competencias en iberoamÉrica análisis de pisa 2015€¦ · puntuación media en lectura en pisa...

69
COMPETENCIAS EN IBEROAMÉRICA Análisis de PISA 2015

Upload: others

Post on 12-Jun-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • COMPETENCIAS EN IBEROAMÉRICA

    Análisis de PISA 2015

  • Tendencias de rendimiento en ciencias (PISA)

    2006 2009 2012 2015

    OCDE

    450

    470

    490

    510

    530

    550

    570

    Media OCDE

    Ren

    dim

    ient

    o de

    los

    alum

    nos

    Gráfico1

    20032003200320032003

    20062006200620062006

    20092009200920092009

    10th percentile

    25th percentile

    Mean

    75th percentile

    90th percentile

    Score points

    256.3483

    46.6272

    355.5382

    108.6307

    54.1984

    250

    51.3242

    361.3257

    125.8997

    60.6792

    273.292

    45.02

    370.564

    105.14

    47.188

    Tabelle1

    Year10th percentile25th percentileMean75th percentile90th percentile

    Australia20033996152413253

    Austria20033845550613255

    Belgium20033817652915553

    Canada20034195553211951

    Chile2003mm

    Czech Republic20033925851613557

    Denmark20033965751412553

    Estonia2003mm

    Finland20034385054411449

    France20033896051112652

    Germany20033636950314654

    Greece20033245944512658

    Hungary20033705649013055

    Iceland20033965851512451

    Ireland20033935250311752

    Israel2003mm

    Italy20033425846613059

    Japan20034026653413855

    Korea20034235654212753

    Latvia20033715348312053

    Luxembourg20033735849312754

    Mexico20032765138511754

    Netherlands20034155653813748

    New Zealand20033946152313857

    Norway20033765749512754

    Poland20033765249012555

    Portugal20033525446612054

    Slovak Republic20033795749812954

    Slovenia2003mm

    Spain20033695848512051

    Sweden20033875950912955

    Switzerland20033966552713457

    Turkey20033005142313475

    United Kingdom2003mm

    United States20033566248313258

    OECD average 200320033785849912955

    OECD average-352003mm

    OECD average-342003mm

    Albania2003mm

    Algeria2003mm

    Brazil20032335235013469

    Bulgaria2003mm

    B-S-J-G (China)2003mm

    CABA (Argentina)2003mm

    Colombia2003mm

    Costa Rica2003mm

    Croatia2003mm

    Cyprus*2003mm

    Dominican Republic2003mm

    FYROM2003mm

    Georgia2003mm

    Hong Kong (China)20034176855913750

    Indonesia20032604635710554

    Jordan2003mm

    Kosovo2003mm

    Lebanon2003mm

    Lithuania2003mm

    Macao (China)20034145352912052

    Malta2003mm

    Moldova2003mm

    Montenegro2003mm

    Peru2003mm

    Qatar2003mm

    Romania2003mm

    Russia20033515546712458

    Singapore2003mm

    Chinese Taipei2003mm

    Thailand20033164441210957

    Trinidad and Tobago2003mm

    Tunisia20032564735610954

    United Arab Emirates2003mm

    Uruguay20032916242513759

    Viet Nam2003mm

    Argentina2003mm

    Kazakhstan2003mm

    Malaysia2003mm

    Australia20064065452012152

    Austria20063736550513953

    Belgium20063817052014852

    Canada20064165552711649

    Chile20063024841112057

    Czech Republic20063766451014162

    Denmark20064045251311550

    Estonia20064115051510947

    Finland20064445054811147

    France20063696149613652

    Germany20063756250413659

    Greece20063415845912354

    Hungary20063775449112058

    Iceland20063915550612151

    Ireland20063964950111449

    Israel20063046444214963

    Italy20063415746212956

    Japan20064045952312451

    Korea20064265954712752

    Latvia20063785348611048

    Luxembourg20063685849012954

    Mexico20062995040611451

    Netherlands20064125553112949

    New Zealand20064015752212956

    Norway20063735549012456

    Poland20063845149512253

    Portugal20063485646612653

    Slovak Republic20063706249212554

    Slovenia20063905150412557

    Spain20063665548012151

    Sweden20063875550212352

    Switzerland20064016353013652

    Turkey20063164442411773

    United Kingdom20063815349512256

    United States20063585347412655

    OECD average 200320063795649712553

    OECD average-3520063765649412554

    OECD average-3420063765649412554

    Albania2006mm

    Algeria2006mm

    Brazil20062555236511960

    Bulgaria20062875841213661

    B-S-J-G (China)2006mm

    CABA (Argentina)2006mm

    Colombia20062585436911753

    Costa Rica2006mm

    Croatia20063615046611451

    Cyprus*2006mm

    Dominican Republic2006mm

    FYROM2006mm

    Georgia2006mm

    Hong Kong (China)20064236355212851

    Indonesia20062934438710755

    Jordan20062795138611248

    Kosovo2006mm

    Lebanon2006mm

    Lithuania20063695748712353

    Macao (China)20064165152611847

    Malta2006mm

    Moldova2006mm

    Montenegro20062915139811454

    Peru2006mm

    Qatar20062124530811170

    Romania20063075141411252

    Russia20063635347411957

    Singapore2006mm

    Chinese Taipei20064096855714852

    Thailand20063174541410754

    Trinidad and Tobago2006mm

    Tunisia20062505136112661

    United Arab Emirates2006mm

    Uruguay20062966343013556

    Viet Nam2006mm

    Argentina20062496738513558

    Kazakhstan2006mm

    Malaysia2006mm

    Australia20093935951412854

    Austria2009mm

    Belgium20093737151514953

    Canada20094135552712049

    Chile20093224442110853

    Czech Republic20093745449312958

    Denmark20093905550311950

    Estonia20094095051210949

    Finland20094315554111245

    France20093616849714052

    Germany20093806351314253

    Greece20093525446612253

    Hungary20093705849012653

    Iceland20093885950712254

    Ireland20093765648711543

    Israel20093106444714660

    Italy20093635748312853

    Japan20094076252912753

    Korea20094305654612350

    Latvia20093794848211047

    Luxembourg20093606348913653

    Mexico20093184841910649

    Netherlands20094065452613347

    New Zealand20093926251913553

    Norway20093875449811651

    Poland20093805449512352

    Portugal20093675748712754

    Slovak Republic20093765649712960

    Slovenia20093795650113460

    Spain20093646148312251

    Sweden20093745949412754

    Switzerland20094016653413753

    Turkey20093314844512868

    United Kingdom20093805449211854

    United States20093685648712656

    OECD average 20032009mm

    OECD average-352009mm

    OECD average-3420093775749512653

    Albania20092615638012155

    Algeria2009mm

    Brazil20092874438110458

    Bulgaria20093025742813660

    B-S-J-G (China)2009mm

    CABA (Argentina)2009mm

    Colombia20092864337910148

    Costa Rica2009319424089645

    Croatia20093475346012253

    Cyprus*2009mm

    Dominican Republic2009mm

    FYROM2009mm

    Georgia20092724937911552

    Hong Kong (China)20094286455912951

    Indonesia2009284403699246

    Jordan20092815238911047

    Kosovo2009mm

    Lebanon2009mm

    Lithuania20093635447712053

    Macao (China)20094155352711650

    Malta20093256746714658

    Moldova20092895239711552

    Montenegro20092955240311251

    Peru20092525236312156

    Qatar20092554535512581

    Romania20093264642610949

    Russia20093605146711451

    Singapore20094226856814855

    Chinese Taipei20094056654714757

    Thailand20093214441510454

    Trinidad and Tobago20092875541214261

    Tunisia20092734537110547

    United Arab Emirates2009mm

    Uruguay20093105442612657

    Viet Nam2009mm

    Argentina20092715638812358

    Kazakhstan20093034540111155

    Malaysia2009312424039947

    Australia20123825550413460

    Austria20123845750613252

    Belgium20123786551514657

    Canada20124025551812353

    Chile20123234242311155

    Czech Republic20123775549913455

    Denmark20123935150011250

    Estonia20124174852111151

    Finland20124095451911452

    France20123656349513657

    Germany20123856251413654

    Greece20123385445312153

    Hungary20123585347712962

    Iceland20123725949312555

    Ireland20123915450111451

    Israel20123286446614862

    Italy20123665648512957

    Japan20124155953613054

    Korea20124256155413855

    Latvia20123874749111351

    Luxembourg20123635849013655

    Mexico20123204341310048

    Netherlands20123976152313447

    New Zealand20123715750014262

    Norway20123735548912452

    Poland20124025251812656

    Portugal20123635748713456

    Slovak Republic20123526148214060

    Slovenia20123845050113358

    Spain20123705448412251

    Sweden20123605547812854

    Switzerland20124085953113055

    Turkey20123394344812570

    United Kingdom20123715849413156

    United States20123685048112657

    OECD average 200320123775649612855

    OECD average-3520123755549412855

    OECD average-3420123755549412755

    Albania20122785939711755

    Algeria2012mm

    Brazil20122944038310355

    Bulgaria20123205243613162

    B-S-J-G (China)2012mm

    CABA (Argentina)20122966642711950

    Colombia2012285413739751

    Costa Rica2012323374038946

    Croatia20123604846812358

    Cyprus*20123205543912757

    Dominican Republic2012mm

    FYROM2012mm

    Georgia2012mm

    Hong Kong (China)20124306856913051

    Indonesia2012288393709250

    Jordan20122904538310149

    Kosovo2012mm

    Lebanon2012mm

    Lithuania20123645347812356

    Macao (China)20124156054213052

    Malta2012mm

    Moldova2012mm

    Montenegro20123064640611355

    Peru20122644736411157

    Qatar20122574936513375

    Romania20123444243911156

    Russia20123715248111855

    Singapore20124326957914957

    Chinese Taipei20124027756716758

    Thailand20123284442110558

    Trinidad and Tobago2012mm

    Tunisia20122924238410351

    United Arab Emirates20123234742912461

    Uruguay20122975040712356

    Viet Nam20124015351011454

    Argentina20122924538810447

    Kazakhstan2012343394299549

    Malaysia20123194341711255

    Australia20153715949412955

    Austria20153706149713353

    Belgium20153746450714151

    Canada20154005551612151

    Chile20153135042312051

    Czech Republic20153735749212553

    Denmark20154055151111147

    Estonia20154154952011248

    Finland20154045251111246

    France20153646149313949

    Germany20153895650612352

    Greece20153365445412752

    Hungary20153515947713254

    Iceland20153675848812955

    Ireland20154005050410947

    Israel20153326447014956

    Italy20153685849012955

    Japan20154165753212149

    Korea20153916652413755

    Latvia20153824848210646

    Luxembourg20153635448613654

    Mexico20153124540810346

    Netherlands20153905951213048

    New Zealand20153755649512953

    Norway20153915350211749

    Poland20153915250412153

    Portugal20153655949213753

    Slovak Republic20153496347513253

    Slovenia20153945551012250

    Spain20153745548611748

    Sweden20153765749412551

    Switzerland20153946152113552

    Turkey20153174642011552

    United Kingdom20153715949212754

    United States20153555347012453

    OECD average 200320153745649112551

    OECD average-3520153735649012551

    OECD average-3420153735649012551

    Albania20153035141311853

    Algeria2015271413579347

    Brazil20152674737111962

    Bulgaria20153155644113859

    B-S-J-G (China)20153886953815155

    CABA (Argentina)20153405745712153

    Colombia20152934238610651

    Costa Rica2015315383989244

    Croatia20153515046212355

    Cyprus*20153175643812857

    Dominican Republic2015243383249245

    FYROM20152515636912862

    Georgia20152855740312658

    Hong Kong (China)20154266455412048

    Indonesia20152894238110556

    Jordan20152715338211551

    Kosovo20152654536010347

    Lebanon20152685639214067

    Lithuania20153655447912052

    Macao (China)20154395254710844

    Malta20153317448515357

    Moldova20153035541912355

    Montenegro20153085041612054

    Peru20152834638411353

    Qatar20152785339713866

    Romania20153345044211855

    Russia20153874949411649

    Singapore20154366557113250

    Chinese Taipei20154047054814254

    Thailand20153134741210853

    Trinidad and Tobago20152945441513661

    Tunisia20152634736311155

    United Arab Emirates20153065442313364

    Uruguay20153094841512055

    Viet Nam20153884849211552

    Argentina20153064740710951

    Kazakhstan20153574745711054

    Malaysia20153434844711048

  • Los beneficios de una educación mejor

    Crecimiento integrador

    Perspectivas del mercado

    laboral

    Compromiso y confianza

    sociales

    Eficacia sanitaria y

    política

  • Fuente: Encuesta sobre las Competencias de los Adultos (PIAAC) (2012, 2015)

