM GE 8 8 H 8 I0 .DE 0 O I0
4 0 S \ = WD/ = O 4
144
QN
R
E /
O
...
JE EM E ^3 3 @ 4 O = GE =E X .DE
0 ^3 [email protected] ^3 = X =
0 ^3 = O . 1 0S E E 8 G;
4 0 0 ^S . 1 I 4 0 E.
E ^S 8: 0E [email protected] 4 ?@ = 4 m ;.
GE Z4 : 1: =O M . E ^S [email protected] O
: : =O M = ^3 o 4 GE 3 O
. 5@ E . WD/ E E E I. Q .
. 4 O. : 8 H ^H 4 pK< O O
. 1. Q ` I = E 3 GE p 3
0 0 = H / [email protected] H 3. E 1 :
l ^3 GE 3: =O M . GE 3 O
8 H 3. E 1 . =O ?4 E 8 : 5H =E
GE ?< E N 5 TJ =O O 3 : ^3 I E .
E 1 8 H TJ . f E 4 f. 0E GE M
f O. 43 E E .:E 8 f E ZL. I
. Q f E ; . =O M = O .
^3 E. Q / =_D3 8 H 8 Y .:
(O O ^3 [email protected] : bA O ^S [email protected] =
qB0 ?DX O C M GE 1 ^L g 8 .
H mrL E E 5 E Q@ 3. = O 4 @4
^3 E ^S [email protected]. Q : ./ E E
I . S ^ S .^ E S [email protected] E ^
8 S )^ ^3 ( E . 0 O
1.
>63 0 VO 3 GE X. = uE vK4
01. l S 8 / GE = .
D3 ^_ / [email protected] 01 1 8 E 5H = O
0_ 01 \1 : E .. . = 4 >Ou D3
; X E 01G vK4 O \ 4 E wuD; =
E. a Q 84 I<X > : =O M .
0 VO. Y GE = dK4 Y [email protected]
l S ;J GE 1X . OV 0 .
J dK4 Y g D Y [email protected] ;J Y = .
0_ 01 GE Z4 : 1 E 01
E. Y G; X E = : 6 3 ]7 .[
X c I4 GE. Wa cL E =O M.
63 . 4 S6 E ^g E 0_ 01 cBE W\ E
fXr IEJ c E =O M . Y _ I0 =
:O . l S :E : =O M E
.: /EH L O 8 H ;J O Gc >5g C O
@ 4 4 E b a FX C l 6 U5
1 @ 4 =_D3 = 4L E qB0 GE .
E b a FX =O M N VKQ dK4 E E
^3 ^S GE I: I E ]8 UE 4 bH .[
N ^S . E b a FX ^S E / I . xL
=O M O 1 =_D3 . 4 y@ E / =O M
1 =O M D O . J\ : :
1 E . ^3 . 1 E V 4 ` 3 ]9.[
T M O= . D3 E / 8 6 E wuD; E
X c >63 Wa = . W\ I0 / g
lSH T Y uE W\ . Y [email protected] O fXr IEJ . E
1KL [ T M = 0E D3 O E . 3
_ [email protected] = X c 8: : .
8 O T;K. zAL C SC H8 GE
F?F 8 H8 zAL . 4 1 T< O 8E
O T M= E. 5E. F?FQN TQ N. E. GE 3.
F?F EE . O T\ = . 4 1 T< ^37=
O T M ^37= . AB0 3. 4 G
F?F GE 60 ?DX E HS O E ) ( Eb 10 H
J dK4 E 8Q O dK4 = > E 2X E (
D@. E / T< E O E O T M . 4 1 J=
. AB0 3. 4 G F?F GE 60 H
: Z @O O ) uEC U ?8_D3 (= E
D@ > E 8SD3 2X. 0 E. B= E=
E / T< E ^37 QN R . 4 1 J
2 - D) (4 - / -1. NFJA
O T M E W 4 E= 8 M 4 E
4 O= O O W\ 8 )= Y 8O E D M (
O= O O W\ 8 )= Y 8O E (
QU E. Q O >63 G 4 .D 33D. NK4 M
3O . 3O E eE > 4 0 4L E.
