4&5˘ 672 84& 3 -./0 *12 gis ’ () * +) , · 2021. 2. 20. · 225 -250 ˛ / 1394 ˘ 2 2 /...
TRANSCRIPT
������� �� / ���2 ���� �2 ������� �1394 /� 250- 225
������ ����� � ������ ��������� ���������� �� ������
��� �!" � �� �� #$%&
!"�#$� !$%��&� *
� ��� '� ()" *��� +�)���,GIS � �-.��/0 *12�� 3���� 4&�5� 6�72�� 84&�
9*:� !;�<� =-�>*�?� ([email protected])
���"� 8@#A#.�#�#;@*12�� 03���� � �-.��/4&�5� 6�72�� �84&�
#(1- �<�*�?� ([email protected])
6��B ��&���"�CD � !"�)��#E*12�� � �-.��/03���� 4&�5� 6�72�� 84&�
�����, 6��4-A� F-$G ([email protected])
6��B ��&���"�CD � !"�)��#E*12�� � �-.��/03���� 84&�4&�5� 6�72�� �
) I.�&�� J&���1/12/1393 - K�&LM J&���25/6/1394(
'�(
=-�' !���E#, P��)� �� !%-5� ������� '� !1& K4/A3� !� ���� ��� 8��Q&' �����G 3� 3A�"�E 3, �Q()� !Q� �#Q� . S<#>6�TU =���� �� ��2A� CD�� ��� � !���E#, 8� ��*%�"� 8���� V$��� !%-5� W&��� � XY #:A��=-�' IQ"� K4Q/A .
Z*E P-:?� =&�S�&�:� [*�S15� �� !\#)]� !5]\*)&��. F-$?�3$�$" �!5����3� �#^)� �Q_G !��Q&'�� =-Q�' K4Q/A ��S<#> ��2A� CD�� I"�. ��#^)� =&* �*��� � �� �`a� 8�E������Mb#c �'=- K4Q/A 3Q&d efQ" � g����Q"� h#Q��� 8�QET�3- *� .ef" S2: �' ),��M=- K4/A 8�Ei� ��� T� 3<#>3- *�. 3���� �� ��� 3�&�:� !"��� S2: �Q� �`aQ� FQ��#\
�� K4/AS2: �' ),��M=- K4/A ��E �E �-`j�k& � F��#\ '��l- Q� IT0�l- �b�QY��� m)Q" �!Q"�)� ����Q, �K��Q�8 <���!?� �� 3E���D � F�B '� 3$n�. �W- 9� ��4.�ArcGIS ()Q"6*- *Q� . =Q&� �� E�oQM 3Q� �#Q^)� 3Q)TM �Q_G 8*Q)�
=-�' �� K4/AS<#> ��2A� CD��� '� [*� 8�ES15� F-$?� � !\#)]� !5]\3$�$" !5����6��Y�"� *� . [*Q� �� S15Q� 5]\! \#)]� p�&�#7A� !eM �_G ��2�� [�%. X��� � *-;#�7-" 8'�" 3Q� ��Q, *Q� 3Q�.�B . QT ���G�Q"�!& ���� 315Q�8 8
���# d ��&S �����8 11 ���# ��S&d � ��T)M1 ���# ��S&d 0��G !*�. eM FQ, �315Q� ����G�Q" �*Q� 3)-T� '� 315� ��-�G� �� 3:_)� ��\r��I.�B ���c �!0��G �'� 3� 30#� �� I&�T �� �S2: 3)TM =-Q�' 8*Q)� *Q� 3Q-T� K4Q/A .
K�� ��3$�$" F-$?� *)&��. ��!5�� '� eM �S�&�:� P-Y$� �� ��E������M �'� g����"� � !0�'�TD =-Q�' F-Q���M !Q�4/A 3<#>3� I"� *�D .3:5� � !��&'�� 8��� [*� !0��G s&�� 8*)� '� 3Q:_)� K4Q/A �Q_G ���D�Q� �� 6��Y�Q"� ��#Q� 8�QE
*� 6��Y�"� �M�, 8���D l&�< . s&��3� I"� !Q� ��Q2 6*�D [*Q� 3Q, *QE� S15Q� \ 8�QM�, l&�Q< �Q� !\#)Q]� !5Q]90/0 K����,� 8��*� F-$?� [*� 3� I5�3$�$" �� !5����S-T� S2: K4/A �_G 8�ES<#> CD�� ��2A�I"� .
')�* +��, +�-: S<#> ���2A� CD��=-�' �K4/Ap��-" ��\r�� �!&�-.��/0 S15Q� �!\#)Q]� !5Q]\ *Q)&��.
F-$?�3$�$" !5����.
* [#t�� 6*)�&# Email: [email protected]
226 ������� �� / ���2 ���� � 2 �������� 1394
����
=-�' K4/A !1& '�*)&��.8�E .�#�#;@!1- $n�! `j���LB�- pQ2U �Q� $��Q1� '�*Q�! P��Q)� ��
���E#,! I"� 3,l5" ��#>u 3%0�. 8��� I"� 6*�]28[. �! � =Q& *Q)&��.� ��#Q� � v�QG
?_"�! �-`jQ� I?� 8��Q- K��Q� ���QB �QE8 *Q��*& � CD '� v�QG �*Q� b�5Q�� �3QA4A'
A�%.I- 8�E ���! ��� *)��l& �#M B!E�- $�\ ���- ?n�w- "*)T�! ���c!� *�-B 3� �
F1� �E8 �M 3� V$���=-& I"� �0 3)�����& �! ��& Q)* . ���Q&� �#Q2, 3Q� FQ-A� ��Q�W& ��QG
CD �#E��!& .!.��B#&4- /� ��-- ����,8 6�#� ��,�> F12� �� 6��#�E �8 3� 30#� � I"� 30�#�
�=& ��*?�I& 5�!%-� ���<8 � �^ 3�! *"�]16[. ���"� ���"�A 4- � 3� 30#� ��!Bo& 8�QE
�' b#)��=- !"�)� ^�- m)" "�)��! �'=- �IG�" 6'�A G 84Q- ��Q� �W& CD ��QG � �#QE�!&
���� P��)� 3$�0'�8 ���MF- I"� K4/A .!&#" '� �� �� =�.�B ���c8 3A4A' *)���, G4- Q xAD
E��-A��- d C��)� �+�B�' y�4� F�B �#5\3& 8�E 1ED I�"! d �3& 8�E I�" ���! � Q!$-
��[�& *c��e& 8�E � �"��" �� y�4�=& ��� ���"�W& *\���8 ��� ��8 �M� 8��*Q& Q�� �QE8
B�4�! 3)��� '� �E8 5�!%- 3� I"� 6���D �#0� ]8[. ���W& .��B#M#�! Q�' �=- !Q"�)� Q:_)�S
P-:?� )S<#> ��2A� CD�� (3� 3#B �8 6�#� � ��%_c K4/A 3, I"� �E8 �� �� v�QG � m)Q"
:�+�- T� y�4� �� kU#,�- I"� 6��, .�E� 3� 30#� ��I- *M*& �'=- K4/A Q����. ��%A�_�!
�$\ �#�� ��! � � ��T0���& 9�(� 3�.�B I"� .'� 3Q$�0 3Q� �Q� ����Q1�E � mQ#�, B��Q,8�-
K�� �E8 �'� E�! "�)���, ���! '�.8 315� � �E8 5]\! \#)]��! � �`a� F��#\ K4/A �
�'=- �'� �� E�! ��,* �� �*)�.�& ��:� '� �B� 3,�& +r, �� �ES15� 5Q]\! ��#Q� 6��Y�Q"�
�=& ��T� 315�=& ��s& ���D *E�#G ��� 3� �� ]30[. zA���#- ����1�E � ��T�-S 2:S 3)TM 8*Q)�
�'=- K4/A '� 6��Y�"� ��S15� 5]\! \#)]�! A�D �4- �B!7��- � 3�=& � 3Q(- Q"�*-* 3Q,
K��S15� 5]\! \#)]�!� !��� l"�)� 8���3)TM �' 8*)�=- K4Q/A IQ"� ]36[ . '�Q�$& ��
3%A�_� �8 ��S�&�:� K�� �E8 ����. I5�!"�B� ��#- ��(Ak- �S15� 5Q]\! \#)Q]�! ��
'��!��& �' �_G=- K4/A ,�� ��, �T� ��3- � 3Q� =Q& � 3Q(- Q"�*- [*Q� 3Q, S15Q� 5Q]\!
\#)]�! �� 3� I5�� K���7& n '�I? �8��2- I"� ����#G�� ]38[. �0�#�-I- 6��Y�"� ��
K�� '�S15� 5]\! \#)]�! �_G=-�' K4/A ��:_)�S 4A�� �#7r"8 '�� ��!��& ��, ]25[.