    II. Sobre el empleo y los ingresos

    IMPACTO POSITIVO SOBRE EL

    EMPLEO Y EL NIVEL DE

    INGRESOS DE LAS PERSONAS

    Efecto de la comprensión lectora en la probabilidad de tener empleo, y en los salarios

    A- Probabilidad de ser empleado B - Salarios

    Comprensión lectora

  • III. Sobre los resultados sociales

    Mejores resultados sociales

    con el desarrollo de competencias,

    a pesar de las diferencias entre

    países

    Competencias de comprensión lectora y resultados sociales positivos

    Fuente: Encuesta sobre las Competencias de Adultos (PIAAC) (2012, 2015)

    Chile

    Chile

    Chile

    Chile

    Spai

    n

    Spai

    n

    Spai

    n

    Spai

    n

    OEC

    D Av

    erag

    e

    OEC

    D Av

    erag

    e

    OEC

    D Av

    erag

    e

    OEC

    D Av

    erag

    e

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    25

    30

    35

    40

    High levels of politicalefficacy

    Participation in volunteeractivities

    High levels of health High levels of trust

    Chile Spain OECD Average

  • IMPACTO DEL DESARROLLO DE

    COMPETENCIAS A NIVEL

    MACROECONÓMICO

    Fuente: Hanushek & Woessmann, 2015

    Asociación entre capital de conocimiento (inferido por aproximación mediante las

    puntuaciones de varias pruebas internacionales) y crecimiento a largo plazo

    (1960-2000)

    Capital de conocimiento y crecimiento económico en distintos países

  • Puntuación media en lectura en PISA 2000 y puntuación en

    comprensión lectora en PIACC (2012, 2015)

    Fuente: Encuesta sobre las Competencias de los Adultos (PIAAC) (2012, 2015), y OCDE, Bases de datos de PISA 2000-2003

    I. Sobre el nivel de competencias futuro

    Se ha comprobado que el rendimiento de los alumnos en

    las pruebas del PISA está relacionado

    positivamente con su nivel futuro de

    competencias para el tratamiento de la información como

    adultos, medidas por la PIAAC. La relación

    existe para las puntuaciones de PISA 2000 y PISA

    2003

  • SITUACIÓN DE IBEROAMÉRICA

    Evaluación del nivel de competencias de

    alumnos y adultos a partir de sus

    resultados en PISA 2015 y PIAAC 2012-15

  • TASAS DE MATRICULACIÓN SIGNIFICATIVAMENTE ALTAS EN TODOS LOS PAÍSES DE IBEROAMÉRICA

    Nivel educativo alcanzado a los 15 años de edad

    Fuente: OCDE (2016), Informe PISA 2015 (Volume I)

    100 80 60 40 20 0 20 40 60 80 100

    Spain

    OECD average

    Portugal

    Chile

    Colombia

    Peru

    Uruguay

    Brazil

    Dominican Republic

    Costa Rica

    Mexico

    % %

    Jóvenes de 15 años no elegibles y excluidos

    Alumnos representados por

    las muestras de PISA

    Curso 12 Curso 11

    Curso 10

    Curso 9

    Curso 8

    Curso 7

    ExcluidosNo elegibles

  • Y PROGRESOS CONSIDERABLES EN LA MEJORA DE LAS TASAS DE MATRICULACIÓN A LO LARGO DE LOS AÑOS

    Variación del porcentaje de jóvenes de 15 años de edad incluidos en PISA

    Fuente: OCDE, base de datos de PISA 2015

  • PERO...

  • 60

    40

    20

    0

    20

    40

    60

    80

    Sing

    apor

    e

    4Fi

    nlan

    d

    3Ja

    pan

    5

    Esto

    nia

    7

    Irela

    nd

    4M

    acao

    (Chi

    na)

    12

    Hon

    g Ko

    ng (C

    hina

    ) 1

    1G

    erm

    any

    4

    Slov

    enia

    7

    Kore

    a

    8Sw

    itzer

    land

    4

    Rus

    sia

    5

    Net

    herla

    nds

    5

    CAB

    A (A

    rgen

    tina)

    0

    Pola

    nd

    9D

    enm

    ark

    11

    Aust

    ralia

    9

    Chi

    nese

    Tai

    pei

    15

    Belg

    ium

    7

    New

    Zea

    land

    1

    0C

    anad

    a

    16Sp

    ain

    9

    Nor

    way

    9

    Cze

    ch R

    epub

    lic

    6La

    tvia

    1

    1Sw

    eden

    6

    Portu

    gal

    12

    Fran

    ce

    9O

    ECD

    ave

    rage

    1

    1Ic

    elan

    d

    7U

    nite

    d Ki

    ngdo

    m

    16

    Cro

    atia

    9

    Lith

    uani

    a

    10U

    nite

    d St

    ates

    1

    6H

    unga

    ry

    10

    Aust

    ria

    17

    Mal

    ta

    2Lu

    xem

    bour

    g

    12Is

    rael

    6

    Slov

    ak R

    epub

    lic

    11

    Italy

    2

    0G

    reec

    e

    9R

    oman

    ia

    7M

    oldo

    va

    7B-

    S-J-

    G (C

    hina

    ) 3

    6U

    nite

    d Ar

    ab E

    mira

    tes

    9

    Chi

    le

    20

    Bulg

    aria

    1

    9Al

    bani

    a

    16Q

    atar

    7

    Viet

    Nam

    5

    1M

    onte

    negr

    o

    10Jo

    rdan

    1

    4U

    rugu

    ay

    28

    Trin

    idad

    and

    Tob

    ago

    24

    Turk

    ey

    30

    Geo

    rgia

    2

    1C

    olom

    bia

    25

    Thai

    land

    2

    9FY

    RO

    M

    5C

    osta

    Ric

    a

    37M

    exic

    o

    38Tu

    nisi

    a

    7Pe

    ru

    26

    Braz

    il

    29In

    done

    sia

    32

    Leba

    non

    34

    Alge

    ria

    21

    Koso

    vo

    29

    Dom

    inic

    an R

    epub

    lic

    32

    Level 1a Level 1b Below Level 1b Level 2

    Level 3 Level 4 Level 5 Level 6

    Rendimiento de los alumnos (PISA, ciencias, jóvenes de 15 años, 2015)

    %

    Porcentaje de jóvenes de 15 años no incluidos en la muestra PISA

  • 60

    40

    20

    0

    20

    40

    60

    80

    Sing

    apor

    e

    4Fi

    nlan

    d

    3Ja

    pan

    5

    Esto

    nia

    7

    Irel

    and

    4

    Mac

    ao (

    Chi

    na)

    12

    Hon

    g K

    ong

    (Chi

    na)

    11

    Ger

    man

    y

    4Sl

    oven

    ia

    7K

    orea

    8

    Switz

    erla

    nd

    4R

    ussi

    a

    5N

    ethe

    rland

    s

    5C

    AB

    A (A

    rgen

    tina)

    0

    Pol

    and

    9

    Den

    mar

    k

    11A

    ustr

    alia

    9

    Chi

    nese

    Tai

    pei

    15

    Bel

    gium

    7

    New

    Zea

    land

    1

    0C

    anad

    a

    16Sp

    ain

    9

    Nor

    way

    9

    Cze

    ch R

    epub

    lic

    6La

    tvia

    1

    1Sw

    eden

    6

    Por

    tuga

    l 1

    2Fr

    ance

    9

    OEC

    D a

    vera

    ge

    11

    Icel

    and

    7

    Uni

    ted

    Kin

    gdom

    1

    6C

    roat

    ia

    9Li

    thua

    nia

    10

    Uni

    ted

    Stat

    es

    16

    Hun

    gary

    1

    0A

    ustr

    ia

    17

    Mal

    ta

    2Lu

    xem

    bour

    g

    12Is

    rael

    6

    Slov

    ak R

    epub

    lic

    11

    Ital

    y

    20G

    reec

    e

    9R

    oman

    ia

    7M

    oldo

    va

    7B

    -S-J

    -G (

    Chi

    na)

    36

    Uni

    ted

    Ara

    b Em

    irate

    s

    9C

    hile

    2

    0B

    ulga

    ria

    19

    Alb

    ania

    1

    6Q

    atar

    7

    Viet

    Nam

    5

    1M

    onte

    negr

    o

    10Jo

    rdan

    1

    4U

    rugu

    ay

    28

    Trin

    idad

    and

    Tob

    ago

    24

    Turk

    ey

    30

    Geo

    rgia

    2

    1C

    olom

    bia

    25

    Thai

    land

    2

    9FY

    RO

    M

    5C

    osta

    Ric

    a

    37M

    exic

    o

    38Tu

    nisi

    a

    7P

    eru

    26

    Bra

    zil

    29

    Indo

    nesi

    a

    32Le

    bano

    n

    34A

    lger

    ia

    21

    Kos

    ovo

    29

    Dom

    inic

    an R

    epub

    lic

    32

    Level 1a Level 1b Below Level 1b

    Level 2 Level 3 Level 4

    Rendimiento de los alumnos (PISA, ciencias, jóvenes de 15 años, 2015)

    %

    Porcentaje de jóvenes de 15 años no incluidos en la muestra PISA

    %

    683 % PIB903 000 millones USD

    12 448 000 millones US

    D

    153 % PIB27 929 000 millones U

    SD

    86 % PIB402 000 millones

    USD Beneficio económico estimado a largo plazo por cada joven de 15 años que adquiere como mínimo las competencias básicas

    143 % PIB3 650 000 millones U

    SD693 % PIB6 448 000 millones USD

    171 % PIB2 721 000 millones USD

    166 % PIB474 000 millones USD

    393 % PIB1 698 000 millones USD

    656 % PIB479 000 millones USD

    910 % PIB6 218 000 millones USD

    461 % PIB346 000 millones USD

    551 % PIB12 448 000 551 % PIBmillones USD

    1076 % PIB4341 000 millones USD

    751 % PIB23841 000 millones USD

    Gráfico1

    Singapore 4Singapore 4Singapore 4Singapore 4Singapore 4Singapore 4Singapore 4Singapore 4

    Finland 3Finland 3Finland 3Finland 3Finland 3Finland 3Finland 3Finland 3

    Japan 5Japan 5Japan 5Japan 5Japan 5Japan 5Japan 5Japan 5

    Estonia 7Estonia 7Estonia 7Estonia 7Estonia 7Estonia 7Estonia 7Estonia 7

    Ireland 4Ireland 4Ireland 4Ireland 4Ireland 4Ireland 4Ireland 4Ireland 4

    Macao (China) 12Macao (China) 12Macao (China) 12Macao (China) 12Macao (China) 12Macao (China) 12Macao (China) 12Macao (China) 12

    Hong Kong (China) 11Hong Kong (China) 11Hong Kong (China) 11Hong Kong (China) 11Hong Kong (China) 11Hong Kong (China) 11Hong Kong (China) 11Hong Kong (China) 11

    Germany 4Germany 4Germany 4Germany 4Germany 4Germany 4Germany 4Germany 4

    Slovenia 7Slovenia 7Slovenia 7Slovenia 7Slovenia 7Slovenia 7Slovenia 7Slovenia 7

    Korea 8Korea 8Korea 8Korea 8Korea 8Korea 8Korea 8Korea 8

    Switzerland 4Switzerland 4Switzerland 4Switzerland 4Switzerland 4Switzerland 4Switzerland 4Switzerland 4

