hvac presentation

20
S Siemens Room Renovation HVAC System Donald Morgan Nick Hunt Steven Kinney David Amrhein

Upload: cswisher

Post on 13-Jan-2017

451 views

Category:

Design


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Hvac presentation

S

Siemens Room RenovationHVAC System

Donald MorganNick HuntSteven KinneyDavid Amrhein

Page 2: Hvac presentation

Problem Statement

PSH M&O renovated room E 219 in the Olmsted Building The group is responsible for the HVAC portion The existing fan coil system needed to be replaced or

upgraded Two ME teams formed

HVAC Controls

Page 3: Hvac presentation

Teams Involved

ME Teams – analyzing old and new system and choosing a suitable control system.

EE – 2 teams choosing wiring and lighting systems for the room.

Page 4: Hvac presentation

Scope

Research 3 different systems and determine which works best

Install and commission HVAC system by end of Spring 2015 semester

Benchmark the newly installed system

Page 5: Hvac presentation

Scope: Approach Break Down

Page 6: Hvac presentation

Alternatives

Three different systems were considered. Two pipe fan coil system Variable air volume system Chilled beam system

The updated Fan Coil system was determined to be the most cost effective solution.

Page 7: Hvac presentation

Alternatives Metric

Installation Cost

EnergyEfficiency

Maintenance

Space Requirements

Total

Fan Coil 1 3 1 1 6

VariableAir Volume (VAV)

2 2 2 3 9

Chilled Beam 3 1 3 2 9* This scale used 1 as the best and 3 as the worst. Once each category

was scored for each system, a total was taken and the system with the lowest score was chosen.

Page 8: Hvac presentation

Installation Cost

Fan Coil- basically already in place. Plumbing for units are already installed in room.

VAV- would require large ductwork and unit. Higher cost to retrofit.

Chilled Beam- highest cost. would require plumbing fitting above ceiling. Higher cost to retrofit. Would also require an additional system to handle humidity.

Page 9: Hvac presentation

Energy Efficiency

Fan Coil- least efficient units to run. They rely the most on electricity to circulate air.

VAV- most efficient system. Keeps air at constant temperature and varies fan speed to regulate temperature.

Chilled Beam- requires fans to circulate heated air around room during winter.

Page 10: Hvac presentation

Maintenance

Fan Coil- easiest and safest to maintain. Conveniently accessible filters, located on ground level along walls.

VAV- located above ceilings, reaching filters requires ladders, increased fall risk, working above-head.

Chilled Beam- requires working at ceiling level on ladder, increased fall risk, most cleaning required.

Page 11: Hvac presentation

Space Requirements

Fan Coil- least amount of space required, retrofits very easily. No above-ceiling additional ductwork or equipment required.

VAV- requires the most above ceiling ductwork and equipment. Making everything easily accessible would be difficult.

Chilled Beam- would require additional plumbing as well as chilled beams installed in ceiling. (42 ft of beams necessary to effectively cool room)

Page 12: Hvac presentation

Final Choice: Fan Coil Units

FCBB0601C**ABH10AC3M00—01x00H30000000000000 B: Cabinet type: Vertical 060: Unit Size: 510 cfm; 48.02 MBh C: Coil: 4 Row Hot Water

Page 13: Hvac presentation
Page 14: Hvac presentation

Manual Calculations

ASHRAE 62.1 Ventilation Standards Vbz = RpPz+RaAz =(7.5*60)+(.06*1075)=514.5 cfm

12” x 5.5” Duct will deliver 260 cfm of airflow to the room.

Page 15: Hvac presentation

Energy Calculations

Energy Savings: Lighting Controls: electricity reduction of 10%

=> 795 Btu/h = 1.45 million btu/year = cost saving of $56

Temperature Controls: Temperature drift from 68°F to 72°F => 510.3 Btu/h = .93 million btu/year = cost saving of

$36

Total: If implemented for 10hr/day around $93 per room can be saved over the warmest part of the year.

Page 16: Hvac presentation

Benchmarking the Room

Page 17: Hvac presentation

Benchmarking the Room

Page 18: Hvac presentation

Benchmark Criteria

Ceiling Diffusers Right Side - 240 cfm Front Wall – 530 cfm Left Side – 230 cfm

Fan Coil Units High – 780 Medium - 575 cfm Low – 435 cfm

Lighting – 86.7°F

Page 19: Hvac presentation

Revit Drawing of Olmsted 219E

Page 20: Hvac presentation

Questions?