���.! � �*:\ ����1�E ���8 3)TM *)�8 �' �� �_G=- K�� '� S15Q� 5Q]\! \#)Q]�! �Q�
���f"�M ���G�"� d*)U3& �#7A� �p�& 8�-B��& eM 6��Y�"� �_G ��2�� *Q��,]11[. Q%,��! �
'�� 3� ����1�E!��& " �����,p��- S15� 5]\! \#)]�! 3)TM �� �' 8*)�=- K4/A �� Q:_)�S
S�&�:� [*�S15� �� !\#)]� !5]\*)&��. F-$?�3$�$" �� !5���� ... 227
Y"3$B��*- *)�G���M ��)�" ���"� �� ]2[ .����8 "��� 3� ����1�E �! ���Q,!& S15Q� 5Q]\!
\#)]�! 3)TM 8��� �' �_G 8*)�=- K4Q/A Q2�� ��! '� SQ<#> ��D 4Q& *Q)�G���M '��QE ]20[.
�#"8 ����1�E � '� 6��Y�"� ��S15� 5]\! \#)]�!� �' �_G=- K4/A ��S<#> ��D4& @# ��Q&
3)TM �� *��, 8*)�]8[. .|- 3A� A�"� �� �#MS ��,�8 3� �#G 3)TM �#^)� *)�8 *%�Q�� P��Q)�
�� K4/A�G���S B8#- �U8 [*� '�S15� 5Q]\! #)Q]�8 ��Y�Q"� 6 ��Q,]12[. |-Q. � �Q-
����1�E ]13[� ����1�E � �.���]9[� !0�]22[� 8*�?�]19[� !B�)-� ����1�E �]24[� �d
����1�E �]32[� 9�,]15[� ����1�E � 8*�>�]1[� 8*�?� ]19[� �k�#, ����Q1�E �]31[
'�*)&��. F-$?� 3$�$" 8��� !5���� 3)TM 8*)� �Q_G =-Q�' K4Q/A 6��Y�Q"� �, *Q�. 3Q, �Q(D'�
M- �-)! �' ��*G� ��1� � ���'-= K4/A Q$%. �� ��#� '�! IQ"� g��QG �Q2�� � 8��Q� Q-��
"��>-I 3)��� 3)TM 3� �E �' �_G 8*)�-= K4/A � V$��� P��)� ��! *'���M .3)TM �� 8*Q)� �
�_G �'-= K4/A �' w_"-= >�# 3�! �4(�!& �� �� p, �_G V$��� ��0�� '�-�� '&�� �:�-p
�! �#� ]9[ .S-T� 32: 8�E3)TM *)�=-�' 8 ��Q1� C���� 8��� ��"*)T� � ��>��� 3� �K4/A
l"�)�3� �#^)� }�� 8��0� !QB�4� kQ�, 3%"#� 8�E !Q� *Q), =Q&� s&�Q� � ��Q%A�_� 3Q#B
!� 3� *�#� 3&�M ��\r�� ��#)\ 8� 8���3���� � I&�&*� 3� k�, 6��Y�Q"� !Q_-?� 84&� �#Q�
]37[ .EZ* �=& E�oM� S�&�:� [*�S15� �� !\#)]� !5]\*)&��. F-$?�3$�$" �� !Q5����
=-�' �_G !��&'�� K4/A ��S<#> ��2A� CD��I"�. '� eMS-T� S2: =-Q�' �Q_G �Q� K4Q/A
[*� '� 6��Y�"� 8�ES15� � !\#)]� !5]\*)&��. F-$?�3$�$" !5����� WQ"#� [*Q� �� =&�
��D l&�<3�&�:� �M�, 8� **�. [*�S15� 8�QM�, l&�< �� !\#)]� !5]\90 [*Q� *Qn��
8��*����, 8���3)TM =-�' �_G 8*)� �� K4/AP-:?� S:_)� *� !.�%�.
�!��� /����
S<#> CD�� ;40 ��2A�! � C#�?� ��2A� ���"�T� '�! �#Q� I>�Q�� �Q� 3Q,803 , ���#Q$-
X���9�G C�~ [��� ����"�A ���"� [��� �� � �Q~ ����D [#Q� �� *Q��T C#Q)0 � ��Q0��� C
.��/0!&�- 48 � 30��3 � 3:-c�6 �� 3-�`48 � 30��31 � 3:-c�13 SQ-�` !c�Q� ��Q\ �
.��/0!&�- 33 � 30��44 � 3:-c�24 3-�` ��34 � 3Q0��3 � 3Q0��15 SQ-�` !A��Q� ���Qc
�B3�. I"� ) F1�1 S<#> � ����#G�� !\#)�� 8@#A#�-A '� ��2A� CD�� 3Q, FQ��\ =Q&� � IQ"
pT� '� !1& =-�' ��(&� �� �`a� F��#\ =&�� �IQ"� K4/A �-`jQ� !&�4Q�� �� 3Q)TM 8*Q)� ���� . '�
!� 3:_)� pT� ��\�Y��� 6#, 3� ��#� �E8 G �=&�B� � fQ"� �C�)�#B 6��Q�� C�QT� ��Q, 3Q,
��#�E�8 8�E !� F-12� �� 3:_)� lA�~ *)E�.
228 ������� �� / ���2 ���� � 2 �������� 1394
��1. 2�34���5�6 �78&� 9:*�;�7��& ;�7�� * ;���� ��
#*� �����
� ��=& E�oM 32: '� �E8 .��B#M#�! :�+�- 1:50000 �#c�! .��/0 ���'�" ��Q- !&�Q- 8�QE
�w$�� ��]� �&*)()" ETM 6��#E�� �8 I"*)A8 �LQB166 �� VQ& 36 �37 3Q� h#Q���15
=;�@20136��� � �E8 $c� 3� h#���p- '� 3:_)� K��Q� � ��� 3$�0 � 3Q, !Q"�)��#E ���'�Q" '
���"� *� 3-T� ���"�A �DEM 30 ���8 SRTM �#$��32: � �E8 �'=- !Q"�)� :� 3Q� +�Q-
1:100000 ���'�" �'=- �!"�)� 6��Y�"�*� .)z�E=- 9� �E��4.�8 ArcGIS 10.2 8��� ���(&
�M6�7& $?� �6���F- 8�E �1�!- ��.!& �T �� �I& M6��- �[*� ���,ENVI 4.8 8��Q� QM K'���
��]��& 6��#E�� �8 �MATLAB 2011 3� �#^)� >���! [*�S15� 5]\! 6��Y�"�*�. =Q&� ��
8��� E�oM3)TM *)�=-�' �_G 8 K4/AI2E �!\�QY��� ��Q:5� �l-Q� IQT0 �l-Q� F��\
8����, m)" �!<��� �!"�)�S$n�. �F�B 3$n�. !"��� K��� � 3E���D '�*� .S2: F��#\ =&�
� 6��Y�"� ��9� ' ��4.�ArcGIS 3Q)TM 8��� � 3-T� �� 8*Q)� S15Q� !\#)Q]� !5Q]\ �� *Q)&��.
F-$?�3$�$" !5���� *� 6��Y�"�. 3%A�_� =&� 3� I.�-E� IT0 � !"��� 3� �*���%A�_� S P��#Q"
�#0#� !�$\� 8��� =--%�-$,S � �E��-%�F��#\ �a �`=-�' b#c� �� 3Q�G���M K4Q/A !Q� �#Q� .
ef"#0#� ��\r��32: F��� � 6��#E�� �&��]� � �E 8��D��QB '�Q- ��#� 8�� � '� eQMT� SQ-
32: ?]� ��E��?- �� �� 9'd8 32: ��Q]� � �E�& 6��#E�Q� �8 ��#Qn IQ.�B . 15Q� [*Q� ��S
S�&�:� [*�S15� �� !\#)]� !5]\*)&��. F-$?�3$�$" �� !5���� ... 229
5]\! 3� �#^)� 315� K'#�D� 3&d 8�ET�3-��*%� �� 6���E �6*�8 3#� '� �QE8 Q%c��! Q�'=-
K4/A �E8 ��Y��� �6���.�3���� ��#)\8 315� ����**� � �� �=& #7A� K��8 Q�=- �QE������M8
����8 )����8 315� (:��)� �! �' 3,=- ���� �#Q0� K4/A) Q0��G! 315Q� ( 315Q� WQ"#�
K'#QQ�D6��� *QQ� .efQQ" 8���� 8�QQE������M 8�'� 3QQ�SQQ<#> 3QQ� �QQ^ ��#QQ�S15QQ� !5QQ]\
K'#�D -�' *%��� P��)� ���E 3, ���)�� !0��G �6*&�= -M I"� K4/A !Q)-� *Q� . 8��Q�
315� 8���� e&���� F-12� �*��� !5]\ 8�E*)U 3� 3_: '� p^)� ��#n SQ<#> �Q^ ��#Q�
9��� �� � C����3&d ��EX_c *� 6��� g����"� �TD K'�� �*�. 3���� �� 3� l5" ���' ��#Q� ��
��#� =-7)" �*)&��. '#�DK3#� '� 8��*%� � � �E3 ��]� ��#n!.� 3� �#^)� K'#Q�D � ��Q(&�
315�3#� !���� 8��� � !0����"� 8�E C����**� .8��� Z*QE e&���� F-12�) !Q0��G
C#$_� (3#� 3� =-�' '� !%c�� 8�E K4/A '�-I"� . 3� 9�*c� �#^)� =&*�3#� !�*Q-� 8�����
��GPS =-�' '� K4/A 3<#> �� �#0#� 8�E*� ��D '� 8��*%� '� 6�B 3#� =&� �E 8��� !��&'��
-M '� Fn�> s&�� 8��*%� � [*� !)-�8��� 6��Y�Q"� Z*QE e&���Q� F-1Q2� *Q� . '� eQM
6���D Z*E e&���� � 8���� e&���� 8'�"��\r�� =&� � 9� ���� IQ� ��4Q.� � *Q� lQA S15Q�
!>��� !5]\*� -M �315� K'#�D '� eM � 3-5� � !)-� ��#n 9'd 8'�"I.�B.