    Russia 5Russia 5Russia 5Russia 5Russia 5Russia 5Russia 5Russia 5

    Netherlands 5Netherlands 5Netherlands 5Netherlands 5Netherlands 5Netherlands 5Netherlands 5Netherlands 5

    CABA (Argentina) 0CABA (Argentina) 0CABA (Argentina) 0CABA (Argentina) 0CABA (Argentina) 0CABA (Argentina) 0CABA (Argentina) 0CABA (Argentina) 0

    Poland 9Poland 9Poland 9Poland 9Poland 9Poland 9Poland 9Poland 9

    Denmark 11Denmark 11Denmark 11Denmark 11Denmark 11Denmark 11Denmark 11Denmark 11

    Australia 9Australia 9Australia 9Australia 9Australia 9Australia 9Australia 9Australia 9

    Chinese Taipei 15Chinese Taipei 15Chinese Taipei 15Chinese Taipei 15Chinese Taipei 15Chinese Taipei 15Chinese Taipei 15Chinese Taipei 15

    Belgium 7Belgium 7Belgium 7Belgium 7Belgium 7Belgium 7Belgium 7Belgium 7

    New Zealand 10New Zealand 10New Zealand 10New Zealand 10New Zealand 10New Zealand 10New Zealand 10New Zealand 10

    Canada 16Canada 16Canada 16Canada 16Canada 16Canada 16Canada 16Canada 16

    Spain 9Spain 9Spain 9Spain 9Spain 9Spain 9Spain 9Spain 9

    Norway 9Norway 9Norway 9Norway 9Norway 9Norway 9Norway 9Norway 9

    Czech Republic 6Czech Republic 6Czech Republic 6Czech Republic 6Czech Republic 6Czech Republic 6Czech Republic 6Czech Republic 6

    Latvia 11Latvia 11Latvia 11Latvia 11Latvia 11Latvia 11Latvia 11Latvia 11

    Sweden 6Sweden 6Sweden 6Sweden 6Sweden 6Sweden 6Sweden 6Sweden 6

    Portugal 12Portugal 12Portugal 12Portugal 12Portugal 12Portugal 12Portugal 12Portugal 12

    France 9France 9France 9France 9France 9France 9France 9France 9

    OECD average 11OECD average 11OECD average 11OECD average 11OECD average 11OECD average 11OECD average 11OECD average 11

    Iceland 7Iceland 7Iceland 7Iceland 7Iceland 7Iceland 7Iceland 7Iceland 7

    United Kingdom 16United Kingdom 16United Kingdom 16United Kingdom 16United Kingdom 16United Kingdom 16United Kingdom 16United Kingdom 16

    Croatia 9Croatia 9Croatia 9Croatia 9Croatia 9Croatia 9Croatia 9Croatia 9

    Lithuania 10Lithuania 10Lithuania 10Lithuania 10Lithuania 10Lithuania 10Lithuania 10Lithuania 10

    United States 16United States 16United States 16United States 16United States 16United States 16United States 16United States 16

    Hungary 10Hungary 10Hungary 10Hungary 10Hungary 10Hungary 10Hungary 10Hungary 10

    Austria 17Austria 17Austria 17Austria 17Austria 17Austria 17Austria 17Austria 17

    Malta 2Malta 2Malta 2Malta 2Malta 2Malta 2Malta 2Malta 2

    Luxembourg 12Luxembourg 12Luxembourg 12Luxembourg 12Luxembourg 12Luxembourg 12Luxembourg 12Luxembourg 12

    Israel 6Israel 6Israel 6Israel 6Israel 6Israel 6Israel 6Israel 6

    Slovak Republic 11Slovak Republic 11Slovak Republic 11Slovak Republic 11Slovak Republic 11Slovak Republic 11Slovak Republic 11Slovak Republic 11

    Italy 20Italy 20Italy 20Italy 20Italy 20Italy 20Italy 20Italy 20

    Greece 9Greece 9Greece 9Greece 9Greece 9Greece 9Greece 9Greece 9

    Romania 7Romania 7Romania 7Romania 7Romania 7Romania 7Romania 7Romania 7

    Moldova 7Moldova 7Moldova 7Moldova 7Moldova 7Moldova 7Moldova 7Moldova 7

    B-S-J-G (China) 36B-S-J-G (China) 36B-S-J-G (China) 36B-S-J-G (China) 36B-S-J-G (China) 36B-S-J-G (China) 36B-S-J-G (China) 36B-S-J-G (China) 36

    United Arab Emirates 9United Arab Emirates 9United Arab Emirates 9United Arab Emirates 9United Arab Emirates 9United Arab Emirates 9United Arab Emirates 9United Arab Emirates 9

    Chile 20Chile 20Chile 20Chile 20Chile 20Chile 20Chile 20Chile 20

    Bulgaria 19Bulgaria 19Bulgaria 19Bulgaria 19Bulgaria 19Bulgaria 19Bulgaria 19Bulgaria 19

    Albania 16Albania 16Albania 16Albania 16Albania 16Albania 16Albania 16Albania 16

    Qatar 7Qatar 7Qatar 7Qatar 7Qatar 7Qatar 7Qatar 7Qatar 7

    Viet Nam 51Viet Nam 51Viet Nam 51Viet Nam 51Viet Nam 51Viet Nam 51Viet Nam 51Viet Nam 51

    Montenegro 10Montenegro 10Montenegro 10Montenegro 10Montenegro 10Montenegro 10Montenegro 10Montenegro 10

    Jordan 14Jordan 14Jordan 14Jordan 14Jordan 14Jordan 14Jordan 14Jordan 14

    Uruguay 28Uruguay 28Uruguay 28Uruguay 28Uruguay 28Uruguay 28Uruguay 28Uruguay 28

    Trinidad and Tobago 24Trinidad and Tobago 24Trinidad and Tobago 24Trinidad and Tobago 24Trinidad and Tobago 24Trinidad and Tobago 24Trinidad and Tobago 24Trinidad and Tobago 24

    Turkey 30Turkey 30Turkey 30Turkey 30Turkey 30Turkey 30Turkey 30Turkey 30

    Georgia 21Georgia 21Georgia 21Georgia 21Georgia 21Georgia 21Georgia 21Georgia 21

    Colombia 25Colombia 25Colombia 25Colombia 25Colombia 25Colombia 25Colombia 25Colombia 25

    Thailand 29Thailand 29Thailand 29Thailand 29Thailand 29Thailand 29Thailand 29Thailand 29

    FYROM 5FYROM 5FYROM 5FYROM 5FYROM 5FYROM 5FYROM 5FYROM 5

    Costa Rica 37Costa Rica 37Costa Rica 37Costa Rica 37Costa Rica 37Costa Rica 37Costa Rica 37Costa Rica 37

    Mexico 38Mexico 38Mexico 38Mexico 38Mexico 38Mexico 38Mexico 38Mexico 38

    Tunisia 7Tunisia 7Tunisia 7Tunisia 7Tunisia 7Tunisia 7Tunisia 7Tunisia 7

    Peru 26Peru 26Peru 26Peru 26Peru 26Peru 26Peru 26Peru 26

    Brazil 29Brazil 29Brazil 29Brazil 29Brazil 29Brazil 29Brazil 29Brazil 29

    Indonesia 32Indonesia 32Indonesia 32Indonesia 32Indonesia 32Indonesia 32Indonesia 32Indonesia 32

    Lebanon 34Lebanon 34Lebanon 34Lebanon 34Lebanon 34Lebanon 34Lebanon 34Lebanon 34

    Algeria 21Algeria 21Algeria 21Algeria 21Algeria 21Algeria 21Algeria 21Algeria 21

    Kosovo 29Kosovo 29Kosovo 29Kosovo 29Kosovo 29Kosovo 29Kosovo 29Kosovo 29

    Dominican Republic 32Dominican Republic 32Dominican Republic 32Dominican Republic 32Dominican Republic 32Dominican Republic 32Dominican Republic 32Dominican Republic 32