3 0 4L E3D. {\ G T M uD; .
=OR c O 3. O . ]10 -14 [R c O 3. I
] E15 -194 E [ J 1 E ; .3D3 . E .
W 4E . T\ =O T M :EX c .
( H .3D3 E I .3 . E .O .3
O T M RJ =DB= ;4 GX :E.
T M ( E =O 3. E / O 9? BE J 1 .
= ( I: 3 3. O . 3. E E I.
33D. G :E O W\ 8 J VH E 8
O= O T M GE Gc E = 4 E J 1 .
( 6 E. 33D. NK4 M S ?< C dK4 E
O O W\ 8 J VH E= GE E
O T M= ;K 1 .uD; 3. E E I. 4 E
W\ EM G C O =O T M EM N\< O 9? B .3
\ 4 =O 1 E .= \1 =O M 4 ;K (
.: O 4E .3= S D3 O (
: EM W\ C =O .O4 X .
: ;< .O4 3 GSD ( O :E f .3
O M = E \ 4 .D = ` E G T<
AB0 CS =O N\< E ( = O \ 4 E .:
145
4
;< ` : GS .O4 1]20 -23[ .Z : 4
NK4 M O E I D3 . E =O T M E
;< K : . 4 T\ 4
.E 4 1 J ;K 9? B .3]24 -32[ .
VH ]33 -34 [.3 C GE F?F E O 6Q@
E b 80 H 45 H O . 1 : .] 80 E
^3 ?< O =O . E ^3 E . G4 1966
T M =O E . .3D3 . GE E . f = GE
F?F E .O 55 H 70 H O R c .3 I E
Z4 |D u ]35 [T< ). G4 1969 .3
I E G C D3 E GE F?F N M =O Z4
?64 } ]36 [>/ 1 ]
O . 1 3 E ] . f Q 1. }g ^D3 E
H >@ E0 T r L 8 .3 : O .3
4 E ]37 -38 .[5 E D33 E GE .3
F?F E 8S O 6Q@ 60 70 75 H XB-70 F-104
U3 E T< U3 E T< 4 L .5 >6D3
E E ^D3 E = / 4 T@\ h/b ≤ /0.4
] 4 I E .D3 . GE .3 F?F XB-70 M
=O ^E O 8S ^E E : . E Y . E E 4
]39 .[ =@ GX 8S mr L =E ] 4
E ^S . f ^3 . G4 1987 8u
3 ]40 [ .3 M 4 M =O E .
GE F?F 60 H G .D3 F-106B G .D3 XB-70
I E @ 4 = >/ .5 E = / 4
8S T Y b a E M =O D O Q
M 4 =O :E. C C . E ;K T M =O
Z4 8 D ]41 [ G4 1989 WE 1 . =
C ` GS E X Q G . C N\< =O b:
: .O4 : .] 4E E T M 4 =O X
N\< EM N\< p N Q 1 .] 80 N\<
p N M D . T M 4 =O .E c ? `
GS [email protected] ^3 M =O Q E X 4 Z :
1.