<�� ����=>� +�-'��?7�� '�
����� @��
=-�' ��(&� !$n� F��#\ '� l-� K�� ��2-� � I"� V$��� P��)� �� K4/A �E�� ������QM =Q&�
*��� *-,j� .3� -M ��#)\ l-� �� ��. '� ���, 8�E5 *E�#� ��Y�� K4/A 30�� ��Q�.� ]27[.
8��� S-T� S2: � 3:_)� !�#c� !\�Y��� [*� '� l-�!� 6��Y�" �#� .S2: 8��� l-� SQ:_)�
P-:?� -M 3#B�E '� 8�-B#$0 8��� 8���� ��6 +rQ,5-0 �15-5 �25-15 �35-25 �45-
35 � � ��2- '�45 *� 3-T� 30��) F1�2.(
��� ��!�� �����
=-�' '� 8��-�� �� K4/A �E� !1& �-B�� wA�]� b# FQ��#\ '� K4Q/A b#Qc� �� !$Qn� IQ"� �
��2-� �K� 3)TM 8�E 3�.�B �^ �� 8#? 3� �� F��\ =&� 8*)� *� .���)� !"��� 8�E9�(� 3Q�.�B
S<#> '� ��2A� CD�� m)" FQ��\ =Q&� 3Q, IQ"� ����#G�� !\#)�� !"�)� �-`jQ� �� !&�4Q��
K4/A ���� 3:_)� 8�E .*'�" �� m)" 8��> 8�E !Q1ED � !��Q� 8�E 3Q� FQ-A� �� I-Q"��>
I-"��> I�#�� F��:� I"� ��2-� K4/A 3� I5�]8[ ) F1�3.(
230 ������� �� / ���2 ���� � 2 �������� 1394
��2 .�8�B @��/���� ��!��
��3 .�8�B ��� �����/���� ��!��
S�&�:� [*�S15� �� !\#)]� !5]\*)&��. F-$?�3$�$" �� !5���� ... 231
�5��� +� ��,
%A�_�S !Q���\ � !�%)n �8'���2, Z��]� �� �D �����, b# � =-�' 8�� !E�-B �#M b#
3)��� K4/A !"��� �� pT� ��-�� �EI"� .30#� �� 3� �#M !E�-B � b# �8����, =-Q�' 8�QE
S<#> 3� ��2A� CD��9 +r, p-�:� **� 3, 5�8�) �D !��%A�_� �#� 3Q, �� X��Q)� ���'�Q"
I"� 3�.�B 9�(� ���"�A ���"� !%-5�) F1�4.(
���?��� D���>
!G�� '� ::?��� �� b�Y��� k& F��\ !A��), �� b#c� =-�' K4/A !��^ �� �E *�-B]38[ . F��\
�6*���& IT0 3E���D �E � ��4-� p,��� 15�S !21E' �� [��), !� *), � �� 4-�v�G I�#�� ��
� l-� 3)��� �E �-`j� 8�-7�2U ����]29[. 8���S-T� S2: '� !\�Y��� ��:5� !\�QY��� [*Q�
!�#c�P-:?� S:_)� 6��Y�"� � � �� !\�Y��� ��:55 *� 3-T� +r, ) F1�5.(
����� @�� 2EF
l-� IT0��2 *)E� IQT0 �� K��Q� � kQ2G � 9�QB 8�E��� �C��.D �# ���Y�� �-`j� QE 8�
V$��� I"�]31[ .3� �<�> E�oM �� =&����)� ��Q2 �#^)� � l-Q� IQT0 =-Q� h�Q5��� ����
K4/A �Ei� 8 �6���S2: 8��� l-� IT0:_)�S P-:?� 3�9 ���Q� ���Q� [��� �[��� +r,
w_�� P��)� � C�~ [��� �C�~ �C�~ C#)0 �C#)0 ���� C#)03:5� *)� *� 8) F1�6.(
� �4. �8�B +� ��, �5��� /���� ��!��
232 ������� �� / ���2 ���� � 2 �������� 1394
��5. �8�B D���> ���?��� /���� ��!��
��6. �8�B 2EF ��@ /���� ��!��
S�&�:� [*�S15� �� !\#)]� !5]\*)&��. F-$?�3$�$" �� !5���� ... 233
��7. �8�B �-�� : � ��K��/���� ��!��
��K���-�� : �
8��� S-T� S2: �3E���D '� 3$n�.S15� 8�� '� 3E���D SQ2: W-Q?� �� � ��Q2� !.��B#QM#�
9� ��4.�ArcGIS *� !�#c� .�D 6�BS2: 3� 3E���D '� 3$n�.5 FQn�#. �� +r,100-0 �200-
100 �300-200 �400-300 '� ��2-� �400 p-�:� ��� *� =-Q� h�Q5��� ���� ��Q2 8��� �
=-�' �_G 3E���D '� 3$n�. � K4/A3� ��, 6��� *� ) F1�7.(
F�B '� 3$n�. :!B*���G � !��� �*� �� P��)� �!$�B �#Y CD '� =&� P��)� FQG�� 3�
3)��� ��E '��� !7�"#-M� �� Z���� F�B �E � &�"�. Zr�G� �� 3)��� �E '� 3$�0 �`�&�E! I"�
!� 3, ��#� 3� �TD 6���� ��, ]8[ .=&�'� �� 8���S-T� FQ�B IQ�� FQ�B '� 3$Qn�. S2: 8�QE
:_)�S P-:?� '� 6��Y�"� ��S2: =-�' 3$Qn�. efQ" �*� !�#c� !"�)� '� �QE 3Q� FQ�B s)QM
Fn�#. �� +r,1500-0 �3000-1500 �4500-3000 �6000-4500 '� ��2-� �6000 �Q��
3:5� *)�8 *�) F1�8.(
#��
��%A�_�S CD �n�)\ � 3� K��� �!&�#E �`aQ� !$Qn� �Qn�)\ '� !1& ��#)\ !Q��-� kQ-��)&� �Q�
I"� 6*� 3%A�_� .3� !B*��� l5" d�� ���� w_" !����&� CD 8�E 3, �!)-�'�&' �#G lQ0#�
234 ������� �� / ���2 ���� � 2 �������� 1394
&�4.� ��2. !1-���"� ��2. � CD 6�Y> �� 8� wA�]� 3)��� �E !� ��#��-`j� !&�4Q�� �� K4Q/A
���� ]20[ . &�4Q.� �� K4/A b#c� F-���M �#G v�G !����:� 8�E������M E�, !Q� *Q)E� .
�(D'� K��� !���E#, P��)� �� 3,3� �*Q� !Q� �-`jQ� b�QY��� '� ���&LQM =Q&�'� �� �� SQ:_)�
P-:?� 4- �3 I$\ ��*%� �#5�, � ��#� !���E#, �6�7��& 8�E ����� !()"� 3_��� 8� =-� b�Y���
� ��*:� !B*��� �� 6�7��&� �#0#� 8�E 3� I"� *�D 3, �� 6��Y�"� '� =&� ��3_� S2: pQE K��Q�
S<#> ��2A� CD�� 3Q-T� *Q�. 8��Q� 3Q� IQ"� 6��� �*Q��� 3Q_��� =Q&� ����D 3Q� h#Q��� 8�QE
6�7��&� 8�E����� !()"P-:?� S:_)� � 6�7��&� b�Y��� F��� ��*:� !B*���6'�*� 8�Q-B 6*Q�
*� 3-T� 6�7��&� �� . �� �#0#� X��#� '� 6��Y�"� �� ef"9� ��4Q.� FQ�,� SQ_��� Q� � K��Q� =-
*� 35"�?� 3:_)� =&� �� b�Y��� ) S_���1(.