    Level 1a

    Level 1b

    Below Level 1b

    Level 2

    Level 3

    Level 4

    Level 5

    Level 6

    -7.182621

    -1.872892

    -0.146444

    14.46738

    22.44061

    26.57358

    17.79243

    5.388878

    -8.653794

    -2.242617

    -0.246627

    18.53263

    28.39781

    25.27387

    11.56485

    2.368095

    -7.32978

    -1.62857

    -0.148185

    17.14539

    26.70862

    27.26591

    12.22037

    2.288055

    -6.974424

    -1.150224

    -0.02496

    18.63119

    28.45867

    24.98674

    10.76908

    1.793913

    -11.9368

    -2.584682

    -0.271043

    25.48864

    30.02112

    19.37957

    6.063881

    0.740529

    -6.094785

    -0.973218

    -0.051344

    18.20861

    30.21386

    24.72253

    7.296453

    0.811746

    -6.884336

    -1.377719

    -0.075744

    17.47305

    31.96958

    24.27308

    6.129494

    0.391276

    -12.23456

    -3.675789

    -0.376819

    21.79784

    26.51528

    21.08657

    8.433431

    1.71036

    -11.07767

    -2.638375

    -0.203349

    21.58335

    26.97287

    20.47065

    8.435864

    1.398428

    -10.16137

    -2.66405

    -0.361524

    19.93238

    26.80526

    22.0444

    8.45122

    1.269525

    -13.39562

    -3.85566

    -0.496984

    21.96588

    25.25142

    21.80955

    8.31041

    1.087912

    -14.47892

    -2.722193

    -0.098968

    29.73494

    29.40826

    15.26772

    3.352763

    0.215297

    -13.58713

    -3.778186

    -0.273526

    20.7782

    24.86898

    21.26986

    9.030828

    1.527395

    -17.19688

    -4.821205

    -0.650914

    30.7675

    29.04706

    14.85139

    2.562152

    0.102899

    -12.11143

    -2.363567

    -0.29456

    24.17885

    27.19502

    18.08073

    5.723498

    0.940892

    -11.14349

    -2.669164

    -0.305199

    22.9995

    27.66229

    17.951

    5.466737

    0.772806

    -11.62258

    -3.854447

    -0.5117

    19.54284

    24.73369

    20.2093

    8.291867

    1.84509

    -8.011347

    -2.306692

    -0.276903

    15.39894

    23.04729

    23.06598

    10.83324

    2.271968

    -13.35459

    -4.574986

    -0.456835

    20.39957

    24.90242

    20.8982

    7.465327

    0.888194

    -11.7622

    -3.618241

    -0.361199

    19.51434

    23.73363

    19.64091

    9.11366

    2.469632

    -7.623892

    -1.514111

    -0.121325

    16.86984

    25.29126

    21.77492

    8.659412

    1.665165

    -13.00345

    -3.331679

    -0.284264

    24.09352

    28.4672

    17.17198

    4.246526

    0.278434

    -12.80011

    -3.735563

    -0.532497

    22.4739

    26.58928

    17.84942

    6.306831

    0.976925

    -15.02246

    -4.022264

    -0.271684

    24.21776

    25.92631

    17.22024

    5.936231

    0.886297

    -12.91

    -2.291548

    -0.112503

    26.46404

    28.15117

    15.47341

    3.100166

    0.281463

    -14.04672

    -5.328881

    -0.873457

    22.44197

    25.11694

    17.82907

    6.719468

    1.240907

    -12.27174

    -2.787772

    -0.180083

    22.24888

    25.19655

    18.4308

    5.910272

    0.601934

    -13.95652

    -5.31665

    -0.796094

    20.04186

    24.08583

    19.51148

    6.53264

    0.732302

    -13.68848

    -4.256818

    -0.517582

    21.89171

    24.37657

    17.19722

    6.06689

    0.962752

    -17.47632

    -5.401253

    -0.735857

    27.06646

    25.43792

    13.60397

    3.2508

    0.256431

    -11.43178

    -2.861638

    -0.320637

    18.94932

    23.11334

    18.1576

    7.621784

    1.507061

    -17.404

    -4.587945

    -0.390564

    26.7563

    24.9932

    13.1118

    3.254885

    0.325755

    -17.0226

    -4.850947

    -0.433161

    26.75422

    23.7178

    13.66027

    3.529491

    0.236234

    -12.94178

    -3.624333

    -0.399107

    21.2951

    22.17752

    15.96245

    6.079789

    1.032376

    -16.45906

    -6.110529

    -0.722055

    22.79374

    24.4644

    14.88674

    3.816642

    0.303164

    -13.19772

    -3.752824

    -0.413261

    19.91961

    23.39573

    16.25698

    5.679518

    0.756999

    -17.56433

    -10.39236

    -3.816939

    22.81777

    21.20299

    14.44403

    5.941299

    1.52284

    -16.56121

    -5.619941

    -0.459331

    21.69084

    22.01584

    15.16123

    5.288604

    0.76425

    -18.63168

    -8.896474

    -1.923515

    22.88987

    21.83783

    14.08239

    4.789442

    0.684352

    -17.59784

    -7.940666

    -1.846693

    24.64625

    22.08151

    11.87102

    2.919484

    0.282797

    -13.82321

    -4.370656

    -0.445427

    21.77347

    22.92149

    13.66236

    3.081399

    0.195115

    -20.42769

    -8.294014

    -1.074896

    25.83213

    23.00333

    10.54321

    1.828559

    0.114094

    -26.41591

    -8.629665

    -0.849971

    32.62523

    18.50691

    5.472446

    0.62235

    0.005329

    -26.16618

    -10.94816

    -2.138447

    29.23679

    18.27077

    5.474323

    0.654389

    0.032504

    -7.554339

    -2.435797

    -0.369879

    13.20148

    16.45887

    15.18829

    7.34342

    1.324213

    -23.74985

    -11.82997

    -2.363156

    24.47156

    17.28635

    8.600751

    2.307597

    0.226478

    -19.93632

    -7.061788

    -0.783968

    24.74052

    19.00263

    7.262736

    0.956741

    0.032057

    -18.36047

    -10.0168

    -2.13987

    20.2954

    18.24984

    9.218804

    2.149878

    0.17576

    -25.09552

    -8.662706

    -1.32236

    29.0407

    15.93093

    3.782645

    0.287936

    0.008702

    -26.10485

    -16.7398

    -3.652454

    23.00957

    15.27196

    7.005967

    1.458871

    0.126222

    -2.756563

    -0.112669

    -0.003679

    12.27872

    17.76197

    11.58972

    3.426519

    0.577732

    -28.89637

    -14.23821

    -2.826677

    26.09641

    13.62813

    3.964732

    0.410057

    0.006917

    -26.13101

    -13.06736

    -3.584298

    26.5355

    13.87346

    2.637676

    0.143972

    0

    -20.31812

    -8.022832

    -0.830132

    21.64151

    14.50629

    5.290574

    0.87063

    0.039743

    -21.22937

    -11.41171

    -2.186651

    20.61073

    13.92175

    5.56786

    0.991841

    0.053146

    -22.0559

    -8.228158

    -0.784962

    21.86693

    13.36076

    3.385217

    0.201679

    0.003362

    -24.04132

    -12.62197

    -3.321883

    22.20512

    11.98137

    3.865638

    0.63769

    0.047799

    -24.49708

    -10.81178

    -1.265946

    22.84196

    11.88462

    3.06295

    0.257571

    0.00467

    -23.90765

    -8.451011

    -0.77817

    22.81223

    11.34309

    3.269293

    0.317818

    0.006884

    -32.04041

    -21.14091

    -6.450961

    23.31584

    9.732592

    1.921353

    0.173925

    0.007986

    -22.57675

    -6.412819

    -0.441467

    22.52952

    9.670304

    1.740405

    0.092806

    0.001019

    -21.57612

    -7.199342

    -0.70125

    21.40319

    9.31586

    1.438081

    0.074136

    0

    -41.10744

    -18.61331

    -1.533223

    24.70307

    6.28241

    0.696535

    0.036465

    0

    -27.27924

    -14.14155

    -2.068954

    20.73766

    8.551948

    1.520509

    0.09017

    0

    -22.89513

    -14.03866

    -3.094119

    17.93618

    9.298245

    2.984315

    0.458795

    0.017006

    -27.52795

    -9.835914

    -0.801899

    21.65457

    7.2456

    1.075038

    0.06867

    0

    -21.31702

    -15.57067

    -4.509401

    14.56631

    7.676528

    2.164935

    0.261868

    0.029232

    -33.68456

    -18.95404

    -3.094386

    17.87923

    4.386116

    0.742895

    0.024511

    0

    -27.84394

    -17.24451

    -2.866799

    17.26905

    5.102083

    0.461333

    0.006559

    0

    -20.81563

    -27.12404

    -10.79412

    7.743438

    1.778274

    0.232094

    0.007195

    0

    Tabelle1

    CNT with share of students not coveredLevel 1aLevel 1bBelow Level 1bLevel 2Level 3Level 4Level 5Level 6Share of students not covered in the PISA 2015 sample

    Singapore 4-7.2-1.9-0.114.522.426.617.85.4Singapore4

    Finland 3-8.7-2.2-0.218.528.425.311.62.4Finland3

    Japan 5-7.3-1.6-0.117.126.727.312.22.3Japan5

    Estonia 7-7.0-1.2-0.018.628.525.010.81.8Estonia7

    Ireland 4-11.9-2.6-0.325.530.019.46.10.7Ireland4

    Macao (China) 12-6.1-1.0-0.118.230.224.77.30.8Macao (China)12

    Hong Kong (China) 11-6.9-1.4-0.117.532.024.36.10.4Hong Kong (China)11

    Germany 4-12.2-3.7-0.421.826.521.18.41.7Germany4

    Slovenia 7-11.1-2.6-0.221.627.020.58.41.4Slovenia7

    Korea 8-10.2-2.7-0.419.926.822.08.51.3Korea8

    Switzerland 4-13.4-3.9-0.522.025.321.88.31.1Switzerland4

    Russia 5-14.5-2.7-0.129.729.415.33.40.2Russia5

    Netherlands 5-13.6-3.8-0.320.824.921.39.01.5Netherlands5

    CABA (Argentina) 0-17.2-4.8-0.730.829.014.92.60.1CABA (Argentina)0

    Poland 9-12.1-2.4-0.324.227.218.15.70.9Poland9

    Denmark 11-11.1-2.7-0.323.027.718.05.50.8Denmark11

    Australia 9-11.6-3.9-0.519.524.720.28.31.8Australia9

    Chinese Taipei 15-8.0-2.3-0.315.423.023.110.82.3Chinese Taipei15

    Belgium 7-13.4-4.6-0.520.424.920.97.50.9Belgium7

    New Zealand 10-11.8-3.6-0.419.523.719.69.12.5New Zealand10

    Canada 16-7.6-1.5-0.116.925.321.88.71.7Canada16

    Spain 9-13.0-3.3-0.324.128.517.24.20.3Spain9

    Norway 9-12.8-3.7-0.522.526.617.86.31.0Norway9

    Czech Republic 6-15.0-4.0-0.324.225.917.25.90.9Czech Republic6

    Latvia 11-12.9-2.3-0.126.528.215.53.10.3Latvia11

    Sweden 6-14.0-5.3-0.922.425.117.86.71.2Sweden6

    Portugal 12-12.3-2.8-0.222.225.218.45.90.6Portugal12

    France 9-14.0-5.3-0.820.024.119.56.50.7France9

    OECD average 11-13.7-4.3-0.521.924.417.26.11.0OECD average11

    Iceland 7-17.5-5.4-0.727.125.413.63.30.3Iceland7

    United Kingdom 16-11.4-2.9-0.318.923.118.27.61.5United Kingdom16

    Croatia 9-17.4-4.6-0.426.825.013.13.30.3Croatia9

    Lithuania 10-17.0-4.9-0.426.823.713.73.50.2Lithuania10

    United States 16-12.9-3.6-0.421.322.216.06.11.0United States16

    Hungary 10-16.5-6.1-0.722.824.514.93.80.3Hungary10

    Austria 17-13.2-3.8-0.419.923.416.35.70.8Austria17

    Malta 2-17.6-10.4-3.822.821.214.45.91.5Malta2

    Luxembourg 12-16.6-5.6-0.521.722.015.25.30.8Luxembourg12

    Israel 6-18.6-8.9-1.922.921.814.14.80.7Israel6

    Slovak Republic 11-17.6-7.9-1.824.622.111.92.90.3Slovak Republic11

    Italy 20-13.8-4.4-0.421.822.913.73.10.2Italy20

    Greece 9-20.4-8.3-1.125.823.010.51.80.1Greece9

    Romania 7-26.4-8.6-0.832.618.55.50.60.0Romania7

    Moldova 7-26.2-10.9-2.129.218.35.50.70.0Moldova7

    B-S-J-G (China) 36-7.6-2.4-0.413.216.515.27.31.3B-S-J-G (China)36

    United Arab Emirates 9-23.7-11.8-2.424.517.38.62.30.2United Arab Emirates9

    Chile 20-19.9-7.1-0.824.719.07.31.00.0Chile20

    Bulgaria 19-18.4-10.0-2.120.318.29.22.10.2Bulgaria19

    Albania 16-25.1-8.7-1.329.015.93.80.30.0Albania16

    Qatar 7-26.1-16.7-3.723.015.37.01.50.1Qatar7

    Viet Nam 51-2.8-0.1-0.012.317.811.63.40.6Viet Nam51

    Montenegro 10-28.9-14.2-2.826.113.64.00.40.0Montenegro10

    Jordan 14-26.1-13.1-3.626.513.92.60.10.0Jordan14

    Uruguay 28-20.3-8.0-0.821.614.55.30.90.0Uruguay28

    Trinidad and Tobago 24-21.2-11.4-2.220.613.95.61.00.1Trinidad and Tobago24

    Turkey 30-22.1-8.2-0.821.913.43.40.20.0Turkey30

    Georgia 21-24.0-12.6-3.322.212.03.90.60.0Georgia21

    Colombia 25-24.5-10.8-1.322.811.93.10.30.0Colombia25

    Thailand 29-23.9-8.5-0.822.811.33.30.30.0Thailand29

    FYROM 5-32.0-21.1-6.523.39.71.90.20.0FYROM5

    Costa Rica 37-22.6-6.4-0.422.59.71.70.10.0Costa Rica37

    Mexico 38-21.6-7.2-0.721.49.31.40.10.0Mexico38

    Tunisia 7-41.1-18.6-1.524.76.30.70.00.0Tunisia7

    Peru 26-27.3-14.1-2.120.78.61.50.10.0Peru26

    Brazil 29-22.9-14.0-3.117.99.33.00.50.0Brazil29

    Indonesia 32-27.5-9.8-0.821.77.21.10.10.0Indonesia32

    Lebanon 34-21.3-15.6-4.514.67.72.20.30.0Lebanon34

    Algeria 21-33.7-19.0-3.117.94.40.70.00.0Algeria21

    Kosovo 29-27.8-17.2-2.917.35.10.50.00.0Kosovo29

    Dominican Republic 32-20.8-27.1-10.87.71.80.20.00.0Dominican Republic32

  • ... pero hay algunas TENDENCIAS positivas

    Tendencia lineal en el rendimiento medio en ciencias

    Fuente: OCDE, base de datos de PISA 2015

  • Abordar el rendimiento educativo deficiente hace el crecimiento económico más integrador…

    • El aumento de los ingresos medios que se logra gracias a la adquisición de las competencias básicas universales equivale aproximadamente al 4,2 % en los 28 países con educación secundaria obligatoria.

    • Este aumento viene acompañado de una reducción media del 5,2 % en la parte de la desviación estándar de los ingresos inducida por los resultados

    …y expande el tamaño de la economía• y, por tanto, difiere de los planes fiscales y de redistribución simples que pueden

    modificar la distribución de la renta, pero que no contribuirían a la consecución de resultados en el ámbito social.

    • Las políticas para mejorar el capital de conocimiento también promoverán la integración y una distribución más equitativa de la renta.

    Crecimiento integrador

  • Alumnos que esperan cursar una carrera de cienciasFigura I.3.2

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    25

    30

    35

    40

    45

    50

    Dom

    inic

    an R

    ep.

