wp3 – dendro-provenancingforseadiscovery.eu/.../nm1_dominguez_delmas_marta.pdf · marta...

23
Marta Domínguez Delmás Universidad de Santiago de Compostela - BIOAPLIC Faculty of Forestry, dpt. Botany ForSEAdiscovery Network meeting Madrid 12-16 Jan 2015 WP3 – Dendro-provenancing ESR9 - Development and implementation of a tree-ring data network for the assessment of the date and provenance of Iberian ship-timbers

Upload: others

Post on 22-Aug-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: WP3 – Dendro-provenancingforseadiscovery.eu/.../nm1_dominguez_delmas_marta.pdf · Marta Domínguez Delmás. Universidad de Santiago de Compostela - BIOAPLIC Faculty of Forestry,

Marta Domínguez DelmásUniversidad de Santiago de Compostela - BIOAPLIC

Faculty of Forestry, dpt. BotanyForSEAdiscovery Network meeting Madrid 12-16 Jan 2015

WP3 – Dendro-provenancingESR9 - Development and implementation of a tree-ring data network

for the assessment of the date and provenance ofIberian ship-timbers

Page 2: WP3 – Dendro-provenancingforseadiscovery.eu/.../nm1_dominguez_delmas_marta.pdf · Marta Domínguez Delmás. Universidad de Santiago de Compostela - BIOAPLIC Faculty of Forestry,

Most exact dating method

Dendrochronology

AD 2008AD 1990AD 1970AD 1950

102030405060

Spring 2009

2

mm

1

3

4

5

Reference chronologyfor a specific site and species

Page 3: WP3 – Dendro-provenancingforseadiscovery.eu/.../nm1_dominguez_delmas_marta.pdf · Marta Domínguez Delmás. Universidad de Santiago de Compostela - BIOAPLIC Faculty of Forestry,

Dendrochronology

GaliciaData USC

Basque CountryData Arkeolan

Page 4: WP3 – Dendro-provenancingforseadiscovery.eu/.../nm1_dominguez_delmas_marta.pdf · Marta Domínguez Delmás. Universidad de Santiago de Compostela - BIOAPLIC Faculty of Forestry,

Dendro-provenancing

Domínguez-Delmás et al. 2013. Dendrochronological dating and provenancing of timbers from the Arade 1wreck, Portugal. International Journal of Nautical Archaeology

• Reference chronologies for the source area• Relative uncertain accuracy

Page 5: WP3 – Dendro-provenancingforseadiscovery.eu/.../nm1_dominguez_delmas_marta.pdf · Marta Domínguez Delmás. Universidad de Santiago de Compostela - BIOAPLIC Faculty of Forestry,

Retrospective extension of chronologies

Eckstein & Wrobel, 2008

Page 6: WP3 – Dendro-provenancingforseadiscovery.eu/.../nm1_dominguez_delmas_marta.pdf · Marta Domínguez Delmás. Universidad de Santiago de Compostela - BIOAPLIC Faculty of Forestry,

Historical timbers

>37 structuresOaks (Quercus spp.)

>30 structuresPines (Pinus spp.)

Current state dendrochronology in the IPLiving trees

Domínguez-Delmás et al., in revision. Forests, tree-rings and Cultural Heritage: current state and future prospects of dendro-archaelogy in the Iberian Peninsula. Journal of Archaeological Science

Page 7: WP3 – Dendro-provenancingforseadiscovery.eu/.../nm1_dominguez_delmas_marta.pdf · Marta Domínguez Delmás. Universidad de Santiago de Compostela - BIOAPLIC Faculty of Forestry,

Approach

1. Timber resources for shipbuilding in literature

Mid 18th-century• Motrico shipyard supplied by Devaforests

• Orio by Zarauz forests• Ugarrice (Pasajes) by Irun (100 oaks) and Rentería (300 coppiced oaks) forests

Page 8: WP3 – Dendro-provenancingforseadiscovery.eu/.../nm1_dominguez_delmas_marta.pdf · Marta Domínguez Delmás. Universidad de Santiago de Compostela - BIOAPLIC Faculty of Forestry,

Approach

2. Division of the Peninsula in watersheds

Domínguez-Delmás et al., in revision. Forests, tree-rings and Cultural Heritage: current state and future prospects of dendro-archaelogy in the Iberian Peninsula. Journal of Archaeological Science

Page 9: WP3 – Dendro-provenancingforseadiscovery.eu/.../nm1_dominguez_delmas_marta.pdf · Marta Domínguez Delmás. Universidad de Santiago de Compostela - BIOAPLIC Faculty of Forestry,
Page 10: WP3 – Dendro-provenancingforseadiscovery.eu/.../nm1_dominguez_delmas_marta.pdf · Marta Domínguez Delmás. Universidad de Santiago de Compostela - BIOAPLIC Faculty of Forestry,
Page 11: WP3 – Dendro-provenancingforseadiscovery.eu/.../nm1_dominguez_delmas_marta.pdf · Marta Domínguez Delmás. Universidad de Santiago de Compostela - BIOAPLIC Faculty of Forestry,
Page 12: WP3 – Dendro-provenancingforseadiscovery.eu/.../nm1_dominguez_delmas_marta.pdf · Marta Domínguez Delmás. Universidad de Santiago de Compostela - BIOAPLIC Faculty of Forestry,
Page 13: WP3 – Dendro-provenancingforseadiscovery.eu/.../nm1_dominguez_delmas_marta.pdf · Marta Domínguez Delmás. Universidad de Santiago de Compostela - BIOAPLIC Faculty of Forestry,