)1( / * /p h= +0 1183 309 62
� 3_��� =&� �� ��*:� !B*���l�>�� �!$- ���� � h b�Y��� '� w_Q" �Q&�� �Q� �Q�� lQ�>
I"�. '� eMS-T� S2: pE �K��� =&� �� 32:5 3�"�3:5� *� 8*)� ) F1�9.(
��8. �8�B ��M � ��K�� /���� ��!��
S�&�:� [*�S15� �� !\#)]� !5]\*)&��. F-$?�3$�$" �� !5���� ... 235
��9. �8�B #�� /���� ��!��
=-�' b#c� �� ��LB�-`j� F��#\ h�5��� !"��� 8��� �� K4/AS<#> '� *%� ��2A� CD��S-T�
S2: 3Q� I5Q� h�Q: =Q&� !B*Q),��M �!Q�4/A h�Q: ),��M IQ2E �`aQ� FQ��\ b#Qc� ��
=-�' 9� W-?� �� K4/A ��4.�ArcGIS !"���*� ) [�*01.(
3� �#^)� 315� 315� ��%�� �3:_)� 8*)� '� �E30 �� ���300 *� 6��� �--/� ���. 3� 30#� ��
��*:� 3<#> ��%��100 *� 6��� �-�2� l"�)� ��� .=&�'� �� 3Q� ��Q\r�� =Q&� 3Q&L/� 8��Q�
S15� :_)� �!\#)]� !5]\S P-:?� 3�80378 p-�:� F�1-M *� �QE '� F�1-M �E � SQ&d
S2: Q\r�� �� 3Q2: �D 3Q� h#Q��� ������ ��� �T 8���� FQ�1-M �QE IQ& IQ2E Q]�2�S
3&d 3� h#��� !��\r�� 8�E`j�=-�' �� ��LB�- !� K4/A �#�. � F��#\ C���� '� eM32: �E 8
!�#c� 6*� �TD 8��� ��\r�� 8�" ���E 9�*, F��#\ =&� '� 8��Q� p�Q�-" �� FQ-$?� S15Q�
!5]\3� ��, *� 3�.�B .
236
�
������ ��
/ ���
2 ���� � 2
�����
���
1394
�*
F1.
�� ��
$%& O��B � #
$%& � �PQ� ����� �
� O����� �
���
�5�6
�78
&� 9:*�
@��
2
EF
@��
+
)�&�7�&
+� ��,
�5
���
#��
� ��K
��
��
M
� ��K��
�-�� :
D���>
���?���
+r,
*n��
K4/A
+r,
*n��
K4/A
r,+
*n��
K4/A
+r,
*n��
K4/A
+r,
*n��
K4/A
+r,
*n��
K4/A
+r,
*n��
K4/A
+r,
*n��
K4/A
5-0
0
5/22-0
86/12
K1aml
0
I\��' !�D
0
521 -481
62/17
1500-0
71/55
100 -0
76/54
1791-1456
95/20
15-5
28/4
5/67-5/22
10
Qt2
57/8
X���� C#G
0
559 -521
05/19
3000-1500
28/14
200 -100
43/11
2117-1791
42/21
25-15
86/2
5/112-5/67
57/18
OMml
0
F7)0 �� g��
�#M p,
38/12
603-559
57/18
4500-3000
38/12
300 -200
50/9
2488-2117
05/19
35-25
60
5/157-5/112
71/5
OMl
0
I\��' p&�
90/41
656-603
05/19
6000-4500
10
400 -300
38/12
2935-2488
19/26
45-35
57/18
5/202-5/157
10
JKbs
0
X��� �� g��
�#M W"#��
86/22
738 -656
71/25
6000>
62/7
400>
90/11
3627-2935
38/12
45>
28/14
5/247-5/202
71/5
JKr
0
32-� ��' �
3�#� ��'
14/7
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
- -
-
5/292-5/247
14/17
K1bs
0
F7)0 �� g��
�#M W"#��
28/14
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
5/337-5/292
14/7
E2c
19/6
X��� �� g��
�#M �-:.
43/1
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
360-5/337
38/12
Ma
43/31
��*?� �T�
0
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Plc
67/6
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Plb
71/5
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
--
-
-
-
-
-
Mf
43/41
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
S�&�:� [*�S15� �� !\#)]� !5]\*)&��. F-$?�3$�$" �� !5���� ... 237
�8�B ��$%& O��B
�&��]� '� 6��Y�"� ��6��#E�� �K4/A �3:_)� 8 8�E��Y�� 3Q� v#1Q2� � *%�Q�� P��)� � 6���.�
**� !&�"�)� 3:_)� �� K4/A .�(D'� 3, K4/A '� 8��-�� 3� �E 8�E�Q� �Q& pQ, ��Q%�� FQ-A�
3)��� �� 3��2� �&��]� �� ����(� 8�E6��#E�� � 8F��c �2�*)��- �-� 8��Q� ���Q\r�� FQ-�1�
K4/A !���� 8�E �� +��"� F, �� � I.�B ���c !&��?n *&�'�� ��#�70 �� !Q�4/A F�1-M
:_)�S P-:?� *� 6��� �-�2�)F1�10.( S2: !�4/A �-~ h�:: P��)� �-~ !:��)� !�4/A
�� K4/A �_G [���>� 3, *)��E�TD !� 3�.�B �^ �� p, !$-G �#� . FQG�� �� P��Q)� =&�
�l- '� ���, 8�E5 FG�� �� � 30��3E���D �^ �� �E !� 3�.�B *#� ]27[ )F1�10.(
"��> �G�� =--%� 8���I- =-�' 3Q:5� '� k& �E K4/A [*Q� '� �VQ$��� FQ��#\ 8�QE
!$-G �D s&�� � 6��" �D �����, ��&' *� 6��Y�"� !����. I5� !A���>���)-��� �� IQ"�
]33[ . �*��� �#^)� =&*��� � 35"�?� !����. I5� �TI& �� K4/A �_G 3� I-"��> �G��
_��� +�"�S 3 *� 35"�?�. b#Qc� �Q� �`a� F��#\ ��:5� '� k& �E !����. I5� =--%� 8���
=-�' '� �K4/A _���S 2 *� 6��Y�"�.
)2( �� =!�4/A8�EF�1-M*n��
!�4/A�-~8�EF�1-M*n��
)3( LSI Fr=∑
LSI :=-�' �_G 3� I-"��> �G�� 3:5� �E �� K4/A
Fr :=-�' b#c� !����. I5� 3:5� �E �� K4/A
8��� T��F- ��7�E �� !&S15� !\#)]� !5]\ 315� I\�" E�, 9*\ �� h#��� �&��:�
3����# *� 64-A��� 8���� 8�E* .6��� ���, 64-A��� 8��� �� �E����S 3��# 6*� Q_��� '�S 4
6��Y�"� *�.
)4( ( )
(min)
(min)max
i ii
ii
z zx
z z−
−=
zi F�1-M �'� �� �������#� �^ �zi(min) FQ��\ �'� =&�Q��, �� ����� ��#Q� �Q^ �zi(max)
F��\ �'� =&��2-� �� ����� ��#� �^ �xi [��� �'� �� ����� 6*� F��\��#� �Q^ IQ"�. S15Q�
)]� !5]\'�" k& !\# 5Q"�?� � ��\r�� =�.�B �� I"� ���c 3, I"� !��5"�?� ��,�S �QTD �
*E� 3;��� �� *&*0 ��\r�� 8�" k& ]33[.
2 ���� � 2 �������� 1394
# ���R '��, ]11[
������� �� / ���2
��10. �8�B ��$%&��T * ��$%& O��B U�,��R
�� 11. ��7"�� �,� �V ��� ���� <�(�� � �-6�*+ # ���R
238
��
S�&�:� [*�S15� �� !\#)]� !5]\*)&��. F-$?�3$�$" �� !5���� ... 239
�� =&�E�oM '�S15� 3&d*)U ����f"�M ���G�" �� !\#)]� !5]\3� F-A� �Q�T� !&���,
b�#� �7&� 3� I5�S15� !\#)]� !5]\] 17[ �� eM 8�-B��& p�&�#7A� 6��Y�Q"� �Q_G ��2��
*Q� . ���G�Q" �� S15Q� -Q�c PQ5� �#QU *Q� 6��Y�Q"� 3Q&d 3Q" '� 4Q- !\#)Q]� !5Q]\S
� 8��� 3&d 3" �Z��#B#�A#, '� 6��Y�Q"� 3Q� 8'�Q- 4QB�E � I"� l"�)� !&��. b# �E k-1Y
3&d ��2-� 8�EI�- ]21[. =-)z�E8��� Ic� ��4-� ���D��S15� !\#)]� !5]\ '� ��L(�
�_G ��%��� =-7�-�)RMSE (3� I"� 6*� 6��Y�"� !�, �G�� k& ��#)\.
)5( ( )n
iobs pre
RMSEn
=−
= ∑2
1
obs 6*E�2� �&��:� � 8�pre �&��:�-M !)-� 6*� �N 6��� F, ��*%� '� 3Q$>�� �QE �� �QE
�#�'D I"� &��'D � K'#�D 8�E. '�~ X��� !Q_G�- *-;#�7-Q" 3Q� FQ-A� P�Q2� ���#Q� �&LQM
�Q� !Q)�5� 8�QE��, ��Q2-� �� �D �����Q, � !B��" S15Q� !\#)Q]� !5Q]\ 3Q� � X��Q� ��#Q)\
[�%. '�"8 6��Y�"�*�.