    12

    Cos

    ta R

    ica

    11

    Jord

    an

    6U

    nite

    d Ar

    ab E

    m.

    11

    Mex

    ico

    6

    Col

    ombi

    a

    8Le

    bano

    n 1

    5Br

    azil

    19

    Peru

    7

    Qat

    ar

    19U

    nite

    d St

    ates

    13

    Chi

    le

    18Tu

    nisi

    a 1

    9C

    anad

    a 2

    1Sl

    oven

    ia

    16Tu

    rkey

    6

    Aust

    ralia

    15

    Uni

    ted

    King

    dom

    17

    Mal

    aysi

    a

    4Ka

    zakh

    stan

    14

    Spai

    n 1

    1N

    orw

    ay

    21U

    rugu

    ay

    17Si

    ngap

    ore

    14

    Trin

    idad

    and

    T.

    13

    Isra

    el

    25C

    ABA

    (Arg

    .) 1

    9Po

    rtuga

    l 1

    8Bu

    lgar

    ia

    25Ire

    land

    13

    Koso

    vo

    7Al

    geria

    12

    Mal

    ta

    11G

    reec

    e 1

    2N

    ew Z

    eala

    nd

    24Al

    bani

    a 2

    9Es

    toni

    a 1

    5O

    ECD

    ave

    rage

    19

    Belg

    ium

    16

    Cro

    atia

    17

    FYR

    OM

    20

    Lith

    uani

    a 2

    1Ic

    elan

    d 2

    2R

    ussi

    a 1

    9H

    KG (C

    hina

    ) 2

    0R

    oman

    ia

    20Ita

    ly

    17Au

    stria

    23

    Mol

    dova

    7

    Latv

    ia

    19M

    onte

    negr

    o 1

    8Fr

    ance

    21

    Luxe

    mbo

    urg

    18

    Pola

    nd

    13M

    acao

    (Chi

    na)

    10

    Chi

    nese

    Tai

    pei

    21

    Swed

    en

    21Th

    aila

    nd

    27Vi

    et N

    am

    13Sw

    itzer

    land

    22

    Kore

    a

    7H

    unga

    ry

    22Sl

    ovak

    Rep

    ublic

    24

    Japa

    n 1

    8Fi

    nlan

    d 2

    4G

    eorg

    ia

    27C

    zech

    Rep

    ublic

    22

    B-S-

    J-G

    (Chi

    na)

    31

    Net

    herla

    nds

    19

    Ger

    man

    y 3

    3In

    done

    sia

    19

    Den

    mar

    k 4

    8

    %Porcentaje de alumnos que esperan trabajar en puestos profesionales o técnicos relacionados con las ciencias cuando tengan 30 años

    Science and engineering professionals

    Health professionals

    Information and communication technology professionals

    Science-related technicians and associate professionals

    % d

    e al

    umno

    scon

    expe

    ctat

    ivas

    vag

    aso

    sin e

    xpec

    tativ

    as

  • SingapurCanadá

    EsloveniaAustralia

    Reino UnidoIrlanda

    Portugal

    TaiwánHong Kong (China)

    Nueva ZelandaDinamarca

    JapónEstonia

    FinlandiaMacao (China)

    VietnamB-S-J-G (China)

    CoreaAlemania

    Países BajosSuiza

    BélgicaPolonia

    SueciaLituaniaCroaciaIslandiaGeorgiaMalta

    Estados UnidosEspañaIsrael

    Emiratos Árabes Unidos

    BrasilBulgaria

    ChileColombiaCosta Rica

    República DominicanaJordaniaKosovo

    LíbanoMéxico

    PerúQatar

    Trinidad y TobagoTúnez

    TurquíaUruguay

    Rendimiento en ciencias superior a la media

    Creencias epistémicas superiores a la media

    Porcentaje superior a la media de alumnos que esperan trabajar en un puesto relacionado con las ciencias

    Noruega

    Res

    ulta

    dos

    múl

    tiple

    s

  • 0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    300 400 500 600 700

    Porc

    enta

    je d

    e al

    umno

    s qu

    e es

    pera

    n cu

    rsar

    una

    ca

    rrer

    a de

    cie

    ncia

    s

    Puntos en ciencias

    Low enjoyment of science High enjoyment of science

    Alumnos que esperan cursar una carrera de cienciaspor rendimiento y disfrute del aprendizaje

    Figura I.3.17

  • BIENESTAR DE LOS ALUMNOS

    EN IBEROAMÉRICA

    Comprensión de la relación entre el bienestar de los

    alumnos y su ESE a partir de los resultados

    de PISA 2015

  • LOS ELEVADOS NIVELES DE SATISFACCIÓN PERSONAL REFERIDOS EN IBEROAMÉRICA (MEDIA DE 7,8) SON SUPERIORES A LA MEDIA DE LA OCDE DE 7,3

    Satisfacción personal entre alumnos de 15 añosFuente: OCDE, base de datos de PISA 2015

    0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100

    Dominican Republic 8.5

    Mexico 8.3

    Costa Rica 8.2

    Colombia 7.9

    Brazil 7.6

    Uruguay 7.7

    Peru 7.5

    Chile 7.4

    OECD average 7.3

    Spain 7.4

    Portugal 7.4

    Very satisfied (9-10) Satisfied (7-8) Moderately satisfied (5-6) Not satisfied (0-4)

    %Satisfacción personal media

  • PERO ESTAS CIFRAS DE SATISFACCIÓN PERSONAL ENMASCARAN OTRAS FACETAS DEL BIENESTAR EN LAS QUE IBEROAMÉRICA NO OBTIENE PUNTUACIONES ALTAS

    En los países iberoamericanos, el rendimiento y la ansiedad ante los exámenes están correlacionados negativamente.

    Ansiedad relacionada con las tareas escolares entre alumnos situados en los cuartiles primero y último del índice de rendimiento en ciencias

    Fuente: OCDE, base de datos de PISA 2015

  • Diferencias en el índice del sentido de pertenencia, por características de los alumnos.

    Alumnos favorecidos -desfavorecidos Niños - niñas

    Alumnos no inmigrantes -inmigrantes

    EspañaPortugalMedia OCDEChileUruguayMéxicoBrasilCosta RicaPerúColombiaRepública Dominicana

    -0,50 0,00 0,50Índice del sentido de pertenencia

    En comparación con ciclos anteriores, Iberoamérica registró una tendencia al alza de alumnos que declararon sentirse alejados de la escuela en el ciclo PISA 2015.

    Índice de sentido de pertenencia, por características de los alumnos

    MAYOR SENTIDO DE PERTENENCIA ENTRE:

    1) FAVORECIDOS2) NIÑAS3) NO

    INMIGRANTES

    Fuente: OCDE, base de datos de PISA 2015

    Sistemas educativos con una diferencia/asociación positiva.Sistemas educativos con una diferencia/asociación negativa.Diferencia/asociación no significativa.Valores ausentes