TQQN : >/ E .3D3 . E 4 80
=DB uE 6Q@ O = . f .3. f .3
4 E I J IEJ 8S E EM W\ .O .3
. 3 8BD3 ( O 3. ?< QNR O O M= E
. GE 3. F?F E I ( :E . = ^37
O T M= . AB0 3. 4
F?F GE G 60 D@ > E 2X E H. E / T< E
O uE O @ 5/1 8?O E 4 1 J
3 - O2/7 0.P ? @ 4 U E I 3 E I . 4 : >/
OE 8O VKQ E 4 8 H E E E I C )
:E I: .1 D. SC ? @ 4 U E I 80
8O VKQ . 4 : . ;E2/2 8/2 Gc E
4 .:E H8 H = C Z4 E I 38
N. / 1 = KJ .5/4 A 8 FX 2/1
T6 :E @ 4 . O = 60 560 J Q IEJ
Y H @ 4 . 48 O 8O VKQ 10 90 M E
Y IEJ :E E .. 5E\ H8 f\N 8O VKQ
O ^C GO ~Q E ~Q1 E9 C 9
O u. G?4 Gc E16 4 D 2 @. 3
E . 4 : \ 4 T:0 [. 1?H . T OS VKQ E
O u O IJ 8O. C @. ^ E; S . 4 :
8S H @ 48 S E 8O VKQ^ KL T< E =
Y 4 E .] 4 8 H8 (0 [ T: VKQ
O D 8O VKQ . E 1/0 < E X E :E
X E (0 [ T: 8O VKQ .5 D43/0 <
: .4T O D 8O VKQ S T:0 [13/0 <
@ 4 .:E X .316 32 M E E (0 [ T:
O ^E1 < C 4 O : wuD X 4
E I = y .:E O E .3
H @ 4 = D3O T:0 [ T: .. H8
S 8O VKQ O^ E .] 4 8 H8 VKQ
80 E I 8O 3 \ H8 D VKQ G
b4 8O :E .G ^O G GE F?F 60 H
E D3 E > .D@ I: 2 80 : 4 .GE
TAE EM E ^BE E IA : 4 .O 6Q@ GE
60 H Gc E KJ E 29/10 :E .E E T<
L4 : 4 .C [ p S E U O 20 H Gc
256/0 C VKQ KJ EM E Gc 836/0 .GE O N\<
B E .3 p S ?DX L4 : 4 .
.S 3 TAE 8Q E Q O 1 . ?DX 20
H 10 H :E .Gc 0 GE 781/0
Gc I GE 1 :E . X GE VH 433/0 VE
Gc Z4 577/0 E .3 01
E ;J c 25 < Z4
O . 1 : 4.
. E J 8 G VKQ 8O O C 4 4
\ 4 : 4 8 8 Y O ?DX O 10 - H
40 +H O ( 4 H O 90 - H 90 +H :E
)I: 3 .(G E \ 4 O C O ^: \ ^ /4
TAE } 4 E 4 56 G IA 1 .O ?DX
O ( 4 H E \ 4 O 3 E . 4
bA : 4 3 .3 01 E \ 4 O
O ^: \ ^ /4 O . 1 1 .0
Z4 C T -C 4 . E VKQ 8O bA :
4 O . 1 1 .? O 0 3
.3 01 TAE H L .34
O . 1 :E Z4 U 4 )L [email protected] 30 E y
146
QN
R
E /
O
30 S 3? (O : E \ 4 O b a
84 4E .3 84 TS5/ E
D .3 S I 1 . E 4 ] 84
TS5/ FX .KL O . 1 . E . H
E E . FX E b G; 13/0 < 3/0 < 4/0
< FX .KL .3 01 0_ H ?[ E b
4/0 < 4/0 < 7/0 < :E . FX .KL
O . 1 O . ?DX ( 4 H 20 QJ :E. VE
O E eE .KL I: .3 01 3 . 1
O 8O .KL X yuE 84 .)1E .3
63 G E .3E M N yuE
O4 X c 4 =: E I .8O bA J >@
]4 ^ 3 .:E VE .KL eE E O ?DX .O . 1
H ( 4 O .3 J . 1 >S O
G E yuE GA . E E8O 56 ? E
.3E N yuE X ^DL 8O 8O N
G .:E
M =O E \ 4 O C N\< EM W\ 8 E G
IEJ Y :E ;K J 1 4 .N\< : O4
=O I< 9? B O G J 1 )I: .3 4 5 ( y O
=: 8 I E 84 @ 4 8 H VKQ 8O E @ 4
f G .O ?DX ( 4 H 9? B
J 1 4 .@ O 3 G; 106×5/1 ) E Gc
Z4 (E 4 E E L E 4 E
=g @ O 0 AN \E E 4.