)6( ƒ( )pipi netnet
e−=
+1
1
���=& E�oM �< '�l& 8�-B��& 6��"3� "� � �*2 ��7�E I$\�*- �_G 3�8 F��c [#5c
Z�n *� �^ .)z�E=- ���4- �_G8 �Q<l& 8�-B��Q& /�� �Q- �:� �� 3Q�& y�5#QA K�� �Q�-
� ���#,�����2- �#�. �E 3�=- A�F- y�5#A K�� '�- ���#,��� *� 6��Y�"�. 30#� �� ��*Q%� 3Q�
������M ��*%� 8���� 8�E���# ��S&d ��*Q%� � I"� ���Y�� 8���� ���#Q 3Q� 4Q- !Q0��G
���� !7��� P-:?� Z*E ]34[ . =&� ��E�oM I2E 3� F��\ ������M ��#)\ kQ& � 8���� 8�E
���# 3� 4- I"� 6*� 3�.�B �^�� 315� !0��G ��#)\ .K�� Q��. � �E[# 8��Q� 8��Q&' 8�QE
=--%� ��*%����# ��S&d ���� �#0� ��T)M� l"�)� '� !1& !A� K�� =&�� =&�Q��, 8��Q� �QE
I"�_G � !%" K�� ��_G ��*:�]2[. ���8 B#$08�- M 3#B�E '�- 8���� Z�Q]� � FQG� �
�� ��s& S15� 5]\�! ���8 ��'D � K'#�D& 3� 315� .��Q]� �#�! ��Q�� �8 ��� Q�4/A! �
~�- !�4/A '� � C����80 � *n��=& 6��� ��� �E8 � K'#�D20 ��Q� *n��8 Q�'D&� 6��Y�Q"�
*� .���8 .��]� C����! �=& 6��� 9� '� �E ���D ��4.�8 SPSS 6��Y�"�8��� � *� %�=-- I5Q�
����1� ��*%� � 8�-B��& 8��� �"�!��- ���, 3�=& %" K�� '� �_G ��*:�! 6��Y�"� �_G � *Q�.
315� 3� 6��� ���� '� *%�� 3&d 3� �E �'� !.��Q]� ��#n !Q� !QE� �� � *#Q� Q$>��S K'#Q�D
8*&*0 �'� 8���� F��\ �E ��2� W���� +�"���*� *E�#G �'� =&� 3, -M 8��� �E !Q)-�
F�1-M �7&� �� �_G ��4-� 6��Y�"� �E!� �#�]7[ . ��*)&��. F-$?�3$�$" !5���� 3Q� 30#� ��
240 ������� �� / ���2 ���� � 2 �������� 1394
�^!"�)���, ���� �*���e& S�&�:� Q0�'! FQ��#\ ��LQB�-`j� F-1Q2� *Q� . F-1Q2� '� eQM
k� 8��� �^ ��#� e&���� 3�Q�# �D �Q&' �� �#�Q" �QE X�0 F��#\ k� �*Q� 8��Q� efQ"
5"�?�S �#�" F, X�0 3� e&���� '� �])\ �E �&��:� F��\ �E �'� � p-Q�:� 3Q&d ���E 8�E
!� 3��# 8�7&� [�*0 �� �#�. � =-7�Q-� �E�_" '� 9�*, �E �� �#0#� ��*\� '� [�*0 =&� �
�*\ =&� � 3�.�B3� !� 3�.�B �^ �� 3&d �E �'� ��#)\ �#Q� . '� 9�*Q, �QE �'� 3Q1)&� '� *Q%�
3&d �E3� �� *�D I"�$>��S *%�*&�� '� 9�*, �E i���:5� ��2� �� V$��� F��#\��, . ��
'� 6��Y�"� �� I&�T_��� S7 :S2 3)TM !&�T =-�' 8*)� K4/A3� I"� !� *&D.
)7( M x x x xα α α α= + + + +…1 1 2 2 3 3 4 4
��_���S 7 �M �I-"��> F��\X � V$��� F��#\ 3� h#��� �#�,�.α �&��Q:� 3Q� h#Q���
3&d ��:5� '� 9�*, �E !'� V$��� 8�EI"� .
�*F2 . +�� D���F�� ������������ ����� �F* ]14[
D���F�� ���� +��
�r��, �& pT� �r��,C#$_� �� 9
8#c !$-G I-�E� 7
8#c I-�#$_� �& I-�E� 5
!�,C#$_� !�, �& ��pT� �� 3
���1& I-�#$_� �& I-�E� 1
Fn�#. =-� I&#A�� 2 �4 �6 �8
������ 2��B +��M ��1
8��,�'�" ����c �� 8��B'�" !"��� 8��� !�\�" 3, �� �E �I"� 3�.�B �^ 5Q"�?�S !5&�Q<
3� 9�8��B'�" I5� I"� FQn�> ��#Q� !.��Q]� �G�Q� 3Q� 8��B'�" �G�� p-�:� '� 3,
!� �#� .kU#, l&�< =&� 3z�)U 8���� �& ��1/0 ����c �� 8��B'�" �*��� [#Q5c ��#Q� �E
�I"���#n =&� �-~ �� ����c �� *&�� �#� �^ *&*(� �E. 8���5"�?�S B'�Q" i� �*Q��� �8��
e&���� *&��S�&�:� C�< �'� ����� �� !0�'�#� �'� '� !5"�)� =-��� �� �E3� IQ"� *Q&D .
�&��:� ef"3� I"� �'� �� �� 6*�D p-Q�:� h#��� 8�E !Q� p-Q), !B*Q)&�M ����Q� �&��Q:� �Q�
1.Consistency ratio
S�&�:� [*�S15� �� !\#)]� !5]\*)&��. F-$?�3$�$" �� !5���� ... 241
�#� 35"�?�. !Q� C��> �� !B*)&�M ����� �&��:� =-7�-� 3���� �� �Q� p-Q),λ 3Q� IQ"� *Q&D.
��*:�λ 3� I"� �� �� 6*�D_��� S8 8�0 !� 8��LB � �#Q� FQn�> 8��B'�Q" �G�Q� �Q� p-),
'� 6��Y�"� �� 4- 8��B'�" l&�<_���S 9 35"�?�!� #� � ��*:� �D �� 3,R.I [�*Q0 '� 4-2
!� g����"� �#� ]14[.
3:5� � !��&'�� 8��� [*� !0��G s&�� 8*)� l&�Q< '� K4/A �_G ���D�� �� 6��Y�"� ��#� 8�E
3#� '� 8��*%� �� 6���E �M�, 8���D =-�' !%c�� 8�E K4/A *� 6��Y�"� 3<#> �� �#0#� 8�E.
)8( λCIn
−= −11
)9( CICRRI
=
�*F3. ������ R.I W����� ������ +�- ]14[
9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 n
45/1 41/1 32/1 24/1 12/1 9/0 58/0 0 0 R.I
�*F4. '-�8� W����� U�R * +� ���
Negative Positive
b a Positive
d c Negative
:-M �� pE � 6*E�2� �� pE 3, *)��E !��: ��*%� � !)-�3 *)��E !�4/A h�: ��#)\.
b : �� 3Q, *)�Q�E !��: ��*%� *E�Q2� -QM �� � !Q�4/A h�Q: Q� !Q)-�3 h�Q: ��#Q)\
*)��E !�4/A�-~.
c : �� 3, *)��E !��: ��*%�*E�2� -QM �� � !Q�4/A�-~ h�: Q� !Q)-�3 Q)\ h�Q: ��#
*)��E !�4/A.
d :-M �� pE � 6*E�2� �� pE 3, *)��E !��: ��*%� Q� !)-�3 !Q�4/A�-~ h�Q: ��#Q)\
*)��E.
!� 35"�?� �&' W���� '� �� �M�, l&�< ��*:� p-),.
)10( Observed Agreement Expected Agreement
Expected AgreementKAPPA Coefficient
−= −1
242 ������� �� / ���2 ���� � 2 �������� 1394
)11( a d a b c d
observed Agreement += + + +
)12( ( ) ( )a c a b b d c d * *N N N N
Expected Agreement + + + += +
'� eM5"�?�S =-� �D ��*:� �B� �M�, l&�<0 �� 20 *��� *n�� -M � 6*E�2� =-� !)-�
=-� �M�, l&�< �B� ����* �#0� !:.�#�20 ��40 *��� *n�� �4-U� P.�#�� =-Q� �M�, l&�< �B�
40 ��60 *��� *n�� �W"#�� P.�#�� =-� �M�, l&�< �B�60 ��80 *��� *n�� � C#QG P.�#�� �
=-� �M�, l&�< �B�80 ��100 *��� *n�� �-M � 6*E�2� =-� P.�#� �#� *E�#G !A�\ !)-�.