Approach

3. Selection of forests, major buildings, sawmills and renovation companies in the selected areas within the watersheds

Page 14: WP3 – Dendro-provenancingforseadiscovery.eu/.../nm1_dominguez_delmas_marta.pdf · Marta Domínguez Delmás. Universidad de Santiago de Compostela - BIOAPLIC Faculty of Forestry,

Photo:  CODEX AiP

Photo: SEAS

Photo: CASC

Photo: Archaeonauta

Photo: RING

Shipwrecks researched by dendrochronology 2009-2013

Domínguez Delmás, M., 2014. Avances de la dendrocronología al servicio de la arqueología subacuática española: ¿qué información podemos extraer de la madera de los pecios?. Actas del I Congreso de Arqueología Náutica y Subacuática Española. MECD.

Moderador
Notas de la presentación
Shipwrecks Barceloneta (CASC) Quercus sp. (13) Triunfante (CASC) Pinus sp. (6) Matagrana (CAS) Quercus sp. (1) San Sebastián (CAS) Quercus sp. (1) Bracara Augusta (DANS) Quercus sp. (2) Ria de Aveiro F (DANS) Quercus sp. (?) Tropical wood (4) Ria de Aveiro G (DANS) Quercus sp. (2) Arade 1 (DANS) Quercus sp. (20) Castanea sativa (2) Mortella III (SEAS) Quercus sp. (11) Fagus sylvatica (2)
Page 15: WP3 – Dendro-provenancingforseadiscovery.eu/.../nm1_dominguez_delmas_marta.pdf · Marta Domínguez Delmás. Universidad de Santiago de Compostela - BIOAPLIC Faculty of Forestry,

Barceloneta I shipwreckClinker-built

Relative date by stratigraphy in mid-15th century

Photo: M. Soberon, CODEX Arqueologia i Patrimoni

Soberón Rodríguez et al. 2012. El Barceloneta I. Una embarcación medieval a tingladillo en Barcelona. ITSAS Memoria 7

Page 16: WP3 – Dendro-provenancingforseadiscovery.eu/.../nm1_dominguez_delmas_marta.pdf · Marta Domínguez Delmás. Universidad de Santiago de Compostela - BIOAPLIC Faculty of Forestry,

Barceloneta I – hull planks

• Radially split• 2-3 cm thick• Slow grown trees

Page 17: WP3 – Dendro-provenancingforseadiscovery.eu/.../nm1_dominguez_delmas_marta.pdf · Marta Domínguez Delmás. Universidad de Santiago de Compostela - BIOAPLIC Faculty of Forestry,

Barceloneta 1 – Framing elements

• Fast grown trees in juvenile period

• Drastic growth suppression afterwards

• Trees selected by shape and diameter

Rin

g w

idth

(mm

*10)

-2)

Page 18: WP3 – Dendro-provenancingforseadiscovery.eu/.../nm1_dominguez_delmas_marta.pdf · Marta Domínguez Delmás. Universidad de Santiago de Compostela - BIOAPLIC Faculty of Forestry,

Framing elements

Trees selected by shape and size

Page 19: WP3 – Dendro-provenancingforseadiscovery.eu/.../nm1_dominguez_delmas_marta.pdf · Marta Domínguez Delmás. Universidad de Santiago de Compostela - BIOAPLIC Faculty of Forestry,
Page 20: WP3 – Dendro-provenancingforseadiscovery.eu/.../nm1_dominguez_delmas_marta.pdf · Marta Domínguez Delmás. Universidad de Santiago de Compostela - BIOAPLIC Faculty of Forestry,

From De Aranda y Antón (1990)

Page 21: WP3 – Dendro-provenancingforseadiscovery.eu/.../nm1_dominguez_delmas_marta.pdf · Marta Domínguez Delmás. Universidad de Santiago de Compostela - BIOAPLIC Faculty of Forestry,

El TriunfanteBuilt in El Ferrol, Spain 1754-56

Sunk in Cabo de Rosas 1793(De la Fuente 2006)

Carvel built

Page 22: WP3 – Dendro-provenancingforseadiscovery.eu/.../nm1_dominguez_delmas_marta.pdf · Marta Domínguez Delmás. Universidad de Santiago de Compostela - BIOAPLIC Faculty of Forestry,

Hull planks• Pinus sp.• Tangential

Ring

 width (m

m*10‐

2 )

Nr of rings

Page 23: WP3 – Dendro-provenancingforseadiscovery.eu/.../nm1_dominguez_delmas_marta.pdf · Marta Domínguez Delmás. Universidad de Santiago de Compostela - BIOAPLIC Faculty of Forestry,

Marta Domínguez DelmásUniversidad de Santiago de Compostela - BIOAPLIC

Faculty of Forestry, dpt. BotanyForSEAdiscovery Network meeting Madrid 12-16 Jan 2015

Thank you!