  • Algunos alumnos aprenden en niveles altos

  • Todos los alumnos aprenden en niveles altos

  • T

    Brasil: Rendimiento escolar y perfil socioeconómico de las escuelas

    Punt

    uaci

    ón

    Gráfico1

    -3.2209065733-3.2209065733

    -3.1805639997-3.1805639997

    -2.9177039788-2.9177039788

    -2.8588686241-2.8588686241

    -2.8554333333-2.8554333333

    -2.8393142857-2.8393142857

    -2.8282498399-2.8282498399

    -2.7743559678-2.7743559678

    -2.7261456768-2.7261456768

    -2.6943333333-2.6943333333

    -2.6907821201-2.6907821201

    -2.6890105498-2.6890105498

    -2.5833836997-2.5833836997

    -2.5773760538-2.5773760538

    -2.5654485955-2.5654485955

    -2.5079411072-2.5079411072

    -2.4843514286-2.4843514286

    -2.3999173137-2.3999173137

    -2.3906931347-2.3906931347

    -2.3751743262-2.3751743262

    -2.3717773708-2.3717773708

    -2.3547565035-2.3547565035

    -2.3128666667-2.3128666667

    -2.3102023501-2.3102023501

    -2.3102013311-2.3102013311

    -2.2723649653-2.2723649653

    -2.2535023732-2.2535023732

    -2.2504273812-2.2504273812

    -2.2356168246-2.2356168246

    -2.2151288921-2.2151288921

    -2.191220625-2.191220625

    -2.1858156133-2.1858156133

    -2.1850786995-2.1850786995

    -2.1593498725-2.1593498725

    -2.1293356866-2.1293356866

    -2.1028861663-2.1028861663

    -2.1006043526-2.1006043526

    -2.0959491546-2.0959491546

    -2.0888565723-2.0888565723

    -2.0859305068-2.0859305068

    -2.0774176723-2.0774176723

    -2.0735493817-2.0735493817

    -2.0733256574-2.0733256574

    -2.0701854314-2.0701854314

    -2.0643100833-2.0643100833

    -2.0578205361-2.0578205361

    -2.0535152107-2.0535152107

    -2.037625-2.037625

    -2.0332630783-2.0332630783

    -2.0238283229-2.0238283229

    -2.0062030384-2.0062030384

    -1.9960304662-1.9960304662

    -1.9952205227-1.9952205227

    -1.9833558852-1.9833558852

    -1.9768737132-1.9768737132

    -1.9718501467-1.9718501467

    -1.9680797949-1.9680797949

    -1.9668658259-1.9668658259

    -1.9655086968-1.9655086968

    -1.9607517688-1.9607517688

    -1.9475-1.9475

    -1.9464048104-1.9464048104

    -1.943678988-1.943678988

    -1.9347333333-1.9347333333

    -1.9341276359-1.9341276359

    -1.933625-1.933625

    -1.9320748401-1.9320748401

    -1.931456519-1.931456519

    -1.9277404004-1.9277404004

    -1.9217370316-1.9217370316

    -1.9211415728-1.9211415728

    -1.9161173913-1.9161173913

    -1.9026746216-1.9026746216

    -1.9013355818-1.9013355818

    -1.9008228401-1.9008228401

    -1.8965016942-1.8965016942

    -1.8928979798-1.8928979798

    -1.8868506155-1.8868506155

    -1.8866666667-1.8866666667

    -1.8862797989-1.8862797989

    -1.8787165845-1.8787165845

    -1.8770941474-1.8770941474

    -1.8752913906-1.8752913906

    -1.8742467181-1.8742467181

    -1.8740725873-1.8740725873

    -1.8726297915-1.8726297915

    -1.8718034146-1.8718034146

    -1.8657821719-1.8657821719

    -1.8598434936-1.8598434936

    -1.859824768-1.859824768

    -1.8548952553-1.8548952553

    -1.8503-1.8503

    -1.8477441134-1.8477441134

    -1.8459440528-1.8459440528

    -1.8425156564-1.8425156564

    -1.8406622851-1.8406622851

    -1.839065253-1.839065253

    -1.8346218319-1.8346218319

    -1.8305643756-1.8305643756

    -1.8275448172-1.8275448172

    -1.826993095-1.826993095

    -1.8247692558-1.8247692558

    -1.823307965-1.823307965

    -1.8190885714-1.8190885714

    -1.8134945112-1.8134945112

    -1.8128984474-1.8128984474

    -1.81085-1.81085

    -1.8104610463-1.8104610463

    -1.7979686299-1.7979686299

    -1.7934534464-1.7934534464

    -1.7931564409-1.7931564409

    -1.7892297358-1.7892297358

    -1.7873554759-1.7873554759

    -1.7849768454-1.7849768454

    -1.7803218813-1.7803218813

    -1.7759325748-1.7759325748

    -1.7749105621-1.7749105621

    -1.766-1.766

    -1.7654930688-1.7654930688

    -1.7643035714-1.7643035714

    -1.7598100914-1.7598100914

    -1.758566492-1.758566492

    -1.7569437156-1.7569437156

    -1.7488833734-1.7488833734

    -1.7453121956-1.7453121956

    -1.7430006511-1.7430006511

    -1.7296354341-1.7296354341

    -1.7250512512-1.7250512512

    -1.7247055059-1.7247055059

    -1.7174586462-1.7174586462

    -1.7158561572-1.7158561572

    -1.71382625-1.71382625

    -1.7086501539-1.7086501539

    -1.706369155-1.706369155

    -1.7045331126-1.7045331126

    -1.7017510204-1.7017510204

    -1.7009750113-1.7009750113

    -1.6948928571-1.6948928571

    -1.6909929982-1.6909929982

    -1.6904178965-1.6904178965

    -1.6903768079-1.6903768079

    -1.6890902288-1.6890902288

    -1.6864090229-1.6864090229

    -1.6864062621-1.6864062621

    -1.6845380837-1.6845380837

    -1.6840512075-1.6840512075

    -1.6832398162-1.6832398162

    -1.682162464-1.682162464

    -1.6813603888-1.6813603888

    -1.6807803515-1.6807803515

    -1.6801984627-1.6801984627

    -1.6793957233-1.6793957233

    -1.6759620189-1.6759620189

    -1.671110051-1.671110051

    -1.6648845663-1.6648845663

    -1.6638461267-1.6638461267

    -1.6637524642-1.6637524642

    -1.663404276-1.663404276

    -1.6631609582-1.6631609582

    -1.6608472142-1.6608472142

    -1.6607437174-1.6607437174

    -1.6591591025-1.6591591025

    -1.6376799718-1.6376799718

    -1.6375079764-1.6375079764

    -1.6363003328-1.6363003328

    -1.6357161576-1.6357161576

    -1.6273883408-1.6273883408

    -1.6260830235-1.6260830235

    -1.6210661835-1.6210661835

    -1.6192779084-1.6192779084

    -1.6179519097-1.6179519097

    -1.6163764865-1.6163764865

    -1.6162338353-1.6162338353

    -1.6160819625-1.6160819625

    -1.6106121317-1.6106121317

    -1.6098826625-1.6098826625

    -1.6087317261-1.6087317261

    -1.6051249106-1.6051249106

    -1.6001113544-1.6001113544

    -1.5908432489-1.5908432489

    -1.5879909486-1.5879909486

    -1.5879424876-1.5879424876

    -1.5830192795-1.5830192795

    -1.5818645192-1.5818645192

    -1.5808455015-1.5808455015

    -1.5760364531-1.5760364531

    -1.5749704227-1.5749704227

    -1.5738151864-1.5738151864

    -1.5707536492-1.5707536492

    -1.5691610095-1.5691610095

    -1.5678324042-1.5678324042

    -1.5674072866-1.5674072866

    -1.5632568196-1.5632568196

    -1.5612700526-1.5612700526

    -1.55871926-1.55871926

    -1.5520854315-1.5520854315

    -1.5497157232-1.5497157232

    -1.5361202049-1.5361202049

    -1.5291916667-1.5291916667

    -1.51835625-1.51835625

    -1.5164082582-1.5164082582

    -1.5161341353-1.5161341353

    -1.5160379908-1.5160379908

    -1.5143326284-1.5143326284

    -1.5095212129-1.5095212129

    -1.5065127208-1.5065127208

    -1.5064228025-1.5064228025

    -1.5034555148-1.5034555148

    -1.5021443889-1.5021443889

    -1.4986348509-1.4986348509

    -1.4984846218-1.4984846218

    -1.4963316739-1.4963316739

    -1.491172797-1.491172797

    -1.4869209998-1.4869209998

    -1.4857912701-1.4857912701

    -1.48103659-1.48103659

    -1.4803903798-1.4803903798

    -1.4782942348-1.4782942348

    -1.476124375-1.476124375

    -1.4734890594-1.4734890594

    -1.4731104019-1.4731104019

    -1.472836526-1.472836526

    -1.4698057617-1.4698057617

    -1.4685411468-1.4685411468

    -1.4638999179-1.4638999179

    -1.4625950156-1.4625950156

    -1.4588150508-1.4588150508

    -1.4550998722-1.4550998722

    -1.4545416157-1.4545416157

    -1.453232474-1.453232474

    -1.4513796064-1.4513796064

    -1.4504315281-1.4504315281

    -1.4482293277-1.4482293277

    -1.4468097362-1.4468097362

    -1.444623162-1.444623162

    -1.4434189684-1.4434189684

    -1.4416152736-1.4416152736

    -1.43763186-1.43763186

    -1.4347040224-1.4347040224

    -1.4305585902-1.4305585902

    -1.4301467948-1.4301467948

    -1.4285764988-1.4285764988

    -1.4224045353-1.4224045353

    -1.4220014541-1.4220014541

    -1.4191547704-1.4191547704

    -1.4174-1.4174

    -1.413625-1.413625

    -1.4108752195-1.4108752195

    -1.4107753503-1.4107753503

    -1.4103486103-1.4103486103

    -1.4065128384-1.4065128384

    -1.4061763979-1.4061763979

    -1.4056588266-1.4056588266

    -1.3992832583-1.3992832583

    -1.3992380738-1.3992380738

    -1.3931796335-1.3931796335

    -1.3921394501-1.3921394501

    -1.3905858202-1.3905858202

    -1.3874340306-1.3874340306

    -1.3860210106-1.3860210106

    -1.3838165334-1.3838165334

    -1.380542633-1.380542633

    -1.3777466517-1.3777466517

    -1.3743973726-1.3743973726

    -1.3740051539-1.3740051539

    -1.3735619114-1.3735619114

    -1.3716022655-1.3716022655

    -1.3712001577-1.3712001577

    -1.3705792745-1.3705792745

    -1.3697909645-1.3697909645

    -1.3688459927-1.3688459927

    -1.3672479403-1.3672479403

    -1.3670439024-1.3670439024

    -1.366701154-1.366701154

    -1.3621004153-1.3621004153

    -1.3620044369-1.3620044369

    -1.3614392205-1.3614392205

    -1.361058586-1.361058586

    -1.3562701006-1.3562701006

    -1.3520780266-1.3520780266

    -1.3507378362-1.3507378362

    -1.3499134364-1.3499134364

    -1.3477924083-1.3477924083

    -1.3476512968-1.3476512968

    -1.3451301659-1.3451301659

    -1.3442903291-1.3442903291

    -1.3439570969-1.3439570969

    -1.3426455923-1.3426455923

    -1.3416497498-1.3416497498

    -1.340019096-1.340019096

    -1.3385297982-1.3385297982

    -1.3378176498-1.3378176498

    -1.337525-1.337525

    -1.3353613167-1.3353613167

    -1.3308754778-1.3308754778

    -1.3293612207-1.3293612207

    -1.3277656506-1.3277656506

    -1.3271251883-1.3271251883

    -1.3232803038-1.3232803038

    -1.3154809786-1.3154809786

    -1.3144883335-1.3144883335

    -1.3136931497-1.3136931497

    -1.3117294393-1.3117294393

    -1.3113870482-1.3113870482

    -1.3104088863-1.3104088863

    -1.3079142857-1.3079142857

    -1.3074339411-1.3074339411

    -1.3074243043-1.3074243043

    -1.3064369238-1.3064369238

    -1.3063607274-1.3063607274

    -1.3035304339-1.3035304339

    -1.2997872152-1.2997872152

    -1.2988698216-1.2988698216

    -1.2973239048-1.2973239048

    -1.2970842597-1.2970842597

    -1.2937766436-1.2937766436

    -1.2901415088-1.2901415088

    -1.2893297524-1.2893297524

    -1.2893044931-1.2893044931

    -1.2861906959-1.2861906959

    -1.2855021281-1.2855021281

    -1.2835273208-1.2835273208

    -1.2815597266-1.2815597266

    -1.2813646277-1.2813646277

    -1.2752444444-1.2752444444

    -1.2730812162-1.2730812162

    -1.2702568948-1.2702568948

    -1.2701072564-1.2701072564

    -1.2689152858-1.2689152858

    -1.267597756-1.267597756

    -1.2675802906-1.2675802906

    -1.2673109347-1.2673109347

    -1.2567036761-1.2567036761

    -1.2557362531-1.2557362531

    -1.2556088211-1.2556088211

    -1.2535713877-1.2535713877

    -1.2533102522-1.2533102522

    -1.251807298-1.251807298

    -1.2515820513-1.2515820513

    -1.2422629015-1.2422629015

    -1.2414833587-1.2414833587

    -1.2399030434-1.2399030434

    -1.239795454-1.239795454

    -1.2395631579-1.2395631579

    -1.2394675233-1.2394675233

    -1.2374101301-1.2374101301

    -1.2349587915-1.2349587915

    -1.2345411095-1.2345411095

    -1.2331507727-1.2331507727

    -1.2322761141-1.2322761141

    -1.2319578024-1.2319578024

    -1.2306421089-1.2306421089

    -1.228573533-1.228573533

    -1.2253590146-1.2253590146

    -1.2238180066-1.2238180066

    -1.2232913726-1.2232913726

    -1.2232253647-1.2232253647

    -1.2231896784-1.2231896784

    -1.2192216027-1.2192216027

    -1.2166854468-1.2166854468

    -1.2158551834-1.2158551834

    -1.2151224098-1.2151224098

    -1.2133342956-1.2133342956

    -1.2053125-1.2053125

    -1.1999460781-1.1999460781

    -1.1996926881-1.1996926881

    -1.199682692-1.199682692

    -1.1977910891-1.1977910891

    -1.1966269868-1.1966269868

    -1.1915775-1.1915775

    -1.1894544737-1.1894544737

    -1.1892611372-1.1892611372

    -1.1877319222-1.1877319222

    -1.1862930812-1.1862930812

    -1.18325-1.18325