X�
���8 ��'D � K'#�D& ��\r�� '� 315�140 MF�1- �4/A! ~ ��- !�4/A '� 3Q, *Q� 6��Y�"�
�=& ��*%�112 MF�1- ���8 � K'#�D28 MF�1- ���8 !()"��5�\� 315�3� ��Q, IQ"� 3Q�.� .
J"�M �E8 0��G! S15� 5]\! \#)]�! $>�� ��S ��'D�& !� ��2 *E� 3Q, S15Q� 5Q]\!
���(& 6*� � '� I"� ���c��- 14 MF�1- �4/A�! 13 3� �� ��#� �Q"��! 3Q, *QE� K��4QB =Q&�
��2 *)E� "��>I- �2��- 3� ��*:� 85/92 *Qn�� IQ"� . Q)z�E=- '� � ��Q- 14 M FQ�1-
~�!�4/A�- �2� 3� ���c 315��- 12 3#� '� ��#� �E8 ��'D!2& *� 3, =Q&� � �7�Q- � !QBo&
�2��- 3� ��*:� 71/85 *n��I"�. ����)�=& �Q� ����� 315� F, Ic�28/89 35Q"�?� *Qn��
*� . '� ���1� ��*%�1000 ��15000 /��-- *� 6���. ���1� ��*%� �� 3,10000 �Q��,=& Q:��*�
�_G*� 35"�?�. 3� �#��#7A� [#�%�p�& eM ��2�� I5� �� �_G8�-B��& �p, ��T�=& C�#Q0
� ��! *E� ]11[. � =�.�B �^�� ��31)& ��� p�)�� I5�8 �#Q7A�p�& eQM �Q_G ��Q2�� 3Q� �#Q�
[#�%� 9/0 �� � 3�.�B �^! �#� I5� �8�-B��& '�1/0 ��7/0 /��-- I5Q� �Q� 3, *� 6���
1/0 ��T�=& 3� C�#0 I"� *�D. ��*%����# �E 8S&d ��T)M �=- 3 ��35 /��-- 3Q, **Q� 6���
��11 ���# ��S&d ���, ��T)M=& �_G ��*:� *Q� FQn�> . =-Q)z�E '� kQ& ���#Q �� SQ&d
0��G! [�%. X��� 3� 30#� �� 3, *� 6��Y�"� 8'�" 3� ��, �� 3�.�S15� >���! 6*� �=- � �YQn
k& /��-� I"�. !&�T ���G�"S15� 1-11-8 !Q)%&8 ���#Q �� SQ&d �8����11 ���#Q ��
S&d � ��T)M1 ���# ��S&d 6��� �-�Q2� lQ"�)� !0��G *Q� ���G�Q" =Q&� +�Q"� �Q� �
3)TM I.�B ��#n !&�T 8*)�. 6��� ���� '� *%� 3Q� �QE S15Q� 5Q]\! \#)Q]��! SQ�E FQ��#\
3� .��]� ��#n! �=- 7/0- ��7/0 �'� E�! � **��D 6�B ��$>��S ���� FQ��\ �QE K'#�D8
*0 �'�&*8 *� 3,'� �&= �'� ��� �E8 M- �-)! � Q-��4 � �� �Q_G& �Q7 M- FQ�1 �QE 6��Y�Q"�
S�&�:� [*�S15� �� !\#)]� !5]\*)&��. F-$?�3$�$" �� !5���� ... 243
�! �#� .eM $n� ���G�" ���, ��2� '�! 15�S 5]\! ��#Q� ��Q\r�� ����D pE��. � '�Q-
���8 15� K'#�DS 5]\! >���! 6*�)z�E �=- "��*- 3� �Q_G8 FQ��c 6��Q�D 315Q� �[#Q5c
!� �#� $?� ��F- :_)�! ��\r�� ��#� ��! � *QE� 9�Q(� IQ"� 6*Q2 3Q0�#� �QTD �� �r5c 3,
M- !)-� 5� �3- 8'�" d9' LM ��#n��& .*�=& �'� '� 6��Y�Q"� �� �#^)� �QE8 Q$>��S �M !�Q&
3, 3:_)� F, �315� K'#�D 3� h#��� F���80387 MF�1- '� 9�*,�E � MF�1- �QE ����8 8
�!Bo& 3� h#���8 `j� F��\�� ��LB�- �'=- K4/A �G� �� �#Q� ��Q- IQ.�B ���Qc 315Q� . '� eQM
$?�F- �=& 6��� #� �EW" ��� �315�8 M '� 9�*,�EF�1- �E ��*:�8 �=- � �Ynk& 3� *�D I"� .
�� �TI& S2: 3)TM *)�8 �_G Zr�G� ��2/0 3�5 S)TM G �_G!$- �p, #�� �pQ, ' �WQ" ��Q& �
G!$- ��&' 3�"� 8*)� *� ) F1�12.( IT0 3)TM =-�' �_G 8*)� '� 6��Y�Q"� �Q� K4/A *Q)&��.
F-$?�3$�$" �� !5����S<#> CD�� ��2A� e&���� �*���S�&�:� �'� � F-1Q2� FQ��#\ !0�'
F��#\ '� 9�*, �E ��LB�-`j�*� 35"�?� )[�*06(.
�*F6. W����������� * ���� * �F* �-���3� ;
���3� ; *
Y�?���
@��
2EF
�-�� : � ��K��
��
M � ��K��
#��
�5
��� +� ��,
+)�&�7�&
@��
�-���3�
3541/0 9 7 7 6 5 3 2 1 l-�
2221/0 7 5 5 4 3 2 1 5/0 8@#A#�-A
1572/0 7 5 4 3 2 1 5/0 3333/0 !<��� 8����,
0981/0 5 3 3 2 1 5/0 3333/0 25/0 K���
0661/0 3 3 2 1 5/0 3333/0 25/0 2/0 F�B '� 3$n�.
0438/0 2 2 1 5/0 3333/0 25/0 2/0 1666/0 '� 3$n�.
3E���D
0346/0 2 1 5/0 3333/0 25/0 2/0 1666/0 1666/0 l-� IT0
0240/0 1 5/0 3333/0 25/0 2/0 1666/0 1428/0 1428/0 b�Y���
244 ������� �� / ���2 ���� � 2 �������� 1394
'� eM5"�?�S 8��B'�" I5� F��#\ �'�0255/0 � 35"�? *Q�. *Q-&j� '� eQM Q)%�� ���
e&���� ��#� F��#\ 8�E�a �`=-�' ��*G� �� K4/A SQ<#> CD�� �QE��-%� !&�QT �'� ���Q2A�
IT0S2: 3)TM 3&d 3� 8*)� [��\� ���)�� 8�E*� pQE XQ��#� '� ��Q, =Q&� 8��Q� 3, � !�Q�#M
�'� � 6��Y�"� ���S2: 3)TM !&�T =-�' �_G 8*)� �� K4Q/A SQ<#> �CD� *Q� 3Q-T� ��Q2A�
)F1�13(.
�*F7. �ER 26���� �- �� ��$%& +�5�6 � '��?7�� � �78&� 9:*� �� +�-��� ����
* ����������� ���������� ������
+r, �E�_G 8 [*� �� I>��� *n��S15� !5]\ �� I>��� *n��*)&��. F-$?�3$�$" !5����
p, !$-G 37/44 54/42
p, 45/7 63/7
W"#�� 93/8 18/9
��&' 49/32 35/32
��&' !$-G 76/6 30/8
��12. �8�B ��ER � + �!" � �� #$%& �� �5�6 9:*� �78&� � '��?7�� � ��� ���� ������
S�&�:� [*�S15� �� !\#)]� !5]\*)&��. F-$?�3$�$" �� !5���� ... 245
��13. �8�B ��ER �!" +� ��� �� #$%&�5�6 ����� � '��?7�� � �78&� $�� :����� ������
��-:?� =&�!��&'�� 8��� P �3:5� [*� !0��G s&�� 8*)� ���D�Q� �� 6��Y�Q"� ��#Q� 8�E
�_G =-�' '� K4/A �M�, 8���D l&�<I"� 6*� 6��Y�"�. � 6*E�Q2� e&���� �*��� �#^)� =&*�
-M [*� �� '� 9�*,�E 3� h#��� !)-�S15� F-$?� � !\#)]� !5]\3$�$" F-1Q2� !Q5����
*� .�� '� 6��Y�"� �� ef" W��10 ��12 6*E�2� P.�#� -QM PQ.�#� � 8� �QM�, l&�Q< � !Q)-�
*� 35"�?�)[�*0 8�E 8 �9(.
6*E�2� P.�#� [*� 8��� 8��S15 !\#)]� !5]\95/0 -QM PQ.�#� � !Q)-� 6*Q� 49/0 �
�M�, l&�<90/0 3� I"� *�D .