Q 1- : 2-)P2. 4 8 Q9 4/
Q 2- .93-G == : 4.9( :60 8
Q 3- S . 4) - == : 4.9( : <5 A/ /
Q 4- F-; : <5 ) -4 . . S 8 A/ /
H/b=1.7
H/b=0.2
4 - T2 @ ( ) U" E . 4 ) T< . ) E eE .3
3 O 3 G E T< D; VKQ 8O bA :
4 4 6 G E T< ; bA : 4 .
] 80 4 3 O . ) 4 L E
4 . J O . 1 E \ 4 O 4N m N =6 VE
b a .3 . ) 4E 4 . . E
] . ;KJ >@ I?N C E J ;KJ >@ =;
I: ;KJ >@ M .3 . 4 1 T< ^O
U 4 J yuE TrL y O .3 Y . 1
Z : .3 Y .:E U 4 ;KJ >@ . 63O . E
S C . 1 O 1 T< .3 . y
G64 l ; 4 E 1 I<X 8Dc .3
b4 yuE 3 4 O .:E D y Q . E
30 S 3 ? .:E U 4 J 8S N . E
O . 1± )V/bit ( ×/ :E . Q
O \ 4 E ; m N Z4 60 O 3000
D O D 3 . E : . E . 4 : . 1 E
) D Z4 =E mr L60 ;DH Z4 Q E ( 3
)3000 (KQ .:E E 4 = ] N .O ?DX
10 - 10 +H J O . 1 b a 004/0 b a E
025/0 b a 01 0_ 02/0 4E 4 . N
.O ?DX 10 + 30 +H J O . 1 b a 006/0
b a E 035/0 b a 01 0_ 025/0 4E 4.
I: 6 N b a E. G GE F?F 60 H E
bX O ?DX 8E 2X N\< =O .3 . )
U4 /4 @ f E . 4 : O I<X .3 .3
. ) VH .3]20[ E eE C F?F GE60
l 4 H: 4. ) G.S . 3 TAE
8Q E Q O 1 . ?DX 15 H
4. E ] 4 . ) .3b: b a E E
O ?DX X KL G; 49/2 E 8 :E .N
b a E O ?DX 25 H TAE KL E E ^S
0E O ?DX E I GQ E .?H KQ /\ E 1 3 O
bQ@ E D4 GE F?F N O X KL xL :
/ b: N ^3 5 O ?DX X
35 H 1 {\ .Q FX b a E G; 3/1
:E . I: 7 N b a 01 0_ bX E O
?DX 8E 2X N\< =O .3 . ) 80
: 4 .Q 01 0_ E KQ 25 < Z4
O . 1 : 4 .N b a 01 0_
O 1 TAE KL :E .Q b: N X
KL G; 2345/0 - :E .b: N b a 01 0_
E b a E G; 3/0 - E = EE S
I ;J 55 < Z4 J . I:
8 b a bX E O ?DX 8E 2X N\< =O
.3 . ) : 4 .Q 5H .3 VH
]20 [I: l : 4 .Q IJX b a G;
0095/0 :E. N b a \ )L/D (bX E
O ?DX 8E 2X N\< =O I: 9 80 :
4 . FX Q E E X 8 O ?DX 5/3
H{\ .I: 10 T Y b a E E bX ?< O
=O .O ?DX 9? B U4 : 4 .KD3 O I:
4 J ?< G N\< =O D O 9A Gc GE
1 b: N E T< KL [ E ` uE ^S
. .O ?DX \ = M ; E ^3 ?< O
N\< =O [email protected] ^3 Q b a E 1 . O ?DX
X 5/3 H Y Q ?< O =O Y g . Q
b a E / D . E H E 3 O ^3 E ?DX
=O N\< O ?< ^S E b a ?< ^3 = EE E
E N b: ^S [email protected] =O O . 1 I: 11 N
8S ^S b a E E bX ?< O =O 80 : 4 .