    -1.1819160877-1.1819160877

    -1.1814297803-1.1814297803

    -1.1800940591-1.1800940591

    -1.1800343573-1.1800343573

    -1.1780721118-1.1780721118

    -1.1761565863-1.1761565863

    -1.1753269138-1.1753269138

    -1.1710537185-1.1710537185

    -1.1706869643-1.1706869643

    -1.16712037-1.16712037

    -1.1669217488-1.1669217488

    -1.1638790003-1.1638790003

    -1.16305-1.16305

    -1.1607617498-1.1607617498

    -1.1585932676-1.1585932676

    -1.1579173411-1.1579173411

    -1.1567705606-1.1567705606

    -1.1558875-1.1558875

    -1.1554516356-1.1554516356

    -1.1528317927-1.1528317927

    -1.1505067363-1.1505067363

    -1.1495468999-1.1495468999

    -1.1442166381-1.1442166381

    -1.1430974764-1.1430974764

    -1.1422485329-1.1422485329

    -1.1416050213-1.1416050213

    -1.1392386947-1.1392386947

    -1.1385109663-1.1385109663

    -1.1367299963-1.1367299963

    -1.1356329645-1.1356329645

    -1.1354791408-1.1354791408

    -1.134924102-1.134924102

    -1.1324112065-1.1324112065

    -1.130359447-1.130359447

    -1.1245303446-1.1245303446

    -1.1207229399-1.1207229399

    -1.1199643779-1.1199643779

    -1.1196179775-1.1196179775

    -1.1192-1.1192

    -1.1190659439-1.1190659439

    -1.114954902-1.114954902

    -1.1141446187-1.1141446187

    -1.1114841952-1.1114841952

    -1.1101132356-1.1101132356

    -1.105801827-1.105801827

    -1.1057416992-1.1057416992

    -1.1032903204-1.1032903204

    -1.1022666637-1.1022666637

    -1.1015873697-1.1015873697

    -1.1009554374-1.1009554374

    -1.0998135816-1.0998135816

    -1.0996725683-1.0996725683

    -1.0986631795-1.0986631795

    -1.0978008477-1.0978008477

    -1.0949042472-1.0949042472

    -1.0939048067-1.0939048067

    -1.0936735114-1.0936735114

    -1.0927418017-1.0927418017

    -1.0904953831-1.0904953831

    -1.0887483637-1.0887483637

    -1.0880881547-1.0880881547

    -1.0874119912-1.0874119912

    -1.0852578198-1.0852578198

    -1.0833854701-1.0833854701

    -1.0825417221-1.0825417221

    -1.0823366333-1.0823366333

    -1.0815218738-1.0815218738

    -1.0802163422-1.0802163422

    -1.079001764-1.079001764

    -1.0773203862-1.0773203862

    -1.0764705404-1.0764705404

    -1.0732946287-1.0732946287

    -1.0731050639-1.0731050639

    -1.0711492006-1.0711492006

    -1.0698072606-1.0698072606

    -1.0690486486-1.0690486486

    -1.0689039854-1.0689039854

    -1.0682060238-1.0682060238

    -1.0671503102-1.0671503102

    -1.0658385567-1.0658385567

    -1.0643692073-1.0643692073

    -1.0577001895-1.0577001895

    -1.0548938954-1.0548938954

    -1.0547614305-1.0547614305

    -1.0508343592-1.0508343592

    -1.0508084406-1.0508084406

    -1.0496958268-1.0496958268

    -1.0481582082-1.0481582082

    -1.0468258736-1.0468258736

    -1.0424476967-1.0424476967

    -1.0348904005-1.0348904005

    -1.0348361549-1.0348361549

    -1.0330165027-1.0330165027

    -1.0323599856-1.0323599856

    -1.0290028647-1.0290028647

    -1.0288803106-1.0288803106

    -1.0284531038-1.0284531038

    -1.0284487332-1.0284487332

    -1.0252711079-1.0252711079

    -1.0242930206-1.0242930206

    -1.0240952901-1.0240952901

    -1.0233765654-1.0233765654

    -1.0232790944-1.0232790944

    -1.0226536585-1.0226536585

    -1.0209449136-1.0209449136

    -1.0205188832-1.0205188832

    -1.0101988305-1.0101988305

    -1.0087458221-1.0087458221

    -1.0083319457-1.0083319457

    -1.0078999879-1.0078999879

    -1.0072255131-1.0072255131

    -0.9996591916-0.9996591916

    -0.9979276332-0.9979276332

    -0.9926925217-0.9926925217

    -0.991468621-0.991468621

    -0.9898324915-0.9898324915

    -0.9833008638-0.9833008638

    -0.9821805287-0.9821805287

    -0.9817436315-0.9817436315

    -0.9810296708-0.9810296708

    -0.9802472643-0.9802472643

    -0.9798349727-0.9798349727

    -0.9798280464-0.9798280464

    -0.979683506-0.979683506

    -0.9781993712-0.9781993712

    -0.9757023849-0.9757023849

    -0.9705105738-0.9705105738

    -0.9699824144-0.9699824144

    -0.9680508515-0.9680508515

    -0.9677426624-0.9677426624

    -0.9658237132-0.9658237132

    -0.9655664508-0.9655664508

    -0.9645637254-0.9645637254

    -0.9626187487-0.9626187487

    -0.9577774273-0.9577774273

    -0.9553241217-0.9553241217

    -0.953687274-0.953687274

    -0.9523565267-0.9523565267

    -0.948708206-0.948708206

    -0.9459383984-0.9459383984

    -0.9446748722-0.9446748722

    -0.9445972885-0.9445972885

    -0.9416695586-0.9416695586

    -0.9352412728-0.9352412728

    -0.9349310897-0.9349310897

    -0.9263726839-0.9263726839

    -0.9256722884-0.9256722884

    -0.9249172533-0.9249172533

    -0.924353232-0.924353232

    -0.9240750088-0.9240750088

    -0.9240607741-0.9240607741

    -0.9182057145-0.9182057145

    -0.9182004049-0.9182004049

    -0.91611092-0.91611092

    -0.9147247187-0.9147247187

    -0.9102929378-0.9102929378

    -0.9099876536-0.9099876536

    -0.9087331965-0.9087331965

    -0.9085943685-0.9085943685

    -0.9059633263-0.9059633263

    -0.9052561364-0.9052561364

    -0.904299601-0.904299601

    -0.9015274568-0.9015274568

    -0.9015266786-0.9015266786

    -0.8977768252-0.8977768252

    -0.8973666223-0.8973666223

    -0.8952783251-0.8952783251

    -0.8942491558-0.8942491558

    -0.8936908312-0.8936908312

    -0.8921701882-0.8921701882

    -0.8894631599-0.8894631599

    -0.8880125245-0.8880125245

    -0.8876169053-0.8876169053

    -0.8855089923-0.8855089923

    -0.8811326936-0.8811326936

    -0.8805589331-0.8805589331

    -0.8782425358-0.8782425358

    -0.8770009371-0.8770009371

    -0.8764256709-0.8764256709

    -0.8718633582-0.8718633582

    -0.8671479605-0.8671479605

    -0.8621976493-0.8621976493

    -0.8606695551-0.8606695551

    -0.8533453341-0.8533453341

    -0.8530412454-0.8530412454

    -0.850335403-0.850335403

    -0.8502203267-0.8502203267

    -0.8493510605-0.8493510605

    -0.849141659-0.849141659

    -0.8455897877-0.8455897877

    -0.8397183733-0.8397183733

    -0.8393565289-0.8393565289

    -0.8378267715-0.8378267715

    -0.8279748404-0.8279748404

    -0.8196581778-0.8196581778

    -0.8155479122-0.8155479122

    -0.8149374531-0.8149374531

    -0.8135078401-0.8135078401

    -0.8105764906-0.8105764906

    -0.8103282659-0.8103282659

    -0.8100222886-0.8100222886

    -0.8068235738-0.8068235738

    -0.80614169-0.80614169

    -0.8050970502-0.8050970502

    -0.8040515232-0.8040515232

    -0.8033572149-0.8033572149

    -0.8017588249-0.8017588249

    -0.8013510308-0.8013510308

    -0.7993240345-0.7993240345

    -0.7976535172-0.7976535172

    -0.7947651587-0.7947651587

    -0.7940277778-0.7940277778

    -0.793005703-0.793005703

    -0.7922775878-0.7922775878

    -0.7915818182-0.7915818182

    -0.7903314996-0.7903314996

    -0.7886049736-0.7886049736

    -0.786721562-0.786721562

    -0.78635-0.78635

    -0.7846786127-0.7846786127

    -0.7808866913-0.7808866913

    -0.7801581886-0.7801581886

    -0.7745999383-0.7745999383

    -0.7739840465-0.7739840465

    -0.7668467216-0.7668467216

    -0.7656333648-0.7656333648

    -0.7630472695-0.7630472695

    -0.7601347649-0.7601347649

    -0.7590130327-0.7590130327

    -0.7520781698-0.7520781698

    -0.7507910095-0.7507910095

    -0.735723804-0.735723804

    -0.730570874-0.730570874

    -0.729512589-0.729512589

    -0.7257164021-0.7257164021

    -0.7236812778-0.7236812778

    -0.7154901785-0.7154901785

    -0.7100461895-0.7100461895

    -0.7079198584-0.7079198584

    -0.7037259431-0.7037259431

    -0.7027098291-0.7027098291

    -0.6991507045-0.6991507045

    -0.6982726041-0.6982726041

    -0.6979782558-0.6979782558

    -0.6977307462-0.6977307462

    -0.6976594861-0.6976594861

    -0.6975986333-0.6975986333

    -0.6948470247-0.6948470247

    -0.6944374171-0.6944374171

    -0.6936929456-0.6936929456

    -0.6904712129-0.6904712129

    -0.6826249952-0.6826249952

    -0.6755635035-0.6755635035

    -0.67410624-0.67410624

    -0.660711208-0.660711208

    -0.6549715435-0.6549715435

    -0.654108141-0.654108141

    -0.6495502506-0.6495502506

    -0.6467327319-0.6467327319

    -0.6426332166-0.6426332166

    -0.6326575394-0.6326575394

    -0.6315117653-0.6315117653

    -0.6276501916-0.6276501916

    -0.6272579607-0.6272579607

    -0.6247333333-0.6247333333

    -0.6239951994-0.6239951994

    -0.6230038189-0.6230038189

    -0.6208930727-0.6208930727

    -0.6179141331-0.6179141331

    -0.6155358242-0.6155358242

    -0.6153044871-0.6153044871

    -0.5985435395-0.5985435395

    -0.5960914286-0.5960914286

    -0.5957427784-0.5957427784

    -0.593842457-0.593842457

    -0.5894776213-0.5894776213

    -0.5803395493-0.5803395493

    -0.5791798355-0.5791798355

    -0.5776954602-0.5776954602

    -0.5755811108-0.5755811108

    -0.5631231086-0.5631231086

    -0.5629610763-0.5629610763

    -0.5592762814-0.5592762814

    -0.5583918366-0.5583918366

    -0.5434930678-0.5434930678

    -0.5409066592-0.5409066592

    -0.5254-0.5254

    -0.520847374-0.520847374

    -0.5197721278-0.5197721278

    -0.5164958504-0.5164958504

    -0.5146971725-0.5146971725

    -0.5136075051-0.5136075051

    -0.4964857626-0.4964857626

    -0.4951727273-0.4951727273

    -0.49253822-0.49253822

    -0.4903662401-0.4903662401

    -0.4885394084-0.4885394084

    -0.4834187793-0.4834187793

    -0.483342314-0.483342314

    -0.4813781449-0.4813781449

    -0.4798232452-0.4798232452

    -0.4789219795-0.4789219795

    -0.4703384367-0.4703384367

    -0.4660348464-0.4660348464

    -0.465822799-0.465822799

    -0.4655377467-0.4655377467

    -0.4639960436-0.4639960436

    -0.4511250331-0.4511250331

    -0.4408576427-0.4408576427

    -0.4387953291-0.4387953291

    -0.4336448651-0.4336448651

    -0.433522405-0.433522405

    -0.4187240865-0.4187240865

    -0.4067429502-0.4067429502

    -0.3955188394-0.3955188394

    -0.3921799614-0.3921799614

    -0.3892420343-0.3892420343

    -0.3889538209-0.3889538209

    -0.3860154178-0.3860154178

    -0.3539665727-0.3539665727

    -0.3524125349-0.3524125349

    -0.3456227272-0.3456227272

    -0.3389142913-0.3389142913

    -0.3385987737-0.3385987737

    -0.3335161353-0.3335161353

    -0.3321676815-0.3321676815

    -0.332152439-0.332152439

    -0.3280581339-0.3280581339

    -0.3257241361-0.3257241361

    -0.3184528293-0.3184528293

    -0.3151345841-0.3151345841

    -0.310139808-0.310139808

    -0.3023304593-0.3023304593

    -0.3013602757-0.3013602757

    -0.2994711936-0.2994711936

    -0.2987252828-0.2987252828

    -0.2977503338-0.2977503338

    -0.296813835-0.296813835

    -0.2908560285-0.2908560285

    -0.2892416006-0.2892416006

    -0.2840848634-0.2840848634

    -0.2819562776-0.2819562776

    -0.2790226045-0.2790226045

    -0.2733554539-0.2733554539

    -0.2547927108-0.2547927108

    -0.2305965637-0.2305965637

    -0.2183-0.2183

    -0.2166537011-0.2166537011

    -0.2151423693-0.2151423693

    -0.2120225799-0.2120225799

    -0.1934961766-0.1934961766

    -0.1928419943-0.1928419943

    -0.1856-0.1856

    -0.1849353328-0.1849353328

    -0.1823228838-0.1823228838

    -0.1778850414-0.1778850414

    -0.1388499581-0.1388499581

    -0.1252701499-0.1252701499

    -0.1222668864-0.1222668864

    -0.1069937279-0.1069937279

    -0.1060663649-0.1060663649

    -0.1000278676-0.1000278676

    -0.0931942079-0.0931942079

    -0.0899453598-0.0899453598

    -0.0867333333-0.0867333333

    -0.0855060544-0.0855060544

    -0.0853303374-0.0853303374

    -0.0715711177-0.0715711177

    -0.0633215934-0.0633215934

    -0.0591219093-0.0591219093

    -0.0488819201-0.0488819201

    -0.0304865262-0.0304865262

    -0.0198833333-0.0198833333

    -0.0133142745-0.0133142745

    0.01992504430.0199250443

    0.02298772330.0229877233

    0.03808666710.0380866671

    0.03813732780.0381373278

    0.03984751140.0398475114

    0.04855705170.0485570517

    0.05447652830.0544765283