�*F8. U�R * '-�8� W����� �� ��� ��� ������ ����
#$%& ;* O��B ��3� ��$%& O��B ��3�
3 67 !�4/A h�: ��*%�
66 4 K4/A ��*� h�: ��*%�
246 ������� �� / ���2 ���� � 2 �������� 1394
�*F9. U�R * '-�8� W����� ����� ��� ����� ������
#$%& ;* O��B ��3� ��$%& O��B ��3�
5 65 !�4/A h�: ��*%�
64 6 K4/A ��*� h�: ��*%�
6*E�2� P.�#� F-$?� [*� 8��� 8� 3$Q�$" !Q5����92/0 -QM PQ.�#� � !Q)-� 6*Q� 50/0 �
�M�, l&�<84/0 3� I"� *�D.
�Z�7B +��M
s&�� !��&'��3� I"� '� 6*�D *)&��. 3$�$" F-$?� � !5����S15� '� 6��Y�Q"� �� !\#)]� !5]\
!� ��2 �M�, 8���D l&�< 3, *E�S15� �M�, 8���D l&�< �� !\#)]� !5]\90/0 3Q� I5�
*)&��. -$?� F3$�$" �M�, l&�< �� !5����84/0 -M �� 8��2-� Ic� '� =-�' �_G !)-� K4/A
��S<#> CD�� I"� ����#G�� ��2A�. 3)TM +�"� �� 8*)���#n [*� '� 6��Y�"� �� 3�.�BS15�
!\#)]� !5]\ 3Q� lQ-���37/44 �45/7 �93/8 �49/32 �76/6 �� 3Q:_)� I>�Q�� '� *Qn��
+r, !$-G �_G 8�E , �p,!$-G � ��&' �W"#�� �p ���c ��&'����. +rQ, !Q"��� s&�Q� 8�QE
!� ��2 l-� *E�) [�*01 ( 3,K4/A 3� I5� I-"��> =&��2-� 8�QEi� 6��� 3Q:_)� ��
l-� ��45-35 I"� 6���.� ��Y�� 30�� . l-� �� 3, I"� �D '� !,�> ��� =&��*), 3Q� FQ-A�
� F:` 8��- E�,�� �l- !$-G 8�E� *)�3 ��#� V-%< F-A�*)&��. v�G &�4Q.� � 8'�Q"
9�1?�"��E*'�" 8�'=- !"�)�� ��*%�K4/A �QE 8i� 6��� ) 3Q� 4Q0 K4Q&� ( E�Q, Q�! *Q��& .
K4/A !B*),��M 3� I5� !&�-.��/0 ��T0 !"��� !Q� ��Q2 �E �-`jQ� ��QT0 =Q&� 3Q, *QE�
=-�' b#c� �� !���Y�� K4/A *��� �E . ��S<#> �2-� ��2A� CD��=-�' 3� I-"��> =&� K4Q/A
���� �#0� C�~ � [��� ��T0 �� .�1�- �� 31)&� 3� 30#� �� 3Q)��� !A��� IQT0 3Q, !&�QE
l-��TD 3� I.�&�� ��2-� �� *-��#G �# I"� C#)0 I�"!� *Q), �� �Q-�5� � �QTD ��Q2-�
!� ��#�=&�'� �� 3)��� �� K4/A �!�#)0 l-� �� !&�E *E� i� 8��2-� 8�E �� ��#� �� ��S<#>
l$_� =&� w-<#� �� � �#� ��^�� '� ��� s&�� ��2A� CD���! kQ& IQT0 FQ��\ 3, IYB ��#�
=-�' b#c� 8��� lA�~ F��\ !Q� C#�?� 3:_)� =&� �� K4/A FQ��#\ ��QT0 =Q&� �� � �#Q�
3� 8�7&� lA�~ F��\ ��#)\ 3�Q��� �-`jQ� *Q�. SQ<#> m)Q" '� ��Q2A� CD�� !\#Q)�� !Q"�)�
G�� ����#I"� K4/A �� !&�4�� �-`j� F��\ =-�E 3, ���� 3Q:_)� 8�E . *'�Q" �� 8��Q> 8�QE
m)" !1ED � !��� 8�E3� F-A� ��Q2-� K4/A 3� I5� I-"��> I�#�� F��:� �� I-"��>
S�&�:� [*�S15� �� !\#)]� !5]\*)&��. F-$?�3$�$" �� !5���� ... 247
I"�� 3� 8�#� !� 3, '� !1& !\# 3� �� F��\ =&� ��#�pT� �� 3Q:_)� �� K4/A ��(&� F��#\ =&
������ . s&��!� ��2 *E�)[�*0 1 (3, 3, +��. 6��B 3Q� ��� lQ- ���Q5\ *Q� 8�E*'�Q" '�
D � ��QQ2-� �����QQ�zB~*)�QQ�E ���� �� K4QQ/A FQQ��:� �� I-QQ"��> =&��QQ2-� 8��QQ0�. s&�QQ�
3� I"� 6*�D !<��� 8����, '���2 *)E� !Q<��� �� K4Q/A 3� I-"��> =&��2-� 3, I"� �D
���� �#0� !$7)0 > �� F��\ =&� 3, 8��&' ��*�! =Q&� =�.�B ���c '� !�� *�#� �E*Q>�� 8��
l-� � !.��B#M#� �K4/A *%��� 8�E3� �#]G *��� !��� 8@#A#�-A 8�� �� =�.�B ���c. *Q%�
*>�� 3� h#��� K4/A ����� �� I-"��> =&��2-� !$7)0 !<��� '� !\��' !<��� 3Q, I"� p&�
�� �D I$\�! �� ��#��-`j� ��� �� ����p��-"#,� l& I�0 !%-5� 8�E � ��Q, #Q0. !Q"���
�D �7�-� !\�Y��� ��:5� �� b�Y��� &�4.� �� 3, I"�S<#> �Q_G 3Q� I-"��> ���2A� CD��
=-�' K4/A/� !�^)�� ���--���� !� =&� 3, =-5� *�#��#5 _���S � b�Y��� &�4.� =-� !_G
=-�' *��� K4/A . 4- l$_� =&� w-<#� ���! ��#� b�Y��� F��\ 3, ��, �\��� lQA�~ FQ��\ k&
=-�' b#c� 8��� �� K4/AS<#> !� C#�?� ��2A� CD�� �#�. s&�� !"��� 3Q� IQ"� 6*Q�D '�
3)TM 8�EpE !B*��� &�4.� �� 3, I"� =&� �7�-� K���� =-�' b#c� 3� I-"��> ��Q2-� K4/A
!� �#� . =&�3$t�� �3 �� �#]Gv�G �E�� K4/A *%��� 83&d *) IQ-�E� ��Q2-� !��� 8�E
����. s&�� +�"���3� I"� 6*�D =-Q�' b#Qc� �� F�B '� 3$n�. F��\ � Q_��� 3Q:_)� �� K4Q/AS
=-�' b#c� 3� I-"��> =&��2-� � ���� p-:��� 3:5� �� K4/A0 �Q�1500 '� 3$Qn�. 8�Q��
m)" !B*���G '� !�� 3, ���� �#0� F�B F�B W"#� �EI"� &�4.� �� � FQ�B '� 3$n�.�
!� ���, I-"��> �#� . s&��3� I"� 6*�D !"��� '�S2: =-�' !B*),��M K4/A 3Q� I5Q� �E
3Q�G��� ��Q), &�Q"�. �Q`� �� 3, ��� ��2 3E���D =&��Q2-� �l-Q� [��Q%� ��' pQE �Q� 8�
�� K4/A 3� I-"��>:5�S 100-0 ���� �#0� 8���.
[ ���
]1[. �8*�>� =�>� ���G*�?� =&�-�� |-. ��- ����"� �!"�*c [��0 )1384.( IG�"
[*� 3:_)� 8� �_G I,�> 8�E 6�#� 8� �� 6��Y�"� '�F-$?� 3$�$" !5����. 8��#� 3%A�_� :
S<#> 4-��D ���:A�� $(�S X��)� !%-5� ����&�58 : 14-3.
]2[. %,��!� �k��� 3��G U-��� ������� 1$�A�*5\!� M4&��� B-zE�!� M3�� D) 1386.( �����,S15�
5]\! \#)]�! ��3)TM *)�=-�' �_G 8 �K4/A$(�S ���T� 6�72�� 9#$\.33)1( :64-57.
]3[. ���'�" !&�-.��/0 8�E��- �w$�� S2: !.��B#M#�1:50000 ���2A� �*��T ���D'��-. �
3%$c p��>.
248 ������� �� / ���2 ���� � 2 �������� 1394
]4[. ���'�" =-�' !"�)� ��#2, S2: 1:100000 9�G ���D.
]5[. ���'�" =-�' !"�)� ��#2, S2: 1:100000 ��*�E.
]6[. ���'�" !"�)��#E ����"�A ���D I�-� A�"S 6�7��&� 8�E ����� !()" � k-�M#)-".