M ; N\< =O O. ?DX \ I: 4 .
O ?DX 30 H cBE /\ 8 H E 1 . . GE 2X
N\< =O uE .. E Q 5/0 < H/b `
T Y uE :E . I: 12 N < ^S b a E E
bX ?< O =O : 4 .< ^S O ?DX 5
H IE I 8E 8 H E 1 . . I dK4 J GE
IEJ H :E Q = ^S N\< O ?< = D
=O X 40 < 4 . I:13 T Y b a
01 0_ E ?< O =O l : 4 . .O
?DX F / [email protected] =O N\< O ?< ^3 01 C
c 4 . / E G rD@ : \ 0_
. 1 GQ [email protected] =O N\< O ?< ^3 VJ
. / : bQ@ E G I S
^S G 4 c .E T M = \ ?DX .O
; .:E I: 14 0_ 01 b a Y 8S
: 80 F ?DH .O . 4 8S uE ?DX .O
0E \ 0_ 01 . 1 b a Y <
I: =O N\< O ?< bX E 0_ 0115 80
. 4 : .O ?DX F Q b a 01 0_ [
148
QN
R
E /
O
= E ^3 ?< O =O ^S Q = ^S
X 50 < 4 . .O ?DX \ = T M ;
: 4 . I: 16 N\< O ?< bX E b a N
E 8: CS E F ?DX .O . 4 : 80 =O
E ^3 I . b a GE Gc E E C =O N\<
0ECS ^S I . b a / =O N\< E 8:
I: .E17 ?< bX E b a ^S 8S N
^3 8S ?< ^S E . 4 : 80 =O N\< O
I:) b a ^S < I . b a18 ^3 (
. 4
Q 7- 3 2)./ <3 - 'W )'X <2-I
Q 8- 3 2)./ <3 - <2-I
Q 9- <2-IL/D 3 2)./ <3 -
Q 10 - A/ /. $Z <3 - 7- <2-I 0.-[
149
4
Q 13- A/ /. $Z <3 - 'W )'X <2-I
Q 14 - O2.PZ. <2-IA/ /. $Z <3 - 'W )'X
Q 15- /. $Z <3 - 'W )'X <2-I O2.PZ. $8
A/
150
QN
R
E /
O
Q 17- A/ /. $Z <3 - <2-I O2.PZ. .P "
Q 18- A/ /. $Z <3 - <2-I O2.PZ. $8 "
5 - 4-X = RQN T M =O .O ?DX U uE E .
AB0 .3 C G .D3 GE F?F 60 H E
2X E > .D@ E T< E / I E U @ 4
@ O O C U 8? 4 E J 1 .]
= RQN 80 4 T M =O ;E O ?< O =O
O ?DX :E . .O ?DX Z4 uE J ?< GE
F?F =O D O 9A Gc GE 1 b: N E E
T< KL [ E ` uE ^S . .O ?DX
\ = M ; E ^3 ?< O N\< =O [email protected] ^3
Q b a E 1 .. E Q 5/0< H/b ` T Y uE
:E. .O ?DX F 1SE O 5/3 H Q b a
01 0_ [ = E ^3 ?< O =O ^S
S I E D4 bQ@ /EH 0 =
bH ^S . 4 1 . .O ?DX
g O 5/3 H .O ?DX \ = T M ; :
4. E ^3 ?< O N\< =O Q b a . I ^S
< ^S 8 E ^3 ?< ^3 4.