    0.05741250.0574125

    0.06905777930.0690577793

    0.07750.0775

    0.15585236650.1558523665

    0.16701846240.1670184624

    0.19413806350.1941380635

    0.20211425470.2021142547

    0.21401005520.2140100552

    0.23632832110.2363283211

    0.23980390630.2398039063

    0.24813710860.2481371086

    0.29553202050.2955320205

    0.3135843360.313584336

    0.32518089930.3251808993

    0.33123298690.3312329869

    0.34534970320.3453497032

    0.36021317240.3602131724

    0.3605259990.360525999

    0.3624250.362425

    0.36939240560.3693924056

    0.39094907560.3909490756

    0.39395954930.3939595493

    0.42944295780.4294429578

    0.43213027860.4321302786

    0.43233809220.4323380922

    0.43454396660.4345439666

    0.44345701820.4434570182

    0.44390312090.4439031209

    0.45246315790.4524631579

    0.474160.47416

    0.47956233020.4795623302

    0.48056842110.4805684211

    0.48780.4878

    0.51727126090.5172712609

    0.5230477980.523047798

    0.54807886180.5480788618

    0.5579055740.557905574

    0.55856599330.5585659933

    0.57705324060.5770532406

    0.5934321510.593432151

    0.59634405620.5963440562

    0.59964296590.5996429659

    0.60441008580.6044100858

    0.64039207710.6403920771

    0.64470765680.6447076568

    0.64755969540.6475596954

    0.67831922120.6783192212

    0.68325868390.6832586839

    0.68707255820.6870725582

    0.72498235290.7249823529

    0.73404156420.7340415642

    0.74796813190.7479681319

    0.76928695280.7692869528

    0.77491622510.7749162251

    0.80020883380.8002088338

    0.85768679140.8576867914

    0.87490583330.8749058333

    0.88121863950.8812186395

    0.88171196820.8817119682

    0.89169917520.8916991752

    0.92483997270.9248399727

    0.94256341460.9425634146

    0.94690889720.9469088972

    0.94888221420.9488822142

    0.97644058640.9764405864

    1.00534627471.0053462747

    1.00858715421.0085871542

    1.01383770981.0138377098

    1.02758609571.0275860957

    1.04388138191.0438813819

    1.09045058231.0904505823

    337.3030

    353.88491666670

    00

    395.79314285710

    375.67685714290

    323.41317266590

    319.95980174220

    341.81637238520

    00

    328.58350

    356.08580735280

    314.56440277040

    0388.3405149265

    Public schools

    Private schools

    PISA index of economic, social and cultural status

    350.3276703331

    342.1887781946

    347.7522267574

    345.3643727127

    337.9398803707

    315.5716666667

    298.615833581

    320.104652244

    364.0069185396

    295.3192534314

    376.7291136136

    389.95284805

    333.8474408163

    293.1562352148

    375.1403684269

    304.9729524441

    377.8362613258

    384.7289548931

    311.2638210068

    339.4191815145

    361.5097371625

    359.5690259212

    371.4520072019

    336.6118989284

    377.7443936344

    369.7882895807

    364.9903805591

    290.9212

    326.4556345155

    382.837597523

    329.8647766286

    373.4562748402

    372.7907787398

    358.8083878677

    369.2568505391

    338.091

    345.6426227644

    366.457

    361.6668775627

    330.705159386

    388.9812374606

    369.9070727129

    331.7092173236

    389.8101304351

    294.5117488591

    361.1832154282

    314.2796662754

    388.0660057165

    390.6016751906

    326.4902902102

    417.6535278892

    287.9283597805

    380.3045856945

    323.2582719839

    395.6897497005

    389.8103873673

    384.7959129943

    307.8629712299

    389.0126371188

    304.4328468485

    448.3906741979

    360.6217327478

    360.6555055806

    335.1753415909

    414.5053654903

    318.1872999998

    374.6627943258

    370.5585922143

    365.1250724336

    362.3767242215

    398.2451839247

    287.2296559997

    358.7490800875

    337.5446697614

    305.0308965517

    383.0172543557

    336.6623752517

    382.5844812721

    329.5271831909

    287.3262884967

    324.9015211217

    386.1233388236

    324.5630788334

    361.6574102564

    306.8839489795

    382.5736904762

    356.2758643148

    348.7011697395

    405.2544861646

    353.1751734384

    402.9144807737

    383.5999125023

    382.107018479

    433.4930913115

    387.0082095851

    378.1718546854

    361.5585491508

    421.0084490313

    412.4628482263

    318.2982219104

    381.5030234813

    373.2500540541

    408.0699843717

    381.4023151435

    380.0437991569

    322.8482073523

    335.5767837862

    415.8104890352

    352.3628529369

    307.4409409773

    369.3466066409

    321.0083753237

    375.8105801461

    293.5839313237

    382.582680712

    314.3598289994

    327.1444545193

    328.1811009461

    319.4704471689

    390.8162751619

    376.645274793

    386.2894023253

    355.7210533892

    369.4298067109

    404.8815336602

    359.3882140853

    377.8926150405

    363.8766646339

    303.3396401333

    320.056053356

    331.9779649607

    370.9634091288

    350.8282285673

    334.3846086957

    337.5000588235

    384.3211883341

    386.1055483336

    399.5685324568

    397.480455697

    308.9131904663

    346.5206499979

    357.5792621061

    332.2224241393

    379.4129353167

    387.8806344509

    391.68972624

    415.1397713825

    417.2593199071

    412.5286937504

    377.7201936323

    338.9070220028

    306.3755833162

    398.1585458743

    397.7749727644

    400.5982907794

    419.6098222745

    386.1103239595

    329.3914491659

    421.5771863253

    336.5458606329

    372.2574071732

    315.5826948286

    351.6826939548

    328.0140870266

    346.4311158474

    347.3398450807

    389.9264723385

    377.4829587086

    410.0118095238

    384.3982709305

    313.6438295678

    347.545286891

    400.9767471154

    386.7440080336

    391.5300538032

    415.1483971783

    327.9630348595

    383.8187307774

    394.5866417899

    354.2174526323

    362.4954462168

    319.7710107401

    302.6580935507

    292.4707841391

    407.2219808583

    353.7067535026

    426.5773333333

    425.8700776895

    380.640282812

    312.182697441

    379.5603623381

    452.1594990018

    299.3590567634

    404.1495583024

    416.835846313

    385.854807972

    328.9005522353

    421.0838439919

    405.6270710842

    337.237154603

    335.0543529601

    386.749779798

    402.2099329098

    381.8823052883

    378.2841490341

    338.5111660011

    374.5937989465

    295.0944998949

    387.9568393835

    326.2576326565

    398.1764607681

    397.8432528702

    371.9511587879

    407.0953946937

    380.9909214067

    375.2295862026

    403.7769759407

    431.4987728066

    342.7635793154

    443.3337295237

    341.2032002367

    415.2709973529

    369.1927675807

    420.2400046533

    385.7780676793

    399.2962649366

    396.5404111946

    300.0648919593

    438.323

    404.5784396426

    369.6542580822

    356.013688164

    370.2056379607

    349.0791933641

    414.8670225164

    357.9795569698

    433.63815

    366.8874317299

    353.7248926832

    382.5495129556

    323.0162857143

    372.0301972295

    413.4043310575

    404.8655064131

    366.0463314607

    402.898150633

    382.1221917612

    389.1653060431

    392.3715880056

    359.2843593715

    325.1008874556

    319.3556976877

    355.2719845478

    391.1667167136

    421.4915830098

    381.4295680447

    382.0033286977

    351.69725

    379.6225265581

    419.2100999126

    354.357065088

    325.188024193

    498.903575

    356.3169573377

    389.0035153044

    343.0932860881

    327.2365691023

    357.7922090265

    392.3489557125

    401.4444285841

    326.5127136434

    386.7128307818

    372.5650847905

    428.5664363418

    373.590905557

    301.6022941176

    400.886217977

    394.2502216766

    401.0517153692

    391.3171002234

    302.268138837

    385.6651823901

    376.1063070144

    329.9258809045

    326.5940087366

    372.732223701

    393.5482249602

    328.7769480495

    392.6946440817

    416.2850314556

    364.8287790531

    379.3519121743

    397.2208938645

    324.4129384616

    370.5455252068

    394.4753260194

    350.5678725686

    372.7168592139

    378.4304415669

    404.9076816286

    345.9243476955

    298.4784565203

    370.0368675376

    426.3160073197

    397.7083228785

    411.4401061332

    379.4864737671

    435.7699554778

    397.2621706178

    368.0487766106

    425.9606345587

    348.0784334545

    385.2695470891

    346.624898963

    362.0902720217

    424.9428675136

    372.1495172501

    389.1539728677

    351.7022877492

    436.9510437069

    408.7770498021

    294.9800951852

    340.719906942

    332.4694057655

    402.973228461

    397.988

    428.1946134317

    390.6817474463

    377.9105040651

    396.0375297181

    365.6424162555

    425.0121654765

    343.2234861458

    387.8499740793

    440.2557236125

    407.3798467236

    432.213335645

    386.0874763524

    430.0325093699

    387.3623109628

    308.1229843454

    413.224579993

    331.3554284235

    434.3131890482

    376.2043065662

    460.6694556708

    449.6645865267

    394.3477276265

    299.3510286866

    382.3592695293

    378.6394736114

    394.0718920298

    406.4015953405

    377.0819085646

    404.8924112622

    349.2639672079

    425.9004742118

    432.3962884787

    503.5242329424

    384.3189305121

    412.5187428197

    408.4487941359

    392.8063449453

    360.1932331789

    348.9690972325

    399.2360853629

    352.4744325425

    345.8552275055

    436.1510434828

    375.7831920176

    352.954431996

    393.8485550181

    387.1735600495

    411.4716099499

    452.8596184845

    385.2428857403

    377.8374717811

    350.1798256697

    318.3596273867

    397.9349076322

    421.5521372477

    473.5556236625

    342.3801280188

    404.9640194066

    378.7840634476

    426.8433993221

    358.4731609985

    386.8717740082

    424.7689207467

    412.0533413346

    417.2734392528

    401.1161445117

    361.6451107855

    375.4402929268

    405.3014665567

    282.9769837189

    421.8606841933

    356.696595516

    395.7463787062

    337.71540647

    370.0256571528

    374.749406742

    394.1825164308

    346.3219352679

    389.6175066727

    310.3764028897

    422.8055263515

    372.3036476297

    382.2556934121

    400.2731947499

    424.795657268

    370.0787322853

    469.4576690505

    404.0622202141

    420.9009764418

    453.9087210834

    400.1359720381

    486.6020066859

    452.1731371797

    428.3000638334

    425.0223859881

    397.7806838852

    429.6140696465

    385.7840880189

    389.5405259552

    446.587364742

    441.7261081612

    359.9025652174

    381.6827059535

    379.825615531

    315.5795

    430.0149651229

    384.199209771

    419.9304500139

    416.8549804548

    407.5021611941

    410.4235650397

    431.3830634531

    426.0224452936

    432.0193902087

    432.1988511982

    399.8508945226

    387.9470712742

    382.6055776779

    402.6861431905

    367.7730797565

    431.2309206789

    407.9676110633

    368.8250917715

    429.8624208668

    426.7960199668

    312.2656498117

    406.583169894

    426.5734965938

    416.8454572151

    420.9038706287

    410.1879473875

    347.4136056046

    366.7696864369

    441.481396799

    395.3298739157

    446.1851397365

    384.3486104963

    427.0613342284

    474.8785428571

    459.7899585453

    437.9387462933

    421.7556427742

    373.0256747562

    391.4817526371

    319.210626394

    417.9999083086

    454.1309425953

    444.8605880073

    413.8666043261

    432.8229477342

    339.1551428571

    330.6168187668

    463.3757789007

    359.8099371197

    439.9533009386

    372.3889090909

    434.2971858168

    408.6431099587

    423.6595293155

    317.6290039765

    443.541