]7[. �*#Tf" !$\ �<� )1389.( 3)TM *)�8 �_G =-�' K4/A �� 6��Y�"� '� S15� !5]\
!\#)]� �� !2�� '� '#> 4-��D �'��E ��&�M ��S !"�)���, �*��� *12�� X��)� !%-5�
� 9#$\ !&�&�� ��# 6�72�� I-��� +�*� .
]8[. �#"8" ����$� �72A8 ~ ��#M�<��r� �#Y~8� �*�? )1391 .(3)TM *)�8 =-�' �_G K4/A
'� 6��Y�"� ��S15� 5]\! \#)]�! ��2&S �'-= "�)�! "*)T�! *$0 �5 ���� 2:
1286-1269.
]9[. n �.���*�� &��!� �!5�(� ~-�#-��� 0�Y% )1386.( 3)TM *)� �_G 8�'-= K4/A 6��Y�"� ��
$?� K�� '�-F 3$�$" 5����!� B*'�" � E�oM! 5� X��)� ��-% �!75 :126-118.
]10[. ��.��� *�n �!5�(� �!��&� �!1� *�?� )1384 .(3)TM *)�8 �_G =-�' K4/A ��
6��Y�"� '� [*� 8�E K'�� �!��\r�� p,��� w_" � LENR �� S<#> ����1A�U S$(� CD �
�4-��D3: 68 -62.
]11[. ��*:\ !���. �#�?�*-"� ���-�#-~ �Y%0 )1382.( !��&'�� !&���, K�� 8�E 8���D ��
=--%� F-���M �_G =-�' �K4/A 3$(� 9#$\ �=-�' ����11: 47 -28.
]12. .-| 3A� *T� ��#M8 )1391(. 3)TM *)�8 �� K4/A *%��� P��)��G���S B-#8 �U8 ��
[*� '� 6��Y�"�S15� 5]\! \#)]�! �A�"�S ��,�8�5� 6�72�� �&�4 �5�&4.
]13[. |-. ��- ����"� �!c��"�r, ���_\� �8*�>� =�> )1383(!"��� � F��#\ �a�` ��
b#c� =-�' K4/A �E � 3)TM 8*)� �_G =-�' K4/A �$(�S !%-5� X��)� ����&� 57 )1(: 20-3.
]14[. !"*c �> *-" ��#M= )1388.( 3$�$" F-$?� *)&��. !5���� !�%)n 6�72�� ����2�� �
���T� �p�YE ��U ��-5,�-��.
]15[. �9�, �-�d�*5\ )1380 .(8'��A*� !�, � 3)TM *)�8 �_G =-�' K4/A �� +�B�'
=-U 6��#G )%A�_�S 8��#� :S<#> 4-��D �#G�"- ���"� [�?���TU � 8��-���(� A�"�S
8��,� 8�-.��/0 %-5��! I-��� 6�72�� +�*�:354.
]16[. !,�#, ���o *�?� )1380.( S�&�:� !&���, �� [*� 3)TM *)�8 �_G =-�' K4/A )8�;�>
� ��#� (�� 6��Y�"� '� *0�" �� S<#> 4-��D 6�-" ���B�B������ ��&�M ��S !"�)���, �*���
6�72�� 9#$\ 8'���2, � X��)� !%-5� ��B�B :24.
]17[. ��-, �!Y_]� )1389(� 315� 8�E !5]\ �� �l$�� ����2�� ��-, �&��S 45" :229.
S�&�:� [*�S15� �� !\#)]� !5]\*)&��. F-$?�3$�$" �� !5���� ... 249
]18[. �8*�?� �<�*�?� ) 1386(. F-$?� �_G ��,�> 6�#� 8� � ;���S [*� l"�)� �� 6��Y�"�
'�GIS )%A�_�S 8��#� :!2�� '� S<#> 4-��D '��E(� ��&�M ��S !"�)���, �*��� 6�72��
�+�*� I-��� *12��X��)� -5�!% � 9#$\ !&�&��: 79.
]19[. �<�*-�> �8����� !$\ �*#Tf"� 4&��M �!1A��A�*5\ ) 1389( ."���! ���,!& S15� 5]\!
\#)]�! 3)TM 8��� =-�' �_G 8*)� K4/A )%A�_�S 8��#� :!2�� '� S<#> 4-��D '��E(�
�2� �d�:� 3\#�(�-= ��E& !$� "*)T� � 9#$\! ��D-8���4 ���TU �-= ��E& !$�
�"�.& C#"� � �"*)T� 6��B! ��D-8���4 *12�� 5� X��)�-%! ��� 6�72��-I *�+�.
]20[. ��&���%�� =-�> )1374.( =-�' !"�)� !"*)T� � �k-)1�#;@ ����2�� 6�72�� ���T�.
]21 [�g�T)� �c��*�?� )1381.( !�5� 315� 8�E �!5]\ ����2�� !�%)n �-5,�-�� )!$M
k-)1� ���T�(� 715 �.
]22[. �!0� �#�?�*-" )1385.( 3)TM *)�8 �_G K4/A �� �#?� 8��"-��"�-, ��&�M ��S
!"�)���, *���=-�' !"�)� �!_-?� I�&' 6�72�� !�%)n ���E��:86.
]23[. �8'�- C#:%&� �!n�]�G� �<�*�?�� �!5A�� !$\� �!G�D wA�n� �8����� =-�>*�?�
)1389.( !��&'�� !&���, [*� 8���D �6�-/��� �� -M !)-� �_G =-�' K4/A �� S<#> *"
�9r&� $(�S !�$\ � !2E�oM 9#$\ � !"*)T� 8���4-��D ���&� [�" 4� ���� 10�
��T�:20 -9. [24]. Binaghi, E., Luzi, L., Madella, P., Pergalani, F., Rampini, A. (1998). Slope
instability zonation: acomparison between certainty factor and fuzzy dempster–
shafer approaches, Natural Hazards, 17, 77–97. [25]. Biswajeet Paradhan, (2010). Remote sensing and GIS based Lanslid hazard
analysis and cross validation using multivariate logistic regression model on three test ares in Malaysia.
[26]. Caniani D., Pascale S., Sdao F., Sole A.,( 2008). Neural networks and landslide susceptibility: a case study of the urban area of Potenza, Natural Hazards, 45:55–72.
[27]. Gomez, H., Kavzoglu, T., (2005), Assessment of shallow landslide susceptibility using artificial neural networks in Jabonosa River Basin, Venezuela, Engineering Geology, 78: 11-27.
[28]. Hattanji, T., & Moriwaki, H., (2009), Morphometric analysis of relic landslides using detailed landslide distribution maps: Implications for forecasting travel distance of future landslides. Journal of Geomorphology, No, 103, Pp. 447-454.
[29]. Hosainezadeh. M., M. Servati., A. Mansouri., B. Mirbagheri., S. Khezri., (2009). Zoning risk of mass movements using a logistic regression model (case study: the path of the Sanandaj - Dehgolan). journal of Iran Geology 11, 27- 37.
[30]. Kanungo, D., Arora, M., Sarkar, S., and Gupta, R., (2006), A Comparative
250 ������� �� / ���2 ���� � 2 �������� 1394
Study of Conventioonal, ANN Blak Box, Fuzzy and Combined Neural and Fuzzy Weighting Proccedures for Landslide Suceptibility Zonation in Darjeeling Himalayas, engineering Geology, Vol. 85, pp. 347-366.
[31]. Komac, M. (2006). A landslide suscepility model using the Analytical Hierarchy Process method and multivariate statistics in perialpine Slovenia.
[32]. Lan, H.X., Zhou, C.H., Wang, L.J., Zhang, H.Y., Li, R.H. (2004). Landslide hazard spatial analysis and prediction using GIS in the Xiaojiang Watershed, Yunnan, China. Engineering Geology, 76, 109-128.
[33]. Lee S., Ryu J. H., Lee M. J., Won J. S., (2006): The Application of artificial neural networks to landslide susceptibility mapping at Janghung, Korea, Mathematical Geology, 38(2): 199-220.
[34]. Lee, S., Ryu. J. H., Kim, L. S.,( 2009), Landslide susceptibility analysis and its verification using likelihood ratio, logistic regression, and artificial neural network models: case study of Youngin, Korea, Landslide, 4:327-338.
[35]. Lee, S., Ryu. J. H., Won, J.S., Park, H. J., (2004), Determination application of the weighats for landslide susceptibility mapping using an artificial neural network, Engineering Geology, 71: 289-302.
[36]. Melchiorre C., Matteucci M., Azzoni A., (2008): Artificial neural networks and cluster analysis in landslide susceptibility zonation, Geomorphology, 94: 379 –400.
[37]. Pradhan, B., Lee, S., (2009), Landslide risk analysis using artificial neural networks model focusing on different training sites, International Journal of Physical Sciences, 4: 001-015.
[38]. Yilmaz, I., (2010), Landslide susceptibility mapping using frequency ratio, logistic regression, artificial neural networks and their comparison: A case study from kat landslides (Tokat-Turkey), Computers and Geosciences, 35: 1125-1138.