6 - (8
L E . (N)
α ) ?DX ODegree(
7 - \.- [1] Qu Q., Jia X., Wang W., Liu P., Agarwal R.K., Numerical Study of the Aerodynamics of a NACA 4412 Airfoil in Dynamic Ground Effect, Aerospace Science Technology, Vol. 38, pp. 56– 63, 2014. [2] Rozhdestvensky K.V., Wing-In-Ground Effect Vehicles, Progress Aerospace Science, Vol. 42, pp. 211–283, 2006. [3] Ahmed M.R., Takasaki T., Kohama Y., Aerodynamics of a NACA4412 Airfoil in Ground Effect, AIAA J., Vol. 45, pp. 37– 47, 2007. [4] Ciffone D.L., Pedley B., Measured Wake-Vortex Characteristics of Aircraft in Ground Effect, Journal of Aircraft, Vol. 16, pp. 102–109, 1979. [5] Han C., Cho J., Unsteady Trailing Vortex Evolution behind a Wing in Ground Effect, Journal of Aircraft, Vol. 42, pp. 429– 434, 2005. [6] Harvey J.K., Perry F.J., Flowfield Produced By Trailing Vortices in The Vicinity of the Ground, AIAA J., Vol. 9, pp. 1659–1660,1971. [7] Halloran, M. O. Meara, S., Wing in Ground Effect Craft Review, DSTO-GD-0201, Aeronautical and Maritime Research Laboratory, Australia. 1999. [8] Advanced Research Projects Agency, Wingship Investigation, Vol. 3, Technology Roadmap, Advanced Research Projects Agency (ARPA) Report, 30 September 1994. [9] Carter A., Effects of Ground Proximity on the Longitudinal Aerodynamic Characteristics of an Unswept AR 10 Wing, NASA TN D-5662, February 1970. [10] Baker P.A., Schweikhard W.G., Young W.R., Flight Evaluation of Ground Effect on Several Low-Aspect-Ratio Airplanes, NASA-TN-D-6053, 1970. [11] Corda S., Stephenson M.T., Burcham F.W., Curry R.E., Dynamic Ground Effects Flight Test of an F-15 Aircraft, NASA- TM-4604, 1970. [12] Curry R.E., Dynamic Ground Effect for a Cranked Arrow Wing Airplane, NASA-TM-4799, 1997. [13] Curry R.E., Owens L.R., Ground-Effect Characteristics of the Tu-144 Supersonic Transport Airplane, NASA/TM-2003- 212035, 2003. [14] Schweikhard W., A Method For In-Flight Measurement of Ground Effect on Fixed-Wing Aircraft, Journal of Aircraft, Vol. 4, pp. 101–104, 1967. [15] Chang R.C., Muirhead V.U., Investigation of Dynamic Ground Effect, in: Proceedings of the 1985 NASA Ames Research Center’s Ground-Effects Workshop, NASA, Ames Research Center, pp.363–393, 1970 [16] Chang R.C., An Experimental Investigation of Dynamic Ground Effect, Ph.D. Thesis, Department of Aerospace Engineering, University of Kansas, Lawrence, KS, 1985. [17] Jones B.L., Experimental Investigation into the Aerodynamic Ground Effect of a Tailless Chevron-Shaped UCAV, Master Thesis, School of Engineering and Management, Air Force Institute of Technology, Wright-Patterson Air Force Base, OH, 2005. [18] Katz J., Levin D., Measurements of Ground Effect for Delta Wings, Journal of Aircraft, Vol. 21, pp. 441–443, 1984. [19] Lee P. H., Lan C.E., Muirhead V.U., Experimental Investigation of Dynamic Ground Effect, Journal of Aircraft, Vol. 26, pp. 497–498, 1989. [20] Chang Ray C. and Muirhead Vincent U. Investigation of Dynamic Ground Effect, Proceedings of the 1985 NASA Ames Research Center's Ground-Effects Workshop, NASA CP-2462, pp. 363– 393, 20 August 1985. [21] Lee P. H., Lan C. E. and Muirhead V. U., An Experimental Investigation of Dynamic Ground Effect, NASA CR-4105, 1987.
151
4
.